Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Gwinnett County (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Georgia

Best Pizza in Gwinnett County (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

395 Views

I’m excited to share the results of my search for the best pizza in Gwinnett County. I’ve traveled the world trying amazing pizzas, and I think I can safely say that after sampling 12 different pizzerias in the area, I’ve got a pretty good sense of what makes for a great pie.

I’m sure you’re all itching to find out what places made the cut so without further ado, let’s dive in and explore Gwinnett County’s top pizza spots!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Georgia

#1 Arditi Pizzeria

I found the atmosphere at Arditi Pizzeria to be quite welcoming. The decor was nice and the staff was friendly and attentive. But, the real star of the show was their pizza!

The crust had a perfect crunchy texture, while still being light and fluffy. And, the sauce had just enough sweetness that it nicely complemented the cheese and topping flavors. I had a pepperoni pizza, but they also offer an impressive variety of other toppings as well.

What really caught me by surprise was how quickly they were able to deliver my food – it arrived piping hot! I usually expect to wait quite a bit for delivery pizzas, so this was a pleasant surprise.

Overall, I think Arditi Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Gwinnett County. Whether you’re after traditional flavors or something more daring, this is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Duluth!

#2 Italy’s Pizza & Pasta Company

The crust is perfectly thin, the sauce is zesty and flavorful, and the toppings are cooked to perfection. Plus, they offer all of the classic Italian favorites like margherita, pepperoni, and even eggplant!

The atmosphere at Italy’s Pizza & Pasta Co. is perfect for a night out with friends or family. The staff is friendly and helpful, always willing to make suggestions if you don’t know what you want. The prices are also very reasonable – with large pizzas starting at just $13.99!

I could go on and on about why I love Italy’s Pizza & Pasta Company, but let me sum it up in one word: wow! Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a fun evening out, this spot should definitely be on your list of places to check out!

#3 Bellagio’s NY Pizzeria

I first visited Bellagio’s about a year ago and have been back at least ten times since. It has quickly become my favorite pizzeria. The pizzas are all hand crafted from the freshest ingredients and you can really taste the difference.

The crust is always light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch, and it’s not overwhelmed by all the toppings. Each slice is packed with flavor, so much so that after one bite I became an instant convert! And their wide selection of specialty pizzas rotate regularly to keep locals coming back for more.

Bellagio’s also features generous portions and very reasonable prices, making it an affordable option for any budget-conscious pizza lover.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Gwinnett County, look no further than Bellagio’s NY Pizzeria!

#4 2 NYERS Pizza

This place has the perfect blend of cheese and sauce. The crust is light, yet hearty enough to carry through the flavors of the toppings. And speaking of toppings, it’s clear that 2 NYERS knows what they’re doing because each pie is loaded up with deliciousness!

The atmosphere at 2 NYERS Pizza is great too. It’s a cozy little joint with just the right amount of hustle and bustle without feeling overwhelming. The staff are friendly and welcoming – like family!

Of course, the best part about 2 NYERS Pizza is the price. You really can’t beat it for such amazing quality pizza – definitely worth every penny.

Overall, I’d highly recommend this pizza restaurant to anyone looking for an amazing tasting pie in Gwinnett County!

#5 Izzy’s NY Pizza

When I walked into Izzy’s NY Pizza, I immediately knew I was in for something special. The interior was bustling with activity, and the smell of fresh pizza permeated the air. No matter what kind of pizza you’re craving, they have it here! From classic Italian to pepperoni to Hawaiian, there’s something to satisfy everyone.

I had the pleasure of tasting a wide variety of pizzas from Izzy’s NY Pizza and let me tell you, I wasn’t disappointed! The dough was light and fluffy, the cheese perfectly melted, and all the toppings were cooked just right. It was truly an incredible experience.

But what really made my visit to Izzy’s NY Pizza so enjoyable was their attentive staff. They took time to answer any questions I had about the menu and never made me feel rushed or overwhelmed. It made dining here a truly pleasurable experience.

If you’re looking for delicious pizza in Gwinnett County, look no further than Izzy’s NY Pizza! With their friendly staff and wide variety of options, it’s truly a slice of heaven on earth.

#6 Two Cities Pizza Co.

The moment I walked in the place, I was sold. The warm and inviting atmosphere made me feel right at home and excited to try their delicious creations.

I sampled a few of their pies and it was unlike anything I’ve ever tasted before. The dough was perfectly thin yet still had just the right amount of crunch – not to mention that it stayed fresh even after being reheated. The toppings were classic but with a unique flavor that left me wanting more.

Two Cities Pizza Co. definitely gets an A+ in my book for their amazing selection of pizzas! From traditional favorites like Margherita to more adventurous pies like The Works, they have something for every palate. And if you’re feeling really daring, you can always build your own masterpiece!

And let’s not forget about the service: beyond polite, helpful and attentive staff that is always willing to go out of their way to make sure your experience is as tasty as possible. This attention to service is what makes Two Cities Pizza Co. stand out from other pizza restaurants in Gwinnett County – and why it’s earned its title as the best pizza in Gwinnett County!

#7 Pizza Piccola New York Style

I stopped by for lunch, and was pleasantly surprised at all the delicious options. From your traditional cheese and pepperoni to their unique creations like their Hawaiian BBQ alfredo pizza, there is something for everyone here.

The crust was light and crunchy, with a hint of sweetness that really went well with the zesty sauce. The toppings were plentiful and flavorful, including a generous helping of fresh veggies like bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and olives.

Overall I had an amazing experience dining at Pizza Piccola New York Style. The staff was friendly and accommodating – plus they have some of the best pizza in Gwinnett County! If you get a chance swing by – you won’t regret it!

#8 Dogwood Pizza

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, making it a great spot to hang out with friends over some delicious pies. I got to try one of their signature pizzas called the Dogwood Fire, and it was amazing! From their homemade crust with artisanal cheese to the fresh vegetables and unique blend of spices, every bite was bursting with flavor.

My favorite part of our meal was the presentation; all of the ingredients were arranged artfully on top of the pizza. It looked almost too good to eat! We had no trouble finishing it off though; we chowed down hungrily, not wanting to waste a single bite.

Overall, I highly recommend Dogwood Pizza if you’re looking for quality pizza in Gwinnett County. They may have been located in an unassuming strip mall but don’t be fooled: they serve up some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 14 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Johns Creek!

#9 Pizza Man

I was so impressed with their traditional Italian-style pizzas; the dough is crunchy yet light, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. The vegetable pizza was especially amazing! But what really struck me is how creative their specialty pizzas are. From the pesto and sundried tomato, to the prosciutto and spinach, these unique blends of flavors make for some truly delicious eats.

The service at Pizza Man is friendly, efficient and welcoming – I’m always greeted with a warm smile when I walk in. The atmosphere inside is cozy too – large booths give ample seating for groups or families, while small tables offer intimate settings for two. And they have a few TVs that often show sports games – perfect if you want a relaxed hangout spot to chow down on some pizza slices.

In short, there’s no doubt that Pizza Man has some of the best pizza in Gwinnett County (or anywhere else!), making it my go-to spot when I’m craving ‘za!

#10 Magazzino Delle Pizza

When I walked in I was immediately greeted by the warm atmosphere and the wafting smell of freshly baked pizza. I couldn’t wait to sample their offerings.

To start, I ordered a classic Margherita pizza and it did not disappoint! The dough was light and fluffy, and the ratio of cheese to tomato sauce was just right. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.

For my second dish, I decided to try something a bit more adventurous. I went with their infamous “spicy pie,” which features layers upon layers of meats and fiery toppings. And boy do they deliver on the heat! It had amazing flavor and left me wanting more.

I washed my meal down with a glass of house wine, which was surprisingly delightful (especially for a pizza joint).

Overall, Magazzino Delle Pizza definitely deserves its reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Gwinnett County. From the friendly service to the amazingly delicious food, there’s no way you can leave without being happy (and full!).

#11 Nancy’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at Nancy’s is great. The decor is entertaining and the staff are friendly and welcoming. It’s a great place to relax, hang out with friends, and of course, eat some delicious pizza!

The pizzas at Nancy’s are absolutely outstanding. From their classic cheese pizza to the more adventurous creations like their Four Cheese Macaroni Pizza, there’s something for everyone here. They use only the freshest ingredients and their crusts are always light and crispy. I’ve even heard they make their dough fresh every day!

The prices at Nancy’s Pizzeria are also great. You can get a large one-topping pizza for what you’d pay for a small at almost any other place in town. Plus, they often have awesome deals and discounts that keep me coming back again and again.

All in all, if you’re looking for delicious, handmade pizza at an affordable price, Nancy’s Pizzeria is definitely the best spot in Gwinnett County!

#12 Stevi B’s Pizza Buffet

The first thing that really stood out to me was the atmosphere. The restaurant had a throwback vibe with its checkered tablecloths and vintage design, taking me back to classic Italian restaurants in Rome.

The pizzas were simply divine! They had a wide variety of toppings, from your typical pepperoni slices to more creative options like feta cheese. I tried a few different pies and each one was cooked just right. The crust was light and crunchy on the outside while still being fluffy on the inside — a perfect balance.

The best part of all is the price: it’s incredibly affordable for such high-quality pizza. It’s definitely worth trying if you’re looking for some great pizza without breaking the bank.

In conclusion, I can confidently say that Stevi B’s Pizza Buffet has earned its spot as one of the best pizza stops in Gwinnett County. If you’re in town, make sure to give it a go!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Cosmo’s Pizza + Social

When I first walked into Cosmo’s, I immediately felt like I was transported to pizza heaven. The aroma of freshly baked dough and melted cheese filled the air, making my taste buds tingle with excitement. As a self-proclaimed pizza connoisseur, I had high expectations, and let me tell you, Cosmo’s did not disappoint.

Their thin crust pizza was perfectly crispy, like biting into a crunchy cloud. It had just the right balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. I couldn’t help but admire the sheer artistry that went into crafting each slice. It was like a masterpiece on a plate, except I wasn’t just looking at it, I was devouring it.

The waitstaff was incredibly friendly, treating me like an old friend from the moment I sat down. The ambiance was cozy, with dim lighting and quirky pizza-themed decorations adorning the walls. It was a place where I felt instantly at home, surrounded by fellow pizza enthusiasts.

But what truly stood out at Cosmo’s was their innovative pizza creations. From the mouthwatering BBQ chicken pizza topped with crispy bacon to the adventurous mac and cheese pizza, they pushed the boundaries of traditional pizza like no other. It was like a culinary adventure with each bite, and I couldn’t get enough.

If you’re craving the best thin crust pizza in lawrenceville ga, look no further than Cosmo’s Pizza + Social. Trust me, as a world-traveled food critic on a never-ending pizza quest, I don’t say this lightly. Head on over to Cosmo’s, bring your appetite and prepare yourself for a pizza experience like no other. You won’t regret it, unless your only regret is not having a bigger stomach to eat more!