Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fargo ND (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Dakota

Best Pizza in Fargo ND (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

263 Views

I’m no stranger to good pizza, having tasted it all over the world. So when I was asked to review the best pizza in Fargo ND I knew it was a challenge I needed to accept.

What followed was an adventure of 12 pizza places sampled and rated, one better than the last. It’s been a wild ride, but I’m ready to reveal Fargo’s top spot for pizza! Join me as I take you on this delicious journey and surprise you with the best pizza that Fargo has to offer.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Dakota

#1 Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza

I was immediately impressed with the fragrant aroma of wood-fired pizza that filled the restaurant upon entrance. The crust was perfectly crisp and flavorful, with just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were brilliantly executed and could have easily been mistaken for those from a pizzeria in Rome or Naples!

The customer service was also top-notch – they must have read my mind because they had my perfect combination waiting for me before I even knew what I wanted! They truly do understand their customers’ desires.

Overall, Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza is a great experience for any pizza lover. Whether you’re looking for an authentic Italian-style pie or something more unique and creative, you won’t be disappointed! If you’re in Fargo ND, it’s definitely worth checking out – trust me!

If you’re willing to go an extra 70 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Grand Forks!

#2 Blaze Pizza

The first time I visited, I was blown away by the selection of toppings and crusts. They have a wide variety of interesting combinations that you can’t find anywhere else. Plus, their creative blends of sauces and spices give each pizza its own unique flavor.

The experience at Blaze Pizza doesn’t end with just the pizza. The atmosphere is lively and inviting, inviting you to stay for a while and enjoy your meal in this hip spot. The staff is always friendly and eager to talk about the pizzas they offer, so it’s nice to know these guys actually care about what they’re making.

The price is also very reasonable for such delicious pizza; two large pizzas for family night only cost me $25! Even better, their delivery service is fast, efficient and free – which makes it even easier to satisfy my craving for great pizza every time.

So if you’re ever in Fargo ND and looking for some great pizza, make sure to stop by Blaze Pizza; you won’t regret it! It’s definitely the best pizza in town!

#3 Rhombus Guys

As soon as I stepped into their restaurant, I was overwhelmed by the heavenly smell of fresh pizza dough and toppings. Everything about the place felt inviting – from the tempting visuals to the friendly staff.

The pizza itself was like an Italian masterpiece, with a thin and crispy Neapolitan crust, just enough chewy charring on the edges, and bursts of flavor in every bite. Each ingredient seemed sourced with thoughtfulness and care – even something as humble as their mozzarella was incredibly delicious!

I also tried a few of their unique topping combinations that you can’t find anywhere else like a truffle mac’n’cheese pizza (my personal favorite). Not to mention they also offer some great vegan options too!

All in all, Rhombus Guys is definitely worth the trip if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fargo ND!

#4 Sammy’s | Pizza & Restaurant

The selection is fantastic, with something on the menu to satisfy any pizza craving. The crust is freshly made and cooked to perfection. It’s so light and crispy – you can definitely taste the quality of this pizza!

Their toppings are incredibly fresh as well – every single ingredient that goes on their pies is handpicked to guarantee deliciousness. And not only do they have your classic toppings, but they also offer unique combinations that really bring out the flavor in each bite.

I’m also a huge fan of their customer service. The staff at Sammy’s | Pizza & Restaurant make sure that everyone who walks through their doors has a great experience from start to finish. They’re always friendly and accommodating to make sure you get exactly what you order.

I’ve been around the world tasting some of the best pizzas, and I have to say that Sammy’s | Pizza & Restaurant definitely takes the cake for having some of Fargo’s best pies!

#5 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The atmosphere was great and it had a real hometown feel. The employees were also very friendly and helpful.

When it comes to their pizza, Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza really hit it out of the park! First off, the crust was perfectly crispy with just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were also fresh and flavorful. From hand-sliced pepperoni to delicious mushrooms, it was all top-notch quality. I especially enjoyed their signature garlic sauce that made every bite even more delicious!

The overall experience at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza was fantastic and I’d highly recommend it for anyone looking for the best pizza in Fargo ND!

#6 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I visited this establishment with a group of friends, and upon entering we were quickly greeted by two friendly faces at the counter.

The options were plentiful; they had something for everyone, including several vegetarian options! My party of 5 settled on one ‘Create Your Own’ pizza, featuring pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives.

As the name implies, Papa Murphy’s does not deliver. It’s ‘take-n-bake,’ meaning you take it home to bake in your own oven. This was a bit of a hassle but I’m willing to accept a minor inconvenience for deliciousness!

Once we got home with our pizza and put it in the oven, we waited – impatiently – for that sweet smell of baking dough and melty cheese. Finally, the timer went off and it was time to feast! And what a feast it was: the crust was crispy on the bottom yet fluffy enough to be enjoyable; each topping was perfectly cooked and blended together fabulously. We all agreed that it is some of the best pizza we’ve ever tasted!

If you’re looking for amazing pizza in Fargo ND then you must go to Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza – trust me, you won’t regret it!

#7 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I’m no stranger to pizza, so I was pleased to hear that this pizza place offers some vegetarian options. However, I was disappointed to find out they don’t offer delivery – it really would have made things easier!

But it’s clear that their pizzas are worth the trip! When you get there, you can choose from a range of pre-made pizzas or create your own masterpiece. The topping selection is impressive and the crusts are cooked to perfection.

Once you’ve made your choice and paid for it, the staff will bake your ingredients in the oven, package them up for you and send you on your way. All you need to do is pop them in the oven at home and enjoy!

Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza has truly earned its place as one of the best pizzas in Fargo ND – I highly recommend it!

#8 Duane’s House of Pizza – Fargo

The atmosphere at Duane’s is casual, yet inviting. The staff are always friendly and welcoming, and it’s clear that they genuinely care about their customers.

The pizza itself is amazing. I have never encountered such delicious crust! It’s thin and crispy in some spots, chewy and fluffy in others. The flavors are also perfect – not too rich or overpowering but still full of zesty toppings and sauce.

What really takes the experience over the top is that you can customize your pizza with whatever toppings you desire. Upon my last visit, I opted for pepperoni, black olives and jalapenos – it was out of this world!

I’d give Duane’s House of Pizza – Fargo 5 stars out of 5…hands down the best pizza in Fargo ND! Do yourself a favor and give them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 152 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in St Cloud!

#9 Spicy Pie – Downtown Fargo

My experience at this restaurant was truly unique. Upon entering the doors, I was immediately taken in by the vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff. The decor was filled with brightly colored walls and fun decorations, making it a great place to enjoy dinner with friends or family.

The menu is full of delicious options, but I highly recommend the classic pepperoni pizza. It has the perfect amount of cheese and spices, plus it’s cooked to perfection in an authentic stone oven. The crust is really what sets this pizza apart from other pizzas; it has a wonderful crunch that keeps you coming back for more!

If you’re looking for something different try one of their specialty pizzas like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza or Thai Curry Pizza. Every bite is bursting with flavor and makes for a truly memorable pizza experience.

To accompany your pizza, Spicy Pie – Downtown Fargo also offers a wide selection of appetizers and craft beer. All in all, this place was definitely one of the best pizza experiences I’ve had, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for an excellent meal in Fargo ND!

#10 Boston’s Restaurant & Sports Bar

From their signature loaded pizza with five different kinds of amazing cheese to their classic pepperoni and mushroom combo, the variety at Boston’s Restaurant is second to none. And all of it is topped with fresh-cut veggies, meats and herbs.

Their crusts are light, airy and perfectly crisp. Sauce options range from tangy marinara to creamy alfredo, each one flavorful and full of character. The chefs really know their stuff!

The atmosphere isn’t too shabby either – with multiple flat screen televisions throughout the restaurant you can keep up on your favorite sports games while savoring a slice or two of pizza. It’s almost like having your own personal sports bar in the comfort of your home (minus the beer selection)!

When I’m looking for great pizza in Fargo ND, Boston’s Restaurant & Sports Bar will always be my go-to spot. Their welcoming staff, tasty pies and laid-back vibe make for an enjoyable experience with every visit. I’d bet you won’t find better pizza around these parts!

#11 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I’m not sure what I like more – the selection of vegetarian options available or the warm, friendly service I received from the establishment. They have everything from classic cheese and pepperoni pizzas to gourmet creations with olives and arugula. No matter what your preference is, you can always find something delicious at Papa Murphy’s.

Of course, the drawback is that they don’t deliver – but that doesn’t take away from the quality of their product. You just have to bake it for yourself at home! With a few simple steps, (including preheating the oven) you’ll be able to enjoy a hot and delicious pizza in no time.

All in all, I’d definitely recommend a visit to Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza if you’re looking for great pizza in Fargo ND – it’s definitely one of my favorite places!

#12 Spicy Pie – West Fargo

The first thing that draws you in is the delicious smell of pizza as you walk through the door. Right away I knew this was going to be a great pizza experience.

The staff was friendly and accommodating. They took the time to explain all the topping options and make sure I got exactly what I wanted. The selection of toppings also lived up to my expectations with plenty of variety for any appetite.

But, let’s get down to the important part: how’s the pizza? Well, it exceeded all my expectations! The crust was thin and crispy, just as I like it. And whatever type of cheese they use has to be top notch because it melted perfectly over the top and had an amazing flavor. Plus, the sauce was one of the best I have ever tasted!

Overall, Spicy Pie – West Fargo gets two big thumbs up from me! It easily beats out any other local pizzeria when it comes to taste and quality – hands down. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fargo ND then look no further than Spicy Pie – West Fargo!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza

As soon as I walked into Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza, I was hit with the intoxicating aroma of wood-fired perfection. The crackling sound of the flames dancing with the dough made me weak in the knees. I felt like I was about to experience a pizza symphony, conducted by the culinary maestros in their open kitchen.

Let’s talk about the crust. Oh mama mia, the crust! Thin, crisp, and slightly charred, it was like biting into a cloud that had been kissed by the fireplace gods. It had just the right amount of chewiness, with a symphony of flavors that made me question if I had ever truly tasted pizza before.

The toppings were out of this world. From classic margherita to wacky combinations like bacon, pineapple, and jalapenos (don’t knock it till you try it), they had it all. Each bite was a delightful surprise, a journey through flavor town that left me wanting more.

The staff at Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza were friendly and accommodating, making me feel like a pizza royalty. They even let me sneak a peek at their wood-fire oven, which I swear is like the Ferrari of pizza-making.

So, if you find yourself in Fargo and crave the best thin crust pizza around, head straight to Blackbird Wood Fire Pizza. I guarantee they’ll whisk you away on a heavenly journey of crispy crusts, tantalizing toppings, and some serious pizza magic.