Ever since I began my gastronomical journey around the world, I’ve had countless slices of pizza in many different countries. But after my 12-stop tour here in Hillsborough NJ, I can safely say that this small town might just be hiding some of the world’s best pizza!
Join me on this mouthwatering adventure as we make our way through 12 of Hillsborough’s best pizzerias and discover why it is a great place to grab a slice!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Russo’s Pizza Shop
The first time I visited this quaint little pizzeria, I knew it was something special. The dough is made fresh every morning and the flavor is simply divine. With a bright, homemade sauce and perfect amount of cheese, you’ll be convinced that there’s no better pizza in town.
In addition to the amazing pizza, one of the best things about Russo’s Pizza Shop is how friendly and accommodating their staff is. Every time I’ve gone in for a slice or two, I’ve been greeted with a warm welcome and a smile from everyone in the shop. It definitely adds to the overall experience!
And if you’re looking for something more than just pizza, Russo’s offers all sorts of delicious desserts like cannolis and tiramisu too. The presentation is top-notch and really adds to the whole experience.
All in all, Russo’s Pizza Shop has quickly become my favorite go-to spot for pizza in Hillsborough NJ! If you’re ever in the area and craving some delicious Italian cuisine – make sure you give them a visit! You won’t be disappointed!
If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Middlesex!
#2 AMA Pizza
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The space is cozy and inviting, with a neon sign in the window of a pizza slice that had me drooling before I even walked in. The menu has all the classic pizzas (pepperoni and cheese, margherita) plus more unique creations like the “AMA Special” which combines pepperoni and sausage under ooey-gooey melted cheese.
The best part of AMA Pizza is their use of fresh and local ingredients: they get their tomatoes from nearby farms, their mozzarella from a local dairy farm, and their dough is made fresh every day! The result is an authentically delicious pizza that I haven’t tasted anywhere else.
Not to be forgotten are the delightful side dishes—the garlic knots were especially amazing. And finally, for dessert, AMA offers some tasty cannolis—they were so good, I might just go back for another round soon!
In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ then AMA Pizza should top your list!
#3 BELLA PIZZA
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The restaurant itself looks like it came straight out of Italy with the decor and atmosphere evoking the cozy charm of a classic Italian pizzeria. The staff were friendly and accommodating, making us feel right at home.
When it comes to the pizza, BELLA PIZZA certainly lives up to its name! The crust is perfectly cooked every time – not too crunchy and not too soft. It’s just right! Toppings are fresh and flavorful, with combinations that left me truly impressed. Whether you go for a traditional Margherita or something more creative like their Spicy Quattro Formaggi, you’re sure to be delighted.
Overall, there’s no doubt in my mind that BELLA PIZZA serves some of the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ! If you’re in the area, I highly recommend giving this spot a try – you won’t regret it!
#4 MARIANA’S PIZZERIA & LATIN GRILL
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
Upon entering this unassuming little pizzeria, I was met with the warm aroma of freshly baked pizza dough and fresh herbs, immediately putting me in a good mood.
The menu offers a variety of Latin-inspired pizzas featuring ingredients like guava paste, black beans, bacon, and mole sauce. But there are also more traditional offerings such as pepperoni and cheese.
I opted for their signature Guava Mole pizza. The mix of sweet and savory flavors on this pizza was simply divine! The combination of the crunchy crust and the creamy cheese made for a truly unforgettable experience. And the portion size was just right – I didn’t feel too full when I finished my slice!
Overall, MARIANA’S PIZZERIA & LATIN GRILL is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ. Every bite has its own unique flavor that will keep your taste buds tantalized until you’ve finished your last slice!
#5 Vinnie’s Pizza & Pasta
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
As soon as I stepped in the door, the amazing scent of Italian herbs and freshly-baked crusts filled the air. After being seated, my taste buds were tantalized by their delicious menu options. I decided to go with a classic Margherita pizza, which did not disappoint!
The crust was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of cheese and a generous helping of tomato sauce. Every bite was an explosion of flavor, followed by the distinct taste of oregano and basil. It was obvious that the ingredients used to make this pizza were fresh and top-notch.
The service at Vinnie’s was also remarkable – everyone was so friendly and attentive! Plus, they have some wonderful pizza specials throughout the week that make it really easy to try different types of pies without breaking the bank.
Overall, I’d say if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ, then definitely check out Vinnie’s Pizza & Pasta – you won’t be disappointed!
#6 Trattoria Uno
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped into Trattoria Uno, I knew this was going to be an experience to remember. The old-fashioned brick walls, cozy decor and friendly staff set the tone for a wonderful evening. But it wasn’t until I tasted their pizza that I truly realized what a treat I was in for!
The crust at Trattoria Uno is cooked to perfection every time, with just the right amount of crunch. The tomato sauce is so flavorful and fragrant that it tempts you even before you get your first bite. And then there’s the cheese – oh boy – not too cheesy, but still incredibly rich and creamy. It’s clear that they take pride in making sure their ingredients are always top-notch!
It’s no wonder why Trattoria Uno has been around for so long; their pizza is truly the best in Hillsborough NJ! Whether you dine-in or order take-out, you’re guaranteed to have an unforgettable experience at Trattoria Uno. If you haven’t tried their pizza yet, don’t wait any longer – head down to Hillsborough NJ and give it a try; you won’t regret it!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in New Brunswick!
#7 Joe’s Pizza & Restaurant
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I was pleasantly surprised when I walked in. From the cozy and inviting atmosphere to the mouth-watering aromas wafting from the kitchen, I instantly knew Joe’s was going to be something special.
The pizza itself is nothing short of fantastic. The crust is crispy with just the right amount of chewiness and flavor. The sauce manages to strike a perfect balance between tangy and sweet, making for a delightful pizza-eating experience. And the cheese! There are no words! It’s so creamy and flavorful that it almost makes me want to cry tears of joy (or maybe just cheesy bliss).
All in all, Joe’s Pizza & Restaurant has definitely won me over with their delicious pizzas. I can confidently say that this place is hands down one of the best pizza places in Hillsborough NJ, and if you’re ever in town looking for some amazing grub, you know where to go!
#8 Victor’s Pizzeria
The pizza comes out piping hot and the cheese is perfectly melted, with just the right amount of sweetness. The crust is crispy and flavorful, lightly seasoned with oregano and basil for an overall delicious bite.
The menu offers a variety of options from traditional to creative flavors. I highly recommend their pepperoni, mushroom and black olive pie, which is a generous portion that could easily feed two people. The other specialty pies are equally delicious, so you can’t go wrong with whatever you choose.
What sets this pizzeria apart from others in the area is that they use only fresh ingredients in their recipes. You can tell they take great care in preparing each dish because the flavors blend together nicely and highlight each ingredient’s unique characteristics.
The staff at Victor’s Pizzeria were friendly and attentive, ensuring my experience was enjoyable from start to finish. It seemed like they had been running the restaurant for years as every customer was greeted with a smile and treated like one of their own family members.
In conclusion, Victor’s Pizzeria has some of the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ! They offer tasty pies prepared with fresh ingredients accompanied by excellent customer service—all without breaking your budget!
#9 La Strada Cafe
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
The flavor of their pizza is something else. The sauce is tangy and the toppings are fresh and delicious. There’s something about the combination that really does it for me.
And, as if that wasn’t enough, the crust is just perfect. It’s not too thick and it’s not too thin either – it’s just right! It has a crunch to it that makes it stand out from the others.
Overall, La Strada Cafe lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizza joints in Hillsborough NJ. The food is great and the atmosphere is relaxed yet inviting. Plus, there’s an outdoor seating area where you can enjoy your meal with a view of the hills while breathing in some fresh air. What more could you ask for?
#10 Pizza ‘n Pasta
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Great place to watch sports
The atmosphere at Pizza ‘n Pasta was casual and cozy, so I knew the food must be good. And boy, was it ever! The pizza here was made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection, making it one of my favorite pizzas in the area.
The crust was crunchy yet soft with just enough flavor. The cheese was flavorful and melty as expected. And the sauce-well, let’s just say that it had me coming back for more. Plus, their combination of toppings were simply perfect – a great way to experience different flavors all in one bite.
The customer service at Pizza ‘n Pasta was top-notch too – the waitstaff were friendly and helpful. Plus, they served up my pizza in record speed!
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ, then look no further than Pizza ‘n Pasta – definitely a dining experience you won’t soon forget!
#11 Dominick’s Pizza Shoppe LLC
First of all, their pies are mouth-wateringly delicious. The crust is just the right combination of crispy and chewy with a light sprinkle of cheese. And the toppings are fresh and full of flavor – I was especially impressed by the unique combinations they offer!
On top of that, Dominick’s Pizza Shoppe LLC has an atmosphere like no other pizza place I’ve ever visited. The walls have hundreds of photos of celebrity customers (including one from me!), and a jukebox pumping out all your favorite tunes. Plus, there’s a awesome arcade where you can play games while waiting for your pie.
Last but not least, their service was incredibly friendly and professional, making sure I had everything I needed for my meal. As if that weren’t enough, when I asked about their speciality pizzas they willingly explained each one in detail and gave me plenty of samples to try!
Overall, I highly recommend Dominick’s Pizza Shoppe LLC as the best pizza place in Hillsborough NJ. Whether you’re looking to enjoy some great food with friends or just have an unforgettable experience on your own – this is definitely the spot!
If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Somerset!
#12 Enrico’s Pizza & Pasta
- Has some vegetarian options
I had the pleasure of dining at Enrico’s recently and I have to say, it was an experience like no other. From the moment I stepped inside, I felt like family! The atmosphere was nice and cozy, with small tables perfect for intimate conversations.
The service was nothing short of excellent. Our waiter was friendly and knowledgeable – he knew all the interesting facts about their pizzas. And boy, were there some interesting facts!
The pizza itself was outstanding. Even though I’m used to tasting some culinary masterpieces in my travels, Enrico’s Pizza & Pasta really stands out from the competition. They use fresh ingredients for all their pies, and it shows in the taste. The crust is perfectly cooked with a delightful crunchiness on the outside and a chewy texture inside; plus, they don’t skimp on toppings!
To top it off (literally!), they also have delicious desserts that you can enjoy after your meal. The ice cream is just as creamy as it should be and their cannoli is one of my favorites!
All in all, Enrico’s Pizza & Pasta offers some of the best pizza in Hillsborough NJ – perfect for those days when you’re craving something special to eat. Go ahead and treat yourself – you won’t regret it!
