Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Gainesville FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Gainesville FL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

176 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, so when I heard about all the amazing places to eat in Gainesville FL, I knew it was time to get my taste buds ready! In my search for the best pizza in town, I visited a whopping 12 places and compared their pies. With so many choices, it was a tough job – but someone had to do it!

So without further ado, let’s dive into my top picks for the best pizza in Gainesville FL.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 The Patio – Pizza & Provisions

The atmosphere inside the restaurant is warm and inviting, with a rustic, homey vibe. The staff is friendly and helpful, giving great recommendations for which pies to try.

The pizza itself is something special – each slice has an incredible combination of flavors that you just can’t get anywhere else. The crust is the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, and the cheese melts in your mouth like butter. The Patio also offers a wide selection of toppings from classic options like pepperoni and sausage to more innovative pies with ingredients like roasted garlic and artichoke hearts.

I’m particularly fond of the signature pie – “The Patio Pie”. It’s packed full of delicious veggie goodness – mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, black olives – all baked on top of a delectable tomato sauce infused with herbs. Every bite brings a new flavor sensation!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Gainesville FL, look no further than The Patio – Pizza & Provisions. With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and mouth-watering pies, it’s sure to be your new favorite spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 33 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Ocala!

#2 Satchel’s Pizza

It’s hard to believe that one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had could be found in a small town, but this place is an absolute gem. The dough was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness and flavor. The sauce was sweet and savory, adding wonderful depth to every bite. And the cheese was perfectly melted, offering a classic balance of both texture and taste.

The staff at Satchel’s Pizza were incredibly friendly too! They made sure we were well taken care of from start to finish – offering helpful menu suggestions, checking back on us throughout our meal, and being happy to chat about their favorite pizza toppings (though they did recommend their house speciality!).

Overall, I’m confident in saying that Satchel’s Pizza has some of the best pizza in Gainesville FL! If you’re ever in town, make sure you stop by and try it out – you won’t regret it!

#3 Blaze Pizza

I mean, where else can you make your own pizza with fresh ingredients and then have it cooked in a blazing-hot oven for about 3 minutes?

The atmosphere was fun and the staff was friendly. I was given a wide selection of toppings to choose from – including some exotic ones like artichokes and oregano. Needless to say, I was in culinary heaven.

As soon as my personal masterpiece came out of the oven, I knew that Blaze Pizza will be the place I come back to again and again. The crust was light yet crisp and packed with flavor. And the taste…oh my goodness…it was simply amazing!

So if you’re in Gainesville looking for great pizza, Blaze Pizza is definitely worth checking out! You won’t be disappointed!

#4 Peppino’s Pizza

The crust was perfectly crispy, like the kind you’d find in Naples. The cheese was flavorful and just right – not too much, not too little. And the sauce had the perfect combination of sweetness and acidity.

But where Peppino’s really shone was with their toppings. From fresh tomatoes to mushrooms, everything tasted just right. They even have some really unique combinations that I wouldn’t be able to find anywhere else!

Overall, my experience at Peppino’s Pizza was great! From the friendly staff to the amazing pizza, there wasn’t a single complaint I could come up with! If you’re looking for good pizza in Gainesville FL, look no further than Peppino’s Pizza!

#5 Scuola Pizza

The crust is thin, yet chewy and flavorful. The perfect base for any amazing pizza, and it’s just that at Scuola Pizza. They also have some great creative topping combinations that pack a flavorful punch without overwhelming the balance of the pizza.

Plus, they also have a great selection of beers on tap to complement your meal, so you can’t go wrong there. Plus, the staff are friendly and attentive to all their customers needs. They make sure that everyone leaves feeling satisfied with their meal, which is always a plus in my book when it comes to restaurants.

All in all, these amazing factors combined with their delicious pizzas make Scuola Pizza one of the best places for pizza in Gainesville FL!

#6 Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

The crust was perfectly cooked and had a great crunch to it that gave each bite an added texture. And the sauce…I can’t say enough about the sauce! It was sweet yet savory and just full of flavor! The cheese was melted to perfection and gave each bite a nice gooey texture.

My favorite topping has to be the mushrooms – they were so flavorful and cooked to perfection. I also tried their pepperoni, which had a nice kick to it.

I was so impressed with this place that I just had to take some back home for later. The staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating and made sure my pizza stayed hot until I reached my destination.

Overall Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza is definitely the best pizza in Gainesville FL that I have ever tasted!

#7 Satch Squared

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with kitchen staff shouting out orders of fresh-baked Italian pies. Whenever I’m in town, I like to take advantage of the dine-in option here – it’s a great way to watch the pizza chefs work their magic.

The pepperoni pies here are legendary! The crust is always perfectly baked and crispy – not too doughy or dry. There’s not too much sauce, but just enough that when you bite into it all the delicious flavors blend together in your mouth. The cheese/pepperoni ratio is spot on – each slice has a generous amount of both ingredients, so no one goes home hungry! And let me tell you, they don’t skimp on toppings either – every bite is loaded with flavor.

If you’re looking for something different, Satch Squared also offers specialty pizzas like BBQ chicken and spinach feta. Every one I’ve tried has been unique and delicious!

Overall, if you’re looking for quality food from friendly folks at an affordable price (especially considering the ingredients!), then Satch Squared should be your go-to spot for pizza in Gainesville FL. I guarantee that once you eat here, you’ll be coming back for more!

If you’re willing to go an extra 53 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in The Villages!

#8 Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

The ambiance was perfect for a pizza experience – from the cozy feel of the restaurant to the delicious smell of pizza that welcomed me as I walked in. The staff was very friendly and welcoming, and I especially enjoyed their selection of craft beers.

But it was the pizza that really won me over. They have an extensive menu with something for everyone, whether it’s traditional pepperoni or more adventurous choices like shrimp scampi. I tasted several kinds, and each one had its own unique flavor. The stonefired crust was especially delicious – crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside – and all of the ingredients were fresh and flavorful.

I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza to anyone looking for the best pizza in Gainesville FL. It’s worth a visit!

#9 Italian Gator Pizza

I visited Italian Gator Pizza recently and once I walked through the door, I was immediately hit with a smell that could only be described as pure pizza paradise. The restaurant is decorated in an old-school Italian pizzeria style that added to the cozy atmosphere, and the staff were extremely friendly.

I ordered their signature pie – the Gainesville Gator Pie – and it was absolutely delicious. The crust was thin and chewy, but still had enough structure to hold up all of the amazing toppings. Plus, there was definitely no shortage of cheese! Every bite I took grew more delicious than the last.

If you’re ever in Gainesville FL looking for a great pizza experience, Italian Gator Pizza should definitely be at the top of your list! This place really has some of the best pizza around and will definitely satisfy any craving you have.

#10 V Pizza & SideCar – Gainesville

I had the pleasure of tasting one of their specialty gourmet pizzas, and I must say, it was a delicious treat. The pizza crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, with just the right amount of seasoning. The toppings were generous and flavorful – from succulent Italian sausage to juicy slices of tomatoes.

The atmosphere inside the restaurant was inviting and cozy, which really added to my dining experience. The staff members were friendly and attentive, making sure that I had everything I needed for a pleasurable meal.

Overall, V Pizza & SideCar – Gainesville definitely deserves its reputation as some of the best pizza in Gainesville FL! Highly recommended for any pizza lover looking for an unforgettable dining experience!

#11 MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza – Gainesville

The atmosphere and decor were inviting and pleasant, adding to the overall experience. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, making my visit even more enjoyable. However, my absolute favorite thing about the restaurant was the pizza!

Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired oven – creating pizzas that are light yet crispy at the same time. I particularly enjoyed their signature “MidiCi Margherita” pizza – a classic Neapolitan delicacy – but all of their other specialty pizzas offer something special as well!

Overall, I had an amazing experience at MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza – Gainesville. Their pizza is simply divine, both in taste and presentation; with quality ingredients coming together with traditional Neapolitan style to make some of the best pizza I’ve had in Gainesville FL (or anywhere else for that matter). If you’re ever in town be sure to check them out!

#12 Five Star Pizza

From the mouth-watering homemade dough, to the fresh and delicious ingredients topped off with their signature blend of herbs and spices; I just can’t seem to get enough. They even use some unique ingredients like figs and goat cheese that you won’t find elsewhere.

The service is always friendly, their prices are affordable, and they offer delivery as well. Plus, the atmosphere is relaxed and laid back—perfect for a casual, yet delicious meal.

I’d highly recommend giving Five Star Pizza a try if you’re in search of the best pizza in Gainesville FL. Go ahead and treat yourself—you won’t regret it!