Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Central OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Central OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

155 Views

I’ve been all over the world, trying delectable pizza from Rome to Tokyo. But I’m here to tell you Central OH’s pizza is up for the challenge against some of the best spots in the world.

After a full day of tasting and judging 12 pizza places in Central OH, I’m excited to share with you my top picks for the best pizza around! This list is sure to have something that will tantalize your taste buds and keep smiles on everyone’s faces.

So buckle up, grab a slice (or two) and let’s explore what Central OH has to offer!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 East Coast Pizzeria

My recent visit to East Coast Pizzeria was a delightful surprise. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with wooden tables and a large brick oven in the back. The pizza master greeted me by name as soon as I walked in, proving their commitment to personal customer service.

I ordered the house favorite—a classic pepperoni and cheese pie made with their signature red sauce. When the pizza arrived at my table, it looked like it had just been delivered from the heavens! Every layer was perfectly cooked: the cheese was deliciously melted and gooey, while the crust had just enough crunch on the outside with a soft pillow-y texture inside. The flavors were so divine that I’m still dreaming about that pizza days later!

In conclusion, East Coast Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Central OH—it’s truly worth the trip if you’re looking for an unforgettable dining experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Columbus!

#2 The Pizza House

I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza, and let me tell you, it’s outta this world. The cheese was perfectly melted, the sausage was cooked to perfection, and the combination of flavors had my taste buds dancing for joy.

The crust was also top-notch. It was crispy on the outside and soft in the middle — exactly how I like it! Not to mention that it held up well even when it got really hot from all that delicious sauce.

The best part is that they have an outdoor patio with seating if you prefer to dine outside while enjoying your pizza. Plus, they usually have live music playing in the evenings so you can enjoy some tunes while munching on your pie.

To sum things up, The Pizza House is hands down the best pizza place in Central OH. If you’re ever in town and looking to satisfy your craving for some Italian goodness then look no further because they can’t be beat!

#3 GoreMade Pizza

The first thing I noticed as soon as I stepped in the door was the smell of fresh-baked pizza. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and I could tell right away that this place was going to be special.

When my pizza arrived, it looked amazing! The crust was perfectly thin, yet still had a nice crispness to it. The toppings were plentiful and flavorful – just the way they should be. Of course, they also had their signature “gore-infused” sauces that made my taste buds sing.

The service at GoreMade Pizza was top notch too! Everyone was friendly, accommodating and knowledgeable about their products. Plus – bonus points for being able to recommend some great local beers to pair with my meal!

All in all, I can confidently say that if you’re looking for the best pizza in Central OH, then look no further than GoreMade Pizza. Delicious food, great service – what more could you ask for?

#4 Mama Nancy’s Pizza

As soon as I walked in, the tantalizing aroma of freshly-baked pizza dough and Italian spices filled the air. Upon ordering, my pizza was cooked to perfection with a crunchy crust and a perfectly balanced mix of cheese and toppings.

The atmosphere at Mama Nancy’s Pizza is inviting and cozy; I felt like I was family. The outdoor patio made for an idyllic spot to savor my delicious slice—I enjoyed the sound of bells ringing from a nearby church steeple, which added to the ambience.

The service at Mama Nancy’s Pizza was great too; it wasn’t too long before my piping hot pizza arrived at my table. The server was both friendly and knowledgeable about the menu offerings. I thoroughly enjoyed every bite of my pizza!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Central OH, then look no more—Mama Nancy’s Pizza is it!

#5 Emelio’s Restaurant

From the cozy atmosphere to the delectable creations, Emelio’s really stands out from the crowd. The menu is packed with unique options that will tantalize your taste buds. I was particularly impressed by their delicious pies, which are made to perfection with fresh ingredients.

The pizza crusts were perfect – crunchy but not too hard and just the right amount of cheese. The toppings were top-notch – a wide range of vegetables, meats and cheeses, all cooked to perfection. Even more impressive was the sauce – an incredibly flavorful mix that added an extra level of depth to every bite.

Overall, I would highly recommend Emelio’s Restaurant as the best pizza spot in Central OH! Delicious food plus a fantastic atmosphere make this restaurant well worth your time and money.

#6 Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

The pizza here is so delicious it will make you feel like you’ve taken a trip to Little Italy. The crust is perfectly thin, crispy and flavorful. The generous amounts of freshly grated cheese and toppings make for a truly mouthwatering experience.

And don’t even get me started on the amazing staff at Adriatico’s! They were so friendly, knowledgeable and helpful when I asked them about their unique recipes. Plus, they gave me tips on how to customize my pizza to my liking!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Central OH, look no further than Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza! You won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Westerville!

#7 Dewey’s Pizza

I recently had the pleasure of trying out their signature “Dewey’s Special” and it didn’t disappoint. The blend of pepperoni, sausage, onion, mushrooms, and garlic was simply mouth-watering. The sauce was perfectly sweet and tangy, while the cheese was melted to perfection. And the crust- oh boy- flawlessly crispy on the outside and airy inside.

But here’s where Dewey’s REALLY shines: they offer 15 different pizza topping combinations ranging from traditional to unique. So if you’re looking for something a bit more daring than just plain ‘ol pepperoni, try out their “Surf & Turf Delight” which features shrimp and steak!

Aside from fantastic pizza, Dewey’s also boasts a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff who were more than happy to answer any questions we had about our pizzas. Whether you’re a first time guest or an old friend, everyone is made to feel welcomed at Dewey’s Pizza.

If you’re ever in Central OH, I highly recommend paying a visit to Dewey’s Pizza! In my opinion, they serve up some of the best pizza around – dare I say it? THE best pizza!

#8 Little Sicily’s Pizza

The first thing that stands out about Little Sicily’s Pizza is the friendly atmosphere. The staff are always smiling and chatting, and they really put you at ease while waiting for your order.

When it comes to the pizza itself, it’s absolutely divine! The crust is perfectly cooked – crispy on the outside but nice and fluffy on the inside. And the toppings are just perfect. I could definitely taste all of the fresh ingredients that were used, which was a real treat. They also offer a wide variety of pizzas with different sauces, cheeses, and toppings so there’s something for everyone to choose from!

All in all, my experience at Little Sicily’s Pizza was simply amazing. It’ll definitely remain one of my favorite places to go whenever I find myself in Central OH looking for some great pizza. If you’re ever in the area, be sure to check them out! You definitely won’t regret it!

#9 Rotolo’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when entering Rotolo’s Pizza was the delicious smell of freshly baked pizza. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the atmosphere was inviting.

I decided to try one of their specialty pizzas: The Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza. It had all of my favorite toppings – bacon, ground beef, sharp cheddar cheese, onions, tomatoes, and pickles-and it lived up to my expectations! The crust was perfectly crisp yet still chewy in the center, and the toppings were fresh and flavorsome. Yum!

Speaking of toppings, Rotolo’s Pizza has an impressive selection that is sure to satisfy even the pickiest eater. From classic favorites like pepperoni and mushroom to unique combinations like spinach pesto and prosciutto – there’s something for everyone!

I’m also happy to report that Rotolo’s Pizza offers delivery service if you’re not able to make it into the restaurant. And lucky for me – they offer online ordering for added convenience!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around Central OH – look no further than Rotolo’s Pizza!

#10 JT’s Pizza, Pub, & Patio

In fact, I would even go so far as to say that JT’s Pizza is the best place for pizza in Central OH! The pizza here definitely stands out from its peers. The environment is great too – it’s cozy and inviting with a nice patio outside for warmer days.

What really makes JT’s Pizza stand out from other pizza places is their wide selection of topping options. From classic pepperoni to exotic options like smoked salmon and artichoke hearts, you can build your own unique creation! I recently tried the Supreme Pizza and was surprised at how flavorful each topping was. And don’t forget about their signature homemade ranch dressing, which is delicious on everything!

The crust here is also something special. It’s a thin-crust style made with garlic butter and topped with parmesan cheese; it’s nothing short of fantastic!

All in all, if you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Central OH, look no further than JT’s Pizza, Pub & Patio!

#11 Hounddog’s Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting, and the staff are friendly and helpful. The menu has something for everyone; you can choose from fresh-made pizza or cold cuts. They also have a wide selection of toppings, so you can create your own unique masterpieces.

The star of the show is the pizza crust. It’s thin yet chewy, and it manages to hold up to all the delicious toppings they pile on. My favorite option was their pepperoni pizza, with plenty of cheese, but I’m sure that each topping will pass muster with discerning palates!

I would highly recommend Hounddog’s Pizza to anyone looking for a great pizza experience in Central OH. For me, this is the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Hilliard!

#12 Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus

I’ve had some pretty amazing pizzas in my day, but Brenz’s pies take the cake. The crust was delightfully thin and crisp on the outside while still maintaining a light fluffy texture on the inside. And the sauce! Not too sweet or tart, it had just enough flavor to enhance the deliciousness of everything else without overpowering it.

Toppings were everything I could hope for – fresh and flavorful –from their spicy pepperoni to their vegan-friendly options. It was almost like they knew exactly what I wanted before I ordered and made sure to deliver perfectly every time.

Beyond taste, Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus has an atmosphere just as delightful as their pizza pies. Instead of being cramped up in a tiny pizza joint with no place to sit, you can enjoy your meal either indoors or on their outdoor patio with a view of downtown Columbus. There’s music playing in the background and a cozy atmosphere that invites conversation and laughs shared over dinner with friends or family. Best of all, their prices are just right – not too expensive but definitely worth every penny!

In conclusion: don’t wait until you’re hungry or traveling before you go check out Brenz Pizza Co – make sure you get yourself there next time you’re looking for one of the best pies Central OH has to offer!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Giordano’s

Picture this: me, Edward the traveling food critic, venturing into Giordano’s with great pizza expectations. As I walked in, the mouthwatering aromas hit me like a cheesy explosion in the face. My taste buds were already dancing with excitement!

I ordered their famous deep dish pizza, and boy, was I taken aback when the massive pie arrived at my table. It was like a pizza mountain; I felt like a brave explorer ready to conquer the peak. With a glimmer of trepidation in my eyes, I took my first bite.

Oh, heavens! The crust was so buttery and flaky, it practically melted in my mouth. Each slice was packed with a ridiculous amount of cheese that stretched like a ship’s anchor. It was a struggle to fit it in my mouth, but I was determined. I felt like a snake unhinging my jaw just to devour this cheesy delight.

The sauce was divine, bathing every bite in tangy goodness. The toppings were fresh and abundant, teasing my tastebuds with bursts of flavors. And did I mention the gooey, stringy cheese? It was like a cheesy version of the fountain of youth – I swear, it made me feel younger with each bite.

Giordano’s is not just a place for deep dish pizza; it’s a journey. A journey to pizza heaven where buttery crusts reign supreme, cheese flows like rivers, and sauce graces your taste buds with divine elegance. So take a detour to Giordano’s because life is too short for mediocre pizza.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Paulie Gee’s Short North

This place is a hidden gem for pizza lovers like myself. As soon as I walked in, I could smell the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. My taste buds were instantly dancing in anticipation.

One of the major perks of this place is that it serves alcohol, and not just any alcohol, but hard liquor! Who doesn’t love a little liquid courage to go along with their pizza feast? I certainly do! As a traveling food critic, I’ve encountered my fair share of dry pizza joints, so this was a pleasant surprise.

The menu also catered to my vegetarian friends with some exciting options. Kudos to Paulie Gee’s for recognizing that not everyone wants to munch on pepperoni all the time. A good variety for all pizza enthusiasts!

And let’s not forget about dessert! Who knew that pizza and dessert could go hand in hand? Well, at Paulie Gee’s, they make it happen. The sweet treats were the perfect ending to a perfect meal. I even caught myself doing a little happy dance in my seat.

The only downside I encountered was that Paulie Gee’s does not accept reservations. But hey, as a world-traveling food critic, I’m used to waiting for greatness. And let me tell you, this pizza was worth every minute of anticipation.

So if you find yourself in Columbus, Ohio, make sure to visit Paulie Gee’s Short North. They’ve got the best thin crust pizza in town, a killer drink selection, delightful vegetarian options, and it’s a nice spot for tourists. Who could ask for more?

Best Wood Fired Pizza – GoreMade Pizza

When I first walked into GoreMade Pizza, I immediately noticed the aroma of delicious wood-fired crust mingling with the sounds of happy customers and clinking glasses. Ah, music to my pizza-loving ears! And speaking of glasses, let’s just say they don’t skimp on the drinks here. This joint serves up alcohol and hard liquor! Now that’s my kind of pizza party!

Now, my fellow vegetarians, fear not! GoreMade Pizza has got you covered. They offer a decent selection of vegetarian options that will make your taste buds dance with joy. I highly recommend the roasted vegetable pizza, topped with an array of colorful veggies that could potentially inspire a muralist!

But wait, my journey to pizza perfection did not stop there! GoreMade Pizza also indulges its customers with a delectable dessert menu. From the mouthwatering Nutella calzone to the heavenly panna cotta, your sweet tooth will be begging for mercy.

Now, here’s the catch. GoreMade Pizza does not take reservations. I know, shocking! So, prepare yourself for a potential wait, but let me tell you, it’s worth it. And in the meantime, you can explore the charming tourist spots nearby. Just don’t stray too far, or the tantalizing smell of fresh pizza might lure you back in!

In conclusion, GoreMade Pizza definitely lives up to its reputation as the best wood-fired pizza in Columbus, Ohio. Good food, good drinks, and a good time await you. Just remember to come hungry and leave your reservations at home!