Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Carmel IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Indiana

Best Pizza in Carmel IN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

188 Views

I’m not one to shy away from a challenge, so when locals asked me to review the best pizza in town, I was more than happy to oblige. After sampling pizza from twelve venues around Carmel IN, I’m about to give you my verdict.

It’s time for some cheese-pulling fun! My taste buds have been through a work out – and there were some surprising results. Ready to dive in? Let’s get started on my journey through Carmel In’s best pizza spots!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana

#1 Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse

I stopped in for dinner and was not disappointed. The menu is varied, but I went with their classic margherita pizza and a local craft beer. The crust was cooked to perfection; not too thick, not too thin – the way a great pizza should be!

Toppings were fresh and flavorful. From the juicy tomatoes to the creamy mozzarella cheese, I could tell that great care was taken in creating this masterpiece of a pizza.

The atmosphere is also worth mentioning. As soon as you walk in, you’re transported to another world full of pizzas and beers from local brewers. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable about their food, making sure that my experience was an enjoyable one.

All in all, I would highly recommend stopping by Crafters Pizza & Drafthouse if you’re ever passing through Carmel IN – it’s undoubtedly the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Fishers!

#2 Bazbeaux Pizza (Carmel)

From the moment I walked into this establishment, I knew my taste buds were in for a treat. The staff was friendly and accommodating, offering me samples of their delicious specialty pizzas so I could make a well-informed decision.

The pizza itself was delectable! A crispy thin crust on the bottom with flavorful toppings, perfect chewy melted cheese and just the right amount of sauce. It’s no wonder they’ve been in business since 1986; their recipes are tried and true!

The atmosphere at Bazbeaux is also top-notch. An eclectic mix of vintage decor and modern touches when it comes to the layout and furniture make for a truly unique dining experience. And let’s not forget about the wide selection of craft beers, wines and cocktails to enjoy with your meal!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Carmel IN (or really anywhere!), you owe it to yourself to check out Bazbeaux Pizza. Not only will you get an amazing meal, but you’ll also have a great time along the way!

#3 Blaze Pizza

From the moment I stepped foot into this restaurant, I knew that this would be a pizza experience like no other. The atmosphere was both relaxed and inviting, and I could tell that the staff truly cared about providing an exceptional experience.

The menu choices were extensive, making it difficult to choose just one type of pizza. Everything from classic combinations to some daringly new creations were offered, so I decided to try out a few! The first was their signature “Blaze Pizza,” which had a delicious mix of sausage and peppers with mozzarella cheese. It was flavorful yet not too greasy, as it had been carefully cooked in their wood-fired ovens. The second slice was the “Spicy Chorizo,” which was packed with flavor. The combination of spicy chorizo sausage and melted pepper jack cheese on top of the dough ensured that my taste buds wouldn’t get bored!

Overall, my experience at Blaze Pizza was excellent – from the atmosphere to the quality of their food – and they certainly deserve recognition for being one of the best pizza restaurants in Carmel IN. So next time you’re looking for a delicious dinner option, don’t hesitate to check out Blaze Pizza!

#4 Pies & Pints – Carmel, IN

The atmosphere at Pies & Pints is lively yet cozy; perfect for a casual meal with family, friends, or even just by yourself. The restaurant was bustling on my visit, but the staff were all very welcoming and friendly.

The menu offerings are diverse and creative, featuring classic pizzas as well as some more unique options. I chose the Grilled BBQ Chicken Pizza, which was an excellent choice! The crust was thin and crisp with just the right amount of char from the grill and the toppings were succulent and flavorful.

I also sampled their garlic bread sticks which went perfectly with my pizza – crunchy on the outside with plenty of buttery garlic goodness inside.

Overall, I have to say that Pies & Pints has some of the best pizza in Carmel IN! I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for great quality food in a relaxed atmosphere.

#5 Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop

The restaurant has a cozy and laid-back vibe, which is a nice contrast to other places that try too hard with their decor. The pizza makers are super friendly and genuinely want to make sure you have the best experience.

I recently tried their signature “Greek Tony’s Perfect Pie” – it was honestly one of the tastiest pizzas I’ve ever had, anywhere! It was loaded up with Greek spiced toppings like tomatoes, olives, feta cheese and spinach. Each bite melted in my mouth and it definitely lived up to its name – perfect!

Their traditional Italian recipes add something extra special to the pizzas that I couldn’t find anywhere else. But their subs are fantastic too! Their handcrafted Italian heroes include fresh baked bread, classic Italian flavors and top-notch quality ingredients.

I can confidently say that Greek Tony’s Pizza & Sub Shop has some of the best pizza in Carmel IN! Whether you’re just stopping by for a quick bite or looking for somewhere special to share with friends – this family owned business should definitely be at the top of your list!

#6 Greek’s Pizzeria West Carmel

I was not expecting much at first, but upon entering Greek’s I was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere reminded me of an Italian trattoria in the heart of Rome – authentic and cozy.

The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, informing us about the various pizza options available. The menu offered a wide selection of thin-crust specialty pies as well as more traditional pizzas like Neapolitan and New York style pies. After careful consideration, we decided on a vegan pizza with artichoke hearts and mushrooms.

Our pizza arrived quickly and at first glance we were impressed! The cheese was melted to perfection, the toppings were plentiful, and the crust had just enough char for a delightful crunch. Every bite tasted like a journey to Italy–it was truly the best pizza in Carmel IN!

In conclusion, I highly recommend Greek’s Pizzeria West Carmel if you’re ever in town looking for great pizza – they certainly have earned their reputation as one of the best pizzerias in town!

#7 Puccini’s Pizza Pasta-Carmel

If you love a thin crust and plenty of cheese, Puccini’s is the place! Their hand-tossed pizzas are a delicious blend of Italian herbs, special sauces, and generous toppings that will make your mouth water. And their pasta dishes? Absolutely divine!

The atmosphere at Puccini’s is the real showstopper. I’ve been to pizzerias all around the world, but this one takes it up a notch with its romantic decor and cozy seating. It’s perfect for an intimate dinner or an evening out with friends.

But forget about the ambiance–the pizza itself is enough to blow anyone away! The crusts are so crispy and light that they almost melt in your mouth. The sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and tang before giving way to gooey cheese and flavorful toppings like fennel sausage, roasted bell peppers, and pepperoni.

I can confidently say that Puccini’s has some of the best pizza in Carmel IN. Whether you’re looking for a slice on the go or a full meal experience, this spot will not disappoint!

#8 Mellow Mushroom Carmel

The restaurant itself has a great atmosphere and fantastic decor, with a lighthearted, mellow vibe that puts you at ease the moment you walk in. You can tell they take their pizza making seriously though – their menu is filled with all sorts of beloved specialties and unique specialty pizzas, so everyone can find something to love.

The pizza itself is truly top-notch, made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection every time. The crust has just the right amount of crispness and the tangy sauce adds an extra layer of flavor without overpowering the toppings. They offer all sorts of creative topping combinations, from classic favorites like pepperoni, to more inventive options like pineapple & jalapeño. The quality of the ingredients is always top notch and it’s definitely worth trying out some new combinations!

My favorite part about Mellow Mushroom Carmel is that there’s always something fun happening – from live music nights to trivia nights and more! There’s never a dull moment here – even if you’re not in the mood for pizza you’ll still have a good time! Plus, be sure to ask about their daily drink specials – they often feature local craft beers that pair perfectly with their pizzas.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Carmel IN then look no further than Mellow Mushroom Carmel! From great food and drinks to fun events and friendly staff, there’s nothing not to love here!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Noblesville!

#9 Pizzology

I have to start with the drinks – they offer a full bar AND hard liquor, which is great if you want to pair your pizza with something special. I also appreciated that there was a kid’s menu for the little ones and plenty of vegetarian options for my plant-based friends.

It’s also an awesome spot to watch sports, as there are TVs everywhere! This made it really fun when we were eating together and cheering on our favorite teams.

And while they don’t offer delivery (which is unfortunate), their food more than makes up for it. The pizzas far exceeded my expectations! The crust was so light and fluffy, and the toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful. My crew absolutely loved it – especially the dessert pizza!

In short, Pizzology serves up some of the best pizza in Carmel IN – whether you’re looking for something special or just some classic comfort food. Highly recommend!

#10 Greek’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere of Greek’s Pizzeria is great. I felt like I was actually in Greece the second I stepped in the door. The staff were friendly and welcoming, and they went out of their way to make sure that my experience was a good one.

Now, on to the pizza. It was spectacular! The crust was thin, yet flavorful and cooked just right. The sauce had that slightly sweet taste that I love in a pizza sauce, with plenty of herbs to bring out some wonderful flavors. And the cheese – it was incredibly creamy and melted perfectly with all of the other toppings. But what really sold me on this place? The toppings! Every ingredient tasted fresh and flavorful, from the pepperoni to the feta cheese. I could tell that each topping was carefully selected to give you an absolute flavor explosion in your mouth!

All things considered, Greek’s Pizzeria is well worth a visit for anyone who enjoys good pizza. In my opinion, it’s one of the best places for pizza in Carmel IN!

#11 Pizza King

The crust is perfectly cooked, fluffy and light on the inside with a pleasant crunch on the outside. The sauce is delicately spiced and its sweet notes pair nicely with the robust cheeses used for each pie. My favorite is the Vegetarian Supreme: it’s packed full of delicious vegetables that are surprisingly fresh and vibrant.

The service here at Pizza King is always friendly, helpful, and quick to bring out your pizza order. Not to mention there’s even a personal greeting from the owner when you walk in! I also love their atmosphere – it feels like an Italian family pizza house with the smell of fresh-made dough in the air.

Overall, I can confidently say that Pizza King offers some of the best pizza in Carmel IN – highly recommended if you’re looking to satisfy your pizza cravings!

#12 Jet’s Pizza

I’ll be honest, I wasn’t expecting much when my friends recommended Jet’s Pizza. After all, how good could pizza from Carmel IN actually be? Boy, was I wrong!

I started with the 6 Corner Deep Dish Pizza and my taste buds were very pleasantly surprised. The crust was crispy and delicious, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was gooey and melt-in-your-mouth delicious. It was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time.

The staff at Jet’s Pizza was also extremely friendly and helpful. They went out of their way to make sure that we had everything that we needed to enjoy our meal.

If you’re ever in Carmel IN, do yourself a favor and stop by Jet’s Pizza for some of the best pizza in town. You won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

Let me start by saying that if you’re looking for a place that accepts reservations, you might want to steer clear of Lou Malnati’s. It’s like trying to get a table at a Jonas Brothers reunion tour – nearly impossible! But hey, who needs reservations when you can have a guaranteed wait time? It’s like a game show, except instead of winning cash, you win a heaping slice of cheesy goodness.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza. Oh my crust, it is an absolute masterpiece! The deep dish is so deep, it’s like a bottomless pit of cheesy delight. Each bite is like a warm, comforting hug from a long-lost Italian aunt. And even though I’m not a vegetarian (sorry, vegetarians), they do have some veggie options that even a carnivore like me can appreciate. The roasted vegetable and goat cheese pizza? Delizioso!

And let’s not forget about the dessert. Lou Malnati’s knows how to end a meal on a sweet note. The Nutella pizza, my friends, is a creative stroke of genius. It’s like someone had a dream about Nutella dancing with a pizza crust, and then they made that dream a reality. It’s gooey, chocolatey, and utterly sinful. You might need to roll yourself out of the restaurant after indulging, but it will be worth it.

In conclusion, if you’re willing to brave the no-reservation policy, Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is well worth the wait. The deep dish pizza is legendary, the vegetarian options are surprisingly delicious, and the dessert will make you forget about counting calories. Just make sure to wear your stretchy pants, because you’re going to need them!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Blaze Pizza

First of all, let’s talk about the benefits of this awesome pizza joint. They have not only a few, but some vegetarian options! As a traveling food critic, I can’t tell you how many times I’ve shown up at a pizza place only to discover they only serve meat lover’s pizzas. I mean, come on, where’s the love for us veggie enthusiasts? But Blaze Pizza understands our plight and offers some delicious, veggie-packed pies.

But wait, there’s more! They also have desserts! Because let’s be real, what’s a pizza feast without indulging in a sweet treat afterwards? So, don’t forget to save room for their mouthwatering dessert options. Trust me, you won’t regret it.

Now, it’s worth mentioning that Blaze Pizza doesn’t accept reservations. So if you’re a planner like me, you might find this slightly annoying. But fear not, my fellow pizza enthusiasts! You can turn this downside into an opportunity and make a fun tourist spot out of it. Grab your fellow foodies, head down to Blaze Pizza, and embrace the thrill of the unknown as you wait in anticipation for a table. It’s like a pizza adventure!

In conclusion, with its vegetarian options, dessert menu, and the excitement of not knowing when you’ll actually get a table, Blaze Pizza is hands down the best thin crust pizza place in Carmel. Trust me, I’m a world-traveling pizza connoisseur, so you know I wouldn’t steer you wrong. So grab your appetite and head on over to Blaze Pizza for a taste of pizza heaven!