Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fayetteville NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in North Carolina

Best Pizza in Fayetteville NC (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

218 Views

I’ve had the pleasure of tasting pizza all around the world, so I thought it would be fun to review the best pizza places in Fayetteville. Out of the 12 places I tried, these are my top picks for where you should get your favorite slice.

My reviews are always lighthearted and humorous, so expect some laughs along with some savvy cheese pulling advice! It’s time to dig in and find out who has the best pizza in Fayetteville NC.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of North Carolina

#1 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The set-up at Papa Murphy’s is unique – they don’t have an oven to bake the pizzas in-house, instead, you’re provided with all of the ingredients and you have to take it home and bake it in your own oven. It feels like a pizza-making class!

I was pleasantly surprised when I finished baking my Papa Murphy’s pizza and tasted how delicious it was. The crust was perfectly crispy and flavorful – everything about it was spot-on! Additionally, the toppings were fresh and flavorful. All of the ingredients worked together wonderfully and made for an unforgettable pizza experience.

Most importantly, though, the price of Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza makes it worth the visit. For under ten dollars, you can get an amazing pizza that you can cook yourself at home – it’s a great value for your money! From my perspective as a traveling food critic, I give Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza five stars out of five!

If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 18 more pizza places in Fuquay-Varina!

#2 Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

My experience here was nothing short of amazing. I started my meal with a nice glass of local beer and one of their veggie antipasto plates, which really hit the spot. From there, my expectations were high… and they were met – the pizza was insanely tasty!

I can wholeheartedly recommend this place to anyone looking for good pizza, especially if you want to impress someone special. It’s so much more than just a tourist spot, it’s an outstanding pizza joint!

Plus, if you like sweet treats after your meal, the dessert here is absolutely heavenly.

The only downside I could find was that this restaurant does not offer delivery service… but trust me, even if you have to go out of your way to get here, it’ll be worth it for the best pizza in town!

#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the inviting atmosphere—the restaurant had a cozy, homey vibe and the employees were incredibly friendly. The menu was full of delicious options and it didn’t take me long to decide on their famous Olallieberry Pie—loaded with mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, and sausage.

I ordered my pizza to-go and took it back to my hotel room where I couldn’t wait to try it out. When I popped open the box, the aroma alone made my mouth water. It looked absolutely divine! The crust was light yet crisp with plenty of garlic seasoning, and the toppings were cooked perfectly. The cheese was melted just enough to be gooey but not so much that it became soggy.

My experience at Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza has been one of the best pizza experiences I’ve ever had—forget Italy and New York City, Fayetteville has some of the best pizza in the world! I recommend Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza to anyone looking for great tasting pizza without having to leave town.

#4 Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant

The pizzas here are made with the freshest ingredients, ensuring that every bite is perfect. The restaurant offers a wide variety of toppings to choose from, so you can customize your pizza just the way you like it.

What really sets Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant apart from other pizzerias is the customer service. Every time I visit, I’m greeted with a warm smile and a friendly attitude that makes me feel right at home.

The atmosphere at Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant adds to the experience as well. It’s decorated in a classic Italian style and has a cozy feel to it. It makes for an enjoyable dining experience each and every time I go there.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fayetteville NC, look no further than Pizza Palace Italian Restaurant. You won’t be disappointed!

#5 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere is great, with a cool, modern vibe and bustling energy. And the pizza… well wow! It’s made-to-order with amazing fresh ingredients, so you can choose your own toppings and create your own custom masterpiece.

Plus, the whole experience is incredibly fast and easy. I always felt comfortable knowing that my pizza was being cooked to perfection right before my eyes.

But what truly makes MOD Pizza stand out from other pizza places is their commitment to quality. The chefs are very friendly and their dedication to creating the best pizza in Fayetteville NC is evident in every bite. My friends were amazed by how delicious it was!

Trust me, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fayetteville NC, look no further than MOD Pizza!

#6 Primo Pizza

The service at Primo Pizza was top-notch. Everyone was incredibly friendly and helpful throughout my visit, which made for a great experience.

The pizza itself is something to write home about! All of the pizzas are freshly made with the highest quality ingredients. The crusts were perfectly crispy, the sauce was flavorful and not too overpowering, and all of the toppings were cooked to perfection. I must say though – their specialty pepperoni pizza is out of this world! It’s definitely worth trying if you’re ever in Fayetteville NC.

Overall, Primo Pizza is a one-stop shop for delicious slices of pizza heaven! I’d highly recommend checking it out if you’re ever in Fayetteville NC and looking for a tasty meal. Trust me…you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Elizabeth’s Pizza & Restaurant

The atmosphere was cozy, with a delightful Italian heritage decor. I loved the little chalkboard that listed daily specials and other fun facts.

I kicked off my pizza tour with a classic Margherita pizza and boy was it delicious! The tomato sauce was rich and flavorful, and the mozzarella was so creamy! Even the crust was just right – not too thick or too thin. I also had a personal pizza covered in peppers, mushrooms, and bacon, which was unbelievably tasty.

Overall, the service at Elizabeth’s Pizza & Restaurant was great. The staff were really friendly and attentive to our needs when ordering. They even brought us out samples of some of their most popular pizzas to try (which I thought was a nice touch).

Overall, Elizabeth’s Pizza & Restaurant is definitely one of the best pizza places in Fayetteville NC. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience – look no further than Elizabeth’s!

#8 Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant

It’s no wonder that this restaurant is a favorite among locals—the flavors here are absolutely delicious. The dough they use is so light and fluffy, yet still charred to perfection in their wood-fired ovens. I had the classic Margherita pizza, which was topped with fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh basil—it tasted like it had been freshly picked from an Italian garden.

The toppings were plentiful, and the combination of ingredients seemed to be chosen specifically for my taste buds! Even the crust was perfect—the sauce was tangy enough to be flavorful without being too overpowering, and the seasoning was just right.

My server was friendly and attentive—he even offered me samples of some of their other pizza offerings! I definitely plan on returning soon to try them all out.

In conclusion, Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant is the best place for pizza lovers in Fayetteville NC! The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, the food is delicious, and there’s something for everyone. Do yourself a favor and check it out—you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 48 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Apex!

#9 Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville

My experience there on a recent visit was outstanding. From the minute I walked in, the staff made me feel like a valued customer. They had beer, hard liquor and even non-alcoholic drinks. If you’ve got little ones, they have kid’s menu items as well, so no one has to be left out of the fun!

Plus, if you’re vegetarian or vegan, there are some great options on offer here. And the dessert? Oh my gosh! Insanely good. Very light but decadently delicious – which is an incredibly tough combination to pull off.

One of the things that make Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville stand out though is that it’s a great tourist spot AND it’s perfect for catching sports games too – usually having them all on multiple different screens at once so everyone can enjoy what they want to watch.

However, the only downside that I could find was that they don’t deliver, but that’s such a minor issue – all things considered – compared to everything else going for Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville. If you’re looking for great pizza in Fayetteville NC – including vegan and vegetarian options – then Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville should definitely be your number one choice!

#10 Litty’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I was welcomed with a friendly smile and an inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is decorated with colorful Italian decorations and vibrant art that immediately put me in the mood for pizza!

I started my meal off by ordering a classic Margherita pizza. It was perfectly cooked – the crust was chewy, the sauce was flavorful, and the toppings were fresh. In addition to being delicious, it was also huge enough to share which made for a great dinner for two.

Next on my agenda was their signature dish – the “Litty’s Delight”. This massive pie came loaded with all sorts of goodies like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and jalapenos. The flavor combination was amazing and definitely lived up to its name.

If you’re looking for something a little out of the ordinary, Litty’s also offers some unique items like chorizo quesadillas and deep-dish calzones. Every item I tried was delightful and left me wanting more!

To top it all off, their prices were very reasonable and their service couldn’t have been better. All in all, Litty’s Pizza is definitely one of the best pizza places in Fayetteville NC and should not be missed!

#11 Elizabeth’s Pizza And Italian Restaurant

From the moment I stepped in the door, it was clear that Elizabeth’s was a cut above the rest. The restaurant was immaculate and smelled heavenly. The attentive staff welcomed me warmly and quickly got me seated with a piping hot pizza waiting on my table.

The pizza was quite simply delicious! The crust had a perfect crunch – not too thick, not too thin – and the sauce was flavorful without being overly acidic or salty. On top of all that, each slice is piled high with generous amounts of cheese and toppings. If you’re looking for a pizza experience to remember, this is where you need to go!

I can honestly say that Elizabeth’s Pizza And Italian Restaurant offers some of the best pizza in Fayetteville NC, so don’t miss out on this amazing spot! With great food, great service and reasonable prices, it really should be on your list of places to try when visiting Fayetteville.

#12 Brooklyn Pizzeria

From their mouth-watering slices to their savory pies, Brooklyn Pizzeria knows how to whip up a delicious pizza pie. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting – perfect for enjoying a slice with friends or family.

Their menu features classic favorites like the Margherita Pizza and White Pie, as well as signature creations like the Three Cheese Pie and Meat Lover’s Delight. Every topping is fresh and flavorful. Plus, they have an extensive selection of vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions. No matter what type of pizza you’re in the mood for, the chefs at Brooklyn Pizzeria are sure to satisfy your taste buds!

But that’s not all that makes this pizzeria special: each order comes with a side of humor! Whether it’s a joke from the friendly waitstaff or witty puns on the menu, there’s never a dull moment when you stop by Brooklyn Pizzeria.

In summary, if you’re ever in Fayetteville NC and looking for some of the best pizza around town – look no further than Brooklyn Pizzeria! And don’t forget to enjoy some good laughs while you’re at it!