Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hanover PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Hanover PA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

91 Views

It’s not the first place that comes to mind when you think about pizza, but I’m here to tell you that the pizza options in Hanover are pretty awesome. In fact, I’ve tasted a dozen different pizzas from around town and I’m ready to declare my favorite.

So grab a slice of pepperoni and get ready for the results – it’s time for me to crown the Best Pizza in Hanover PA!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 OAK Hanover

I could tell right away that the restaurant has a real passion for great pizza. From the moment I walked in, I was impressed with the warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly and helpful, and clearly had a passion for great food.

The menu at OAK Hanover had some great options for vegetarians – something you don’t always find with Pizza places. I’m a huge fan of veggies on my pizza, so that was a nice bonus!

The real test though, as always, is how good the pizza is. Now… this is where OAK Hanover really shines! Their thin-crust pizzas are cooked to perfection and all of the toppings are fresh and full of flavor. The crust has just enough crunch, but is still chewy enough to make it enjoyable. And the sauce! It’s perfectly balanced between sweet and savory – exactly like it should be! All in all, OAK Hanover has some serious pizza skills…the best I’ve come across so far!

The only downside to OAK Hanover is that they don’t offer delivery. But that’s okay…because once you’ve tasted their delicious pizzas, you won’t mind making the trek every time you’re craving some slices!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Gettysburg!

#2 Brothers Pizza

The first thing I noticed when stepping into Brothers Pizza is the amazing smell of fresh dough and melted cheese. I knew from that moment that I was in for a treat. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it easy to settle in and enjoy a delicious pizza meal.

Next, the pizza! To start, they offer thin crust and regular crust options which are both cooked just right; not too crispy but not too floppy either. On top of that their pizzas are topped with only fresh ingredients, including flavorful house-made sauces! Plus they have plenty of specialty pizza options to choose from as well.

For my part, I opted for their famous Supreme Deluxe pizza. It had everything anyone could ask for on a pizza: sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers… you name it! It was so good that I’m considering taking up residence at Brothers Pizza until further notice.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hanover PA then look no further than Brothers Pizza! You won’t be disappointed.

#3 Amores 2

From the moment I stepped inside the restaurant, I was blown away. The interior was spacious and inviting, but most impressive were the quality fresh ingredients they use to make their pizzas. The dough is light, fluffy and cooked to perfection—just enough crispness without being overly burnt or soggy.

The toppings are delicious too! The combination of tomatoes, onion, olives and cheese are incredible. In addition to their classic pizza varieties like pepperoni and supreme, they also have some unique creations like garlic shrimp and jalapeno popper pizza that will blow your mind.

I must admit that ordering by the slice is a great way to get a taste of what Amores has to offer. Not only would it fill you up for lunch (or dinner), it’s also an affordable option for large groups. Plus, their staff is friendly and accommodating so you won’t feel rushed or unwelcome if you choose to sit down for a meal instead.

I’d give this place five stars! Whether you’re looking for a quick bite on the go or a more leisurely experience with friends, Amores 2 has pizza perfection written all over it—definitely worth checking out if you’re in Hanover PA!

#4 Divino Pizzeria

The atmosphere of the restaurant was truly divine, with rich colors and modern decor. The staff was friendly and accommodating, which only added to the experience.

When it came to pizza, Divino Pizzeria really knocked it out of the park. From their classic margherita to their pepperoni and pesto pies, all of their pizzas were bursting with flavor. Every bite melted in my mouth like butter! Their crusts are cooked to perfection, neither too thick nor too thin – just right for an amazing Italian-style pie.

To top everything off, Divino Pizzeria offers some unique specials that you won’t find anywhere else. Whether it’s their deep-dish potpie or a BBQ chicken special, I can guarantee that you’ll be leaving Divino Pizzeria a happy customer!

All in all, Divino Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Hanover PA and is definitely worth trying out if you’re in the area!

#5 New Alfredo’s Pizza II & Ristorante

Let me just say that I was bowled over by the quality of the pizza. From the perfectly-cooked crust to the tangy sauce and enormous selection of toppings, it’s the total package. And don’t even get me started on those luscious, gooey mozzarella cheese slices!

The restaurant itself is a delight as well. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and you can tell that the staff cares about their customers. Every one of my visits has been met with friendly smiles and attentive service.

Last but certainly not least is their amazing selection of craft beers—a must-have for any pizza joint worth its salt! Their inventive combinations make for unique pairings with all kinds of pizzas, making for an unforgettable experience every time.

All in all, if you’re looking for an incredibly memorable pizza experience in Hanover PA, look no further than New Alfredo’s Pizza II & Ristorante! Highly recommended!

#6 Giovanni’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

The pizza dough was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char around the crust. The tangy tomato sauce was plentiful, with a perfect combination of sweet, herby flavors balanced against a hint of garlic and oregano.

The toppings were all fresh and flavorful, from yellow squash to crumbled sausage to chopped-up pepperoni. I was truly impressed by the quality and variety of the ingredients used in Giovanni’s pies!

I took home two pies in my flimsy cardboard box—a classic Margherita and an experimental concoction topped with Thai basil, spicy red pepper flakes, and lots of garlic. I could barely wait until they cooled down before diving into the first slice. It was nothing short of heavenly!

Giovanni’s is certainly worth a visit if you’re ever in Hanover PA looking for delicious pizza. I can confidently declare that it has some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Westminster!

#7 Come a Casa

I was immediately impressed by the atmosphere – wood-fired ovens and imported Italian ingredients. The menu featured traditional Italian pizzas, plus a few unique specialty pizzas that really stand out.

My favorite pizza at Come a Casa is the classic Neapolitan. It’s made with Naples-style dough, San Marzano tomatoes, bufala mozzarella, and basil. It has an incredibly thin crust that is both crispy and chewy – it’s as close to real Neapolitan pizza as you can get without actually going to Italy!

The other specialty pizzas are also wonderful – the Arugula & Prosciutto pizza is especially delicious and it’s topped with roasted garlic, balsamic reduction, and Pecorino Romano cheese.

To top it off, the service at Come a Casa is excellent. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable about their food – they’ll even offer recommendations if you’re stuck on what to order!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hanover PA (which I believe you are), look no further than Come a Casa!

#8 MOD Pizza

I’m always looking for an excuse to get some pizza, but MOD Pizza takes it to a whole new level. The crazy thing is, you can customize your slice as much as you want – the topping combinations are only limited by your creativity. I love that they give me the freedom to create whatever type of pizza I want without feeling restricted by the menu.

But what really impressed me was how delicious the pizzas were! Every bite was full of flavor and cooked to perfection. They use quality ingredients and their dough is light and fluffy. It’s clear that they take pride in crafting great pizzas!

And not only is the food incredible, but MOD Pizza also has a really cool atmosphere. You’re always welcomed with a smile when you walk in and their cheerful staff will make sure you’re taken care of in no time. Plus, it’s family-friendly so everyone can enjoy a great meal together!

Overall, MOD Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Hanover PA that I’ve ever tasted! If you haven’t tried it yet, you have to give them a try – you won’t be disappointed.

#9 Brother’s Pizza

I arrived at Brother’s Pizza, eager and excited to try a piece of their delicious pies. As soon as I walked in the door, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The friendly staff was happy to take my order and let me sample one of their specialty pizzas.

I went for the classic cheese pizza and boy, it was out of this world! Thick crust with just the right amount of crispiness, gooey cheese, flavorful sauce – everything about it was absolutely perfect! Plus the topping choices were endless; you could get anything from pepperoni and sausage to mushrooms and peppers.

The sides were also outstanding. The garlic bread sticks were heavenly! They came out hot and fresh from the oven with a delicious melted butter topping that was to die for.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hanover PA – look no further than Brother’s Pizza! With great ambiance, excellent service, and impeccable taste – you definitely won’t be disappointed when you enjoy your next meal here!

#10 Sal’s Pizza & Subs

The atmosphere at Sal’s is warm and inviting. The staff is always friendly, and they greet you with a big smile. The menu is varied, yet simple enough to make finding something that satisfies your craving a breeze.

The pizza itself is just divine! It’s served hot and fresh out of the oven, so you know it’s going to be delicious. The crust has the perfect balance of crunchiness and lightness, while the toppings are covered in sauce that melds all the flavors together in perfect harmony. I’m still dreaming about those slices!

My favorite topping combination was mushrooms, onions & sausage – a classic that never fails to impress. I would definitely recommend it if you’re feeling adventurous!

Overall, Sal’s Pizza & Subs is an excellent pizza destination for everyone from locals to travelers looking for the best pizza in Hanover PA. Make sure to grab some extra napkins though – it gets pretty messy once you start chowing down on those amazing slices!

#11 Domino’s Pizza

I had my first slice of Domino’s Pizza a few weeks ago and I was absolutely delighted. The crust was thin, crispy and full of flavor. The cheese was ooey gooey, just the way I like it, and the sauce had the perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess.

The toppings were top quality too; fresh vegetables, premium meats like sausage, pepperoni, and ham that were cooked to perfection. I truly felt as if I had stumbled upon some of the best pizza in Hanover PA!

The staff at Domino’s Pizza were also friendly and helpful throughout my visit. They were quick to answer any questions I had about their menu options and even provided helpful suggestions for those new to the restaurant.

If you’re ever in Hanover PA looking for a delicious pizza experience, look no further than Domino’s Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 31 more pizza places in York!

#12 Genova’s To Go Hanover

I can say with utmost confidence that the pizza from Genova’s To Go Hanover is as good as, if not better than, what I’ve had in Italy. The crust was light and crispy, and the sauce was delightfully flavorful. The cheese melted perfectly, and the toppings were fresh and plentiful.

The service at Genova’s To Go Hanover is also top-notch. Every time I order their pizza, it arrives hot and fresh. They also have great deals like their Tuesday two-for-one specials!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hanover PA, look no further than Genova’s To Go Hanover. You won’t be disappointed!