Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Cedar Falls (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Iowa

Best Pizza in Cedar Falls (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

86 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all around the world, and for my latest tasting tour, I decided to check out what Cedar Falls had to offer. After hitting up 12 pizza places in town, I’ve found some delicious concoctions that are sure to please any palate.

I’m here to tell you about the best of the best – which pizzas are worth driving across town for? Read on to find out! With a lighthearted but critical eye, I can help you decide which pies will be sure to satisfy your cravings.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Iowa

#1 Cedar Falls Brown Bottle

The pizza dough was cooked to perfection and had a delightful crunch. The sauce was full of flavor and the perfect amount of cheese blanketed each slice. No matter what topping combination you might choose, you can’t go wrong with something from Cedar Falls Brown Bottle.

I especially enjoyed the atmosphere of this restaurant – it has a cozy charm that made me feel right at home. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable and seemed genuinely interested in my opinion of the pizza. I felt like I could trust them to serve me delicious food that was made with quality ingredients.

Overall, Cedar Falls Brown Bottle is an ideal spot for a great pizza experience. From its scrumptious slices to its inviting atmosphere, all signs point to some of the best pizza in Cedar Falls!

If you’re willing to go an extra 54 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Cedar Rapids!

#2 The Other Place

The Other Place definitely lives up to its local reputation. The pizza here is always scrumptious and the atmosphere is relaxed and inviting. It’s a great spot to take a break from your adventures and chow down on some of the tastiest pies in town.

Aside from their signature pizzas, they have an extensive menu featuring other Italian classics like calzones, focaccias, pastas, and salads. But what really sets this restaurant apart from the rest is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients. Every slice tastes fresh and flavourful – there’s no artificial preservatives or fillers in anything!

On top of that, the staff are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about their food. It’s clear that they take pride in what they do, which just makes every bite more enjoyable.

Whether you’re looking for a classic pepperoni or something more unique like BBQ chicken pizza with balsamic glaze, The Other Place should be your go-to spot for delicious pies. There’s simply no other option for getting the best pizza in Cedar Falls!

#3 Wild Hare American Bar & Grill

I could tell that the restaurant put a lot of thought into the crust as it was perfectly crisp on the outside yet still soft and chewy inside. The topping selection is also impressive, from classic cheese to pepperoni to even pineapple! Plus, you can’t go wrong with their unique BBQ chicken pizza.

The atmosphere at Wild Hare American Bar & Grill is also top-notch. It’s actually quite spacious, and there are TVs playing sports games all around – perfect for watching your favorite team while enjoying a slice. The waitstaff was extremely friendly and attentive. They checked in frequently to make sure my experience was enjoyable and the food came hot and fresh out of the oven each time.

If I’m ever in Cedar Falls again, I’ll definitely be returning to Wild Hare American Bar & Grill for more of their delicious pizzas! It honestly might be one of the best pizza places I’ve been to in my travels!

#4 Double Tap (Tap Tap)

It was well worth making the trip here to sample their delightful pies. The crust was thin and crunchy and the toppings were freshly cut and incredibly flavorful. I couldn’t believe it for a small-town joint like this!

My favorite thing about Double Tap (Tap Tap) is that they don’t just serve pizza but also serve alcohol, including hard liquor! A pizza restaurant with drinks? Now that’s something special. It makes this place a great spot for tourists looking to grab a bite and relax.

The only downside here is that there’s no delivery option. You’ll need to take the time come by in person if you want to get your hands on some of their deliciousness. That being said, it’s definitely worth it!

In short, I can say with complete confidence Double Tap (Tap Tap) has some of the best pizza in Cedar Falls – maybe even the entire state! So if you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by and grab one of their flavorful pizzas. You won’t regret it!

#5 Urban Pie

I visited the restaurant with high expectations and was amazed at what I found. The atmosphere was cheerful and inviting; it was evident from the moment I stepped through the door that this place takes pizza seriously.

The menu was full of unique flavors, like the BBQ bacon cheeseburger pizza and the “Urban Pie-t” – a thin crust with a variety of toppings like pepperoni, ham, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers – that make it hard to decide which one to order! Even though I’m normally a traditionalist when it comes to pizza, I decided to be adventurous and try something different.

The staff at Urban Pie were friendly and attentive throughout my visit. They made sure that I had all the condiments and sides I needed for my meal.

But the real star of this establishment is their pizzas. The crust is thin but not overly so, allowing for a nice crunch in every bite. The toppings are flavorful and fresh – especially with my chosen topping combination! All in all, it was an amazing experience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Cedar Falls then look no further than Urban Pie! Deliciously creative flavors, excellent customer service, and amazing presentation make them one of my favorite spots for great pizza!

#6 Chad’s Pizza & Restaurant

The pizza is cooked to perfection – with a thin and crunchy yet still soft crust and the perfect combination of sauces and toppings, I guarantee that you won’t find a tastier slice around.

The atmosphere at Chad’s Pizza is also something to take note of – it’s family friendly, but also has a bit of an edge. You can relax in the comfortable chairs and watch the sports game on their flat screen TVs while you wait for your meal.

Not only does Chad’s Pizza have the best pizza in Cedar Falls, but they also offer a variety of other dishes. I especially enjoyed their crispy wings, which were slathered in a spicy garlic sauce that was absolutely delectable.

I’m so glad I had the chance to experience Chad’s Pizza & Restaurant first-hand, as it was one of the most enjoyable food experiences I’ve ever had! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cedar Falls, this is definitely the spot!

#7 Other Place

I visited Other Place on a Thursday evening. With its vintage decor, warm ambiance and close proximity to the local brewery, it was obvious why this family-owned restaurant was so popular.

When I stepped up to order my pizza, I could see why they’ve earned such a stellar reputation. The toppings were fresh, the crust was perfectly cooked and the sauce had just enough tang to make me smile.

The best part of my experience, however, was the service. The wait staff welcomed me like an old friend and made sure my every need was taken care of. Plus, they have a selection of local craft beers so I could enjoy an ice cold one while waiting for my pie!

To sum it up: if you’re looking for the best pizza in Cedar Falls then look no further than Other Place. From their delicious pizzas to their friendly service, it’s certainly worth going out of your way for a visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 69 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Ames!

#8 Godfather’s Pizza

When I walked in, I was met with a happy staff ready to serve up some delicious pizzas. The atmosphere was fun and inviting – it felt like an authentic Italian pizzeria! The music was great, and the décor of classic pop culture artwork added a unique touch.

The pizza options were truly something special. From veggie pies to classic pepperoni choices, there’s something for everyone here. I tried a few different styles and they all had amazing flavor and texture. The secret lies in the dough they use – you can tell it’s made fresh daily because it tastes so good!

I also recommend trying their salads – they’re delicious too! The variety is impressive, and the dressing pairs perfectly with every type of salad you could imagine.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cedar Falls, Godfather’s Pizza definitely deserves top billing! Whether you’re looking for classic Italian flavors or something a bit out of the ordinary, this restaurant has you covered.

#9 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

First off, the selection here is amazing. They have all sorts of specialty pies, like mac and cheese pizza, bacon cheeseburger pizza, and even a veggie delite. Plus, they have all the classic options like pepperoni and cheese.

The crust is always perfectly cooked and always just the right thickness. The sauce has the perfect hint of sweetness to it that really makes all their pizzas stand out from the rest. And their toppings are always wonderfully fresh!

As for customer service, I’ve never had one bad experience in any of my visits. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their products as well as accommodating to special requests.

In sum, I would highly recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza for anyone looking for delicious pizza in Cedar Falls – it’s definitely among the best the city has to offer!

#10 Casey’s

I’m always impressed by the atmosphere at Casey’s. It’s got an old-school pizzeria feel that immediately transports me to my childhood days when I would drag my brother there for a slice and a Coke. The staff is friendly and attentive, which is always appreciated.

As for the pizza itself, it never disappoints! The crust is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of seasoning. The sauce is savory and flavorful, and the cheese melts perfectly. Every topping I’ve tried has been fresh and delicious, whether it’s classic pepperoni, spinach, or sausage. And let me tell you their special house blend of herbs and spices that goes on top? Divine!

Overall I can safely say Casey’s serves up some of the best pizza in Cedar Falls. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a full family dinner, you won’t be disappointed here!

#11 Tony’s La Pizzeria

A relaxing atmosphere, friendly staff, and an even friendlier chef make Tony’s the perfect place to enjoy a slice of ‘za. The pizza itself was some of the best I’ve ever tasted. Thin crust, crisp veggies, and flavorful cheese that melted in my mouth – it’s like a little piece of Italy brought straight to Iowa!

And let’s not forget about their $5 lunch special: Two slices and a fountain drink for five bucks? It doesn’t get any better than that!

When it comes down to it, if you’re looking for delicious pizza in Cedar Falls, Tony’s La Pizzeria is your best bet. You might not be able to travel all over the world to taste the different styles of pizza out there, but Tony’s will make you feel like you did!

#12 Pizza Ranch

I was tremendously impressed by the restaurant’s extensive buffet, offering a wide variety of pizzas to please even the most discerning palate. From classic pepperoni and cheese to specialty varieties such as Mexican-style pizza with jalapeños and chicken fajita pizza, there’s something for everyone.

But what really makes Pizza Ranch stand out is its delicious crust. That thin but not too thin base is just perfect – crisp on the outside yet chewy on the inside – and gives each bite a burst of flavor that will have you coming back for more!

To top it all off, Pizza Ranch also offers an impressive selection of sides which includes garlic breadsticks, mozzarella sticks, and loaded potato skins. Not to mention that their salad bar has about everything you could want in a side dish!

Overall, I’d rate Pizza Ranch an A+, easily the best pizza in Cedar Falls!