Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Cortland NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Cortland NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

106 Views

I’m sure I don’t have to tell you how good pizza can be, but just in case you need some help making the choice, I decided to sample 12 different pizza options around Cortland NY. With a humorous and lighthearted attitude, I’m ready to share my favorite of the bunch. So buckle up, and let’s get into it!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Melodyland

When you visit Melodyland, you know you’re in for an unforgettable experience! Not only do they offer delicious pizza, they also have a full bar, so you can enjoy some adult beverages while you’re there. On top of that, they have a great kid’s menu with plenty of options, so even the little ones are sure to find something they love.

As if that weren’t enough, their desserts are simply divine – perfect for when you want something sweet after your pizza.

The only downside I can think of is that there’s no delivery service. But honestly, how often do any of us really feel like going out for pizza? With all the other amazing amenities at Melodyland, it’s worth making the trip.

All things considered, I give Melodyland two thumbs up for having some of the best pizza in Cortland NY!

If you’re willing to go an extra 19 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Ithaca!

#2 Little Italy Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped inside, I was overwhelmed by the smells of freshly prepared pizza. The staff had all sorts of interesting personalities, which made my experience even more enjoyable.

The pizzas here are definitely something special. They use only the freshest ingredients and lots of love in their creations. Every slice is like a work of art, with each topping perfectly balanced and distributed. All the sauces have that signature Italian flavor to them, so you know you’re in for a treat!

One thing that really sets Little Italy Pizzeria apart from other pizzerias is their presentation. Each pizza is presented in its own unique way, with fresh herbs and colorful vegetables sprinkled on top for added appeal.

I’m a big fan of their specialty pies as well; the garlic chicken mozzarella is especially delicious! The combination of cheeses and seasonings creates a flavor explosion that can’t be beat!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Cortland NY, Little Italy Pizzeria is where it’s at! The friendly staff, incredible flavors, and beautiful presentation will make you feel like you’ve stumbled into an Italian delight!

#3 A Round Pizza

I had the pleasure of trying their signature ’round’ pizza and it was incredible! The dough was cooked to perfection and the topping selection was just right. I had pepperoni, mushrooms and olives – all fresh ingredients that blended together for a truly unforgettable flavor.

The atmosphere of the restaurant was cozy and inviting. The staff were very friendly and accommodating, ensuring my visit was perfection from start to finish.

But back to the pizza… To say that A Round Pizza has some of the best pizza in Cortland NY is an understatement. The crust had the perfect texture with a crispy exterior that balanced perfectly with the freshly made toppings placed on top – really a delightful combination!

For those looking for a culinary experience, A Round Pizza is certainly worth checking out. If you’re exploring Cortland NY, I definitely suggest stopping by this pizza joint! It’s quite possibly the best pizza around!

#4 Hollywood

The atmosphere is perfect for a tourist spot; there’s cozy seating, TVs playing sports shows and live music on the weekends. Plus, they serve alcohol (including hard liquor!) – ideal for an after-dinner drink.

Hollywood also offers a great kid’s menu to make sure the little ones are happy as well. Then there’s the pizza of course – insanely good! The crust is golden brown with just the right amount of crunch, and the flavors are bold and full. Pizza perfection!

The only downside I noticed was that it seemed like they didn’t offer delivery. But with such a delicious ‘za waiting inside, it’s definitely worth the trip to visit Hollywood in person!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in West New York!

#5 Pontillo’s Pizzeria Cortland

I was immediately impressed with the pizza when I walked in. The crust was light, crispy and flavorful. Toppings were generous and fresh! The cheese melted just right, not too greasy or dry.

The staff was friendly, helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. We asked a lot of questions and they answered every one with enthusiasm. I also noticed that they use a lot of local ingredients from their Cortland neighboorhood, which is awesome!

I can tell you with confidence that Pontillo’s Pizzeria Cortland has some of the best pizza in Cortland NY – so if you’re looking for truly great pizza without all the commercial chains, this is the place to go!

#6 D P Dough

Upon arriving, the first thing I noticed was how inviting the atmosphere was. The cozy and comfortable seating immediately put me at ease, allowing me to take in the mouthwatering smells coming from the kitchen.

The next thing that struck me was their menu; D P Dough offers an impressive selection of specialty pizzas, like white and veggie pies. They also had a variety of calzones and sides like garlic breadsticks and salads. No matter what your taste preference is, you can easily find something to satisfy your hunger!

But most importantly, their pizza was absolutely delicious. The crust was crispy yet chewy, while the toppings were wonderfully fresh and flavorful- just perfect for someone who wants their pizza loaded with flavor!

All in all, I highly recommend D P Dough for anyone looking for the best pizza in Cortland NY. Whether you choose to dine in or order delivery, you will definitely be delighted with their delicious offerings!

#7 Domino’s Pizza

As soon as I walked into the restaurant, the delicious smell of pizza took over my senses and I was instantly ready to dig in. When I got to the counter, the friendly staff were more than happy to help me decide what type of pizza to get. They even offered suggestions on how to make it tastier!

The pizza itself was cooked perfectly with a big crust that provided a perfect balance of crunch and chewy texture. With the right amount of sauce and toppings, it was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The service was quick and friendly which is always great when you’re trying to get your hands on some delicious food.

Overall, Domino’s Pizza in Cortland NY is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some amazing pizza! Whether you like traditional favorites or something unique, they have options that will satisfy everyone’s cravings!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Syracuse!

#8 Pudgie’s Pizza

I came here on a Sunday night, and the place was packed! It’s a small shop, but they had all kinds of pies to choose from. I opted for their signature “Pudgie Special” and it did not disappoint! The crust was light and fluffy with just the right amount of crispiness. It was perfectly cooked with a delicious char flavor.

The sauce was savory and sweet with plenty of herbs, giving it great depth. And the cheese! It was freshly shredded mozzarella that melted in your mouth and complemented the other flavors perfectly. The toppings were generous and fresh, making every bite a delight.

Overall, Pudgie’s Pizza is an excellent pizza joint that knows how to deliver some serious flavor! If you’re ever in Cortland NY looking for the best pizza around, look no further than Pudgie’s Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Little Caesars Pizza

On my first trip to Little Caesars I was greeted with a warm atmosphere, friendly staff, and mouth-watering aroma of their freshly made pizza. I had high expectations for the pizza and was not disappointed; it was incredible! All the toppings were fresh, the crust was perfectly crisp and golden brown, and the sauce was flavorful and well balanced.

The staff at Little Caesars made sure my experience was top notch. Every order is checked to ensure quality control — insuring each slice is cooked to perfection. Even when it’s busy (which it often can be!), they still manage to make sure each customer gets great service.

I’m tempted to move to Cortland NY just so I can enjoy Little Caesars Pizza on a regular basis — it really is that good! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cortland NY, then look no further than Little Caesars Pizza.

#10 A Pizza & More

I’ve had my fair share of pizza from all over the globe, from Naples to Sydney, but I’m here to tell you that A Pizza & More has some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. From their signature “Old-Fashioned” combo pie, with its savory mix of tomato sauce and melted cheese, to their unique “Italian Garden” focaccia pie – they have it all.

The crust at A Pizza & More is always cooked to perfection – light and flaky on the outside, chewy and fluffy on the inside. The ingredients are top-notch too; they only use the freshest tomatoes, best cuts of meats like pepperoni and sausage, and a variety of freshly picked vegetables. All these goodies come served together on a warm and flavorful base.

The staff at A Pizza & More is likewise top notch too; courteous and knowledgeable about all things pizza! They take great care in preparing your meals quickly, so you don’t have to wait long for your meal to arrive. Plus, with many locations throughout Cortland NY area as well as delivery options – cuisine cravings can be satisfied quickly and conveniently!

After looking for the best pizzas across the globe – I’m confident enough in saying that A Pizza & More has some of the best pies around – hands down! So what are you waiting for? Get yourself a slice (or two!) from this awesome spot today!

If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Binghamton!

#11 Rex’s Pasta

When we arrived at the restaurant, I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere. It was a cozy, intimate spot where you could enjoy a delicious pizza without feeling rushed.

The pizza was simply amazing. The crust was soft and chewy and cooked to perfection. The sauce had just the right amount of sweetness and it went perfectly with the fresh ingredients that were used on top of it. They also offer some creative topping combinations if you’re in the mood to try something new!

Aside from the pizza, Rex’s Pasta also offers an impressive selection of pasta dishes, including lasagna, spaghetti, ravioli and more. All were cooked perfectly al dente and had a wonderful flavor.

The service at Rex’s Pasta was wonderful as well. Our waiter was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu offerings, so we felt very well taken care of throughout our meal.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Rex’s Pasta for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Cortland NY!

#12 Mangia Stattizitto

The atmosphere is quaint and the staff are always friendly and helpful. Their pizza is made with high-quality ingredients that make every bite worth taking. The crust is thin, yet crispy; the sauce has a kick but not too overwhelming; the cheese gives each slice an extra flavor zing!

Their menu offers several types of pizzas including classic Italian styles like Margherita or pepperoni. They also have a wide selection of specialty pies that will tantalize your taste buds, from spinach artichoke to BBQ bacon—there’s something for everyone at Mangia Stattizitto!

The portions are generous and filling without being overbearing. Plus, their prices are affordable so you can enjoy multiple pies without breaking the bank. The pizza is cooked in wood-fired brick ovens which adds an extra layer of smoky flavor that elevates these pizzas beyond anything I’ve ever tasted before!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Cortland NY, look no further than Mangia Stattizitto—it’s worth every dime!