Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Central FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Central FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

78 Views

I’m sure I’ve had better pizza elsewhere around the world, but in Central FL, these 12 pizza places really deliver. I thought it was high time to share my findings with the world.

So what you’ll find in this article is a humorous and lighthearted review of 12 of the best pizza places in Central FL. Whether you’re a native Floridian or just visiting, get ready for some serious pizza-tasting action!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Brad’s Underground Pizzeria

Upon entering, the first thing I noticed was the eclectic decor — it’s like entering a pizza-lovers secret hideaway. But what really made me take notice was the amazing aroma of freshly-baked pizzas wafting through the air!

The menu is heaven for pizza lovers. You can customize your own pies, or choose from one of their signature creations. I recommend trying the Meat Lover’s Pie — it will satisfy even the pickiest of palates with its mix of pepperoni, sausage, bacon and ham.

The crust is just as important as all those tasty toppings and Brad’s knows it. The dough is made fresh every morning and you can tell that the chefs here are passionate about crafting the perfect slice (pardon me while I wipe away a tear!). It’s crispy on the outside and tender in the middle — just how a pizza should be!

To top it off (get it?), Brad’s also has an impressive selection of craft beers to accompany your savory experience.

If you’re looking for some truly delicious pizza in Central FL, Brad’s Underground Pizzeria deserves to be at the top of your list!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Oviedo!

#2 1803 Pizza / Kitchen

I went to this restaurant on a whim, hungry and looking for something special. I wasn’t disappointed! From the moment I stepped through the door, it was obvious that 1803 Pizza / Kitchen took their pizza seriously. The decor was perfect and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable.

But, of course, the most important thing is the pizza! And let me tell you, 1803 Pizza / Kitchen has some amazing slices! The crust is perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They put just enough sauce to give it a great flavor without overpowering it. And their toppings are fresh and tasty – no canned vegetables or sub-par ingredients here!

If you’re looking for an excellent pizza in Central FL, you won’t be disappointed with 1803 Pizza / Kitchen. It’s definitely one of my top choices for best pizza around!

#3 Pizza Xtreme

I arrived at the restaurant and was immediately overwhelmed by the inviting atmosphere. The walls were adorned with brightly colored Italian images, classic photos of Italy’s most beloved spots, and a large mural of an Italian landscape.

The menu lived up to the same high standards as the decor. There was a wide variety of pizzas to choose from, including some unique specialty pies. I ordered the “New York” pizza, because I love traditional NY-style slices and was not disappointed. The crust was perfectly crisp yet still tender and chewy—it was clear that they use quality ingredients here. No skimping on anything!

The toppings were unbelievably delicious too; large chunks of sweet tomato sauce and generous doses of cheese and pepperoni that all combined into a heavenly flavor experience. Plus, it wasn’t overly greasy or heavy—just full of amazing flavors!

To top off my experience, the staff were incredibly friendly and attentive throughout my meal. They even surprised me with a complimentary slice for dessert (which tasted equally as good as my entrée!).

I can honestly say that Pizza Xtreme has some of the best pizza in Central FL—or anywhere else for that matter! Each bite had me dreaming about returning one day for another taste…and maybe I will soon!

#4 Lazy Moon Pizza

My first time there I was absolutely floored by the quality of the pizza. The crust was perfectly crisp and chewy at the same time, the sauce was well-balanced with a hint of sweetness, and the cheese had just enough tanginess to make it stand out from all other pizzas. The toppings were plentiful and flavorsome–I couldn’t have asked for more!

I also really appreciated their friendly staff and lively atmosphere. Not only did they make me feel welcomed, but they also made sure that my pizza order was cooked to perfection. Every single slice tasted like it had just been taken out of the oven.

All in all, I’m giving Lazy Moon Pizza five stars! If you’re searching for some of the best pizza in Central FL, then look no further than Lazy Moon Pizza. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#5 Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere is great and their menu offers something for everyone. Vegetarians have some options, there’s a kid’s menu for the little ones, and if you’re in the mood for a drink, they even serve alcohol!

However, no delivery means you have to make the trip out to see them. But it’ll be worth it. Their pizza is outstanding. The crust is crispy on the outside and soft in the middle, and the toppings are just delicious – plus they offer dessert so you can finish off your meal with something sweet!

All-in-all, I’d highly recommend Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant as one of the best pizzas in Central FL. I’m sure once you try it out, you’ll agree!

#6 Muzzarella Pizza and Italian Kitchen

Of course, the atmosphere leaves something to be desired – it’s a bit old-fashioned and stuffy. But that doesn’t matter when you’ve got amazing pizza! Their signature pies feature a delicious variety of flavorful toppings plus a perfectly thin crust. One bite, and you won’t want to leave!

The staff at Muzzarella Pizza are also super friendly, which I always appreciate. They seem to genuinely enjoy working here and making sure everyone enjoys their food. Plus, they’re always so accommodating with any requests or modifications I make to my order.

In my opinion, nothing in Central FL compares to the quality of pizza you’ll find at Muzzarella Pizza. Whether you like classic cheese or something more out there like BBQ chicken – they’ve got it all! I’d highly recommend giving them a try if you’re looking for the best pizza around.

#7 The Corner Pizza Bar

I’m talking about a thick and chewy crust, generous toppings, and creamy cheese all cooked in a wood-fired oven that gives it just the right amount of smokiness. Every bite was like pure bliss!

My favorite pizza was the Sausage & Onion. The sweet onions complemented the sausage perfectly, and I could taste every ingredient in perfect harmony. And you can tell they put lots of love into each slice because it had just the right amount of seasoning.

The staff at The Corner Pizza Bar could not have been nicer or more welcoming. From my first bite to my last, they made sure I was having a great time – even offering me an occasional beer on the house!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Central FL then look no further than The Corner Pizza Bar. Delicious pizza, friendly staff, and a great atmosphere – what more could you want!?

#8 NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

I visited the restaurant recently, and was really impressed. The atmosphere inside is comfortable, but with a hint of energy that comes from watching all the talented pizza makers at work behind the counter.

The pies were incredible. From the thin-crust to deep-dish options, there’s something for everyone here. The cheese is rich and creamy and the toppings are plentiful and flavorful. They must be using some secret spices that I can’t figure out as it tastes like nothing else I’ve had before!

On top of great pizza, they also have some unique side dishes. They have a unique selection of salads, wings, garlic knots and even fried mozzarella sticks that you won’t find anywhere else.

Next time you’re in Central FL looking for great pizza, make sure to check out NYPD Pizza Lake Cay – you won’t regret it! It’s easily the best pizza in Central FL!

If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Altamonte Springs!

#9 Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria

The atmosphere of the restaurant is quaint and inviting. It feels like home. The staff are very friendly, always eager to answer any questions you may have about the food or drink selections.

Their pizza is fantastic! The crust is thin and crisp, with a light garlic flavor. The sauce is flavorsome and not too spicy. As for toppings – everything from mushrooms and peppers to salami and onions – it’s all just delicious!

When I visited, I even tried their spaghetteria dishes, which were equally as delicious. Their pasta dishes are cooked al dente, just how they should be.

Overall, Tartini Pizzeria & Spaghetteria is a great place to get your fix of Italian comfort food. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Central FL, then this is definitely the place to go!

#10 Pie Fection

The restaurant itself has a great atmosphere that is cozy and inviting. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to offer advice on what to try. But most importantly, their pizza is absolutely delicious!

I sampled several different kinds of pies, from classic cheese and pepperoni to zesty white pizza with garlic and ricotta. Each one had its own unique flavor profile and the crust was perfect – light, crispy in spots, yet still chewy in others. No matter how much I ate, I wanted more!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Central FL, Pie Fection is the place to go. I highly recommend it to anyone who’s craving something out of this world.

#11 Mario’s Pizza

I stumbled upon this place while on the hunt for a quick slice. The second I stepped in, the smell of freshly baked dough and homemade tomato sauce filled my nostrils. My mouth began to salivate as I made my way to the counter.

The service was fast and friendly, which is always a plus in my book. After ordering a slice of their classic pepperoni pizza, I settled in at one of the tables. It didn’t take long before my order arrived steaming hot with a side of fresh parmesan cheese.

One bite and all doubts about Mario’s Pizza vanished from my mind – this pizza was absolutely delicious! The crust was thin yet crisp and had just the right amount of chewiness. The tomato sauce was cooked perfectly, with a sweet flavor that complimented the generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese. Lastly, topping it off were the slices of pepperoni that provided just enough zing to keep me coming back for more!

If you’re ever in Central FL looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Mario’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting and cozy. With its brick ovens and simple decor, it felt like I was eating pizza in Italy!

From the moment I bit into my first slice of their signature coal fired pizza, I knew I had stumbled upon a gem. The crust was so thin and crisp but still managed to hold all of the tasty toppings that were piled high. The cheese was perfectly melted and the sauce was just right – not too sweet, not too tangy.

I also tried an order of their wings that were literally falling off the bone. They weren’t terribly spicy but they had a nice kick to them that cut through the richness of the pizza nicely.

I can easily say that Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings has some of the best pizza in Central FL! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by for a slice (or two!)

Best Deep Dish Pizza – UNO Pizzeria & Grill

Now, I must admit, I’ve had my fair share of deep dish pizzas. I’ve climbed Mount Cheese and swam in a sea of tomato sauce. But UNO Pizzeria & Grill truly takes the cake, or should I say, the crust!

Walking into UNO, I was greeted by the scent of freshly baked dough and melted cheese, and my stomach started doing a happy dance. I knew I was in for a treat. I sat down, ready to embark on a deep dish adventure.

When the pizza arrived at my table, I couldn’t believe my eyes. It was like staring at a work of art. The crust was so thick and flaky, I almost mistook it for a pillow. And the cheese… oh, the cheese! It was gooey and stretchy, like a cheese lover’s dream come true.

With each bite, I could taste the love and care that went into making this masterpiece. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. It was like a party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

Now, let’s not forget about the size. This pizza was massive! I could barely finish a slice without feeling like I was about to give birth to a food baby. But trust me, it was worth every bite.

So, if you find yourself in Orlando and craving a deep dish pizza that will knock your socks off, head over to UNO Pizzeria & Grill. Your taste buds will thank you, and your pants may never forgive you.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Brick & Fire Pizza

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was about to embark on a culinary adventure. The smell of freshly baked pizza hit me like a delicious punch in the face (in a good way, of course). As I took my seat, I couldn’t help but admire the brick ovens that stood proudly in the open kitchen, like ancient pizza deities watching over their worshippers.

As I perused the menu, my taste buds started dancing in anticipation. With toppings ranging from classic pepperoni to exotic prosciutto and arugula, there was something for every pizza lover. I decided to go for their signature Margherita pizza, a timeless classic that is always the true test of a great pizzeria.

When my pizza arrived, I was in awe. The crust was thin and crispy, yet somehow managed to hold the weight of the generous cheese and sauce. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, the tanginess of the tomatoes complemented perfectly by the creamy mozzarella. As I savored each bite, I could almost hear the Mwah of an Italian chef kissing his fingers in approval.

To top it all off, the service at Brick & Fire Pizza was top-notch. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure my dining experience was nothing short of fantastic. They even offered me a free cannoli for dessert, because who can resist a crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese?

If you find yourself in Orlando craving a pizza experience that will transport you to Italy, look no further than Brick & Fire Pizza. Trust me, their thin crust pizza is no joke. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to plan my next trip back for round two. Ciao!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Brick & Fire Pizza

Upon walking into the restaurant, I was greeted by the delightful smell of smoky goodness. The aroma immediately transported me to a rustic Italian countryside, where pizzas are made with love and passion. Or maybe it was just the fact that I hadn’t showered in days, but who’s keeping track?

As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I’ve had my fair share of disappointment. So when the waiter brought out the crispy Neapolitan-style pizza, I held my breath in anticipation. The first bite, my friends, was like a party in my mouth. The crust was perfectly charred, with just the right amount of chewiness. All the while, the flavors exploded in a symphony of tomato, cheese, and whatever the hell else they put on it. I didn’t care, I was too busy dancing with joy.

What truly sets Brick & Fire Pizza apart from the other joints is their creativity with toppings. I mean, who would’ve thought that smoked salmon and pineapple could work so well together? It was like a decadent ocean and tropical paradise colliding in my mouth. Truly a match made in pizza heaven, or at least, pizza purgatory.

The staff at Brick & Fire Pizza also deserves a shoutout. They were attentive, friendly, and had a wonderful sense of humor as they witnessed me inhaling every slice like a starving velociraptor. They even played along when I asked if I could order a pizza in the shape of Mickey Mouse. I didn’t really care if they tried to kill me by making me eat one of those monstrous ears, it would have been worth it for the Instagram likes alone.

So, if you find yourself in Orlando and craving some incredible wood fired pizza, head to Brick & Fire Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and your arteries will curse you, but hey, life is all about finding a good balance, right?