Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Brookfield WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Brookfield WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

229 Views

I’m no stranger to pizza, having tasted it in all corners of the globe. From Italy to New York, India to Brazil – I’ve sampled some excellent pies! But I was curious what Brookfield had to offer. So, I set out on a mission – to find the Best Pizza in Brookfield WI.

To that end, I visited 12 pizza places across Brookfield and tasted their signature pies. I’m ready to share my findings with you. Hold tight – this will be an entertaining ride!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 Marvino’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, it was clear this place has character. The décor had a classic Italian feel with plenty of old-world charm. Then there was the staff, who welcomed me like an old friend and made sure I had everything I needed.

The menu options were very impressive and unique to Marvino’s. From traditional Neapolitan pizzas to gourmet creations, they had something for everyone! They even have vegan-friendly options so you don’t have to miss out on the deliciousness.

When my pizza arrived, it looked better than anything I’d eaten on my travels thus far. The crust was perfectly thin and crisp while the toppings were expertly composed with quality ingredients.

I can honestly say that Marvino’s Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI! If you’re having cravings for a delicious slice of pizza, then look no further than Marvino’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in West Allis!

#2 Sluggo’s Sports Pub & Grill

The atmosphere at Sluggo’s is really cool. Not only do they have the classic sports pub vibe, but they also serve up some hard liquor! Nothing like watching a game and having a strong drink to go along with your pizza.

Speaking of the pizza, it is outstanding! The crust isn’t too thick or too thin. The sauce is perfectly seasoned, and all of their toppings are fresh and flavorful. Be sure to try their house special—it’s out of this world, especially when washed down with one of their craft beers on tap!

My only complaint about Sluggo’s Sports Pub & Grill is that they don’t offer delivery services. But that doesn’t take away from the fact that this place has some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI! If you’re looking for tasty pizza and an awesome place to watch sports, look no further than Sluggo’s Sports Pub & Grill.

#3 The Red Mill Inn & Pizza

From the moment I walked through the door, I knew this was going to be a special experience. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with a warm and friendly staff.

The menu had some interesting options, but I opted for the classic cheese pizza on thin crust. As soon as it arrived to my table, my taste buds sprang into action. The ingredients were all fresh and flavorful, and the pizza was cooked to perfection- crispy on the bottom with just enough sauce and cheese on top.

I also sampled their famous deep dish sausage pizza, which tasted like something you’d find in Italy! It was full of layers of flavors – from sweet tomato sauce to savory Italian sausage – that worked together perfectly.

Overall, I can confidently say that The Red Mill Inn & Pizza is serving up some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI! If you’re ever in town, do yourself a favor and try it out – your taste buds won’t regret it!

#4 Giuseppi’s Pizzeria

I arrived hungry and eager to sample their menu, and the first item I tried was the signature Giuseppi’s Special. It was a lovely blend of savory meats, vegetables and cheese that had just enough spice. The crust was cooked perfectly – not too crunchy or too soggy!

Next, I decided to try their famous Stuffed Crust Supreme – it was mouthwatering! This pizza had a thick, buttery crust with all sorts of delicious toppings. From bacon to mushrooms and pepperoni to olives, every bite was an explosion of flavor. Not only did it taste amazing but the presentation was incredible as well!

Finally, I sampled their dessert pizza – a classic apple pie pizza with warm apples and homemade caramel sauce. Again the quality shone through – the apples were crisp yet juicy while the caramel sauce added a sweetness that balanced out the tartness from the apples.

Overall, I would highly recommend Giuseppi’s Pizzeria for anyone looking for amazing pizza in Brookfield WI! Their quality ingredients combined with excellent craftsmanship make each bite truly unforgettable.

#5 Marty’s Pizza Pasta & Subs

The pizza was simply outstanding. The crust had just the right amount of crunch, the cheese melted perfectly on top and the flavor of the sauce was spot-on. I’ve never tasted a better slice anywhere else!

The other menu items were equally as delicious. The pasta dishes were packed with flavor and the subs were hearty and well seasoned. I made sure to sample as much as I could during my visit, but before I knew it, it was time to leave (believe me, that was no easy task).

I’d highly recommend Marty’s Pizza Pasta & Subs to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town!

#6 Brookfield, WI – Lou Malnati’s

This family-run pizzeria has been serving up delicious pies since the early 1970s. The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, with classic Italian music playing in the background.

The pizza at Lou Malnati’s is always made fresh with premium ingredients. They serve up a variety of classic favorites, like the famous Chicago deep dish with its thick crust and buttery sauce, as well as specialty pies like the Spinoccoli, which features spinach and mushrooms tucked between two layers of gooey cheese.

In my opinion, it’s impossible to leave Lou Malnati’s without feeling satisfied. From the warm welcome to the amazing food, this restaurant never fails to make me smile. With prices that are reasonable for what you get – there’s no doubt that Lou Malnati’s earns its spot as one of Brookfield WI’s best pizzerias!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Wauwatosa!

#7 Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Brookfield

The restaurant is cozy and inviting, and the staff are extremely friendly and helpful. The menu has a great selection of classic pizzas as well as some unique specialty creations. I opted for a simple cheese pizza, but was pleasantly surprised at how delicious it was. The crust was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunch and the cheese melted into gooey goodness that made my mouth water.

In addition to their amazing pizza, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Brookfield also serves up some delicious sides including breadsticks, garlic knots, salads and more. The garlic knots in particular were a hit—seasoned just right with plenty of buttery flavor.

My experience at Glass Nickel Pizza Co was one for the books! Not only do they serve up some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI, but their sides are on point too! I’ll definitely be back next time I’m in town.

#8 Pistol Pete’s Pizza and Grill

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. Not only is it a great place to watch sports, but they also offer an extensive selection of alcoholic drinks and hard liquor. That’s right – you can get your pizza and beer all in one spot!

They also offer other great dining options, such as a kid’s menu, vegetarian options, salads, and desserts. And while they unfortunately don’t offer delivery (the horror!), their food is worth every step you take to get there. I mean come on – it’s the best pizza in Brookfield WI!

All in all, Pistol Pete’s Pizza and Grill is an excellent choice for both families and adults looking for a great meal – and some good fun too!

#9 Badger Burger Company Brookfield

I stumbled upon the place while I was out and about exploring the city. It had a small but inviting atmosphere, with lots of locals coming in and out to get their pizza fix. The menu was full of delicious creations, each more appetizing than the last.

But what surprised me most was how huge their portions were! The slices were as big as my head, yet still thin enough to fold in half and eat like a traditional pizza slice. And the toppings! Oh boy, they were aplenty – from pepperoni to spinach and feta – there was something for everyone. Even the crust was light and airy, yet strong enough to hold up all those toppings without getting too soggy.

But I think what really sets Badger Burger Company Brookfield apart from other pizza places is their unique flavors; from pumpkin spice sauce to pulled pork with pineapple – they have something special that you won’t find anywhere else.

I rate Badger Burger Company Brookfield 5 stars out of 5 – I definitely recommend it if you’re looking for the best pizza in Brookfield WI!

#10 Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

I had the pleasure of visiting Grimaldi’s Pizzeria recently and I can say without a doubt that it has some of the freshest ingredients (and biggest slices) around. The dough is perfect—crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The sauce is flavorful without being too heavy, and they have a nice variety of toppings to choose from.

But what really set Grimaldi’s apart was their friendly staff and cozy atmosphere. Everything about this place just screams “welcoming”, from the smiling employees to the inviting décor, it truly felt like I was visiting family instead of just another pizza joint.

So if you’re ever in Brookfield WI, be sure to check out Grimaldi’s Pizzeria for some of the best pizza around!

#11 Jet’s Pizza

The atmosphere is informal and inviting, making it a great place to bring the family. It was easy to find seating inside and the staff was friendly and accommodating.

The pizza menu at Jet’s Pizza is vast and includes a variety of ingredients that allowed me to create my own masterpiece! I decided on a classic pepperoni pie but with grilled chicken, jalapeños, spinach, onions for an interesting twist. The flavors were well balanced and the crust was perfect- crispy on the outside yet chewy in the middle.

It comes as no surprise that Jet’s Pizza has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Brookfield WI! From fresh ingredients to great service, you won’t regret eating here. I can honestly say it was one of the most enjoyable meals I’ve had in quite some time!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Waukesha!

#12 Pizza Man Wauwatosa

The atmosphere in the restaurant is energetic and alive, with a variety of people from all walks of life enjoying some delicious pizza. The staff was also incredibly friendly and went out of their way to make sure that everyone was happy and had a great experience.

The pizza itself was simply amazing! The crust was crisp yet chewy, with just the right amount of seasoning, and the sauce was tangy yet perfectly balanced. The toppings were generous – deliciously fresh vegetables mixed with savory meats, creating flavor combinations that I’ve never tasted before.

I got to try a few different kinds of pizza at Pizza Man Wauwatosa, and each one exceeded my expectations! From classic margarita pizzas to unique toppings like goat cheese and spinach, it’s hard not to find something you’ll absolutely love on their menu.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Brookfield WI, then you must stop by Pizza Man Wauwatosa! You won’t be disappointed – I guarantee it!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked through the door, the heavenly aroma of fresh pizza made my taste buds dance in anticipation. I was promptly greeted by a friendly server who seemed downright thrilled to have me as a guest. I mean, I get it, I’m a pretty big deal in the pizza world.

As I settled into my seat, I couldn’t help but notice the quirky decorations that adorned the walls. From vintage pizza boxes to pictures of smiling customers with sauce-stained faces, it was clear that this place had character. And let me tell you, the character continued into their pizzas.

The thin crust was perfection. It was delicate yet crispy and held up all those glorious toppings without feeling overwhelmed. Each bite was a harmonious symphony of flavors, melodically dancing across my palate. I found myself singing pizza-themed show tunes with each bite – I’m pretty sure the woman at the next table was impressed with my vocal range.

Now, let’s talk about the cheese. Oh, the cheese! It was like a blanket of melted deliciousness, stretchy and gooey with just the right amount of saltiness. It clung to each bite like a clingy ex, refusing to let go until you were fully satisfied. And believe me, I left feeling more satisfied than after my first kiss.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, you have stolen my heart (and stomach) with your incredible thin crust pizza. Thank you for filling my life with cheesy joy and reminding me why I love being a pizza connoisseur. If you haven’t experienced the magic of Grimaldi’s yet, dear reader, put on your stretchy pants and prepare for a pizza journey of epic proportions.