Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fayetteville AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Arkansas

Best Pizza in Fayetteville AR (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

154 Views

After having tasted pizza from different parts of the world, I’m excited to share with you my top twelve picks for the best pizza in Fayetteville AR. Though this quest was no easy feat, I managed to try out over a dozen pizza places and found some real gems that impress even a food critic like me.

I’m sure you’ll read with much anticipation as I take you through what makes each of these pizzas so special. Get ready for stories about the wood-fired ovens and cheesy crusts that will make your mouth water and your stomach grumble!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Arkansas

#1 Wicked Wood Fired Pizza

The pizza crust was perfectly thin and crispy, just like I like it. The combination of savory and sweet flavors in the sauce was masterfully done. The toppings were fresh, tender and flavorful. All in all, the pizza hit all the right notes for me.

I also tried their salads, which were fresh and delicious. They had a nice selection of dressings to choose from, which made for excellent pairings with each salad.

The staff at Wicked Wood Fired Pizza are friendly and helpful, making sure I got exactly what I wanted. Plus they let me sample some of their other creations so I could find something that suited my taste buds even better!

Overall, this is one of the best pizza restaurants I’ve ever been to. Whether you’re looking for classic Italian-style pies or creative specialty pizzas, Wicked Wood Fired has something to satisfy everyone’s cravings!

If you’re willing to go an extra 21 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Bentonville!

#2 Tim’s Pizza

When I first arrived at Tim’s Pizza, I was surprised to find a pizza joint tucked away in an unassuming shopping center. The interior was small but cozy and welcoming.

I quickly ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza with extra cheese – one of their signature dishes – and waited anxiously for it to arrive. When it finally did, it smelled heavenly and tasted even better! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, the cheese melted perfectly on top and there were plenty of pepperoni and mushrooms.

It’s no wonder why this place is so popular among locals; they know good pizza when they taste it! After just one slice of Tim’s Pizza, I can confidently say that this is the best pizza in Fayetteville AR. If you’re ever in town, make sure to stop by Tim’s Pizza – your tastebuds won’t be sorry!

#3 Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville

I was incredibly impressed by the tasty, fresh ingredients and the wood-fired crust. It’s a great combination that makes for a memorable experience every time.

The service at Mellow Mushroom is friendly, helpful and fast. They make ordering and paying for your pizza quick and easy. Plus, they always have a variety of different sauces available to customize your pizza however you like it!

But what really sets Mellow Mushroom apart from other pizzerias is their unique atmosphere. From the bright colors to the fun decor, they’ve managed to create an exciting pizzeria experience unlike any other. There’s plenty of seating available both indoors and out, so there’s always room for everyone!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Fayetteville AR, you can’t go wrong with Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville!

#4 Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar

The atmosphere is great — it always feels like a lively party. Not only does the pizza taste amazing, but you get to watch it being made right in front of you! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, so you can be sure to get exactly what you asked for.

I’ve had several different types of pizzas from Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar and each one has been fantastic. The crusts are thin and crispy with just the right amount of crunch or softness depending on your preference. The toppings are expertly chosen, perfectly combined, and perfectly cooked so that each bite is as delicious as the last.

I also have to mention their house made beer which accompanies the perfect slice of pizza! When I’m visiting Fayetteville AR I make a point to visit Marley’s Pizzeria & Bar — they truly have some of the best pizza that I have ever had!

#5 Geraldi’s

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was immediately impressed by the quaint and cozy atmosphere. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, informing me about their specials before sending me off to sample their fantastic pizza.

The pizza itself was divine! The crust had the perfect amount of crispiness, with a nice chewy texture that made each bite absolutely delicious. Toppings were flavorful and plentiful, sprinkled generously across the entire pie. I couldn’t help but finish every last piece of it!

The restaurant also has an impressive selection of drinks to choose from, including a wide variety of craft beers as well as wines and cocktails.

All in all, I would highly recommend Geraldi’s to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Fayetteville AR. Not only is the food excellent, but the service is top-notch and the atmosphere is extremely inviting. Definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

#6 Pieology Pizzeria, Fayetteville, AR

I was skeptical at first, as I’d heard of Pieology Pizzeria before and it is mainly a chain restaurant. But after sampling their delicious thin-crust pizzas with a variety of toppings, I can confidently say that this is the best pizza in Fayetteville AR!

The atmosphere at Pieology Pizzeria was inviting and cheerful. They had all the classic favorites available, as well as some more unusual options for those looking for something different. The staff were friendly and helpful, making sure we had everything we needed and that our orders were correct.

The pizza itself was cooked to perfection – crispy and bubbling. The toppings were incredibly flavorful, and paired perfectly with the salty thin crust. We tried several flavors from classic pepperoni to Italian sausage and even a unique vegan option! Each one was cooked to perfection, so there’s something here for everyone’s taste buds.

Overall, I highly recommend Pieology Pizzeria for amazing thin-crust pizza in Fayetteville AR! Whether you’re looking for an old favorite or something new and exciting, they have it all here. Even the most discerning pizza connoisseur will be satisfied!

#7 Wood Stone Craft Pizza

My first impression walking into Wood Stone Craft Pizza was that the decor was modern and inviting—I instantly felt at home. The menu boasted a variety of specialty pizzas, from classics such as Margherita to exotic creations like the “Peppered Apple Bacon.” My mouth watered just looking at the menu!

In the end I decided on their best-known pizza, the “Sky High Pie,” which features four cheeses and an array of fresh vegetables. It looked absolutely delicious. Taking my first bite, I immediately knew why Wood Stone Craft Pizza had such a stellar reputation—the crust was perfectly cooked, with a unique charred flavor that made it incredibly enjoyable. Every component of the pizza complemented each other in perfect harmony; it was truly one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted!

Finally, I can say without hesitation that Wood Stone Craft Pizza has some of the best pizza in Fayetteville AR. If you’re ever in town, be sure to stop by and get a slice—you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Mojo’s Pints & Pies

When I arrived, I immediately noticed the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Then, when I got my hands on their pizza, I’m glad to report that it was an absolute delight. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy without too much grease, while the toppings were just in the right ratio – not too skimpy but not overly generous either.

The highlight of Mojo’s Pints & Pies, however, has to be their unique flavor combinations. From classic cheese and pepperoni to more adventurous options like chorizo and jalapeno, Mojo’s offers something for everyone. I’m still dreaming about their smoked Gouda and bacon pizza – a true masterpiece!

All in all, I can definitely see why Mojo’s Pints & Pies is considered to have some of the best pizza in Fayetteville AR. If you’re looking for a great place for pizza night with friends or family, then this is definitely where you should go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 32 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Eureka Springs!

#9 Wood Stone Craft Pizza Uptown

The atmosphere was great, the staff was friendly and accommodating, and the menu had something for everyone. On top of their regular pizza menu they also offer vegetarian options, a kid’s menu, and even desserts! And to top it all off, they serve alcohol – including hard liquor!

Of course, nothing’s perfect. They don’t offer delivery service so if you’re looking for pizza to come to you – this isn’t your spot.

But if you’re looking for great pizza in Fayetteville AR then Wood Stone Craft Pizza Uptown should definitely be on your list of places to visit. It’s a great tourist spot with delicious pizza that won’t disappoint!

#10 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

I recently visited the Fayetteville location of this famed pizza restaurant and was not disappointed. The staff were incredibly friendly, and they even allowed me to sample a few pieces of their delicious pizza while I was there!

I tried some of their classic pepperoni pizza, as well as a few of their creative specialty pies, including a Hawaiian-style pizza with pineapple and ham. Both options were cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside but still chewy in the middle – just like real Italian pizza should be! The toppings were fresh and flavorful.

One thing that really sets Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza apart from other pizzerias is their unique “Take N Bake” process. Customers can select from an array of different pre-made pizzas, add any additional toppings they want, then take it home to bake in their own ovens at whatever temperature they choose. It ensures that you get the absolute best out of your pizza every time you order!

All in all, I can confidently say that Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza is one of the best pizzerias in Fayetteville AR! Highly recommended if you’re looking for a delicious slice (or two!) of authentic Italian-style pizza.

#11 Gusano’s Chicago Style Pizzeria

I was impressed with the variety of options that Gusano’s had to offer. From a classic deep dish to a unique corn pizza- there is truly something for everyone. And boy, it was delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked and nicely crispy, just how I like it. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, and the sauce was out of this world!

The atmosphere at Gusano’s is quite cozy and inviting. The staff were friendly and helpful, offering suggestions on what pizza I should try. Plus they had some great beer on tap that complimented the meal perfectly.

In my opinion, Gusano’s has the best pizza in Fayetteville AR! Whether you’re looking for something simple or something more adventurous- you’ll find it here. Highly recommended!

#12 Jim’s Razorback Pizza

I was immediately taken back by the amazing aromas coming from the restaurant when I stepped inside. I knew I was in for something special. The menu was impressive, offering a variety of styles and types of pizza. Everything from Chicago-style deep dish to Hawaiian-style pizza!

The pizzas themselves were fantastic. The crust was expertly cooked, with just the right amount of crispiness and charring around the edges. The toppings were flavorful and plentiful, making every slice even better. All of their ingredients are fresh and high-quality, so you can taste the difference in each bite.

To top it all off, the staff at Jim’s Razorback Pizza is some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered. They make sure all customers have a great experience and are happy with their food.

Overall, Jim’s Razorback Pizza has earned its place as one of the best pizzerias in Fayetteville AR! If you’re ever in town, be sure to give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!