The style of pizza I’m looking for is something that will leave a lasting impression and the shop must be the best in town. After eating through every single pizza place in town, I’ve narrowed down my favorite 12 to share with you.
Now, don’t expect any formal tasting or structured review here – instead you’ll get my humorous take on why these are the world’s classic pizzas. Let’s get started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Bella Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
I’m not just saying that, either. The menu selection is extensive with a wide range of delicious options that capture the essence of pizza culture around the world. From classic Neapolitan style to tasty deep-dish Chicago pies, they have something for everyone here.
The atmosphere is warm and inviting with traditional Italian decor and even a few Sicilian touches. The staff are friendly and welcoming with great customer service, so you can be sure you’ll get your order in good time – no matter how busy they are!
But most importantly, the pizza itself is fantastic! The crust is crispy but not too thick or too thin, just right. The sauce is flavourful without being overpowering and the toppings – from Pepperoni to Prosciutto – are always fresh and cooked to perfection.
In my experience, Bella Pizza has surpassed all my expectations, delivering some of the best pizza I’ve had in Elizabeth NJ!
If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Linden!
#2 LEO’S PIZZERIA 🍕
- Offers dessert
When I arrived at Leo’s Pizzeria, the first thing that struck me was how warm and inviting the atmosphere was. It’s clear from the moment you walk in that this is a place where people come to relax and enjoy some of the best pizza around.
The menu boasts a wide variety of pizza varieties, each one more delicious than the last. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic all-cheese pizza or something with more toppings like pepperoni, sausage, or olives, there’s something here to suit everyone’s taste buds. And if you’re feeling extra adventurous – they even have an ‘international’ section offering unique pizzas from around the world!
The staff at Leo’s Pizzeria are friendly and attentive – always willing to help should you require any assistance with ordering or recommendation.
As for the pizza itself – it is simply divine! The crust has just enough crunch but still manages to remain soft; truly a perfect balance. Each topping complemented each other perfectly too – so much so that I had difficulty deciding which one was my favorite!
To put it simply – Leo’s Pizzeria is hands down one of the best pizza places in Elizabeth NJ! Highly recommended!
#3 Pizzeria Montevideo
- Nice tourist spot
- Has insanely good dessert
The atmosphere at Montevideo was great. The staff was friendly and very knowledgeable about their menu. I especially liked the colorful decorations and vibrant music playing throughout the restaurant.
The pizzas at Pizzeria Montevideo were absolutely delicious! I had a traditional cheese pizza, and it was one of the best pies I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just enough sauce and gooey cheese to make each slice tempting.
For a more adventurous experience, I also tried their speciality pepperoni pizza with garlic cream sauce – wow! It had an amazing combination of flavors that left me wanting more.
Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Elizabeth NJ, Pizzeria Montevideo should definitely be your go-to spot! With its cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and delicious pizzas, it’s no surprise why this place has been declared the best pizza in town!
#4 Jersey Pizza USA
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
I visited the restaurant for lunch one day and was quickly impressed by their commitment to quality. The ingredients were fresh, and the dough had a perfect texture – light and airy with just enough crunch from the crust. The sauce was so flavorful that I almost wanted to drink it as soup!
The menu offers a variety of pizzas ranging from classic margheritas to more creative takes such as spicy pepperoni and pineapple. After much deliberation, I settled on the classic cheese pizza. Let me tell you – it did not disappoint! The cheese was gooey and melted in my mouth, while the flavors of basil, oregano, and garlic were perfectly balanced.
Overall, Jersey Pizza USA is a fantastic place for anyone looking for great pizza at an affordable price. I highly recommend them to anyone in Elizabeth NJ who wants the best pizza around!
#5 Pizza Express
On my recent visit to the restaurant, I was met with a friendly staff ready to provide a quality experience. The menu was full of delicious options, each one more tempting than the last! I decided on their pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint – it was so flavorful and covered in just enough cheese.
The atmosphere of Pizza Express is like a home away from home. It’s cozy yet energetic, just what you need for a great pizza experience. Plus, they have awesome daily specials, so you can save some money while enjoying the best pizza in Elizabeth NJ!
To top things off (no pun intended), the price at Pizza Express is unbeatable considering the quality of food that’s served. Their customer service is also top-notch – you feel welcomed as soon as you walk in the door. Frankly, I’m not sure why anyone would choose another pizza place over this one – Pizza Express is simply fantastic!
#6 John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
My experience was nothing short of amazing. When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately taken by the cozy atmosphere. The interior had a classic feel to it, with exposed brick and wooden tables that matched the pizza ovens in the back.
The staff were all incredibly friendly and welcoming, which definitely made me feel right at home. Most importantly, though, they certainly know their stuff when it comes to pizza! The menu items were all creative and delicious.
I decided to try their signature dish: a bacon-and-black olive pie with fresh basil on top. It was like nothing I’ve ever tasted before! The crust was cooked perfectly – crispy but not too crunchy – and the flavors of the toppings melded together flawlessly. Not only that but the portion size was more than generous for its price point too!
Overall, I can confidently say that John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers is one of the best pizza places in Elizabeth NJ (if not THE best!). If you’re looking for an incredible Italian eatery that provides great quality food with a relaxed vibe and friendly service, this is definitely worth checking out!
#7 Bruno’s Pizzeria
- Nice tourist spot
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
When I walked in I was overwhelmed by the tangy aroma of oregano and tomatoes. As soon as I took a seat, the friendly staff rushed over to take my order, their enthusiasm for pizza infectious.
The menu is extensive and varied enough to satisfy pizza lovers of all ages, with offerings ranging from traditional sauce-and-cheese pizzas to specialty pies topped with whatever ingredients you might choose. After long consideration (because it’s not easy when you have so many delicious options!), I decided on a classic pepperoni.
When it arrived at my table, I must say that I was gobsmacked! The melted cheese pulled apart like stringy Italian mozzarella and had a creamy, robust flavor that really brings out the taste of the sauce underneath. Topping it off was generous amounts of pepperoni; it was definitely a pizza worthy of being called one of the best in Elizabeth NJ!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Elizabeth NJ, Bruno’s Pizzeria is definitely worth a visit. Here, you’ll find some truly delicious food good enough to make your taste buds sing!
#8 Eli’s Pizza Pasta Ristorante
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
I recently visited this restaurant in hopes of finding the perfect slice of pizza, and I must say my expectations were exceeded. They offer a wide variety of toppings including the classic cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, and much more! The crust was cooked to absolute perfection and had an excellent flavor.
The service was also top-notch – the staff was friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting as well – it’s not just your typical pizza joint.
All in all, if you’re looking for some good ‘za in Elizabeth NJ then Eli’s Pizza Pasta Ristorante is definitely worth a visit! They have some of the best pizza in town and make sure they give customers a memorable experience.
If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Union!
#9 Michelinos
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
From the moment I walked in I knew that this restaurant was something special. The decor was inviting and the staff was friendly and welcoming.
What really blew me away, however, was the pizza! The crust was thin and crispy with just the right amount of char. Toppings were plentiful and fresh with an excellent combination of flavors. Not to mention their delicious homemade sauces that really made their pizza stand out from the rest.
At Michelinos you can tell they take great pride in what they do, which makes eating at their restaurant an experience all its own! All-in-all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Elizabeth NJ then be sure to check out Michelinos – you won’t be disappointed.
#10 Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve sampled pizza from all over, from Naples to New York City and everywhere in between. But nothing compares to the heavenly slices of goodness coming out of Santillo’s oven. The crust is perfectly cooked – not too thick and not too thin – and the sauce is incredibly flavorful with the right amount of spice. The cheese is gooey, melted goodness that really brings the whole dish together.
The toppings are also top notch – they use fresh vegetables and high-quality meats like pepperoni, sausage and ham. I had a slice of pepperoni pizza that was absolutely mouthwatering!
To top it all off, the atmosphere at Santillo’s is really inviting – dim lighting, cozy booths and an overall relaxing vibe. And even though they get quite busy at times there’s rarely much of a wait time.
If you’re ever in Elizabeth NJ looking for some delicious pizza, you absolutely have to try Santillo’s Brick Oven Pizza – it truly is some of the best pizza I have ever tried!
#11 Mario’s Famous Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The pizza here is truly one of a kind, with a very thin crust that has just the right amount of crunch. The sauce has an amazing blend of herbs and spices that will tantalize your taste buds. The cheese used is made from freshly shredded mozzarella and tastes absolutely delicious!
But what really stands out here are the toppings – they are huge chunks of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, olives, peppers and so much more! Each topping is cooked to perfection and adds an incredible flavor dimension to the pizza. It’s impossible to not love this pizza!
The prices are also surprisingly affordable – for a large pizza you can expect to pay about $15.
Overall, Mario’s Famous Pizza is without a doubt one of the best pizzas in Elizabeth NJ. If you’re ever visiting the area and looking for something special to eat at an affordable price point – this is definitely your place!
#12 Slices Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The first time I had the pleasure of visiting Slices Pizza, I was immediately impressed with the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. From the moment I walked in until the time I left, I felt right at home.
The pizzas were just as amazing as the atmosphere. Each slice was loaded with flavor and melted in my mouth! The crust was crispy and golden brown, while the toppings were fresh and oh-so-tasty. Not to mention, every cheese pull was spot-on! My taste buds were doing a happy dance after each bite.
But that’s not all; Slices Pizza also offers an impressive selection of drinks and desserts that are just as scrumptious as their pizzas. The Italian sodas are out of this world – definitely worth trying if you’re looking for something extraordinary!
All in all, I can honestly say without hesitation that Slices Pizza has some of the best pizza in Elizabeth NJ. The food is delicious and incredibly satisfying – no wonder they have a steady stream of customers coming back for more!
