Of the twelve pizza places I’ve sampled so far, I’ve found some real gems. Each of them offer a unique flavor thanks to their individual ingredients and cooking methods.
I understand that people have different preferences when it comes to pizza, so I’m not here to tell you which one is best. However, I will be offering my humorous and lighthearted take on the pizzas in Canandaigua in the following article – so get ready for lots of cheesy puns!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York
#1 Faro’s Pizzeria
- Nice tourist spot
The pizza is fantastic! The crust has just the right amount of crunch and softness to it, and the dough is perfectly light and fluffy. The sauce is just sweet enough that you don’t need to add on anything else. And the cheese – oh my goodness, the cheese! It’s like a blanket of mozzarella heaven over the top of your pizza!
When I got there, I was immediately greeted by friendly staff members who made me feel welcome. They even gave me some great recommendations for toppings; I ended up going with their suggestions and it was delightful.
The atmosphere at Faro’s Pizzeria makes dining there an enjoyable experience as well. There’s plenty of seating available, which is great if you’re coming with a group, but even if you’re dining alone they’ve got cozy spots where you can just relax in a corner with your slice.
All in all, Faro’s Pizzeria is easily one of the best pizza joints in Canandaigua – definitely worth a trip if you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Geneva!
#2 Pontillo’s Pizzerias
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped into Pontillo’s, I could tell it was a special place. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff welcomed me as soon as I walked in, and then there was the pizza – simply amazing!
I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and was not disappointed. The crust was crispy yet tender, just crunchy enough to give it some bite. The sauce was sweet and zesty like a good Italian marinara should be, while the pepperoni had a nice smoky flavor that balanced out the sweetness perfectly. And of course, their signature blend of mozzarella and provolone cheeses made this pie one of a kind.
I’m no food critic but if I had to sum up my experience in one word it would be “heaven”. It’s honestly some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted – hands down! From the atmosphere to the toppings, Pontillo’s is an absolute must-try for any pizza lover looking for only the best.
#3 Pizza Sangiorgi
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere was inviting and the service was top-notch. But the real star of the show is the pizza. The dough was soft and light, with a perfect amount of char on the crust. The sauce had just enough sweetness, but wasn’t too overpowering. And the cheese! It was so unbelievably cheesy—it practically melted in my mouth!
I also had the pleasure of sampling a few different types of pies during my visit. My favorite was their signature Margherita Pizza—thin slices of prosciutto and fresh basil mixed with tomatoes and mozzarella—simply heavenly!
So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Canandaigua, make sure to check out Pizza Sangiorgi! I’m confident that you’ll be as pleasantly surprised as I was!
#4 Domino’s Pizza
When I stepped foot in the restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a smile and a warm welcome. The atmosphere was welcoming and inviting. After taking a seat at the bar, I had the opportunity to watch the staff make my pizza right in front of me!
To start off my review, I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza. The crust was cooked just right – not too thick or thin – and it had just enough crispiness to make it enjoyable. The sauce was flavorful and not too sweet; it was absolutely perfect. Even more impressive was the cheese – it was gooey, melted well, and had a great consistency. Finally, the pepperoni added just the right kick to finish off this delicious pie.
I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention Domino’s Pizza’s fantastic service as well! From when I walked in to when I left with my pizza box in hand, everyone on staff treated me kindly and made sure that my experience exceeded expectations.
Overall, Domino’s Pizza is one of the best pizzerias in Canandaigua and is definitely worth checking out! Anyone looking for great-tasting pizza should definitely give them a try; you won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 22 more pizza places in Webster!
#5 Perri’s Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
Let me start with the basics – the dough! They have perfected the art of making thin and crispy crust, with just a hint of sweetness. The texture is perfect – not overly chewy or tough like some other pizzas I’ve tried.
The sauce is incredibly flavorful, made with only the freshest tomatoes and herbs. It compliments the crust perfectly, without being too overpowering or bland.
Next up for review: toppings! Perri’s offers a wide range of topping options, from traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more creative offerings like artichokes and shrimp. Each was cooked perfectly and added an extra layer of flavor and texture to my pie.
I could go on about how amazing their pizza tastes but I’m sure you get the idea by now. If you’re ever in Canandaigua looking for top-notch pizza, look no further than Perri’s Pizzeria!
#6 Byrne Dairy and Deli
The pizza here is outstanding. The crust is perfectly cooked – it’s thin, crispy, and just the right amount of crunchiness. The toppings are fresh and generously portioned. Whether you go with a classic like pepperoni or something a bit more creative like their “Greek” pizza with sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, and feta cheese, you’re sure to get a delicious pie each time.
The atmosphere at Byrne Dairy and Deli adds to the experience. The decor has all the charm of an old-fashioned deli but with enough modern touches that it still feels current and inviting. And of course, the staff is always friendly and helpful – which makes the entire experience even better!
If you’re looking for great pizza in Canandaigua, then look no further than Byrne Dairy and Deli. It may have taken me traveling around the world to figure this out, but I can guarantee that it’s one of the best places around for pizza!
#7 Pudgie’s Pizza Pasta & Subs
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
When I first walked in, I was struck by the sheer selection of pizza choices they had available. Iaving had Italian and New York style pizza everywhere else, I was curious to try out their specialty–a Canadian-style pizza!
The wait staff were friendly and helpful as I waded through what seemed like an endless sea of possibilities. In the end, though, I settled on a classic topping combination – pepperoni, sausage and green bell peppers.
The pizza itself was excellent – the crust was cooked just right and full of flavor without being too greasy. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and the cheese melted perfectly on top. I asked for extra-spicy red pepper flakes which they happily obliged.
Pudgie’s Pizza Pasta & Subs offers an extensive selection of pasta dishes as well, which are equally delicious-I highly recommend their lasagna! All in all, Pudgie’s is one of the best pizza places in Canandaigua. Hands down my new favorite spot for Italian fare!
If you’re willing to go an extra 24 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Rochester!
#8 Pizanos Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
I arrived at Pizanos Pizza with high expectations, and I was not disappointed. The menu boasted an array of pizzas with unique and delectable toppings, and the smell from the ovens had me drooling before I even ordered!
When my order came out of the oven, I couldn’t believe my eyes. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese melted perfectly over the toppings, and the sauce was unbelievably flavorful. Every bite was more delicious than the last!
The restaurant itself is surprisingly cozy for a pizza place. The staff take their time to make sure each order is perfect, so you know that you’re getting exactly what you want! They also carry some truly unique beers (Belgian-style pale ales!), which paired exceptionally well with my meal.
In conclusion, Pizanos Pizza definitely deserves its title as the best pizza in Canandaigua! Delicious food, great beer selection, and friendly service make this spot a must-visit for any pizza lover.
#9 Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I was especially impressed with the selection of pies. From classic pepperoni to more exotic options like shrimp and roasted garlic, Salvatore’s had something for everyone! The pizzas themselves were cooked perfectly – crisp crusts with gooey cheese and just the right amount of sauce.
The atmosphere at Salvatore’s made it even better. The restaurant has a old-school Italian vibe that really takes you back in time. In addition to great pizza, they also serve amazing Italian dishes like lasagna, linguine, and other classics.
The service was top notch; our waiter was very friendly and attentive. He provided us with some great recommendations when it came to choosing the perfect pie!
Overall, I highly recommend Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria to anyone looking for an authentic Italian experience and some of the best pizza in Canandaigua!
#10 Mark’s Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
Their incredible crust lives up to its reputation, and their pizzas are a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings. For my favorite pie, I like to go with the classic pepperoni pizza. It has just the right amount of bite and delicious flavor.
The staff at Mark’s Pizzeria are passionate about what they do and always ensure that you have an amazing dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy, casual, and inviting – which makes it the perfect spot for a family dinner or date night.
What truly sets them apart from other local pizzerias is that they use only fresh ingredients from local vendors. Plus, their prices are very reasonable compared to most places in town.
If you’re ever looking for some really great pizza in Canandaigua, Mark’s Pizzeria should be your go-to spot! You won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Rochester!
#11 Wegmans Meals 2GO
I’d heard about their speciality pizzas from a few friends, and I just had to try them out for myself. When I arrived at the restaurant, I was blown away. The staff welcomed me with open arms and made sure that all my needs were met.
The selection of pizzas on offer is quite impressive – from classic combos like pepperoni and sausage to more unusual options like eggplant and feta cheese, there’s a pizza for everyone here! Plus, you can customize your toppings to suit your own tastes.
And the quality? Let me tell you – this is some of the best pizza in Canandaigua! The crust was crispy yet chewy, the sauce was tangy and flavourful, and the toppings were cooked just right. Absolutely delicious!
To top it all off, Wegmans Meals 2GO also offers some great sides – my personal favourites are their garlic knots and fries. They taste amazing when paired with any of their amazing pizzas!
Overall, I’m pretty impressed with Wegmans Meals 2GO’s selection and quality of pizzas. If you’re ever in Canandaigua looking for a great meal, you should definitely check them out!
#12 Casa Italiana
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
I’ve sampled pizza from Chicago, Rome and even Naples, but Casa Italiana is on a different level. Not only do they have the best crust in town, but their recipe for the perfect sauce also impressed me. The addition of fresh herbs gave it an extra depth of flavor that really brought out the complexity of the dish.
The toppings were also top-notch. It was clear that they went to great lengths to source quality ingredients – the pepperoni slices had a rich smokiness that you rarely find outside of Italy. The quality mozzarella cheese melted perfectly and gave each bite a luxurious mouthfeel that was truly unforgettable.
In addition to delicious food, Casa Italiana’s atmosphere was equally wonderful. The dimly lit restaurant has an air of authenticity and class – everything from its brick walls to its vintage décor exuded a certain old-world charm that does not come around often these days.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Canandaigua, look no further than Casa Italiana!
