Having tasted pizza all over the world, I’m happy to give my honest opinion on what I think are the best 12 pizza places in Erie. And to make it even more fun, I decided to keep things humorous and lighthearted along the way.
From classic cheese slices to unique toppings, I’m excited to share my experience finding the perfect pies in Erie PA. So let’s get this pizza party started!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Perry’s Tavern
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has some vegetarian options
The crust was perfection – light, chewy and nicely charred with just the right amount of seasoning. And the sauce that they use is so flavorful with a perfect balance of sweet and acidity. The toppings are fresh and plentiful, making every bite as good as the last.
The atmosphere at Perry’s Tavern was also top-notch! It was cozy and inviting, with lots of exposed brick walls, warm lighting, and some of the friendliest staff I’ve encountered in my travels. The prices were also incredibly reasonable for what you get; you’ll definitely get your money’s worth here!
All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Erie PA – look no further than Perry’s Tavern. Everything about it from the pizza to atmosphere was simply divine!
If you’re willing to go an extra 44 miles, you can get to 14 more pizza places in Jamestown!
#2 Virgil’s Plate
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
Upon entering, I was stunned by the incredible smell of their homemade dough and freshly melted cheese. The atmosphere was inviting and warm – definitely a great spot to hang out with friends!
I decided to go with the classic pepperoni pizza and I’m so glad I did. As soon as it arrived in front of me, I knew this pizza was something special. The crust was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunchiness; the pepperonis were flavorful without being too greasy; and the sauce was so well-balanced that it had me going back for more slices.
The best part? Virgil’s Plate offers some really unique toppings such as artichoke hearts and arugula that take your regular pizza up a few notches.
If you ask me, Virgil’s Plate has truly mastered the art of making delicious pizza. If you’re ever in Erie PA looking for an amazing pizza experience, make sure to check them out!
#3 Maria’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- No delivery
I recently visited Maria’s Pizza, and I must say I was very impressed. Not only were the pizzas top-notch, but there was also a great selection to choose from. There was something for everyone, from classic pepperoni to Hawaiian. As a traveling food critic and pizza lover, this place is truly a gem.
The atmosphere at Maria’s Pizza is fun and inviting. The place has a cozy, family-friendly vibe that makes it enjoyable for everyone. They also have a kid’s menu which is perfect for families with young children.
As an added bonus, they offer desserts too! Although desserts are not usually my thing, I have to admit that their sweet treats were quite delicious.
However, if you’re looking for delivery service then you’ll be disappointed to hear that Maria’s Pizza doesn’t offer delivery services. But on the bright side, the pizzas are so good that it’s worth it to make the drive over there!
Overall, Maria’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out if you’re craving some of the best pizza in Erie PA.
#4 Patti’s Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
I’m serious. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is perfect, the crust is nice and thick without being too doughy, and the veggies are always fresh and flavorful. There’s something new to try on their menu each week, and they really know how to get creative with toppings.
Plus, the customer service is out of this world! Every time I’ve come in, the staff has treated me like family. They remember my name and what sort of pizza I like, which is always a plus for me.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Erie PA that can rival any other place around the globe, look no further than Patti’s Pizza!
#5 Colony Pizza
- No delivery
I was immediately impressed with the quality of wood and brick used to decorate the interior. It felt cozy and inviting, as if I were in a pizza place right in the heart of Italy. The aroma of bubbling cheese and homemade dough filled my nostrils as soon as I stepped inside.
The menu boasted an abundance of delicious offerings. From classic pizza pies to specialty creations like steak tacos– there truly is something for everyone at Colony Pizza! After some deliberation, I opted for a classic pepperoni pie with extra cheese and ranch dipping sauce.
The pizza exceeded all expectations: the crust was light and crispy, the cheese was soft and gooey, and each pepperoni had been lovingly placed with attention to detail. The addition of fresh basil made this meal truly top-notch.
My taste buds have been on quite a journey since my visit to Colony Pizza! Sadly, they do not offer delivery services (yet). But if you’re in Erie PA looking for an incredible pizza experience, look no further than Colony Pizza– it’s simply the best!
#6 ippa Pizza Napoletana
It all starts with the dough, which is made fresh daily in-house. It’s light, fluffy and tastes incredible – truly a treat for the taste buds. I was particularly impressed with the wide selection of gourmet toppings they offer, from portobello mushrooms to goat cheese to kalamata olives – something for everyone!
I went for their famous margherita pizza, which comes topped with juicy tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and a sprinkle of basil. The crust was perfectly cooked and all those gorgeous flavors blended together perfectly in each bite.
The atmosphere at ippa Pizza Napoletana was really great too; from the decor to the music. The staff were friendly and attentive, making sure our experience was top notch.
So if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Erie PA then look no further than ippa Pizza Napoletana – you won’t be disappointed!
#7 Mama Mia’s Pizzeria
The first thing I noticed when I walked into Mama Mia’s was the fragrant aroma of fresh ingredients. The dough was perfectly cooked and had just the right amount of crunch, while the sauce was perfectly spiced with a hint of garlic that made my mouth water.
The toppings were piled high with flavorful goodness. The sausage was juicy and savory, the pepperoni had a pleasant snap to it and the mushrooms were tender and full of flavor.
I even tried one exotic slice – pineapple with jalapeno. At first, I thought it sounded like a crazy combination, but it surprisingly worked! It gave me a nice kick that balanced out the sweetness from the pineapple.
Overall, I’d definitely recommend Mama Mia’s Pizzeria to anyone seeking out great pizza in Erie PA. Their pies are always served hot and fresh, making for an enjoyable meal every time I’m in town!
#8 Skippereno’s Italian Restaurant
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- No delivery
The atmosphere is inviting and warm, and the staff were very welcoming. I was instantly taken with the place even before tasting their delicious offerings. The pizza was some of the best I’ve ever had! A perfect re-creation of an Italian classic, it was simply delicious.
In addition to great pizza they also offer a kid’s menu, so parents can bring along their little ones as well. And if you still have room for dessert after dinner, Skippereno’s Italian Restaurant has you covered there too!
Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery which would be a great addition to their already excellent services. But this is my only complaint about this wonderful restaurant. All in all, Skippereno’s Italian Restaurant is definitely worth checking out for anyone looking for great pizza in Erie PA!
If you’re willing to go an extra 69 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Mentor!
#9 Sticks & Bricks Wood Fired Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
From the first moment I walked through their doors, I could tell this was a place serious about pizza. The ovens were blazing hot, and you could smell the delicious aroma of wood-fired pies in the air. Their menu had enough variety to satisfy any pizza lover’s cravings – from classic cheese to veggie-packed specialties.
I’m always a sucker for a good crust, so I opted for the “Caramelized Onions & Mushroom” pie with their signature handmade dough. It was simply divine! Perfectly light yet crunchy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. On top of all that goodness was a layer of freshly picked herbs that really tied it all together. And don’t even get me started on their unique blend of sauces – creamy and just a little bit spicy!
All in all, Sticks & Bricks Wood Fired Pizza provided me with one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had yet. If you’re looking for some seriously scrumptious pies in Erie PA, this is definitely worth checking out!
#10 U Pick 6 Tap House
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Great place to watch sports
- No delivery
The great thing about this place is that it’s not just pizza they serve – they also offer a full selection of beers and hard liquors. So whether you’re looking for a solid meal or just after something to drink, U Pick 6 will sort you out.
I was also impressed by their range of child-friendly options. The kids’ menu is impressive and sure to keep the little ones happy. Plus, they offer delicious desserts as well!
Speaking of desserts, I’m pretty sure I just found my new favorite hangout spot in Erie PA – U Pick 6 Tap House is a great tourist destination as well as a great place to watch sports while downing some beers with friends.
One downside is that they don’t provide delivery services – but if you can manage to make it out there then believe me, the pizza is worth it. On the plus side though, you get the Tap House experience which you wouldn’t get with delivery!
Overall, my experience at U Pick 6 Tap House has been wonderful and I highly recommend it as one of the best places for pizza in Erie PA!
#11 Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I’ve been to some posh pizzerias and some not-so-posh, but Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is the perfect balance. It has an inviting atmosphere with a modern vibrancy that still stays true to its Italian roots.
The pizza here is simply outstanding! There’s something for everyone with their extensive menu ranging from classic pies to creative combinations featuring gourmet ingredients like truffle oil. I love how they pair the right toppings with their doughs to create amazing flavor profiles. The crust of each pizza is cooked perfectly and the cheese melts just right – never too much or too little.
What really stands out about Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is the care that goes into every bite. From the fresh ingredients to the generous portions, you can tell this place takes pride in what they do. They also have a great selection of beers and wines to complete your meal.
It’s no wonder why Valerio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria has earned its reputation as one of the best pizzas in Erie PA! In my opinion, it’s definitely a must-try when you’re in town.
#12 Donatos Pizza
- Offers dessert
Having tried pizza from all corners of the world, I was prepared to be disappointed when I stepped into this humble shop. But boy, was I surprised! These folks have perfected the art of pizza making. The crust was light and fluffy yet with a nice crunch to it. The toppings were generous yet not overpowering. Everything came together perfectly resulting in a flavor that I could savor for days.
What really impressed me though was the customer service. Everyone there was super friendly and welcoming regardless of how busy they were. All my questions were answered with smiles and genuine care, making me feel like part of the family in no time at all!
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Erie PA, look no further than Donatos Pizza. You won’t regret it!
