Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Harrisonburg VA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Virginia

Best Pizza in Harrisonburg VA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

110 Views

Having tasted pizza in cities all over the world, I thought I’d see what Harrisonburg had to offer. I visited twelve pizza places and sampled each one.

So if you’re looking for the best of the best when it comes to pizza in Harrisonburg, read on and find out where these tasty pies can be found! With a humorous and lighthearted approach, this article will give you the lowdown on which pizzas made the grade and which weren’t quite there yet. Bon Appétit!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Virginia

#1 Little Italy Pizza – Neff Avenue

I was immediately impressed by the decor. From the moment I stepped into this cozy little Italian-style restaurant I felt like I had been transported to a quaint little trattoria in Naples. The atmosphere just screamed “authentic pizza!”

The pizza itself is out of this world! The crust is thin and crispy, not too chewy, with just the right amount of oil to give it a nice crunch. The sauce has a beautiful balance of acidity and sweetness that pairs perfectly with the delectable toppings – fresh vegetables, delicious sausages, and creamy cheese. Every bite seemed to melt in my mouth!

And if that wasn’t enough, Little Italy Pizza also offers an amazing array of specialty pizzas to choose from, including their signature garlic knots topped with Parmesan cheese and parsley – simply divine!

When it comes to pizza, Little Italy Pizza – Neff Avenue really knows what they’re doing; hands down it’s some of the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA. If you’re looking for an amazing experience you’ll definitely want to check them out for yourself!

If you’re willing to go an extra 34 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Charlottesville!

#2 Beards & Broads Axecade – Harrisonburg

It’s a great place to watch sports and the atmosphere is inviting for friends and family. Plus, you can get the added benefit of some cold brewskis from the bar!

The menu also has a variety vegetarian options, so no one should feel left out during dinner time. They also offer dessert too which means there’s something for everyone.

The only downside I found was that they don’t deliver – but if you’re in Harrisonburg, it’s worth it to make the trip over anyway.

I’m giving Beards & Broads Axecade – Harrisonburg five stars and can honestly say it’s some of the best pizza I’ve had on my travels!

#3 Your Pie Pizza

When I walked in, it was like stepping into a pizza oasis. The warm, inviting atmosphere made me immediately feel welcome and comfortable. After perusing the menu, I knew that this place had something special to offer.

The main highlight of Your Pie Pizza is definitely the pies themselves. The crust was nice and thin, so every bite gave you a great crunch. The sauce was flavorful and perfectly balanced with the cheese and toppings. And the toppings were always fresh – no canned mushrooms or limp peppers here!

I think what really sets Your Pie Pizza apart from other pizzerias is their dedication to using local ingredients whenever possible. They take pride in supporting their surrounding community, making sure that only the best produce ends up on their pizzas. It’s clear that they care a lot about delivering quality food to their customers – something that I truly appreciate as a traveling food critic.

Overall, I would highly recommend stopping by Your Pie Pizza next time you’re craving some delicious pizza in Harrisonburg VA! You won’t be disappointed – in fact, you might just find it’s the best pizza you’ve ever tasted!

#4 Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza

I had the pleasure of being invited to Bella Luna for a “tasting expedition” and it was nothing short of amazing. From the moment I arrived, I was greeted with a warm smile and good vibes from everyone. I could tell this was going to be a fantastic experience!

The wood-fired pizzas were truly delightful. The crust was crispy, yet doughy in just the right places … practically perfect in every way. And the toppings! They were so fresh and flavorful that I could hardly contain myself.

Not only did I enjoy my meal, but the atmosphere of the restaurant made it even better. Everything felt cozy and inviting — there’s something special about sitting outside on a summer night enjoying a pizza cooked over an open flame!

In conclusion, if you’re looking for one of the best pizzas in Harrisonburg VA, look no further than Bella Luna Wood-Fired Pizza!

#5 Pale Fire Brewing Co.

I was a bit skeptical when I first arrived, as the restaurant doesn’t offer delivery which seems to be an essential part of pizza-eating these days. But once I took my first bite I was immediately convinced that this place was worth the extra effort of visiting. The fresh ingredients and homemade sauce make all the difference; it’s obvious that Pale Fire Brewing Co. takes quality seriously.

The atmosphere here is also fantastic. With craft beers on tap and a cozy setting, Pale Fire Brewing Co. has created an inviting environment for pizza lovers to hang out and enjoy their meal. Plus, since they serve alcohol, you can finish off your dining experience with a cold beer or glass of wine if you’d like!

Overall, I think Pale Fire Brewing Co. deserves recognition as one of the best pizza spots in Harrisonburg VA. Whether you’re looking for quality ingredients or an enjoyable bite with friends, this place is certainly worth checking out!

#6 Benny Sorrentino’s

From the moment I stepped through their doors, the mouth-watering aroma of fresh herbs, cheese, and tomatoes wafted over me. I knew right away I was in for a treat.

The service was friendly and helpful right from the start. The staff was knowledgeable about their menu and gave me plenty of time to decide what kind of pizza I wanted.

I finally settled on one of Benny Sorrentino’s classic pies; the classic Italian sausage pizza with peppers, onions, and mushrooms. It was absolutely delicious! The crust was thin and crispy just how I like it, and the toppings were cooked to perfection.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA look no further than Benny Sorrentino’s!

#7 Brothers Italian Restaurant

I visited this restaurant recently and what a pleasant surprise. The atmosphere was warm, inviting, and smelled of fresh-baked pizza crust. The staff was friendly and the service was fast.

But let’s talk about the pizza! My family ordered the “Family Special” which included 1 large cheese pizza and two toppings – we chose mushrooms & pepperoni. The pizza crust was golden perfection – soft and chewy on the inside with a crispy crunchy exterior. And oh my goodness, that sauce! Such a perfect balance of oregano, basil, garlic, and tomato – it was delicious!

The toppings were fresh and plentiful, and they had some unique options like feta cheese (which made me say “YUM!”). Overall, this pizza was an absolute delight! I would definitely recommend Brothers Italian Restaurant to anyone looking for the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA.

If you’re willing to go an extra 63 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Winchester!

#8 The Galley

I’m not sure what their secret is, but the crust had a unique flavor and texture that was unlike anything I’ve ever had before. The sauce was perfectly spiced and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. Even the cheese was top notch, which is always a plus!

The atmosphere of the restaurant was outstanding as well. It felt cozy and inviting, with a friendly staff that made me feel right at home. There were even plenty of TVs to watch all the sports games!

In conclusion, I can confidently say that The Galley has some of the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA. So if you’re looking for a great pizza experience, definitely check out The Galley!

#9 Ciro’s Lasagna House

From the moment I arrived, I was overwhelmed by the amazing aromas that were filling the air. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, which made me feel right at home.

The pizza itself was delicious! The crust had an excellent balance between crispy and fluffy and the tomato sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. The toppings were high quality and fresh, making every bite a delight.

What really sets Ciro’s apart from other pizzerias is their delicious lasagna. It’s made with layers of fresh pasta, homemade ricotta cheese, delicious vegetables, meats, and a special blend of spices that make it simply irresistible.

Overall, Ciro’s Lasagna House is definitely a must-experience for any fan of great pizza!

#10 The Golden Pony

From the moment you walk in, you can tell The Golden Pony is a special place. Their decor is unique and inviting – and the pizza ovens are front and center! Plus, they have a friendly staff that cheerfully greets all their guests.

The pizza itself is delicious – I’ve tried almost every type and they’re all great. My personal favorite is their classic Margherita – the dough is so fluffy and light, while the tomato sauce has just the right amount of sweetness to it. And don’t forget about the generous portion of mozzarella cheese! It’s divine!

I also have to mention how generous they are with toppings. Every pizza I’ve tried has been generously covered in fresh veggies and meats – no skimping here!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA, look no further than The Golden Pony. I’m confident you won’t be disappointed!

#11 Domino’s Pizza

I’m sure all of us have heard of the renowned Domino’s Pizza, but nobody can truly understand its superiority until they’ve tasted it for themselves. The crust is as crispy and delicious as if it was cooked in a wood-fired oven, and the perfect ratio of cheese, sauce, spices and toppings will make your taste buds pop!

The best part about Domino’s Pizza though is its convenience. If you order your pizza online or through their app, they’ll deliver it right to your front door. Plus, they have a large variety of toppings so you can customize your pizza exactly the way you like it.

Overall, I highly recommend checking out Domino’s Pizza if you’re ever in Harrisonburg VA looking for some of the best pizza around!

#12 Ruby’s Arcade

The first thing that impressed me about this restaurant was the service. Everyone was so warm and welcoming, and the staff really knew their stuff about making great pizza. After ordering a classic pepperoni, I could immediately tell why they had such a great reputation. The crust was perfectly cooked, with a nice balance of crunchiness and chewiness. The cheese was melted to perfection (not too greasy or stringy), and the tomato sauce flavor was spot-on.

I then decided to try something more adventurous from their menu: a Hawaiian pizza with jalapenos on top for an extra kick! The pineapple on top added the perfect amount of sweetness, which combined perfectly with the jalapenos to bring out all of the delicious flavors in this pie.

I can confidently say that Ruby’s Arcade is one of my go-to places when I’m looking for some serious pizza pleasure. With an incredible selection of both traditional and inventive pizzas, it’s sure to please any pizza connoisseur looking for the best pizza in Harrisonburg VA!