In my quest for the best pizza, I’ve tasted pies from over a dozen different spots. With my trusty slice in hand, I was ready to roll out the dough and find the top spot to get pizza in Hilliard OH.
This time around, I’m setting out with a light-hearted and humorous tone. Pizzas can be serious business, but there’s no reason not to have a little fun along the way.
So prepare yourselves for some cheesy entertainment as I reveal my findings on the best pizza places in Hilliard OH.
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio
#1 Off Center: Patio & Pub
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
The building itself is charmingly rustic, and the patio and pub area creates a wonderfully inviting atmosphere. I particularly enjoyed sampling their selection of craft beers while feasting on their delicious pizza.
I’ve sampled pizzas all over the world, but the one thing that really stands out about Off Center’s pies is their crust. It’s delightfully crispy on the outside yet delightfully soft and airy on the inside – truly delectable!
The toppings are all fresh and flavorful, making each bite an exciting new adventure. From classic pepperoni to exotic mushroom-truffle, there’s something for everyone at Off Center.
Overall, this is easily one of my favorite pizza places in Hilliard!
If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Dublin!
#2 Flyers Pizza Hayden Run
- Offers dessert
Let’s start with the atmosphere. The restaurant looks like your typical pizza joint, but it also has a bit of a modern twist. There are lots of TVs playing sports games and the staff are always friendly. The music playing was really cool, and it felt like I was transported to a late-night pizza party.
The pizza itself is amazing! They have all sorts of toppings to choose from, and I can’t get enough of their signature “Flyers” topping – which consists of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and olives. It tastes like a gourmet pizza without being overly expensive.
The crust is delicious too – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. And the cheese… oh man! It’s so ooey gooey and melty that I could just keep eating it forever.
When it comes to service, they make sure that you’re taken care of right away. I was served my food in no time and they were even nice enough to bring out some extra plates for me when my friends came over to join me for dinner.
Overall, if you want some of the best pizza in Hilliard then Flyers Pizza Hayden Run is definitely the place to go! Not only will you be treated like royalty by their friendly staff, but you’ll also get an incredible meal that won’t break the bank.
#3 Ten Pin Pizza & More
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Offers dessert
The crust was perfected to perfection. It had just the right amount of chewiness, and the flavor leapt off the pizza and exploded my taste buds! The toppings were incredibly fresh, and they certainly didn’t skimp out on them. Every bite was loaded with so much flavor that I had to keep reminding myself to slow down and savor it.
The atmosphere inside Ten Pin Pizza & More is something special as well. The walls are lined with classic arcade classics, like Pac-Man and Space Invaders, giving off a vintage vibe that made me nostalgic for childhood pizza nights. Plus, their staff is always friendly and welcoming – which is always appreciated!
Overall, I’d recommend Ten Pin Pizza & More to anyone in Hilliard looking for some of the best pizza around. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!
#4 DiCarlo’s Pizza – Hilliard
- Nice tourist spot
When I walked into DiCarlo’s Pizza, I was met with a warm welcome from the friendly staff. The atmosphere of the restaurant was cozy and inviting, and the smell of freshly baked pies filled my nostrils.
The pizza at DiCarlo’s Pizza is second to none. The dough is light yet chewy, and the sauce is sweet and slightly spicy. To top it all off, the cheese they use melts in your mouth like butter!
I tried several types of pizza at DiCarlo’s Pizza – Hilliard, including their classic pepperoni, a luxurious white pizza with garlic oil, and an innovative pie topped with exotic vegetables. Each one was cooked to perfection and I couldn’t get enough!
My meal at DiCarlo’s Pizza – Hilliard didn’t end there. I also enjoyed an appetizer of cheesy breadsticks which were cooked to golden perfection and had just the right amount of garlic flavor. To drink, I enjoyed a cold craft beer on tap that went perfectly with my meal.
Overall, my experience at DiCarlo’s Pizza – Hilliard left me feeling satisfied and stuffed! It’s no wonder why this place has been named as one of Hilliard’s best pizzerias- their food is simply too delicious to ignore. If you’re ever in town looking for great pizza, make sure to stop by DiCarlo’s Pizza – it will not disappoint!
#5 Flyers Pizza Hilliard
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The first thing I noticed when I walked into the restaurant was the pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff that made me feel right at home. The decor is modern yet traditional, with bright colors and memorabilia from Hilliard’s past adorning the walls. It really felt like a hometown pizza joint—a great place to come with family or friends.
The pizza itself was simply delicious. The crust was cooked perfectly so it had just the right amount of crunch, and the sauce was flavorful without being overpowering. Toppings were plentiful and fresh, making every bite flavorful and enjoyable. Even better than the food were their prices—I could get a large pizza for less than what I’d pay in other cities!
All in all, Flyers Pizza Hilliard is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hilliard! Their knowledgeable staff, welcoming atmosphere, impressive selection of toppings, and unbeatable prices make this spot a must-try for any pizza lover.
#6 Grandad’s Pizza & Pub
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- Great place to watch sports
- Offers dessert
I had the chance to visit this pizzeria recently and I’m still talking about it. From the moment I walked in, I was immediately transported to an old school Italian eatery. The place is covered in red and white checkered walls and the staff was very friendly and welcoming.
The pizza was out of this world! The crust was crisp on the outside, but still soft enough inside that it melted in your mouth when you bit into it. And the toppings had me swooning with each bite. Of course, there’s also a great selection of craft beers from all around the world, making it impossible not to enjoy one with your dinner.
All in all, Grandad’s Pizza & Pub has some of the best pizza in Hilliard for sure. The atmosphere is cozy, the staff is friendly and attentive, and most importantly – the food is unbeatable! So if you’re ever in Hilliard looking for a good slice, definitely go check out Grandad’s Pizza & Pub!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Columbus!
#7 Zuko’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere here is great. The place is bustling and lively, but it’s still cozy with its wood-paneled walls, vintage posters, and dim lighting. It’s the kind of place you’d want to take a date or hang out with friends over a few slices.
The pizzas at Zuko’s are top-notch. Whether you want something classic like marinara and pepperoni or a creative combination like feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and artichokes – they have it all. They also make their own unique pies, such as the smoked mozzarella mushroom pizza which I highly recommend.
What really makes Zuko’s stand out among other pizza restaurants is their attentive service. The waitstaff are all friendly and knowledgeable – they even offered suggestions on what toppings to add to my pizza! Plus, they’re always willing to accommodate special requests, which helps make every visit truly memorable.
To put it simply: If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hilliard, look no further than Zuko’s Pizza! Trust me on this one; you won’t regret it!
#8 Ange’s Pizza Hilliard
The moment I stepped through the door, the mouth-watering aroma of baked tomatoes, cheeses and spices filled my nostrils. The interior was inviting and cozy, with a homey atmosphere and wooden tables perfect for sharing tales of past adventures.
The service was friendly and efficient. My server asked me what type of pizza I wanted and quickly prepared my order. I proceeded to sample one of their specialties, a garden delight pizza loaded with fresh vegetables, mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and basil. All the ingredients melded together perfectly in every bite!
I also tried their classic pepperoni slice, which was packed with flavorful pork sausage slices that melted in my mouth. Both pizzas were cooked in a stone oven to perfection. The crust was light and airy yet crunchy at the same time – a difficult feat to pull off but Ange’s Pizza Hilliard accomplished it with ease!
I’d recommend anyone looking for delicious pizza in Hilliard to visit Ange’s Pizza Hilliard for sure! It just might be the best pizza in town!
#9 Jet’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
From the moment you walk in the door, it’s clear that Jet’s Pizza takes pizza seriously. The delicious smell of baking dough and bubbling cheese greets you right away. The dining area is filled with vibrant colors and exudes an upbeat atmosphere.
The employees at Jet’s Pizza are some of the friendliest I’ve ever encountered. They always greet me with a warm smile, and they take special care to make sure my order is exactly how I want it. Every time I’m there, I can tell they really enjoy making pizza!
As for the pizza itself, let me just say: wow! Loads of gooey cheese, top quality ingredients, and perfectly cooked crust–the combination is unbeatable! My favorite is their signature Detroit-style deep dish pizza; it tastes like a miracle in each bite! Plus, their extensive selection of topping combinations means that everyone can find something to love.
In conclusion, Jet’s Pizza is some of the best pizza in Hilliard. Friendly staff, great vibes, and amazing pies–what more could you ask for?
#10 Luna Pizza Kitchen
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
In terms of visuals, the restaurant itself is quite inviting. The interior is warm and cozy, with a comforting ambiance that makes it perfect for an evening out with friends.
The pizzas here are made to perfection. The crusts are cooked just right so they are both crispy and fluffy at the same time. And the flavors! Oh my! From classic pepperoni to innovative creations like pesto chicken, there’s something for everyone here.
If you’re in Hilliard and looking for a pizza that can stand up to what I’ve had around the world, Luna Pizza Kitchen is your best bet! Don’t forget to try one of their delicious desserts before you leave either – their tiramisu is particularly noteworthy!
#11 Marco’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. The place smelled amazing, and the decor was fantastic. As I looked at all the options on the menu, my mouth started to water in anticipation!
I finally settled on their classic Margherita pizza that was loaded with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and basil. The pizza arrived steaming hot and within minutes it was devoured! Every single bite was absolute perfection – from the crispy crust to the fresh toppings.
The service staff were incredibly friendly and helpful too. They didn’t rush me through my meal as if they wanted me to get out quickly like some other places do. Instead, they were more than happy to answer any questions about the menu or give recommendations for what dish to try next time.
After tasting Marco’s Pizza, it’s easy to see why it has earned a reputation as having some of the best pizza in Hilliard OH! If you’re ever in town looking for a delicious slice of pizza or just a cozy Italian eatery to have dinner at – look no further than Marco’s Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Columbus!
#12 Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard
The atmosphere is cozy, but the pizza-making process is anything but. The culinary team serves up an impressive menu of toppings that ensures every bite is tailored to suit your individual tastes. And when it comes to the crust, well, just trust me and order a slice – it’ll be worth it!
From classic pepperoni pies to unconventional combos like pineapple and capers with pesto, this place does pizza as good if not better than any other in town. And for those who take their cheese seriously? Cottage Inn takes pride in its specialty blend of cheeses that can’t be rivaled anywhere else.
My favorite part was the delicious garlic knots they offer as an appetizer. Not greasy or overly garlicky, they were light and fluffy and had just the right hint of garlic – perfect for a side dish before digging into an enormous slice of pizza (which I highly suggest).
In conclusion, Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard deserves a five-star rating in my book – easily the best pizza you can find in Hilliard!
