From the deep dish I sampled in Chicago to the wood-fired thin crust of Rome, I’m no stranger to pizza. So, you can imagine my excitement when I heard about the pizza scene in Islamorada! Being a curious critic, I decided to get down there and sample some of their offerings.
I visited 7 different places over the course of my stay; each with its own unique style and flavor. It’s been quite an adventure. After much tasting and evaluation, it is my pleasure to introduce you all to what I believe are the best pizzas Islamorada has to offer. Ready your forks!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida
#1 KRUST pizza & pies
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
I must say, the moment I walked in and saw the wood fire oven, I knew it was going to be a delicious experience. The smell of cheesy goodness was so inviting, it was hard not to be instantly drawn in.
The menu had something for everyone, from classic pepperoni and margherita pizzas to more creative pies with gourmet toppings. I decided to go for the classic Italiana with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella and basil. It was cooked perfectly in their wood fire oven and really embodied what pizza is all about!
The service at KRUST is top-notch too – everyone was super friendly and helpful without being overbearing. You could tell they take pride in their craft and wanted us to enjoy our meal as much as possible.
Overall, KRUST pizza & pies definitely lives up to its name – it’s undoubtedly some of the best pizza in Islamorada! Whether you’re looking for a fun night out or just want a delicious slice of pizza, this place comes highly recommended!
If you’re willing to go an extra 11 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Key Largo!
#2 Bayside Gourmet
- Serves alcohol
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The service was great, the staff were friendly and helpful (despite my sometimes picky requests). I was even offered a free soda for dessert.
I opted for their signature dish – a triple-decker pizza with three layers of crust, tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni and Italian sausage. The flavors melded perfectly together and each bite was better than the last! The toppings were generous and the crust was crunchy and flavorful.
The atmosphere at Bayside Gourmet is perfect for a night out. The restaurant is well-decorated with nautical themes – from the hanging ropes to the pirate paintings. It’s definitely an experience you won’t forget anytime soon!
Overall, I’d highly recommend Bayside Gourmet to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Islamorada. From the flavor combinations to the relaxed vibe, it’s truly an unforgettable experience!
If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Marathon!
#3 Stone Oven Pizzeria – The Whistle Stop
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere is just perfect – it’s a cozy little place with bright colors and cobbled-together furniture. The smell of the perfectly cooked pizza wafted through the air, drawing me in.
The pizza itself was out of this world! It was freshly made with their special blend of spices and ingredients, making it really flavorful. The crust was just right – not too thin, not too thick, and crispy on the outside with a nice crunch. The sauce had an Italian flavor that really set off the rest of the pizza.
The service at Stone Oven Pizzeria – The Whistle Stop was great too! The staff were friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. They even gave me some suggestions on what toppings would work best for each type of pizza I ordered, so I got to experience a bit of a ‘pizza tasting’!
All in all, Stone Oven Pizzeria – The Whistle Stop has earned my seal of approval; it’s officially one of the best pizzas in Islamorada! If you’re ever in town, make sure to stop by for a slice (or two!). You won’t regret it!
If you’re willing to go an extra 45 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Kendall!
#4 Enrico’s Pizza
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere at Enrico’s is perfect for a laid-back vacation. With its rustic Italian decor, it makes you feel like you’re in an Italian pizzeria in the heart of Italy. The staff were all very friendly and welcoming – just like any pizza place should be!
My first bite of the Capricciosa pie was heavenly! The fresh ingredients combined with the thin, hand-tossed crust created the kind of flavors that can only be found in Italy. It’s no wonder why this restaurant has been around for so long and has countless loyal customers.
But let’s not forget about their other pies – each one was even better than the last. From their classic Margherita to their more adventurous Hawaiian pizza, there’s something for everyone here. The pasta dishes are also a must-try if you’re looking for something different.
Overall, my experience at Enrico’s Pizza was nothing short of amazing! If you’re looking for the best pizza in Islamorada, then look no further – this is definitely your destination!
If you’re willing to go an extra 49 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in South Miami!
#5 Ciao Hound
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has insanely good dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
Upon walking into Ciao Hound, I was immediately struck by the amazing aromas of freshly baked pizza. The warmth radiating from the wood-fired oven enticed me to take a seat at one of their outdoor tables where I could really take in the experience.
The food itself is out of this world! I tried the Margherita pie which had a light and crispy crust with just the right amount of char. The tomatoes were ripe, sweet and full of flavor, while the mozzarella cheese was creamy and delicious. Also, the basil added an aromatic herbaceous note that really completed the dish.
I have to say, Ciao Hound is hands down one of the best pizzas in Islamorada. The fantastic atmosphere paired with incredible pies make it a top destination for any pizza lover looking for excellence. Treat yourself to some amazing pizza today at Ciao Hound – you won’t regret it!
#6 Domino’s Pizza
The crust is perfectly cooked and the cheese is a great combination of gooey and flavorful. The toppings varied from pepperoni to vegetables to hearty meatballs — all cooked to perfection.
The atmosphere at Domino’s Pizza was really enjoyable. The decor was inviting, the staff were friendly and helpful, and the music was just loud enough to make it feel like a party!
Overall, I would highly recommend Domino’s Pizza if you’re looking for the best pizza in Islamorada. The fresh ingredients, excellent cooking techniques and relaxing atmosphere make it an ideal place for a pizza night out with friends or family.
#7 Mia Cucina
- Serves alcohol
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- No delivery
As a pizza connoisseur, I’m always looking for the perfect crust. Mia Cucina’s thin and crispy crust is like no other – it’s the perfect foundation for all of their delicious toppings.
Their specialty pizza, the ‘Islamorada Supreme’, is truly divine – with fresh toppings of cheese, tomatoes, peppers and olives on top of that perfect crust, it’s sure to satisfy your craving and make you come back for more!
And if you’re looking for a night out with family or friends, Mia Cucina also offers alcoholic drinks as well as delectable desserts. What could be better?
The only thing missing from Mia Cucina is delivery – unfortunately they don’t offer that service yet. But in my opinion, this pizzeria is still worth visiting; there’s no comparison to the atmosphere inside their restaurant!
In short: If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Islamorada, Mia Cucina is a must-visit spot. Even though they don’t offer delivery service, it’s still well worth it for the amazing taste and atmosphere of this local gem.
