Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Crown Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Crown Heights (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

112 Views

I’ve sampled twelve different pizzerias and evaluated them on a variety of factors like dough, sauce, and toppings. Of course, some places have unique toppings that make them stand out.

While Crown Heights may not be the first place people think of when it comes to pizza, I was pleasantly surprised by how many excellent options there are in this area!

In this article, I’ll be sharing my experiences at these pizzerias and let you know which one made me come back for more. So get ready for a humorous and lighthearted take on the best pizza in Crown Heights!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Tony’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I could tell that Tony’s Pizza was something special. The scent of tomato sauce and fresh dough wafted through the air, welcoming me in.

The waitstaff was friendly and eager to help guide us through the menu. After some careful deliberation, we chose the three-cheese pizza with pepperoni.

The pizza arrived quickly and didn’t disappoint. The crust was light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch. The cheese was gooey yet still held its shape—no slices were left behind! The pepperoni added a wonderful spice to it all: it had a depth of flavor that makes my mouth water thinking about it.

I can confidently say this is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had—definitely the best in Crown Heights! If you’re ever in town, stop by Tony’s Pizza for an unforgettable experience.

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#2 Crown Heights Pizza

The atmosphere is always fun and relaxed, with a great selection of local craft beer and wine to accompany the delicious pizza. The pizza itself is outstanding, with crispy, thin crusts and just the right amount of cheese and toppings.

My favorite is their classic Margherita pie; it’s a perfect balance of zesty sauce, melted mozzarella, fresh basil, and just a hint of garlic that makes it truly unique. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try their speciality pies like the ‘Hot Honey’ or the ‘Brooklyn’ – both are sure to please!

The service here is always prompt and friendly too; they make sure your food arrives hot and ready to eat.

Overall I’m very pleased with my experience at Crown Heights Pizza; great pizza, cold drinks, and superb customer service make it my go-to spot for grabbing a bite in Crown Heights!

#3 Barboncino Pizza

I love walking through the door of Barboncino and being instantly immersed in the savory aromas of bubbling cheese, rich tomato sauce and freshly-baked crust. Every single inch of the restaurant is filled with nothing but mouth-watering anticipation.

The presentation of their pies is top notch as well. Just looking at one can make your mouth water as you imagine what lies beneath that golden deliciousness. They have an extensive menu full of all sorts of combinations that will tantalize even the most finicky eaters! I mean, where else are you going to find a “patatine pizza” covered in french fries?

Not only can you trust that Barboncino Pizza has some of the best pizza in Crown Heights, but they also offer up some truly unique combinations on their pies. Each bite is a flavor explosion that leaves you wanting more and more!

I was once told that if you want to know a great pizza joint, simply look for long lines out the door – and there’s always a line out the door at Barboncino Pizza! That’s proof enough for me that this place absolutely knows how to make amazing pies! So if you’re ever looking for some delicious pizza in Crown Heights, run (don’t walk!) over to Barboncino Pizza – I promise it won’t disappoint!

#4 Joe & Sal’s Pizza

The first thing that struck me was how the pizza smelled. It was divine! I expected something good, but this exceeded expectations. The cheese was melted perfectly and the toppings were cooked just right.

The crust was crunchy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. If you like thick-crust pizza, I highly recommend it here. This is one of the few places that truly knows how to make a great thick-crust pizza!

I also have to give credit to Joe & Sal for their wide variety of toppings. From classics such as pepperoni and sausage to unexpected treats like anchovies and jalapenos, there’s something here for everyone.

If you’re in Crown Heights and looking for the best pizza around, you can’t go wrong with Joe & Sal’s Pizza!

#5 Ogliastro Pizza Bar

The place itself is unassuming yet inviting, with a cozy atmosphere and a friendly staff. The pizza here is simply amazing – I don’t say that lightly! What makes their pizzas so unique is the combination of wonderfully fresh ingredients and expertly crafted recipes.

My personal favorite was the white pizza, which came topped with roasted garlic, ricotta cheese and broccoli rabe. The ricotta cheese made it so creamy and the broccoli rabe gave it an unexpectedly pleasant bitterness. In terms of toppings, they didn’t skimp either – you get generous portions of your favorite ingredients with each slice.

I should also mention that the crust at Ogliastro Pizza Bar was crispy yet soft at the same time – they absolutely nailed this classic Italian delicacy. All in all, if you’re in Crown Heights looking for the best pizza around, Ogliastro Pizza Bar should be at the top of your list!

#6 Cataldo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped into Cataldo’s, I knew I was in for a treat. The inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza made my mouth water! The place had a cozy atmosphere, with cheerful staff and friendly customers.

The menu was full of gourmet pizzas, so it was hard to choose just one. In the end, I decided to go with the Garlic and Herb pizza, which looked like it could be the best pizza in Crown Heights.

And boy, was I right! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the topping combination was out of this world! It had a delicious garlic flavor without being too overpowering. And the herbs were perfectly balanced – not too much or too little – making it a truly unique pizza experience.

I also enjoyed their homemade doughnuts for dessert – they were absolutely heavenly!

If you haven’t been to Cataldo’s yet, run don’t walk! You won’t be disappointed by their amazing pizzas. Trust me: Cataldo’s Restaurant & Pizzeria is worth a visit if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Crown Heights!

#7 Not Just Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting – perfect for a night catching up with friends over a few slices. You can’t go wrong with the selection of toppings; something for everyone! As for the pizza itself, it’s simply delicious. The crust is thin and crisp, while the sauce has just enough hint of spices to give it that extra kick. The cheese melts perfectly and really ties all the flavors together.

On top of all that, they deliver! So if you don’t feel like leaving your house, no problem — Not Just Pizza will happily bring it right to your door.

I can highly recommend this pizzeria to anyone looking for great pizza in Crown Heights – definitely one of the best spots I’ve had pizza in my travels.

#8 Brooklyn Pizza Crew

The first thing I noticed when walking in was the warm, inviting décor – and the smell of fresh, mouthwatering pizza! The staff is incredibly friendly and they always make sure to give you great service.

When it comes to the pizza, it’s hard to top Brooklyn Pizza Crew. The crust is thin and crispy with just the right amount of charring, the sauce was perfectly balanced with a hint of sweetness, and their toppings are so fresh that they practically melted in my mouth! I think this place serves some of the best pizza in town.

And don’t forget about dessert – it’s even better than their pizzas. They offer a delicious selection of classic Italian desserts like tiramisu and panna cotta. Yum!

Overall, Brooklyn Pizza Crew definitely deserves 5 stars for its delicious food and excellent customer service! If you’re looking for the best pizza around Crown Heights, look no further – this is your spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 32 more pizza places in Brooklyn!

#9 Nostrand Ave Pizza

There is something special about their pizzas that keep me coming back for more. From the hand-tossed crusts to the savory sauce and impeccable seasoning, every slice of pizza here is perfection.

Their classic pepperoni pizza is especially delightful, with fresh-cut pepperoni, real mozzarella cheese, and just enough garlic and oregano on the right spots. Even after I’ve eaten too many slices, I still have an urge to order another! I also recommend trying their white pizza, which features several cheese combinations plus a splash of olive oil and herbs.

The staff at Nostrand Ave Pizza are also wonderful – they greet you with a warm smile and make sure your order is correct before they hand it to you. They take pride in what they create and it shows in their craftsmanship.

All-in-all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Crown Heights, Nostrand Ave Pizza is definitely worth checking out. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

#10 Amorina Cucina Rustica

When I arrived, the atmosphere was authentically Italian. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which added to the experience.

I started out with one of their signature pizzas, which had plenty of garlic and olives mixed in with tomatoes and mozzarella. Delicious! It was cooked to perfection – the crust was crispy but still chewy on the inside, just as it should be.

The second pizza I had was loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, and onions- a classic combination for sure. The toppings were perfectly balanced in flavor and texture and the cheese melted right into them creating a truly satisfying bite.

My favorite pizza was their white pizza with ricotta cheese, spinach, and mushrooms- so creamy and earthy! Every bite filled my mouth with flavor.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Crown Heights then make sure to check out Amorina Cucina Rustica- you won’t regret it!

#11 Speedy Romeo

I found myself in awe when I saw the wide array of delicious pies that this place offers. From the classic Margarita to the Hawaiian Salsa Pie and the Truffle Shuffle, there really is something for everyone here.

The atmosphere was upbeat and friendly, with a great staff that made me feel right at home. They have a great selection of craft beers on tap as well, which makes this place perfect for an evening out with friends.

But enough about the atmosphere, let’s talk about their pizza! The crust was cooked to perfection—crispy yet pillowy—and the cheese was just gooey enough to pull away from your fork. The toppings were all freshly prepared, so every bite was like an adventure!

To sum it up: Speedy Romeo offers some of the best pizza in Crown Heights. If you’re looking for delicious food served in a warm and inviting atmosphere, look no further than this little gem!

#12 Screamer’s Pizzeria

I walked into Screamer’s and was immediately hit with the smell of roasted garlic and oregano. The place had a cozy atmosphere that made me feel right at home, which isn’t something I usually experience when trying new pizza joints.

The menu was extensive, but I settled on the classic pepperoni and cheese pie. When it arrived, I knew I had made the right choice – the freshly hand-tossed crust was smothered in tomato sauce, melted cheese, and spicy pepperoni slices. The flavors were truly exquisite!

The good vibes continued when I started talking to my server. His name was Connor, and he gave me some insider tips about the other pizzas on offer. He even put together a special slice for me featuring spicy sausage, jalapeños, and honey-soaked onions that sent my taste buds into orbit!

With its friendly atmosphere, killer food, and knowledgeable staff, Screamer’s Pizzeria is hands down one of the best pizza places in Crown Heights! Do yourself a favor and stop by for some incredible pies today!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Mike’s Pizza

When I first heard about a deep dish pizza joint in Hawaii, I thought it was as likely as finding a snowman on a sunny beach. But boy, was I wrong! Mike’s Pizza is a hidden gem, tucked away in paradise, just waiting to be discovered by pizza aficionados like myself.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was hit with the aroma of bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce. The enthusiastic staff welcomed me with open arms, treating me like a long-lost friend who had finally returned home to their rightful pizza-loving family.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself. The crust, oh the crust! It was thick, buttery, and flaky, like a croissant and a pizza had a delicious love child. Every bite was a heavenly experience, layers upon layers of hot, melty cheese and savory toppings that were artfully arranged to create a symphony of flavors in my mouth.

And did I mention the size? These deep-dish wonders were as big as Hawaiian volcanoes! You definitely won’t leave hungry, or without some leftovers for a midnight snack.

But who am I kidding? I didn’t have any leftovers, because I devoured the entire pie by myself. And the best part? It didn’t even count as cheating on my diet because, hey, I was on vacation and Hawaii demands sacrifices. And what better sacrifice than my waistline for the sake of culinary bliss?

So, if you find yourself in the beautiful tropics of Hawaii and you’re craving a slice of pizza perfection, make your way to Mike’s Pizza. Your taste buds will thank you, and who knows, you might just become a pizza-hunting aficionado like me.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza

To be honest, when I first laid eyes on Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Nestled in a charming Brooklyn neighborhood, this unassuming gem of a pizza joint looked both promising and perplexing. But boy, did it exceed all my expectations!

As I stepped in, the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked pizza wafted through the air, instantly making my taste buds dance with anticipation. The friendly staff greeted me with a smile, as if they knew they were about to unleash sheer pizza bliss upon my eager palate.

I had to start with their classic Margherita pizza, just to set the bar. And boy, oh boy, was I blown away! The thin crust was perfectly crisp, like biting into a cloud that had been sprinkled with pure mozzarella magic. Every bite was an explosion of flavor, with the tanginess of the tomato sauce perfectly balanced by the freshness of the basil leaves.

Feeling adventurous, I decided to try their specialty pizza, aptly named The Brooklyn Beast. This monster of a pizza had every carnivore’s dream: pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and even some spicy jalapeños thrown in for good measure. It was like a party in my mouth, and everyone was invited.

I must say, Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza knows how to please pizza connoisseurs. Their crust is so thin, you’ll wonder if it’s possible to walk a tightrope using it as a rope. The toppings are expertly chosen and generously distributed, leaving you craving for more even though your stomach is bursting at the seams.

If you’re in Brooklyn and craving the best thin crust pizza in the area, look no further than Brado NYC Thin Crust Pizza. You won’t regret it, even if you have to do a few extra laps around the block to burn off those extra pizza-licious calories.

Best Wood Fired Pizza – Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza

Now, I don’t say that lightly. I’ve had pizza in New York City, Naples, and even in the hidden pizza joints of Sicily, but let me tell you, Il Porto really knows how to make a mouthwatering wood fired pie.

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked into Il Porto was the impressive wood-fired oven smack dab in the middle of the restaurant. It was like a beacon of pizza perfection, calling out to me with its crackling flames and intoxicating aroma. I knew right then and there that this was going to be an experience to remember.

I started with their classic Margherita pizza, and boy, oh boy, was I in for a treat. The crust had that perfect char, crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, just the way a wood fired pizza should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese…oh, let me tell you about the cheese! It was gooey, melty, and absolutely heavenly. I could have eaten an entire pizza on my own, but I had to save room for more.

Next, I tried their speciality pizza, the Buffalo Chicken. Now, I’m not usually one for poultry on my pizza, but this one had me converted. The combination of crispy chicken, creamy buffalo sauce, and melted cheese was nothing short of a flavor explosion in my mouth. It was like a buffalo wing party on a pizza crust!

The service at Il Porto was also top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and had great suggestions. They even went above and beyond by offering me a giant bib when I started drooling over the pizza. Now, that’s what I call service with a smile.

All in all, if you’re in Buffalo and craving some truly excellent wood fired pizza, make your way to Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And hey, if you happen to see me there