Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Freehold NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Freehold NJ (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

248 Views

For my latest review, I wanted to see which of the 12 pizza places in Freehold NJ offer the best pies. From classic New York slices to wood-fired ovens and beyond, I’ve explored it all!

I’m now ready to share my findings with you – in a humorous, lighthearted way – so that you can finally decide who has the best pizza in Freehold NJ. To find out who came out on top, keep reading…

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Romeo’s Pizza Italian American

I recently visited Romeo’s for lunch and had an amazing experience. The atmosphere was inviting and the staff was friendly and welcoming. Not to mention, the pizza was absolutely delicious! The crust was light, airy, and perfectly crispy on the outside with a wonderful chewy texture inside. Each bite me made my mouth water!

The selection of toppings was also great with choices ranging from traditional pepperoni, sausage, and green peppers to more creative options like olives, jalapenos, and artichokes. Every bite was filled with a delicious combination of flavors that really added to my overall experience.

Overall I would highly recommend Romeo’s Pizza Italian American as some of the best pizza in Freehold NJ. As a food critic who has been all over the world tasting pizza I can confidently say they have earned their place among other high-quality pizzerias!

If you’re willing to go an extra 10 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Jackson!

#2 Federici’s Family Restaurant

I’m always a big fan of restaurants that serve alcohol and this place has it all – from beer to hard liquor! Plus, there’s a great kid’s menu and some vegetarian options.

The pizza was simply amazing. The crust was thin, crispy and had just the right amount of char-grill on it. The sauce was sweet, tangy and complemented the cheese and toppings perfectly.

And would you believe they have insanely good desserts too? I had the tiramisu which was so delicious that I am still dreaming about it.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery, but considering how great their food is, I definitely didn’t mind going there myself. It’s also a nice tourist spot to check out if you’re ever in town!

In conclusion, Federici’s Family Restaurant is hands down the best pizza in Freehold NJ – don’t miss out!

#3 Dino’s Pizzeria

On my first visit to Dino’s Pizzeria, I knew this place was something special. From the warm, inviting atmosphere to the mouth-watering aroma of oven-baked pizza, it was clear that big things were in store here.

The menu is stacked with options ranging from classic Italian pies to gourmet creations like the divine “Dino’s Supreme” that comes loaded with pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms and green peppers. I decided to stick with a classic; the Margherita Pizza. A 10″ White Pie with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese and basil leaves.

Let me tell you something – this pizza was a thing of beauty! The crust was perfectly crunchy yet soft and chewy at the same time. The ingredients were fresh, vibrant and packed with flavor. It melted on my tongue like sweet butter! This pizza was one for the books!

And guess what? They deliver! So now you don’t even have to leave your home or office to enjoy some of the best pizza in Freehold NJ – thanks Dino’s Pizzeria!

#4 Romeo’s Pizzeria

To start with, the atmosphere is wonderful; it’s quaint and cozy, yet modern and vibrant. The staff is so friendly – they make you feel like family.

Now onto the pizza! I had the classic pepperoni pizza and I must say – this was one of the best pies I’ve ever tasted! The crust was perfectly crispy and crunchy, while still being light and fluffy. The pepperoni was savory and well-seasoned, providing a delightful contrast to the cheesy goodness.

I also had a margherita pizza that blew my mind. Not only was it loaded with fresh ingredients, but it also had just the right amount of sauce to keep everything tasting great.

Overall, Romeo’s Pizzeria definitely gets my seal of approval as the best pizza in Freehold NJ! If you’re ever in town and looking for an excellent slice of pizza, this is definitely the place to go.

#5 Dusal’s Italian Restaurant

The atmosphere in Dusal’s was cozy and inviting, with a few TVs playing classic Italian movies. Sitting down we were immediately offered some of the best breadsticks I’ve ever had. They were light and crispy on the outside, with a bit of cheese inside to give them an extra flavor boost.

When our pizza finally arrived it was clear that the owners take their pizza seriously, as it was cooked to perfection! The crust was crunchy yet had a soft, chewy center and the sauce and cheese enhanced each other perfectly. The toppings added to the experience, ranging from pepperoni to broccoli to Canadian bacon – anything you can imagine!

I highly recommend stopping by Dusal’s if you’re ever in Freehold NJ looking for some great tasting pizza. All in all, they serve some of the best pizza in town ­ and that’s coming from a world traveler!

#6 Krispy Pizza

I stopped in for a visit recently, and what a treat it was. The atmosphere was warm and inviting as soon as I stepped inside and the staff was friendly. Plus, the doughy aroma of fresh pizza in the air was quite enticing!

The menu had all sorts of delicious options available. I opted to try a mushroom and pepperoni pizza that they had just finished cooking. When it arrived at my table, I could immediately tell how fresh the ingredients were—the flavor combination was delightful!

The overall experience at Krispy Pizza was fantastic. The price point is just right for those on a budget, yet the quality of food is absolutely outstanding. From the fluffy crust to the melty cheese, every bite was worth savoring on its own!

Krispy Pizza may not be well known worldwide (yet!), but I can confidently say that it has some of the best pizza in Freehold NJ. In my opinion, this little pizzeria is worth trying out if you’re ever in town!

#7 Trevi Pizza & Italian Restaurant

My first bite of the cheese pizza had me hooked. The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, while the tomato sauce had the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. As for the cheese, it was so fresh and flavorful that it seemed like it had just come from a farm!

The pepperoni pizza was my next favorite. It had a good amount of spicy, greasy pepperoni which added a great texture to the pizza. I also enjoyed how simple yet flavorful the basil topping was-truly an unforgettable experience.

If you’ve never been to Trevi Pizza & Italian Restaurant before, do yourself a favor and give them a try! You won’t regret it. It’s easily some of the best pizza in Freehold NJ-and trust me, I know my pizza!

#8 Mateo’s

My first impression as I walked into Mateo’s was warmth and charm. The decor is inviting, with walls covered in vintage posters that add to the cozy atmosphere.

The pizza selection at Mateo’s is among the best I’ve seen anywhere. They have traditional pizzas like pepperoni as well as unique specialty creations like the “White Pizza” topped with ricotta, mozzarella and spinach.

The star of the show, however, is definitely the pizza dough. It has just the right amount of chewiness, yet still manages to have a crisp and flaky crust.

I’ve tasted many pizzas around the world but none can compare to Mateo’s! Their software combination of ingredients and cooking method produces a truly unique flavor and texture that you won’t find anywhere else. If you’re looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza experience, look no further than Mateo’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Red Bank!

#9 Anabela’s & Sherlyn’s Pizza & Restaurant

The pizza here is truly exceptional. Everything from the salty, crunchy crust to the gooey melted cheese and delicious toppings is just perfect. I particularly enjoyed their classic marinara sauce that infuses each slice with a complex blend of herbs and flavors.

But don’t get me wrong – this isn’t just another pizza joint! The atmosphere of Anabela’s & Sherlyn’s Pizza & Restaurant is something special. Not only do they have an authentic Italian feel, but the staff are friendly and welcoming, making your experience much more enjoyable. It’s almost like you’re being welcomed into a family home for dinner – something I really loved about my visit here.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Freehold NJ then look no further than Anabela’s & Sherlyn’s Pizza & Restaurant! I can guarantee you won’t be disappointed by their delicious food and warm hospitality.

#10 New wine restaurant

The first thing that stands out is their Crust. It’s perfectly thin and crispy, just the way I like it. I had a slice of the Italian Sausage and it was absolutely delicious! The sausage was perfectly cooked and the flavors blended together wonderfully.

Next, their toppings are top notch. Every combination I tried was different, yet all of them were equally amazing. From mushrooms to olives to pepperoni, there’s something for everyone here!

And finally the ambiance. This place is tucked away in a cozy corner of Freehold which gives it a unique feel – like you’re at an Italian trattoria! The staff is friendly and always willing to help, not to mention accommodating when I asked for options as a vegetarian.

Overall, New wine restaurant has some of the best pizza in Freehold NJ! If you want delicious pizza that won’t break your wallet – this is the place to go!

#11 Vinnie’s Pizzeria

I was immediately blown away by the atmosphere when I arrived at Vinnie’s – it has a real classic Italian feel with red-and-white checkered tablecloths, old black-and-white photos on the wall, and opera music playing in the background.

The pizza itself is incredible! The crust is perfectly thin and crisp, and you can really taste the homemade quality of it. As for toppings – wow! They offer all kinds of creative combinations that really push the boundaries – my favorite is their BBQ chicken pizza with cheddar cheese and ranch dressing. But if you’re looking for something more traditional they have plenty of classics like pepperoni and mushrooms.

The service here is also top notch – they’re friendly, quick, and always accommodating to whatever your needs may be. Plus they have takeout available so you can enjoy their world-class pizza on the go!

All in all, it’s easy to see why Vinnie’s Pizzeria has become known as one of the best pizza places in Freehold NJ. Whether you’re picking up a quick pie for lunch or looking for an evening out with family or friends, this place will not disappoint!

#12 Frankie Fed’s

I must admit, when I saw the small storefront and the unassuming decor of this place, I wasn’t expecting a whole lot. But boy was I wrong! From the moment I took my first bite, I knew this was something special.

The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, while still being light and airy. The Italian sausage was flavorful yet not overpowering, and the cheese was melted to perfection. All in all, it just tasted like how pizza should taste; pure bliss!

To top it all off, the service at Frankie Fed’s was exceptional. They were friendly yet professional, so that’s always nice. Plus, their prices were surprisingly affordable for the amazing quality of food they serve up.

In conclusion, Frankie Fed’s is easily one of the best pizzerias in Freehold NJ —no question about it! If you’re ever in town be sure to check this place out —you won’t regret it!