Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Chapel Hill (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in Chapel Hill (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

185 Views

I’ve sampled pizza from all over the world, so I have a good sense of what makes a great pie. For this article, I’ve made a point to sample twelve of the best-rated pizza places in Chapel Hill, and I’m here to report on my findings!

You can trust that these results are coming from an expert – one who loves nothing more than finding the perfect combination of crust, sauce, and melted cheese resting atop their slices. So if you’re looking for the tastiest pizza in Chapel Hill – or just some tasty recommendations – read on!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Pizzeria Mercato

The atmosphere is lively, and it’s also a great spot for tourists who want to experience the local culture. And when I’m done stuffing my face with pizza, I can indulge in some insanely good desserts.

The service is top notch and they even serve alcohol should you want an extra kick. There are plenty of vegetarian options for us non-meat eaters as well, so everyone can enjoy themselves!

My only complaint would be that they don’t offer delivery, but that’s really nitpicking because the food is worth it.

I’m giving Pizzeria Mercato 5 stars due to its tasty pies, scrumptious dessert and upbeat atmosphere. If you’ve been searching for the best pizza in Chapel Hill, this is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Durham!

#2 Italian Pizzeria III

When I first walked into Italian Pizzeria III, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. I could tell the staff had a real passion for pizza, and that made me feel right at home.

The pizza menu offered something for everyone. Whether you like traditional margherita or something a little more extravagant, like their Fig and Prosciutto Pie, they have you covered! And while all of their pizzas are delicious, their pepperoni is truly something special. The combination of perfectly cooked crust and a mouthwatering cheesy topping makes it one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted.

The service provided by the staff was also top-notch. They were friendly, attentive, and always willing to answer any questions I had about their pizzas or ingredients.

To sum it up: if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Chapel Hill, then Italian Pizzeria III is where you need to be!

#3 Napoli Pizzeria & Gelateria

For starters, the atmosphere is great – bright and inviting, with a warm and inviting staff. The decor is authentic Italian and I felt right at home. The menu options are diverse; there’s something for everyone here!

The pizza itself is where it really stands out. The crust is perfectly crispy and the flavors of the ingredients come through loud and clear – not too greasy or overly cheesy. My favorite was the margherita, but the pepperoni was also amazing. Plus, you can’t go wrong with anything from their wood-fired oven!

To top it off, they have delicious gelato that complements a slice of pizza perfectly. It’s always nice to find a place where both sides of your Italian craving can be satisfied!

So if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Chapel Hill, look no further than Napoli Pizzeria & Gelateria. Trust me when I say you won’t be disappointed – that’s coming from a world traveler who knows his pizza!

#4 Brenz Pizza Co. Chapel Hill

The first thing that struck me about Brenz Pizza Co. Chapel Hill was the atmosphere. The warm, inviting charm of the restaurant makes it a great place to hang out and relax with friends.

When it comes to the pizza itself, I can confirm that this is some of the best pizza I have ever tasted! The dough and ingredients are made fresh each day and cooked to perfection in their wood-fired ovens. The crust is perfectly crispy while at the same time remaining light and fluffy. And the topping combinations they have on offer are simply amazing—from classic margheritas to signature pies topped with smoked pork shoulder and pickled jalapenos.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for an unbeatable pizza experience in Chapel Hill, look no further than Brenz Pizza Co. Chapel Hill—the best pizza in town!

#5 Aidan’s Pizza

When I first visited this place, the feeling of anticipation was palpable. From the moment I stepped foot into Aidan’s, I knew I was in for a special treat. The decor was cozy and inviting – it made me feel right at home!

The first thing that caught my eye was the selection of pizzas. There were pizzas of all shapes, sizes and varieties to choose from. I settled on the Sausage and Pepperoni pizza, which did not disappoint! The dough had just the right amount of crunchiness and chewiness, while the toppings were flavorful without overwhelming the palate.

The next thing that really sealed my experience at Aidan’s Pizza is their service. All of the staff members were warm and friendly, making me feel like a valued customer; they definitely go out of their way to make sure you feel welcome.

Overall, Aidan’s Pizza is truly one of Chapel Hill’s gems for a fantastic pizza experience! With its tasty pizzas and great service, it earns five stars from this food critic!

#6 Tarantini Italian Restaurant

When I first arrived, I was taken aback by the atmosphere. The restaurant had a rustic, old-school Italian vibe that made me feel like I was in an authentic pizzeria in Italy.

The menu had plenty of great options to choose from, and all of them looked incredibly appetizing. But at the end of the day, I decided on a classic pepperoni pizza — it was love at first bite! The crust was thin and crisp, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It seemed as though Tarantini had put a great deal of thought into making this pizza, and it really showed!

I also want to acknowledge the fantastic service that I received while dining at Tarantini Italian Restaurant. My server was friendly and attentive throughout my meal — they were quick to refill drinks, clear plates, answer questions, and generally make sure that everything went smoothly.

Overall, Tarantini Italian Restaurant is an incredible place for great pizza and excellent hospitality. If you’re ever in Chapel Hill and are looking for some of the best pizza around, this is definitely the spot to go!

#7 Capp’s Pizzeria & Trattoria

I was not disappointed. The pizza had a perfect crust to cheese ratio and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. I also appreciate that they offer some vegetarian options, allowing everyone to enjoy a delicious meal.

On top of that, Capp’s has the added bonus of serving alcohol. This makes it a great spot for casual get-togethers or dinners where you just want to kick back and relax with your favorite brew pairing perfectly with their famous pizzas!

Unfortunately, they don’t offer delivery, but I guess that’s a small sacrifice considering how amazing their pies are. Plus they have desserts like indulgent Tiramisu and chocolate cake if you still haven’t got your fill!

Trust me, you won’t be disappointed when you visit Capp’s Pizzeria & Trattoria! It’s definitely the best pizza in Chapel Hill – trust an experienced critic on this one.

#8 Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar

The atmosphere of the restaurant is great, with a cozy dining area and an impressive craft bar. The menu had plenty of options to choose from, and they also allowed custom toppings.

The pizzas were amazing! The flavor was incredibly complex, but perfectly balanced with sharpness and sweetness. The crust was thin, but possessed a perfect amount of crunchiness that held up the toppings very well.

I had the pleasure of trying out some of their sides too, which were nicely seasoned and cooked to perfection. My favorite was their delicious garlic Parmesan truffle fries; I could have eaten them all day!

Overall, Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar serves some of the best pizza in Chapel Hill. I would highly recommend it for those looking for a high quality pizza experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Durham!

#9 Alfredo’s Pizza Villa

As soon as I stepped inside, the overwhelmingly delicious smell of pizza wafted through the air and took my taste buds right to Italy. I was immediately drawn to the freshness of the ingredients – their tomatoes were still on the vine, their cheese freshly grated, and their dough just-made! The waitstaff were friendly, helpful and even offered me a sample before I made my decision. Plus there was plenty of seating in both the dining room and patio area for larger parties.

But let’s get down to business: The pizza is what we came here for, afterall! Alfredo’s truly knocked it out of the park. The crust was perfectly crispy yet still pillowy soft, with just the right amount of sauce and melted cheese on top. And with all those toppings-onion, bell peppers, olives-to choose from, you’ll definitely want to come back for seconds!

Between the atmosphere at Alfredo’s Pizza Villa and their amazing pizzas (that are almost too delicious!), this charming place should be your first pick when you’re craving pizza in Chapel Hill. They have proven themselves time and time again to serve up some of the best pizza around.

#10 Pop’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Pop’s is just perfect. There’s a chill jazz tune playing in the background, and everyone looks very relaxed. Plus, the tables are perfect for big groups as well as small ones. You can even get a romantic table overlooking the street if you’re feeling extra special!

But what really makes this place stand out is the food. The pizza here is delicious! Every slice is perfectly cooked, with the perfect balance of crusty outside and soft inside. The sauce has just enough spice to wake up your taste buds without overpowering them. And all toppings are fresh and flavorful – from vegetables to meats. Everything complements each other perfectly, making for some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!

Pop’s Pizzeria is definitely one of my top choices for great pizza in Chapel Hill. From its cozy atmosphere to its delicious pizza, it’s definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for a great place to grab some slices!

#11 The Loop Restaurant

The crust is thin and crisp, yet still soft and chewy. The sauce is perfectly balanced and flavorful, not too sweet or too salty. And the cheese – oh the cheese! It’s melty, gooey perfection that’s sure to satisfy any pizza lover.

Topping options are plentiful – from classic pepperoni to more adventurous selections like pineapple on a classic pie. If you’re feeling really daring, they’ve got a few specialty pizzas that’ll make your taste buds tingle with delight!

I can confidently say that The Loop Restaurant lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizza places in Chapel Hill. If you’re ever in town looking for great pizza, I highly recommend checking them out!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

I’d heard good things about Domino’s, but nothing prepared me for the deliciousness of their pizza! The crust was so light and airy it almost melted in your mouth. The sauce was sweet and had a nice kick to it that held up against the tangy cheese and wonderfully-crafted toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions.

Service at Domino’s was great, too. They went out of their way to make sure I was well taken care of and got exactly what I wanted. I think they even gave me a few extra slices for free!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Chapel Hill then you can’t go wrong with Domino’s. With their delicious pies and friendly service, it’ll be tough to find a better spot for pizza around here!