Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hayward (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Hayward (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

86 Views

I’ve tasted pizza in cities all around the world, and I’m happy to report that there is a wide variety of high quality pizzas here in Hayward. I’m here to tell you about my top picks from the 12 places I visited.

My quest for the best pies in Hayward has been a long one — but it’s definitely paid off! Read on to find out which pizzeria stood out, and why.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Susie Q’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, I knew this was going to be an exceptional experience. The atmosphere was casual and inviting and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable. The kitchen was spotless which let me know that the chefs take their craft seriously.

The menu at Susie Q’s Pizza had so many mouth-watering options that it was hard for me to decide. I chose their classic cheese pizza but with a special twist – jalapenos! It turned out to be the best decision of the night because the combination of flavors was simply divine – it even made my taste buds dance!

The crust on the pizza was perfectly cooked, not too thin, not too thick – just right in texture. The sauce and cheese were flavorful and fresh ingredients, making this pizza a winner! Moreover, each bite left you wanting more, thanks to its tantalizing blend of spices and herbs used to make it so delicious.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for great Pizza in Hayward then look no further than Susie Q’s Pizza – they have truly mastered the art of creating a perfect pie!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in San Leandro!

#2 Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace

I was blown away by the taste and texture of their signature hand-tossed crust. It was light and heavenly, with just the right amount of crunch. To top it off, they offer a multitude of fresh, delicious ingredients to make your own perfect pizza creation.

The pizzas cooked up perfectly in the brick oven, giving them that extra something special. Whether you order a specialty pizza or craft your own masterpiece, you are in for a treat at Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace!

The atmosphere was also spot on – festive decorations and friendly staff made me feel right at home. In addition, the prices were very reasonable for all of the quality food I enjoyed.

If you’re ever craving some top-notch pizza in Hayward, note to self: head on over to Bronco Billy’s Pizza Palace!

#3 El Triunfo Pizzeria

First, let’s talk about the taste. The crust was just the right combination of crispy and chewy and slightly charred on the edges. The sauce was savory, with a hint of garlic that made my mouth water. And then there’s the cheese – so creamy and flavorful. It was honestly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

The toppings were also top notch. Fresh vegetables, delicious meats, not too much so it overwhelms but enough to make every bite interesting. Nothing compares to El Triunfo when it comes to mixing tastes and textures in one amazing pizza pie.

Finally, the service was great! Everyone at the restaurant was friendly and helpful; they really went out of their way to ensure that we had a great experience. From start to finish everything was taken care of quickly and efficiently; we didn’t have to wait long for our food or drinks once we ordered them.

If you’re looking for great pizza in Hayward, El Triunfo Pizzeria is definitely worth checking out! My taste buds will definitely be coming back here again soon!

#4 Edgewater Pizza

I was very impressed with the selection of specialty pizzas they offer. From their Margherita and Hawaiian varieties to their Seafood, Taco, and Veggie Lover’s creations, you can always find something new and exciting to try.

The crusts are thin but chewy, with just the right amount of crunchiness. The sauces are flavorful and have an excellent balance between sweet and savory notes. As for the toppings, they use the freshest ingredients that really make the pizzas stand out from the rest.

The atmosphere is also great; it’s lively but still cozy enough to enjoy a slice in peace. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about all things pizza related, so I didn’t have any trouble finding what I wanted or getting tips about what combinations I should try next time.

All in all, Edgewater Pizza is definitely my go-to spot when looking for a delicious slice of pizza here in Hayward!

#5 Americana Pizza & Taqueria Hayward

My experience here was nothing short of amazing. From the moment I stepped in the door, I knew that I was in for a treat. The decor was comfortable and laid-back but with a modern twist, and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable.

When it came to the pizza, my expectations were exceeded. The crust was light and crispy and absolutely perfect. The sauce had a delicious, slightly sweet flavor and each topping was carefully selected to compliment each other perfectly. Not only was it aesthetically pleasing, but every bite was filled with intense flavor that made me wonder why all pizza isn’t made this way!

I also tried their tacos – another excellent choice for anyone looking for great Mexican food close to Hayward. The flavors were bold and complex, yet still light enough to not overwhelm your palate.

Overall, Americana Pizza & Taqueria Hayward takes its pizza seriously and it shows in everything from their decor to the quality of ingredients they use in their dishes. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hayward, look no further – this is your place!

#6 Round Table Pizza

I started my meal out with their “Legendary” pepperoni pizza, a classic favorite. The toppings were fresh, juicy and flavorful, and the crust was cooked to perfection – the soft but crunchy texture was absolutely amazing! I really appreciate that the slices were big enough for me to enjoy two at a time.

Next up was their Hawaiian pizza; it tasted like a tropical paradise in my mouth! The sweet taste of the pineapple combined perfectly with the savory ham and melted cheese- wow! Can’t forget to mention how light and fluffy their crust is too – even my Hawaiian pizza had that fantastic crunchy yet soft texture.

Finally, I had to try one of their specialty pizzas: the Pesto Chicken Alfredo Pizza. It sounded like an unusual combination but it worked perfectly together! The blend of pesto, chicken, alfredo sauce and cheese made for a flavor experience that I won’t forget soon.

At Round Table Pizza you can tell that they take pride in their product- every pizza is made with freshly prepared ingredients and thoughtfully created recipes. All of this equals one thing: delicious food from a place that truly cares about making people happy.

If you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Hayward then look no further than Round Table Pizza- you won’t be disappointed!

#7 Rayo’s Pizza

On a recent visit to Rayo’s, I was nothing short of impressed. From the pleasant and inviting atmosphere to the mouth-watering aroma, it felt like I had been transported to the streets of Rome.

I started off with an order of cheesy garlic bread – and boy, was it good! The cheese melted in my mouth and the garlic flavor was just right. My main course was a classic Margherita pizza made with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and basil leaves on a thin crust. The thin crust was perfectly crisp yet light as air – something that could only be achieved by master pizza makers!

The flavors in each bite were amazing. I could taste both the freshness of the ingredients as well as an underlying hint of smokiness from their wood-fired ovens. After devouring the entire pizza, I felt completely satisfied – but there was still room for dessert!

While they don’t typically offer dessert pizzas, they do serve up some fantastic tiramisu and cannoli. And trust me when I say that those dishes alone are worth a visit to Rayo’s Pizza!

Without a doubt, Rayo’s is one of my favorite places for pizza in Hayward. Whenever you’re in town looking for great pizza (which should be quite often!), you simply cannot go wrong at Rayo’s Pizza!

#8 Straw Hat Pizza

I’m a pizza connoisseur, so I know good pizza when I taste it. I was blown away by the quality of the ingredients used at Straw Hat Pizza! The crust was thin and crispy, and the cheese and sauce tasted like they were made from scratch daily.

The staff at Straw Hat Pizza were friendly, welcoming, and efficient. They even offered to give me an extra topping for free since it was my first time there.

I’m pleased to say that Straw Hat Pizza has the best pizza in Hayward! If you’re ever in town, be sure to check out this hidden gem – you won’t be disappointed.

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in San Ramon!

#9 Pizza Express Redwood Rd

The first thing I noticed was the welcoming atmosphere – the employees were friendly and knowledgeable, and they made sure I felt right at home. The decor was also quite inviting, with vibrant colors on the walls that perfectly matched the delicious aromas wafting through the air.

When it came to pizza, there were so many options to choose from that I actually had trouble deciding. In the end, though, I went with their classic pepperoni – and it definitely did not disappoint! The crust was light and fluffy, but still held its shape when cut. As for the toppings, they were fresh and flavorful – especially the cheese which melted just right in my mouth.

Overall, Pizza Express Redwood Rd is an excellent place to get some of the best pizza in Hayward. From its cozy atmosphere to its delicious pizzas, this restaurant will definitely make you come back for more. Highly recommended!

#10 Razzos Pizza And Salads

I had the pleasure of sampling Razzos Pizza And Salads’ freshly made pizzas for lunch recently and I must say, it surpassed all my expectations. The crust was light and crunchy, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted. A real treat!

On top of that, their salad bar was impressive; it had a wide variety of fresh vegetables and toppings to choose from. My favorite topping combination had to be arugula, pine nuts, walnuts and feta cheese – so delicious!

One thing that really made this restaurant stand out was their friendly staff. Everyone was so kind and helpful in answering my questions and making sure that I enjoyed my meal.

From the delicious pizza to the wonderful customer service, Razzos Pizza And Salads is clearly a top choice for anyone looking for the best pizza in Hayward. Highly recommended!

#11 Ghazni Afghan Kabobs & Pizza

I have to say, when I heard the name of this restaurant, I was a bit skeptical. After all, how good can pizza from an Afghan Kabob shop be?

Well, my doubts were dashed as soon as I took my first bite. The perfect combination of tangy tomato sauce and soft, chewy dough was enough to make me a believer. And the surprise ingredient on top – ground lamb – was a delicious and unexpected treat!

The atmosphere at Ghazni Afghan Kabobs & Pizza is relaxed and friendly. The staff always greet you with a smile and are happy to offer suggestions for pizza toppings or other menu items. Plus, the prices are very reasonable.

I’m convinced that Ghazni Afghan Kabobs & Pizza has some of the best pizza in Hayward. If you’re ever in the area, you owe it to yourself to give it a try – your taste buds won’t be disappointed!

#12 Express Pizza

The crust is just the right combination of crunchy and chewy, with a hint of garlic that gives it that perfect flavor. The sauce is also delicious – made from fresh tomatoes, oregano, and basil for a savory Mediterranean flavor.

And let’s talk about the toppings – Express Pizza puts an extra special emphasis on quality ingredients. All the meats are locally sourced, and every vegetable is handpicked from local farms to give you the freshest pizza experience possible.

But don’t take my word for it – try it yourself! I guarantee you won’t be disappointed! Express Pizza has quickly become my go-to spot for great pizza in Hayward. In other words, it’s the best pizza around!