Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Cape Coral FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Cape Coral FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

662 Views

I’m no stranger to trying pizza from all parts of the world, so when I was given the opportunity to review the 12 best pizza places in Cape Coral FL, I jumped at the chance.

I’m always up for tasting new kinds of pizza and learning about all the unique flavors that keep people coming back for more. This time around, I’m looking forward to diving into what Cape Coral FL has to offer in terms of its delicious pizzas.

I hope you’re prepared for a journey full of cheesy goodness and some lighthearted humor along the way, because I plan on finding out exactly which place serves the best slice in town!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Leone’s Italian Market & Pizzeria

As a food critic, I’m always searching for the perfect pizza. I’ve tried pizza in Rome, New York, Chicago and all throughout Florida – but Leone’s Italian Market & Pizzeria has consistently produced delicious pies. The crust is freshly made and cooked to perfection, the toppings are fresh, and the sauce is mouth-wateringly flavorful.

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Leone’s Italian Market & Pizzeria when I was in town on vacation. Although there is no delivery option here, it was definitely worth making the trip to sample their amazing pies. The restaurant itself is quite nice, with nice Tuscan inspired decor that creates a great atmosphere while you enjoy your meal.

On top of their pizzas, Leone’s also offers some amazing desserts like tiramisu and cannoli – so don’t forget to save room for one of these! All in all this is an excellent place if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Cape Coral FL. I would wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone looking for a great experience without breaking the bank!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Fort Myers!

#2 Dairon’s Cuban Pizzeria

The journey to get here was worth it. The smell of freshly baked pizza hit me as soon as I entered the restaurant. I quickly realized that this was going to be no ordinary pizza experience!

I sampled so many of their specialty pizzas that I lost count. Each one was better than the last, but my favorite had to be their Cuban-style pizza. It had a delicious combination of sweet and savory flavors that just exploded in your mouth with every bite!

Another great feature about Dairon’s is their atmosphere. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and they even took the time to explain the different ingredients used in each of their pizzas!

To top it all off, the prices are more than reasonable for the quality you get – no doubt a real steal for locals who can pop in for some amazing pizza.

If you live in Cape Coral FL, I highly suggest checking out Dairon’s Cuban Pizzeria – hands down the best pizza in town!

#3 Nice Guys Pizza and Beer

The atmosphere is a real highlight – it has a cozy, inviting feel that makes you want to stay for hours. There’s even a large selection of craft beers to choose from, so you can pair your pizza with beer that complements it perfectly.

The menu is diverse and interesting; I’ve never had anything like their unique combination pizzas. The cheese blend they use on all of their pizzas gives them an unbeatable flavor. And the crusts are just as good – they’re crunchy and herby, with a slight sweetness that really brings out the taste of the topping ingredients.

Speaking of topping ingredients, Nice Guys Pizza and Beer offers something for everyone – from classic pepperoni to exotic combos like mango and prosciutto. Not only are the toppings unique and delicious, but they also offer an array of vegan options as well!

If you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Cape Coral FL, then Nice Guys Pizza and Beer needs to be at the top of your list! Their delicious food, cozy atmosphere, and extensive beer selection make it an unbeatable experience.

#4 Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral

My first impression of Paradise Pizza was that it had a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. The decor was inviting and welcoming, which set the tone for an enjoyable experience.

I started off my meal with a plate of their famous garlic knots. They were soft, fluffy and full of flavor–without being too greasy or salty. They really hit the spot!

Next up was their famous cheese pizza. The crust was light and crispy and the combination of cheeses melted perfectly with each bite. Their tomato sauce had just the right amount of spice to make it stand out, but not overpower the other flavors in the pizza.

Finally I tried Their Specialty Pizza, which is a combination of sausage, peppers and onions surrounded by melted mozzarella cheese. It tasted like a gourmet slice fresh from Italy! Everything came together nicely and created an amazing flavor combination unlike any I’ve tasted before.

In conclusion, Paradise Pizza is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Cape Coral FL looking for some of the best pizza around! Their selection is varied enough to satisfy everyone’s needs, but their Specialty Pizza stands out above all else.

#5 Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with plenty of TVs to watch sports and a great selection of craft beer. The service was excellent, and the staff were friendly and attentive.

But I didn’t come here for the atmosphere – I came here for the pizza! And believe me, once you try it, you won’t want to leave. The crust is perfect – golden and crunchy on the outside yet soft on the inside. The cheese is just the right amount of gooeyness, and there are so many unique topping combinations that you could probably have something new every time you visit.

I’m not exaggerating when I say that Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub has some of the best pizza in Cape Coral FL – it’s truly phenomenal! Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or an evening out with friends, this place is a must-try.

#6 IL Primo Pizza & Wings

From the moment I stepped in, the friendly faces of the staff made me feel welcome. The restaurant itself was inviting and comfortable – the perfect place to relax and try some great pizza.

When it comes to the pizza, IL Primo definitely knows what it’s doing! Their crust is perfectly crisp and buttery, their sauce is made with just the right amount of heat and sweetness – and their toppings are all fresh! Whether you like traditional pepperoni or want something more adventurous like eggplant bacon or even vegan cheese, they’ve got plenty of options that won’t disappoint.

But it’s not just the pizza that makes IL Primo one of the best pizza places in Cape Coral FL! They also offer a great selection of wings – everything from mild to extra spicy – along with plenty of other side dishes like salads, garlic knots and calzones. Plus, their prices are extremely reasonable for such quality food.

Overall, if you’re looking for a fantastic pizza experience in Cape Coral FL, look no further than IL Primo Pizza & Wings!

#7 Jet’s Pizza

I’m not sure how they manage it, but the dough here is always so light and airy – like eating a pizza-flavored cloud! Plus, the sauce is that perfect balance of sweet and zesty that really brings out the flavor in the toppings.

The best part about Jet’s pizza is the variety of toppings available – from classic combos like pepperoni and mushroom to unique recipes like Grilled BBQ Chicken. No matter what your palate desires, Jet’s Pizza will have something for you!

My personal favorite pizza at Jet’s is their 8 Corner Pizza – with eight different slices loaded with cheese, meat, and veggies. It might sound intimidating to tackle such a large creation but trust me, it’s totally worth it!

Jet’s Pizza easily takes the cake as the best pizza in Cape Coral FL and definitely deserves my five star review. If you’re ever in town or just craving a delicious slice of pie, head to Jet’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!

#8 Joe Daddy’s Pizza

The presentation of their dishes is top notch. The pizza looks just like the pictures, with golden-brown crust and fresh ingredients that make your mouth water.

The flavor was amazing! I had a taste of the classic cheese pizza and it was definitely flavorful! Each bite was better than the last. The sauce was perfect, the cheese was melted to perfection, and the crust had just enough crunch that I wanted more.

As a food critic, I know how important it is to have an attentive staff which Joe Daddy’s Pizza provides. Our waiter answered every question we asked during our visit and made us feel welcome throughout our entire meal.

Overall, Joe Daddy’s Pizza is a great place for pizza lovers of all types – from those who love a classic cheese to more adventurous diners who prefer unique topping combinations. Everyone will find something to enjoy because they offer the best pizza in Cape Coral FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Fort Myers Beach!

#9 Chicago Pizza

This restaurant is an absolute gem. The atmosphere is cozy, with cozy booths and Italian decor that sets a perfect tone for enjoying a nice slice of pizza. The pizzas themselves were excellent — their signature Chicago deep-dish style was particularly great. The crust was buttery, the sauce had a hint of sweetness, and the cheese melted to perfection. Plus, they put creative toppings on their pizzas that really brought out the flavor!

The service at Chicago Pizza was also top-notch, with friendly staff and prompt service. My pizza arrived quickly, piping hot and delicious! To top it all off (literally!), I had some freshly made cannolis for dessert — which were divine!

In short, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Cape Coral FL, look no further than Chicago Pizza! With its amazing crusts, flavorful sauces and toppings, friendly staff and quick service — this restaurant should be your go-to spot for a fantastic meal.

#10 Lelulo’s

I’m not joking when I say the crust alone is worth trying out. The perfectly crunchy yet doughy texture combined with the perfect amount of seasoning makes it a pizza lover’s dream. You can tell they put an extra effort into ensuring the quality of their dough and it really shows in the taste.

The topping combinations are really something else too! I tried their famous Sausage Pepperoni Pizza, complete with fresh vegetables and sausage, as well as their Supreme Pizza with onions, black olives, green peppers, mushrooms and pepperoni. Both were absolutely delicious – so much so that I found myself getting seconds!

The atmosphere at Lelulo’s is just right to take your friends or family for a nice evening out. Friendly staff, a cozy dining area and good music combine for a great experience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Cape Coral FL, Lelulo’s is definitely the place to go. Delicious crusts, amazing toppings and a great atmosphere make this spot one of my favorites around town!

#11 Luciano’s Pizza

I was particularly impressed with the light and crispy crust, which had a nice crunchy texture that wasn’t too thin or thick. The sauce had just the right balance of sweetness and tanginess, while the cheese melted perfectly on top.

The toppings were fantastic as well – I tried the classic margherita pizza, which came loaded with fresh tomatoes, garlic and basil. Delicious!

Overall, Luciano’s Pizza has become my favorite pizza spot in Cape Coral FL. The staff is always friendly and accommodating, so if you’re ever in town I highly recommend checking them out for a great pizza experience!

#12 Cicis Pizza

I recently had the opportunity to sample some of their delicious pizzas, and I can honestly say that it was an experience like none other. The crust was perfectly chewy and crunchy, and the toppings were incredibly fresh. The combination of flavors really brought out the best in each bite.

The atmosphere at Cicis Pizza is also something worth noting. The restaurant is vibrant and inviting, with loud music playing in the background. It’s a fun place to hang out with friends while you enjoy a slice (or two!) of amazing pizza.

Overall, I have to say that Cicis Pizza has some of the best pizza in Cape Coral FL! They have an extensive menu full of delicious offerings, all made fresh for your enjoyment. So if you’re ever in town looking for a great pizza fix – this is definitely the spot to look for!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Chicago Pizza

Picture this: you walk into Chicago Pizza and are immediately overcome by the scent of bubbling cheese and the lively atmosphere. The first thing that caught my eye (and taste buds) was their impressive selection of hard liquor. Yes, you read that right – they serve alcohol! Nothing pairs better with a mouthwatering slice of pizza than a cold beer or a deliciously crafted cocktail.

But the wonders don’t stop there. Chicago Pizza also offers an array of decadent desserts. Who needs to worry about counting calories when you can indulge in a heavenly slice of tiramisu or a velvety chocolate lava cake? It’s like a party in your mouth, and you’ll be thanking them later.

Now, if you’re a sports enthusiast like myself, Chicago Pizza is the place to be. With TVs scattered all around, you won’t miss a second of the game while enjoying your perfect thin crust pizza. Plus, the friendly atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for tourists looking for a taste of local cuisine and a fun time.

The downside? Chicago Pizza does not accept reservations. So if you’re planning a special night out, be prepared to wait or arrive early. But trust me, it’s worth the inconvenience. The combination of their heavenly pizza, fantastic drinks, and electric ambiance will leave you craving more. So go ahead, take a bite, and let the flavors transport you straight to pizza paradise!