Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Bradenton FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Bradenton FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

450 Views

I think I can definitively say that Bradenton has some of the best pizza in the world, regardless of what random fanatics on social media might tell you. It was a tough job, but I decided to take it upon myself to find out just which pizzeria reigns supreme.

I visited 12 different venues and tasted each one’s offering. After careful consideration and evaluating my options, I’ve come to a conclusion: the best pizza in Bradenton FL is… You’ll have to read on to learn more about my findings!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 My Slice Pizza

The first thing that impressed me about My Slice Pizza was their wide selection of mouth-watering toppings. You could go with your standard pepperoni and cheese, or you could be daring and try something new like pineapple, sausage, and jalapenos! The crust was just the right thickness and had a nice crunch to it.

The atmosphere was inviting, cozy, and homey. I noticed the staff were friendly and went out of their way to ensure my experience was enjoyable.

But perhaps the most impressive part of my visit to My Slice Pizza is the fact that they offer a variety of vegan options. They also are generous with their portions, so each slice has plenty of deliciousness!

All in all, I absolutely recommend paying a visit to My Slice Pizza if you’re in the Bradenton FL area looking for some truly delicious pizza. In my opinion, it’s the best pizza you can find anywhere in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Anna Maria!

#2 San Remo Pizza & Pasta

My first visit to this authentic Italian restaurant was a pleasant one. The atmosphere of the place was inviting and the staff were friendly and helpful. Upon tasting the pizza, I was impressed with its freshness and flavor. The thick-crusted Neapolitan style pie, made with San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella cheese, and fragrant basil were truly an experience I won’t forget!

The other items on their menu complemented the pizza nicely. Their homemade pasta selections are full of flavor, with the garlic breadsticks being a highlight for me. The salad combinations were also excellent. Every dish had its own unique flavor that left me wanting more.

Overall, my experience at San Remo Pizza & Pasta was awesome and I can honestly say that it is some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL. If you’re looking for a delicious Italian meal in a relaxed setting, then look no further – San Remo is definitely worth a visit!

#3 Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe

I’ve tried pizza from Naples to Singapore and from New York to Chicago, so I’m confident that Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe is the crème de la crème.

When I arrived at Agrigento, the first thing I noticed was the beautiful Italian-inspired décor. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which made for a pleasant experience.

The menu boasted a wide array of unique pizzas with toppings ranging from classic pepperoni to creative combinations like shrimp scampi and artichoke hearts. I decided to try their signature pie – the Agrigento Special – and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly cooked and had just enough char, while the fresh mozzarella was ooey-gooey deliciousness. I also had their house salad which was simply divine.

In summary, Agrigento Pizzeria Caffe offers some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL – hands down! Their pies are tasty, the atmosphere is inviting, and the service is top notch. If you’re in town and looking for an incredible pizza experience, then visiting Agrigento should definitely be on your list!

#4 Fav’s Italian Cucina

I was greeted warmly when I arrived, as if they knew I was coming to sample their delicious pizza. The knowledgeable waitstaff informed me that the pizzas here are made using fresh ingredients and homemade dough, each carefully crafted by a master pizzaiolo.

The menu boasted over a dozen unique pies with toppings ranging from artichoke hearts and pesto to spicy sausage and mushrooms. After much deliberation, I settled on a classic Margherita pizza with extra virgin olive oil and finely shaved Parmesan cheese. I could tell from its golden crust and bubbling cheese how truly delicious it would be!

I’m pleased to report that my expectations were exceeded tenfold! The pizza was absolutely scrumptious! It had a crispy crust cradling gooey mozzarella cheese, tangy tomatoes, savory basil, and highly flavorful olive oil. Each bite was more delightful than the last!

After finishing my meal, I concluded that Fav’s Italian Cucina serves up some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL. Highly recommended for all pasta-lovers out there!

#5 D. Americo’s Pizzeria

It’s clear that the folks at D. Americo’s really know their stuff when it comes to pizza. The thin crust is just perfect – not too thin and not too thick – with a perfectly baked doughy texture. And the toppings are always fresh and flavorful!

It’s not just the quality of the ingredients that make D. Americo’s a standout pizzeria, but also the atmosphere. Whether you’re on date night or simply grabbing dinner with friends, this place always manages to be cozy, inviting, and full of good vibes.

I can’t say enough great things about D. Americo’s Pizzeria in Bradenton FL – definitely one of the best places to get pizza in the area!

#6 Casa Di Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I arrived was the inviting atmosphere. The red and white checkered tablecloths and the sound of Italian music playing in the background reminded me of a cozy home.

The menu had several delicious options to choose from, including classic Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella, pepperoni and sausage pies, and specialty items like carbonara pizza topped with eggs and bacon. I settled on a simple but incredibly flavorful margherita pizza loaded with fresh ingredients.

When my Margherita pizza arrived at my table, it took everything in me not to dig right in! The cheese was perfectly melted, the crust was thin yet crispy, and the tomatoes were sweet and juicy. This was clearly one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Good thing I had my camera ready to take pictures for proof because this definitely wasn’t something I’d forget anytime soon.

Casa Di Pizza is truly one of Bradenton’s hidden gems when it comes to great pizza. Whether you’re looking for a classic pie or something more unique, this place will satisfy your cravings without breaking the bank! I would highly recommend it if you’re ever in town looking for a tasty slice of pizza perfection.

#7 Wilder’s Pizza

My favorite thing about this place is that it offers a range of styles, from classic thin crust to gourmet-style hand-tossed pies. I’ve tried them all and they all taste amazing! The toppings are always fresh and flavorful, the sauces are rich and satisfying, and – the best part – the crust is cooked to perfection every time.

The atmosphere at Wilder’s Pizza is also top notch. It’s a cozy little spot with brick walls adorned with historic images of Bradenton FL. The staff is friendly and helpful and they really make you feel welcome. Plus, if you want to take your pizza to go, they even offer delivery!

All in all, Wilder’s Pizza has definitely earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL! If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by for a delicious slice (or two!). You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Lakewood Ranch!

#8 Verona Pizza & Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere is quite nice – dark woods and white tablecloths give it a classic Italian vibe. The wait staff is friendly and will go the extra mile to make sure you have a great experience.

But most importantly, the pizza! It’s cooked to perfection – thin, crispy crust with just enough toppings to hit the spot. I especially enjoyed the Italian sausage, which was nicely spiced and made for an excellent addition to my slice.

I would go so far as to say that Verona Pizza & Italian Restaurant makes some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL! I highly recommend it for anyone looking for an authentic Italian experience right here in Florida.

#9 Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery

It starts with the dough. Freshly made every day, Joey D’s pizza dough is light, fluffy and full of flavor. Of course I had to try a variety of toppings, so I opted for sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms – a classic combination!

The sauce was amazing – really flavorful and not too sweet. All the ingredients tasted incredibly fresh and perfectly seasoned. The cheese was stringy and delicious; it melted in my mouth like magic!

The crust was perfectly cooked – just crispy enough without being burnt. It had that perfect chewiness that only great pizza has! I also have to mention that their staff is top notch – they were friendly, attentive and helpful throughout my entire experience.

Overall, I can confidently say that Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery has some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL! If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience that won’t disappoint, definitely give them a try! You won’t regret it!

#10 Danny’s Pizzeria

I’m no stranger to pizza, so when I first walked into Danny’s Pizzeria and saw their selection of pies, I was rather impressed. The crust was golden-brown and the ingredients were fresh and flavorful.

The real highlight of my experience at Danny’s though was the service. The owner (presumably Danny) went out of his way to make sure my meal was perfect. He had a great sense of humor and made me feel right at home in his restaurant.

My favorite part about this place is the atmosphere. The walls are painted with colorful murals that really bring the place to life. It’s like walking into another world full of deliciousness!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL then Danny’s Pizzeria should be your first stop. I’ve been around the world searching for great pizza, but there is nothing quite like the experience you get here!

#11 Gianni’s NY Pizza

The first thing that will stand out to you when you walk into Gianni’s is the delicious smells coming from their brick oven. The place had a classic, authentic New York pizzeria vibe to it, with a warm ambience and plenty of seating.

When I tried their pizza, I was truly amazed at how good it was. The crust was light and airy yet had a nice crunch to it, while the cheese tasted like it had been freshly made that day. The toppings were generous—not stingy like some other places I’ve visited—and cooked perfectly.

If you’re looking for top-notch pizza in Bradenton FL, then look no further than Gianni’s NY Pizza! Their pizza is not only delicious but also reasonably priced. This place definitely deserves its five-star rating—I’d give my stamp of approval to any pizza fan who decides to pay them a visit!

#12 Five Star Pizza – Bradenton

The atmosphere is great: a warm, inviting space that encourages conversation and socializing. Plus, the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming.

I started off with the Supreme Pizza – it had pepperoni, sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions, peppers, and olives. The flavors were phenomenal! All of the ingredients complemented each other perfectly and combined with a savory sauce to create something truly special.

Next, I tried the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. I’m not usually a fan of buffalo-style food but this one won me over! The chicken was juicy and full of flavor, while the mild sauce had just enough kick to make it interesting without being overwhelming. And the combination of mozzarella and cheddar cheese on top finished off the pizza perfectly.

Finally, I sampled their Meat Lovers Pizza – loaded with five different types of meat! Again, all of the flavors worked together amazingly well to create an unforgettable taste experience that I won’t soon forget.

Overall, Five Star Pizza – Bradenton really lives up to its name – they serve some of the best pizza in Bradenton FL! From start to finish it was an amazing experience that I highly recommend to anyone looking for fantastic pizza!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery

Let me start by saying that this place knows how to have a good time. Not only do they serve alcohol, but they have a dessert menu that is so insanely good it should be illegal. I mean, who needs to count calories when you can have a slice of their heavenly chocolate lava cake?

Now, let’s talk about the ambiance. Joey D’s is a nice tourist spot, which means you can watch unsuspecting visitors attempt to fold their thin crust pizza like they do back in Chicago. It’s like a free comedy show! Plus, the place is outfitted with TVs everywhere, making it a great spot to catch the game. Just make sure to keep an eye on your slice, because you might get distracted by a touchdown and find your pizza missing when you turn back around.

The only downside? They don’t accept reservations. Apparently, they subscribe to the first come, first serve philosophy. So be prepared to show up early and be ready to pounce on a table like a hungry lion on a gazelle. But hey, the anticipation is part of the fun, right?

In conclusion, Joey D’s Chicago Style Eatery not only serves the best thin crust pizza in bradenton, but it also offers a great atmosphere, delicious desserts, and plenty of sports action. So go ahead and indulge in some mouthwatering pizza while enjoying the spectacle of tourists attempting to fold their slices. It’s a win-win!