Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Central Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Central Park (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

857 Views

I recently visited twelve pizza places around Central Park and tasted all of the pizzas they had to offer. After hours of eating pizza and taking notes on each one, I’m ready to share with you my take on the best pizza in Central Park.

Don’t worry, this won’t be boring like most food reviews—I’m bringing a humorous and lighthearted approach to this search! I’m sure this adventure will make your stomach growl while leaving you with a few laughs. Let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Made In New York Pizza

When I first arrived, I was impressed with the authentic NYC flair they had going on. The decor was neon-lit and lively and even their customers had that unique NY pizzeria energy. I knew right away this place was special!

I ordered a slice of New York-style cheese pizza and it was simply delicious. The crust was thin and perfectly crispy, while the cheese had an incredible creamy texture. And there was just enough tomato sauce to give the perfect balance of tangy sweetness. This pizza far exceeded my expectations!

What’s more, the restaurant staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, making sure my experience was top notch. They even got me a to-go box for my leftovers so I could enjoy them later (which is rare!).

Overall, I can confidently say that Made In New York Pizza has hands-down some of the best pizza in Central Park. If you’re ever in the area, make sure you stop by for some truly NYC-style ‘za!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in New York!

#2 Mimi’s Pizza

I’m not exaggerating when I say that Mimi’s Pizza has the best crust I’ve ever tasted, with a perfect crunchy texture and just the right amount of seasoning. And the toppings, oh my gosh, they were simply delicious! They had all kinds of options so you can make a pizza to suit any taste.

The service at Mimi’s Pizza was also top notch. Everyone was really friendly and helpful in ordering my pizza and making sure it got to me piping hot and fresh.

It’s no wonder why Mimi’s Pizza is one of the most popular spots in Central Park for getting a good slice. If you’re ever in the area, make sure to check out their selection; I guarantee it won’t disappoint!

#3 Ortomare

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this place was going to be special. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting – perfect for grabbing a slice after a stroll through the park.

The pizza is truly top-notch! The dough is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of chew. Toppings are generous and fresh, making every bite an absolute delight. My favorite creation has to be their Bianca Pizza – it’s simple but oh so flavorful!

The service at Ortomare is also excellent. Our waiter was friendly and helpful. He took his time explaining all the ingredients and recommended some great combinations, which really made our meal extra special.

I can confidently say that Ortomare has some of the best pizza in Central Park! So if you’re looking for delicious pizza on your next trip to New York City – this is definitely the place to go!

#4 My Pie Pizzeria Romana

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this place was something special. The decor was classic and inviting, with vibrant colors, old-world charm, and plenty of seating for everyone. Plus, my nose told me the pizza was going to be good before it even arrived at my table!

As a food critic, I take my pizza seriously and I have to say that My Pie Pizzeria Romana did not disappoint. The dough was golden brown and cooked to perfection; the tomato sauce was just the right amount of sweet with enough acidity to balance things out. The cheese used was also top-notch; it melted beautifully and had that mouthwatering flavor only found in great pizza.

I was also impressed by their selection of toppings – there were so many options available that I couldn’t decide what to go with! Ultimately, I settled on a classic Margherita and it exceeded all expectations; it really hit the spot after a long day walking around Central Park.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Central Park then My Pie Pizzeria Romana is your destination! Their unique flavor combinations make them stand out from the rest and provide an experience that you won’t soon forget.

#5 B Side Pizza Bar

Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately blown away by the atmosphere. It has a cool, casual vibe that really sets it apart from other pizza places. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which only added to my positive experience.

When it came time to order, I was pleased to find out that B Side Pizza Bar had an impressive menu with delicious options for every kind of pizza lover. They even have gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

The pizza itself was nothing short of amazing! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I especially loved their specialty pies like the “Meatlovers” and the “BBQ Chicken”. I also tried some of their appetizers like garlic knots and calamari which were both delicious.

Overall, I would highly recommend B Side Pizza Bar to anyone looking for great pizza in Central Park. With its inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and tasty food, B Side is undoubtedly one of the best pizzerias in the area!

#6 99 Cent Fresh Pizza

When I first ordered a large pizza from this establishment, I must admit that I had serious doubts about the quality of the food. After all, it was only 99 cents! However, my skepticism quickly dissipated as soon as my order was served. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the cheese and toppings were flavorful and fresh.

It didn’t take me more than a few bites to realize that this place is truly something special. What’s even better is that they offer an amazing variety of pizzas at incredibly low prices. Whether you’re looking for a simple pepperoni or a gourmet topping like artichoke hearts and fresh basil, there is definitely something for everyone here.

To sum it up: If you’re looking for one of the best pizza experiences in Central Park, look no further than 99 Cent Fresh Pizza! It’s a must-stop destination for any pizza lover!

#7 Celeste

In fact, it’s almost like they just took a pizza oven straight from Rome and dropped it right into the heart of Manhattan. Every bite of their classic margherita or napoli is exploding with flavor – as soon as you take your first bite, you’ll be hooked.

Plus, their deep-dish pizzas are to die for! The dough is so light and airy that you feel like you’re eating an Italian cloud. One thing I especially love about Celeste is the variety of toppings available for their pies – from spicy chorizo sausage to creamy goat cheese, there’s something for everyone here.

The atmosphere at this restaurant is also really nice – the staff is always friendly and accommodating, which makes for a great dining experience. Not to mention, it’s always crowded with locals who know that Celeste serves up some of the best pizza in town.

I give Celeste two thumbs up and definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a great place to get some delicious pizza in Central Park. It just might be the best pizza spot in the neighborhood!

#8 Joe G Pizza & Restaurant

The atmosphere of Joe G’s is a great combination of old school and modern – the perfect place to enjoy a good slice of pizza. The restaurant has a cozy feel, with plenty of seating available, and an open kitchen where you can see your pizza being made right in front of you.

The menu has various options, but I always come back for the classic Margarita pizza. It’s perfectly cooked every time, with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Plus, they offer some delicious sides like garlic knots and cheesy bread that are worth trying.

The service at this restaurant is top-notch; friendly staff who are knowledgeable about their offerings and quick to fill up your drink glass.

Of course, it’s all about the food here, and I have to say that Joe G Pizza & Restaurant delivers every time! It’s definitely one of the best places to get pizza in Central Park – you won’t be disappointed if you visit!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in New York!

#9 PizzArte

The experience starts with a pleasant stroll along the always-beautiful Central Park, leading you to the door of this charming restaurant. Taking your first steps inside, you are immediately enveloped in the mouth-watering smell of freshly made pizzas and quickly seated.

The menu is classic Italian wood fired pizza, but with a delicious twist. I tried their signature PizzArte which had artichoke hearts, creamy mozzarella and olive oil – it was so good! Every bite was perfectly cooked and balanced with an amazing blend of flavourful toppings.

But the highlight has to be the house-made marinara sauce. It’s totally unique and adds just the right amount of sweetness to each slice. It’s no wonder why locals rave about this place!

Overall, PizzArte definitely deserves its reputation as some of the best pizza in Central Park – if not all of New York City! Whenever I’m in town again, I know where I’ll be headed for a slice or two… or three!

#10 Pizza Collective

The atmosphere was inviting and cozy, with a great view of the park. The staff was very friendly and helpful, recommending some of their specialty pies. I had the margherita pizza and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, the cheese melted perfectly, and the tomatoes were juicy and flavorful – it really hit the spot.

I also sampled a few other pizzas from the menu like their sausage & peppers pie, which featured juicy pieces of sausage, roasted red peppers, and melty mozzarella cheese. The flavors blended together perfectly for an incredible tasting experience!

All in all my experience at Pizza Collective was definitely one to remember – I have no doubt that it is one of the best pizza places in Central Park (or anywhere)! Even if you’re not a fan of pizza, you’ll find something delicious here. Highly recommended!

#11 Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria

The pizzeria is a small, cozy spot tucked away in a corner of the park. I was impressed by their quick service and friendly staff when I visited, which made it all the more enjoyable.

The pizza itself was exquisite. They bake their pies in an authentic coal oven, giving their pizzas a unique flavor that is sure to please. The dough was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunchy edge to provide that extra bit of texture. The topping selection featured some classic favorites as well as some unique options, like truffle olive oil and smoked ricotta!

To top it all off, Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria also has a great selection of craft beer on tap and delicious Italian wines. This place is truly a pizza-lover’s paradise!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Central Park, look no further than Angelo’s Coal Oven Pizzeria!

#12 Marinara Pizza

The moment I stepped inside the restaurant, I could tell that they take pride in their food. Everything from the inviting staff and warm atmosphere to the delicious aroma of mouthwatering pizza made me feel right at home.

Their menu is a culinary dream come true! You can find traditional Italian pizzas like Margherita and Prosciutto, as well as inventive modern creations like Spicy Caponata and even Sicilian-style slices featuring cream cheese. No matter what your favorite flavor is, you’re sure to be satisfied with Marinara Pizza’s offerings.

But what really sets this restaurant apart is their incredible wood-fired ovens. They bake up some of the best pizza crusts I’ve ever tried! Crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, each slice is a delight for your taste buds. Plus, they use fresh ingredients to top their pies – so you don’t have to worry about skimping on flavor or quality.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Central Park, then look no further than Marinara Pizza! From start to finish, it’s an experience that can’t be beaten.

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Emmett’s

Stepping into Emmett’s is like stepping into a time machine that takes you back to the old-school pizzerias of yesteryear. The smell of melted cheese and freshly baked dough wafts through the air, causing my taste buds to dance in anticipation. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I take my job very seriously. So naturally, when I heard about the best deep dish pizza in downtown, I had to put it to the test.

Let me tell you, the moment that golden, cheesy heaven arrived at my table, it was love at first bite. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside but oh-so-soft on the inside, resembling a fluffy cloud of deliciousness. It held up to the mountain of toppings like a champ, without sacrificing its integrity. I mean, who needs a plate when you have a slice of Emmett’s pizza?!

The combination of gooey, melted cheese and tangy tomato sauce was like a symphony in my mouth. Each ingredient played its part and came together harmoniously. And don’t even get me started on the generous toppings! From juicy chunks of sausage to fresh vegetables, every bite was an explosion of flavor.

But be warned, this pizza is not for the faint of heart. It’s a commitment—a glorious, cheesy, and utterly satisfying commitment. So if you find yourself craving the epitome of deep dish pizza, head to Emmett’s and prepare to have your taste buds blown away. Your stomach may never be the same again, but trust me, it’s a risk worth taking.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The smell of fresh dough being rolled out filled the air, and my stomach growled in anticipation. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and a delightful introduction to their pizza creations.

As I perused the menu, I couldn’t help but chuckle at the variety of toppings they offered. From classic margherita to inventive combinations like prosciutto and figs, Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza takes pizza to a whole new level of deliciousness.

When my pizza arrived, I couldn’t believe my eyes (or my taste buds). The crust was thin and crispy, with the perfect amount of chewiness. It was like a symphony of flavors exploded in my mouth with each bite. I couldn’t help but do a little happy dance in my seat, much to the amusement of the neighboring tables.

To top it all off, the service was exceptional. The waitstaff was attentive and knowledgeable. They even recommended some locally brewed craft beers to pair with my pizza, and boy, did they hit the spot!

So, if you find yourself in midtown manhattan and craving some incredible thin crust pizza, Vezzo NYC is a must-visit. Just be prepared to have your taste buds blown away and your funny bone tickled. Trust me, this place is truly a slice of pizza heaven!

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza

First of all, let’s talk about the crust. Oh, the crust! It’s like biting into a cloud that’s been infused with the essence of a thousand Italian grandmothers. It’s crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy on the inside. I even contemplated stealing a few extra slices to use as pillows on my flight back home.

And the toppings! They are a work of art, hence the name Arturo’s. From the classic margherita to the wild and wacky combinations they come up with, each pizza is a masterpiece in its own right. I had a pizza topped with prosciutto, arugula, and balsamic glaze, and let me tell you, it was like a tastebud tango. The flavors danced and twirled on my tongue, leaving me in a state of pizza bliss.

The atmosphere at Arturo’s is like a cozy Italian trattoria, with red checkered tablecloths and charming, gesticulating waiters. You can almost hear the faint strains of an accordion playing in the background. It’s the perfect setting to enjoy a piping hot slice of pizza and imagine you’re sitting in a quaint little piazza in Naples.

So, if you find yourself in Buffalo, do yourself a favor and head straight to Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza. It’s the kind of place that will make you want to throw all your travel plans out the window and stay in Buffalo forever, just so you can indulge in their wood-fired pizzas every day. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Bellissimo!