Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Fernandina Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Fernandina Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

124 Views

Over the years, I’ve eaten my way through Europe, Asia, South America and beyond in search of amazing pizza. But on a recent visit to Fernandina Beach, I decided to check out what this city had to offer. To that end, I followed my nose and my stomach to sample pizzas from 12 of the area’s pizza joints.

I’m eager to share my findings — what topped the list for best pizza in Fernandina Beach? Read on and you’ll find out! But first things first: let’s keep things light and humorous as we embark on this gastronomical exploration!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Townies Pizzeria

On the outside, Townies is your typical neighborhood pizzeria. But it’s what’s inside that makes it special. The moment you walk in, tantalizing aromas of freshly-baked crust and sweet tomato sauce fill the air.

The menu is extensive and offers a variety of delicious pies to choose from – whether you prefer classic Margherita or something spicier like pepperoni and jalapenos – there’s sure to be something for everyone.

But what sets Townies apart is their unique combination of fresh ingredients and homemade dough which they make with only the finest ingredients. They don’t skimp on quality here. Every bite is filled with cheesy goodness and hits just the right notes of saltiness and sweetness.

I’m also a huge fan of their customer service, which I’d describe as friendly yet professional. Everyone in the restaurant was willing to answer my questions regarding their ingredients and recipes – they want their customers to know exactly how much effort goes into making each pie perfect!

At the end of my visit, I can confidently say that Townies Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Fernandina Beach. Whether you’re looking for an Italian favorite or something a little more adventurous, this place has got you covered!

If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Jacksonville Beach!

#2 Moon River Pizza

The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff was very friendly. I was especially impressed at how quickly they were able to get my pizza out – usually when you order a ‘gourmet’ pizza like this it takes forever, but not here.

The pizza itself was really something else. The crust was perfectly done, with just enough crunch to satisfy yet still flavorful. Plus the amount of toppings they put on was incredible! I had a lobster and goat cheese pizza that was just overflowing with fresh ingredients. What more could you want?

Overall, Moon River Pizza really is one of the best pizzerias in Fernandina Beach – definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in town craving some good old-fashioned Italian flavor!

#3 Coastal Pizza

The atmosphere here is great. You walk in and the smell of fresh-baked pizza fills the air. You can watch them making it right there in the kitchen while you wait for your order.

The pizza itself was awesome! It had a really thin, crispy crust that held up well to all the toppings. I had my usual favorite – pepperoni and sausage – but they also had an amazing selection of specialty pizzas, too. The ingredients were fresh and full of flavor.

The staff was friendly, chatty, and fun to be around; they certainly added to the experience. I got a few recommendations from them while ordering and everything I tried ended up being worth it!

In conclusion, I’d say Coastal Pizza is definitely up there with some of the best pizza in Fernandina Beach. If you’re looking for good pizza, this is definitely a spot you should check out!

#4 Arte Pizza

The ambience was perfect – a cozy, brick-walled interior that was buzzing with activity. The staff were very friendly and accommodating – they made sure we got exactly what we wanted.

But the real star here is the pizza! The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, with just the right amount of charring on the edges. The tomato sauce had the perfect balance of flavor and sweetness, and was nicely complemented by the generous amounts of cheese. Every bite tasted like I was eating a little piece of heaven!

I tried several different pies during my visit, but my favorite had to be their large pepperoni pizza. The juicy slices of pepperoni added an amazing depth of flavor to each slice. I could have eaten it all night!

All in all, Arte Pizza has easily earned its title as one of the best pizzerias in Fernandina Beach – I’d highly recommend it to any pizza fanatics out there who are looking for a delicious meal.

If you’re willing to go an extra 27 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Jacksonville!

#5 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I arrived at the restaurant was that the atmosphere was friendly and inviting. The staff were helpful and knowledgeable about their menu, which made it easy for me to make a decision.

The pizza itself was truly exquisite! The crust had just the right amount of crunch, and the sauce was flavorful without being too overpowering. Topping choice is a breeze – you can get anything from pepperoni to mushrooms, or create your own combination.

I also thought that the prices were reasonable – they definitely won’t break your wallet! Plus, they offer delivery if you’re too busy to dine in-house. You really can’t go wrong with Domino’s Pizza!

To sum it up, Domino’s Pizza is an excellent choice if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Fernandina Beach. Highly recommended!

#6 The Loop Restaurant

When I first walked in the door I was met with a pleasant surprise. The interior was cozy and inviting, and everyone was so friendly! After sitting down, I was eager to get to the pizza.

The menu was impressive – they had some amazing specialty pizzas as well as more classic pies. To start things off, I ordered a delicious margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, the tomato sauce delightful, and the fresh mozzarella cheese melted just right.

I also had the chance to try out one of their unique concoctions – a bacon and jalapeno pizza. It sounded strange at first but once it arrived at my table, I knew this would be something special. Each ingredient blended together perfectly and the combination of smoky bacon and spicy jalapeno peppers gave the pie an incredible depth of flavor.

All told, The Loop Restaurant provides some of the best pizza in Fernandina Beach. From classic pies to creative combinations, every pizza is top-notch in quality here. If you’re looking for good food without pretentiousness or expense, look no further than The Loop Restaurant for your next pizza fix!

#7 OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café

The pizza is delicious. The crust is thin, crunchy and full of flavor with just the right amount of charring. The topping options are plentiful and creative, from classic pepperoni to more creative choices like roasted garlic mushroom.

The atmosphere in OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café is outstanding. It’s an inviting space, filled with rustic wood décor and a cozy ambiance. The staff is friendly and helpful, so you can just sit back and relax while enjoying their delicious pizza.

And let’s not forget about the desserts either! They have an amazing selection of cakes, pies, cookies and ice cream sundaes – all made from the freshest ingredients.

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Fernandina Beach, look no further than OPS Pizza Kitchen & Café!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Jacksonville!

#8 Natural Slice Pizza And Surf Shop

The first thing that really caught my eye was the pizza. It’s perfectly cooked every single time, with a crunchy and chewy texture. The flavors are just right – not too much sauce, not too spicy, but just enough to make your mouth water.

As far as toppings go, they have a great selection of traditional and gourmet choices. My personal favorite is the Mushroom Bacon Pizza – crispy bacon and juicy mushrooms are always a winning combination!

The staff at Natural Slice is incredibly friendly and helpful. They always take their time to explain all the options available on the menu so that you can make the most informed decision possible.

I was also pleasantly surprised by their prices. Their pizzas are reasonably priced, considering how good they are. Plus, if you get there early, they offer daily happy hour specials for even more savings!

All in all, Natural Slice Pizza And Surf Shop has become my number one choice for great tasting pizza in Fernandina Beach. I’d highly recommend it to anyone in search of the best pizza in town!

#9 V Pizza – Fernandina Beach

The atmosphere is great – it’s a great tourist spot and an awesome place to watch your favorite sports games. What’s more, they serve alcohol and offer a kid’s menu – what more could you want?

The pizza itself is even better than the atmosphere – the crust is thin and crispy, the cheese melted to perfection and the toppings are out of this world! All in all, you can expect a delicious slice no matter your craving!

My only concern with V Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery – which can be a bit of a bummer. But trust me—it’s worth it to make the trip to get their amazing pizza (especially if you’re looking for something sweet afterwards as they also have some pretty delicious desserts).

Overall, I think V Pizza is one of the best pizzerias in Fernandina Beach – so make sure to check it out for yourself!

#10 Coastal pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting, with an open kitchen and plenty of seating. The staff were friendly and eager to help, making sure I had everything I needed during my meal.

The pizza itself was amazing! The crust was crunchy on the outside but still tender on the inside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, making every bite a delight. They also have different specialty pies like the seafood pizza that is just out of this world good!

But the best part of my experience came when I tried their garlic knots. They were really light and fluffy, and when you dipped them in the garlic butter sauce it was pure bliss!

All in all, Coastal Pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in Fernandina Beach looking for some of the best pizza around. Trust me – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 21 more pizza places in Brunswick!

#11 la Finestra Italiana, Amelia

The restaurant itself is a nice tourist spot and an inviting atmosphere. I enjoyed the wood-fired oven baking up thin crust pizzas – you can literally smell them from blocks away!

I had a classic Margherita pizza with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, garlic and basil. It was simply delicious! The dough was thin and crispy, and the toppings were just right. I also tried some of their other pizzas like the Napoletana which was loaded with mushrooms, olives and prosciutto.

The only downside to this restaurant is that they don’t offer delivery – you have to come in if you want to experience its deliciousness. So even though it may be a bit inconvenient having to go there, it’s worth it for one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!

#12 Ciao Italian Eatery

The atmosphere was great – it’s the perfect spot for tourists and locals alike. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed for a great evening. Plus, they even serve alcohol! I’m not much of a drinker myself, but if you’re in the mood for something more than just soda or iced tea, you’ll be happy here.

As for the food – it was amazing! The pizzas are cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and delicious toppings. They have vegetarian options so everyone can join in on the fun. One of my favorite parts about Ciao Italian Eatery is their insanely good desserts. Even though I was stuffed by the end of our meal, I still made room for some of their signature desserts – it was worth every bite!

Unfortunately, this restaurant doesn’t offer delivery, so you’ll have to dine-in or pick up your order if you want to join in on the pizza party at Ciao Italian Eatery. But I promise – it’s worth the trip!