I’ve been around the world (well, almost!) looking for the perfect slice. On my pizza pilgrimage to Gettysburg I stopped at 11 of the best places and sampled some of their finest pies. My quest to determine the best pizza in Gettysburg begins now!
I’m going to rate each place according to a variety of criteria, with a humorous and lighthearted tone. So get ready, because I’m about to review some great (and not so great) pizza in Gettysburg.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania
#1 Antica Napoli Pizza
- No delivery
First off, it’s in a great spot – right on the main street of town. Inside, there’s a cozy atmosphere with a small bar area and lots of smiling faces.
As for the pizza itself, it was mouth-wateringly good! The thin, crisp crust was perfectly cooked and the toppings were fresh. Even though they don’t offer delivery, it’s worth getting up and going to get this deliciousness!
If you want to treat yourself to the best pizza in Gettysburg, Antica Napoli Pizza is the place for you. The pizza alone is worth getting out of bed for!
If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Hanover!
#2 Deliso Pizza
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere was great – the open kitchen design allowed me to observe and salivate as the fresh ingredients were put together and cooked. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, offering great suggestions on which toppings to choose.
When my pizza finally arrived, I could tell it was made with love! There was a perfect combination of delicious sauce, stretchy mozzarella cheese, flavorful peppers, and zesty pepperoni. The crust was perfectly crisp without being dry or burnt – just how I like it.
Overall, Deliso Pizza is one of the best pizzas I’ve had the pleasure to eat in Gettysburg. They really know how to make a classic dish come alive with flavor!
#3 Clementina’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- No delivery
The atmosphere is very cozy and inviting, with a bar that serves up some delicious hard liquor alongside their extensive beer selection. Even better than the drinks, they have some vegetarian options to offer such as veggie calzone or vegetable pizzas. And don’t forget: Clementina’s always has dessert options ready to close out your meal like tiramisu or cannoli!
The only downside was that they don’t offer delivery services, though it’s worth a quick trip out of the house for this delicious fare. If you’re ever in Gettysburg looking for the best pizza around – Clementina’s Pizzeria & Ristorante should be at the top of your list!
If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Westminster!
#4 Brother’s Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
I visited Brother’s Pizza for the first time and was blown away by its unique and delicious pies. From the very first bite, I could tell that this place puts a lot of care into their food. The crust was crispy and flavorful, while the cheese and toppings worked together in perfect harmony.
The best part of my experience at Brother’s Pizza was its menu. No matter what kind of pizza you’re looking for – whether it be traditional, vegetarian, or something more out there – Brother’s has got you covered! There are also some great sides like garlic knots and their famous “Brothers Bombs.” Whatever combination you choose, you can’t go wrong with these generous portions.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Gettysburg then look no further than Brother’s Pizza! No matter how many times I travel around the world looking for great pizza, I always come back here. You won’t regret trying out this Italian masterpiece!
#5 Tommy’s Pizza
- Great place to watch sports
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
Upon entering the restaurant, I was immediately struck by its charming atmosphere. You could tell that the owners put a lot of thought into making the space inviting and comfortable, from the warm wood paneling to the whimsical art on the walls.
The menu at Tommy’s Pizza has something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a classic pepperoni pizza or something more creative like their white pizza with kale and garlic, there’s no shortage of delicious options here.
I opted for their signature Tommy Pie – a traditional pizza that’s loaded with mozzarella, mushrooms and sausage – and it did not disappoint. The crust was just the right amount of crunchy while still remaining tender, and the sauce was nicely spiced but not overbearing.
Overall, Tommy’s Pizza is definitely worth taking a trip to Gettysburg if you’re in search of authentic Italian-style pizza! Not only do they offer up some of the best pizza in town, but they also have an inviting atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Highly recommended!
If you’re willing to go an extra 26 miles, you can get to 16 more pizza places in Carlisle!
#6 La Bella Italia
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- No delivery
As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I knew that this was going to be a great experience. From the wonderful decor and atmosphere to the delicious aroma of pizza cooking in the oven, La Bella Italia is a must-try for anyone looking for an Italian dining experience.
The menu has something for everyone – from kids to adults. Kids can get their favorite dishes on the kid’s menu, while adults can enjoy a good glass of wine or beer with their meals. They also have some vegetarian options available, so no one will feel left out.
My favorite part was definitely the desserts! They were unbelievably good and definitely worth saving room for when ordering your meal. Not only were they tasty, but they were also aesthetically pleasing as well!
The only downside I could find when it comes to La Bella Italia is that they don’t offer delivery services – but that doesn’t take away from what a great tourist spot this is! All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Gettysburg (which you certainly are!), then look no further than La Bella Italia!
#7 Pizza House
There’s nothing quite like the atmosphere of Pizza House. Walking in, I’m greeted by the wonderful aroma of fresh pizza dough and spices wafting through the air. The staff is friendly and helpful and their selection has something for everyone.
The pizza at Pizza House is simply superb! Their thin crusts are crispy and full of flavor. With options ranging from classic pepperoni to an annoyingly popular Hawaiian, they have every flavor imaginable. I’m especially fond of their veggie delight which comes loaded with a variety of fresh vegetables and cheese.
But what really sets Pizza House apart from other restaurants is their unique spin on toppings. From bacon jam to pulled pork, they offer some seriously creative topping options that make you question why more places don’t do this!
Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Gettysburg then look no further than Pizza House. You won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 31 more pizza places in York!
#8 Domino’s Pizza
The first thing that struck me was the variety of toppings. Domino’s Pizza has over thirty different topping options, so you can customize your pizza to your heart’s delight. You can get creative, like adding extra olives and pineapple, or stick with the classics: pepperoni and mushrooms.
The crust is always cooked incredibly well. It’s thick and crunchy on the outside, but still soft and chewy on the inside. I never leave Domino’s without a full stomach – their pizzas are definitely filling!
They also have a wide range of side dishes, from cheesy breadsticks to mozzarella sticks to buffalo wings. They really understand how to satisfy all types of cravings!
The staff at Domino’s is always friendly and accommodating – it’s easy to tell that they take great pride in their work. And last but not least, the prices are totally reasonable – you won’t find better value for money anywhere else when it comes to pizza in Gettysburg!
Overall, Domino’s Pizza deserves its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Gettysburg – if you’re looking for delicious flavor and great value for money, give them a try!
#9 Pizza Hut
From the first slice, I could tell that I had found something special. The dough was light and fluffy, while the toppings were flavorful and abundant. Every bite was an absolute delight!
The atmosphere of Pizza Hut is also worth noting. Not only are the staff friendly and helpful, but they know their stuff when it comes to pizza! They’re more than happy to help you choose the best topping combinations for your taste buds.
Speaking of which, there’s a great selection of pizzas here – everything from classic pepperoni to unique creations like Buffalo Chicken Ranch or Mediterranean Veggie. You really can’t go wrong.
And no visit to Pizza Hut would be complete without sampling one of their delicious desserts – we recommend the Chocolate Chip Cookie Stix or Cinnamon Sticks with your favorite dipping sauce.
All in all, I am extremely confident in saying that Pizza Hut serves up some of the best pizza in Gettysburg! Highly recommended!
#10 Papa Johns Pizza
- Offers dessert
I’ve had the pleasure of trying different kinds of pizza everywhere I go, including Italy and New York City. So when I decided to stop in Gettysburg and try what Papa Johns Pizza had to offer, I was very impressed.
Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and they always have plenty of topping options. The crust is also one of the best I’ve ever tasted! It’s light, crispy and has just the right amount of flavor. It’s clear that a lot of attention goes into preparing every single pizza.
The service at Papa Johns Pizza is also top-notch. Their staff is always friendly and eager to help. Plus, their delivery times are second to none; you can get your pizza almost instantly if you order online!
Overall, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Gettysburg, then Papa Johns Pizza is definitely worth checking out! They provide quality food with excellent service at an incredibly affordable price – what more could you ask for? In my opinion, this place has the best pizza in Gettysburg!
#11 Mamma Ventura’s Restaurant & Lounge
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- No delivery
The atmosphere here is perfect—it’s a nice tourist spot, and they even let you bring your own beer if you’re over 21. The food is top-notch: the pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. And for those who aren’t fans of pizza, there’s an great kids menu!
But the best part about eating at Mamma Ventura’s Restaurant & Lounge is the insane desserts they have. From tiramisu to creme brulee, they have something for everyone! I was blown away by their ability to mix sweet flavors with savory ones in a way that just works.
One slight downside is that they don’t deliver, but if you’re willing to make the trip, it’s well worth it. Whether you’re looking for dinner or just a snack, Mamma Ventura’s Restaurant & Lounge has something delicious waiting for you!
