Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Hudson Valley (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Hudson Valley (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

210 Views

I’ve eaten pizza in some of the most renowned places all around the world, from Italy to New York City. Now, it’s Hudson Valley’s turn to get my attention. I’ve reviewed twelve pizzerias in the area and have a funny and lighthearted take on which one stands out as the very best.

Stay tuned for an entertaining journey through inadequate cheese ratios, soggy crusts, and the triumphant slice that tops them all!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Pizzeria Posto

To start off, the atmosphere of this place is top-notch. Not only is it a prime tourist spot for visitors in the area, but it also serves as a great hangout spot for locals.

The menu was jam-packed with various options and I had no problem finding something to suit my tastes. Vegetarians will be happy to know that Pizzeria Posto offers many vegetarian options, including a delicious gluten-free crust that has won rave reviews from everyone I’ve spoken to who’s tried it!

But let’s get to the important part – the pizza! The pizzas here are some of the best I’ve had anywhere in the world. They have a unique crust that’s crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside with plenty of tangy tomato sauce and melted cheese that make each slice a masterpiece on its own. To top it all off, Pizzeria Posto also has an impressive selection of wine and beer which pairs perfectly with your meal.

My only complaint about Pizzeria Posto would have to be that they don’t offer delivery – but hey, sometimes you just have to jump in your car and drive for great pizza! All things considered, I’d definitely recommend Pizzeria Posto if you’re ever in Hudson Valley – it’ll be worth every kilometer you travel!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Kingston!

#2 Lolita’s Pizza

When I entered the restaurant, I was taken aback by the cozy atmosphere. The brightly lit dining area was perfect for a group of friends or even a romantic dinner. And the smell of freshly baked pizza in the air made my mouth water with anticipation.

As soon as we got our seat, one of the wait staff came over and asked us what we wanted to order. We opted for their signature pizza, “The Lolita’s Special”, which had an abundance of toppings! The combination of red sauce, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, and onions was divine. Every bite melted in my mouth and satisfied my cravings for Italian goodness.

But that wasn’t all that this restaurant offered. We also ordered some appetizers; namely Garlic Bread Sticks covered in a garlic and parmesan mixture and calamari rings drenched with hot sauce! They were both so delicious that I’m already looking forward to going back again soon to sample more of their amazing fare!

To conclude this review, I can honestly say that if you’re ever looking for some of the best pizza in Hudson Valley than look no further than Lolita’s Pizza!

#3 Hudson & Packard

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I was greeted by the friendly staff and a delicious aroma of cheese, sauce and Italian herbs. I grabbed a seat in the cozy dining area and took in the atmosphere, which had been designed to be warm and inviting.

The menu at Hudson & Packard boasted some great options for pizza lovers like myself. There were classic pies like pepperoni and mushroom, as well as more creative toppings such as feta-olive and buffalo chicken. After much deliberation (and several helpings of breadsticks!) I decided on two specialties: The Meat Lover’s Pizza with its generous amount of sausage, ham, salami, bacon, pepperoni and mozzarella; and the Smoky Eggplant Pie with its mix of smoky eggplant puree, ricotta cheese and fresh basil.

The pizzas arrived quickly, plated on thick wooden boards that lent an air of rustic elegance to the meal. The flavors of each pie were layered in complexity but harmoniously combined; my taste buds were in heaven! The crust was perfectly cooked through with just a hint of crispness that helped bring out the savory flavors further.

I would highly recommend Hudson & Packard to anyone looking for amazing pizza in the valley. In my opinion this is hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

#4 Martio’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Martio’s is certainly unique. It has the perfect mix of casual and cozy. The walls are adorned with vintage movie posters, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a delicious pizza while reminiscing on the good ol’ days.

When it comes to the food, they definitely don’t disappoint. They use only the freshest ingredients, so you can be sure that every bite will be loaded with flavor! Their signature pies are absolutely amazing; I recommend trying their ‘Mighty Meaty’ – it’s a delectable combination of various meats, fresh vegetables and gooey cheese all piled on top of a delicious thin-crust pizza. Not to mention, their crusts are made from scratch daily, which makes for a light and crispy delight!

In my opinion, Martio’s Pizza is simply unmatched when it comes to finding the best pizza in Hudson Valley. When you’re looking for an evening out that won’t break your budget, then this is the place to go!

#5 Paulina’s Pizza & Restaurant

I was surprised as I walked in by the cozy atmosphere – they really went all out with the decor! The walls were covered with framed pictures of Italy, and even a few autographs from some famous Italian chefs – it gave the place an authentic feel.

The menu had a lot more than just pizza on it – from chicken parmesan to calzones and even desserts like tiramisu and cannolis. But let’s get to what matters most here: the pizza.

I ordered a large pepperoni pie, which was good but nothing special. However, after trying their signature “Paulina Pie”, I was blown away! It had all the classic flavors of an Italian pizzeria, plus a few special touches that set it apart from other places. The toppings were fresh, the crust was crunchy, and the cheese melted perfectly to create an amazing flavor combination.

Overall, Paulina’s Pizza & Restaurant is easily one of my top 3 favorite restaurants for pizza in Hudson Valley – if you’re ever in town craving a slice (or two), be sure to check them out!

#6 Baba Louie’s

From the moment I stepped through the door, I was amazed. The atmosphere was fun and inviting, with a lively staff that truly enjoyed their job.

The pizza itself is fantastic. It’s cooked to perfection, with a perfectly crisp crust and an array of flavorful toppings. The menu offers something for everyone – from classic combos to specialty pies. And don’t forget the fantastic homemade sauces!

They offer more than just pizza, though – there are salads, sandwiches, sides and even desserts to choose from. And when it comes time for drinks – well, let’s just say you won’t be disappointed!

Overall, Baba Louie’s is definitely my go-to place for pizza in Hudson. If you’re looking for the best pizza around – this is it!

#7 Ollie’s Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I knew this was a special place. The décor was cozy and inviting, and the owners greeted me warmly, as if I’d been a regular for years.

The menu is immense and eclectic. You can get classic Italian pizzas like my favorite Margherita or you can try something off the beaten path, like their Mexican Chicken Pizza with refried beans, tomatoes, peppers and jalapenos! It’s so unique that it should be on its own culinary world tour!

The pizza itself is delicious. The crust is thin and crunchy, yet still perfectly chewy. Their sauces are full of flavor and none of the ingredients taste artificial or microwaved. They must use high-quality ingredients to achieve such a great balance!

In conclusion, Ollie’s Pizza has earned my recommendation for being one of the best pizza places in Hudson Valley! Whether you want a classic Italian pie or something to tantalize your taste buds with a Mexican twist – this is THE place to go for the best pizza in town.

#8 Rino’s Pizza

From the moment I walked in, it felt like I’d been transported to a small Italian pizzeria. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a genuine pizza-lovers’ vibe that was hard to resist.

The menu has an impressive selection of classic and contemporary pizza options. My favorite is the four-cheese white pie — the balance of flavors and textures was spot on! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese had a wonderfully creamy quality, and each bite melted in my mouth.

The service at Rino’s Pizza is also excellent. The staff are all friendly, knowledgeable and attentive, making sure that your experience is as enjoyable as possible.

In conclusion, if you want some of the best pizza in Hudson Valley, you owe it to yourself to visit Rino’s Pizza! From their delicious food to their incredible service, they’ll keep you coming back for more!

#9 Lucoli

First and foremost, the crust is perfection. It’s a perfect balance between fluffy and crunchy. I’ve never had a pizza with a better bready consistency!

The toppings are equally as delightful – they’re always fresh and flavorful. Plus, Lucoli has an incredible variety of topping options that you won’t find anywhere else in the area. From classic pepperoni to creative combos like wild mushroom and broccoli rabe, this place has something for everyone.

Beyond just pizza, Lucoli also has some delicious sides. The garlic knots are a must-have – soft on the inside with a crispy outside that just melts in your mouth! Then there’s the fried calamari – it’s light and airy yet flavor-packed.

But of course, no review would be complete without acknowledging the fantastic service provided by the staff at Lucoli. They’re always friendly and make sure everyone’s Happy Slice experience is top-notch!

So, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Hudson Valley, look no further than Lucoli!

#10 Turiello’s Pizza House

From their hand-crafted dough and homemade sauce to their generous toppings, I must say that Turiello’s Pizza House really knows how to make a pizza. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every slice and no matter which topping you choose, you can expect a great combination of delicious flavors.

I recommend trying one of Turiello’s signature pies for an extra special treat. My personal favorite is the Meat Lover’s which comes loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, bacon and ham. Another great option is the Chicken Bacon Ranch for those looking for a slightly lighter option.

The atmosphere at Turiello’s Pizza House is equally as amazing as their food. There are TVs all around playing sports games and the staff are always friendly and accommodating. Plus, they offer beer and wine so you don’t have to worry about going thirsty while enjoying your meal!

At Turiello’s Pizza House I can guarantee that you’ll get quality pizzas at a great price. If you’re ever in the Hudson Valley area and craving some of the best pizza around, I highly recommend stopping in at Turiello’s!

If you’re willing to go an extra 15 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in New Paltz!

#11 Vera Pizzeria

The atmosphere here is great. It has a cozy, welcoming feel that immediately puts you in the pizza-eating mood. The décor is inviting and charming, with lots of Italian-themed decorations scattered around the restaurant.

The service here is top-notch. The staff are friendly, quick and attentive – they make sure to get your order right and take care of any special requests you might have.

Now onto their amazing pizza! Their crusts are cooked to perfection – just the right amount of crunch that makes you want to grab another slice before you even finish the first one. And their toppings? Oh wow! They use only the freshest ingredients – everything from locally-sourced meats and vegetables to homemade sauces and cheeses – which really helps bring out all the flavors in each bite.

Overall, my experience at Vera Pizzeria was excellent and I highly recommend it for anyone looking for the best pizza in Hudson Valley! Bon Appetit!

#12 Emiliano’s Pizza

When I arrived at Emiliano’s, I was amazed by the interior decor. It was warm and cozy, with a classic Italian vibe throughout. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable about all their offerings – including some delicious drinks to go along with my pizza.

When it came to the pizza itself, I was really impressed. The crust was crispy yet chewy, the sauce had just the right balance of tangy and sweet, and they had some great topping combinations. My favorite was the Primavera which had fresh veggies like tomatoes, artichokes, mushrooms and olives – simply delicious!

I can honestly say that Emiliano’s is one of the best pizzerias in Hudson Valley. If you’re looking for a genuine Italian-American experience with some of the best pizza around – look no further than Emiliano’s Pizza!