Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Kihei (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Hawaii

Best Pizza in Kihei (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

322 Views

I’ve tasted pizza all over the world, and now I’m ready to share my top picks for the best pizza in Kihei. I went above and beyond to find delicious pies, testing 12 different places.

The results may surprise you, but I’m here to provide a humorous, lighthearted look at Kihei’s pizza scene. We’ll discuss what makes each restaurant special, so you can decide which one is right for your next meal!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Hawaii

#1 Johnny’s Heist Pizza & BBQ

The atmosphere of the restaurant is cheerful and comfortable, with a laid back vibe that makes it easy to relax. The decor features an eclectic mix of Italian-American touches, like a mural of the Italian flag draped in graffiti art.

The pizza at Johnny’s Heist Pizza & BBQ is truly something special. They offer a variety of toppings, from classic pepperoni and sausage to unique options such as pineapple and bacon. I have to say that their BBQ-style pizzas are especially delicious – something about the combination of tangy sauce with smoky pulled pork makes for an unforgettable flavor!

But the real star of Johnny’s Heist Pizza & BBQ is the crust. It’s light and fluffy on the inside while being crunchy around the edges – without being too hard or burnt. It gives you that perfect balance between chewiness and crunch – exactly what you want in great pizza!

Overall, I can confidently say that Johnny’s Heist Pizza & BBQ has some of the best pizza in Kihei! The atmosphere, toppings, and crust all come together to make an exceptional experience. If you’re in Kihei, be sure to check them out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Wailea!

#2 Pizza Madness Maui

When I walked into Pizza Madness Maui, the first thing that struck me was the amazing aroma of freshly baked pizza. I knew from the moment I walked in that this place was going to be something special.

The selection of pizza on offer is incredible! From classic pepperoni and cheese to unique toppings like sausage pineapple and Canadian bacon, there is something for everyone’s taste. Even better, you can build your own pizzas with all sorts of crazy combinations of ingredients so each slice is truly unique.

The staff at Pizza Madness Maui were friendly and helpful throughout my visit. They took extra care to make sure my order was correct, and they even gave me a few complimentary samples while I waited! The staff here clearly care about their product and it shows.

Without a doubt, Pizza Madness Maui offers some of the best pizza in Kihei. If you’re ever in town and looking for an authentic pizza experience then look no further than Pizza Madness Maui – you won’t regret it!

#3 Outrigger Pizza Co 1

The pizza is homemade; I was pleasantly surprised by the freshness of the dough and the selection of toppings offered. And the flavors were like a flavor bomb in my mouth! The combination of herbs and spices was tantalizing. Plus, you can customize your order with whatever toppings you want.

The atmosphere of Outrigger Pizza Co 1 is cozy and inviting. It has a laid-back vibe that puts me in a relaxing mood. The staff are friendly and accommodating, which I really appreciate when eating out.

I’d recommend Outrigger Pizza Co 1 to anyone looking for a delicious pizza experience in Kihei. Whether you’re in for a slice or an entire pie, their quality ingredients and generous portions will have you begging for more! Best pizza in Kihei? Definitely!

#4 Penny’s Pizza and Pasta

First of all, the atmosphere at Penny’s is great. It has the perfect mix of cozy and casual – perfect for a night out with friends or even family. And if you bring the kids along, they’ll have something to choose from too – there’s a kid’s menu! Plus, what pizza night would be complete without a few drinks? Thankfully, Penny’s serves alcohol (even hard liquors!) so you can enjoy your evening here.

The food also does not disappoint at Penny’s. From the moment I took my first bite, it was evident that they serve up some quality pies here. Not to mention their wide selection of pasta dishes too! But whatever you order, make sure to add dessert – they have some delicious options that are hard to pass up on.

Overall, Penny’s Pizza and Pasta makes a great tourist spot and offers some of the best pizza in Kihei. However, there is one slight downside – they don’t offer delivery service. But trust me, this place is worth visiting!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Lahaina!

#5 Matteo’s Osteria

The atmosphere is great and the staff really cares about making sure you have a good time. Plus, it doesn’t hurt that they serve alcohol (and hard liquor) for all my adult friends!

The menu has something for everyone; there’s a kid’s menu for the kids, some vegetarian options, and insanely good desserts. I had their traditional Italian dessert Tiramisu and it was to die for!

My only complaint is that they don’t offer delivery. That would come in handy during those hungover days when I just can’t bear to drag myself out of bed!

But if you’re planning on visiting Kihei or spending time there, you’ll definitely want to check out Matteo’s Osteria. With its delicious pizza, great atmosphere, and creative offerings like Tiramisu, this spot is definitively the best place in town to get your pizza fix.

#6 South Shore Tiki Lounge

From the moment I entered, the friendly staff welcomed me with open arms and a menu full of delicious options. There were plenty of vegetarian options to choose from, so everyone in my party had a dish they could enjoy.

The pizza was absolutely divine – it was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of cheese and spices. I could tell it had been carefully prepared with fresh ingredients, which is something you don’t always find in pizza places. The unique flavor combinations set South Shore Tiki Lounge apart from other pizza restaurants in Kihei.

But that’s not all! South Shore Tiki Lounge also offered a fantastic selection of local beers on tap, plus hard liquor for those who like to have their drinks on the stronger side. And if you’re feeling like treating yourself or your kids to something sweet afterwards, there’s a great selection of desserts available as well.

It truly is an ideal tourist spot for sampling some of the best pizza in Kihei. The only downside I can think of is that South Shore Tiki Lounge doesn’t do delivery – but trust me when I say it’s worth the visit!

#7 Java Café

I was pleasantly surprised to find a pizza joint in Kihei that offered such great quality. The toppings were fresh, the sauce was flavorful, and the crust was flawlessly cooked. Not to mention, their dessert selection is outstanding – definitely something I would recommend trying if you get a chance!

As a tourist spot, Java Café has quite a bit going for it. Its location near the beach makes it the perfect place for grabbing some food after spending the day in Kihei. The atmosphere is also nice, with friendly staff and plenty of seating options.

The only downside I could find was that they don’t offer delivery service, which could be inconvenient if you’re not able to make it out to the restaurant. That being said, it’s well worth the trip – I promise you won’t be disappointed. Java Café is definitely one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever been to!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Lahaina!

#8 Round Table Pizza

I stopped by Round Table Pizza to give their pies a try, and I was not disappointed. The decor of the restaurant was classic, with retro red booths, bright lights and charming staff.

The service here was fast and friendly; everyone seemed genuinely happy to be there and eager to help out customers.

But what about the pizza? Well, let me tell you – it was truly incredible! The crust was perfectly cooked and had a delicious flavor that only a hand-tossed dough can create. The cheese was gooey and flavorful and the toppings were fresh and plentiful. Absolutely delicious!

Overall, my experience at Round Table Pizza was amazing. Their pizza is definitely some of the best in Kihei. Highly recommended!

#9 Manoli’s Pizza Company

The crust on their pizza is perfect; thin and crispy, but with just enough structure so that it holds up to heavy toppings. The cheese is some of the best I’ve ever tasted – rich and creamy without being too greasy. And the sauce? Let’s just say it ranks up there with the top pizzerias in Italy!

I had the pleasure of trying several pizza combinations: a classic margherita for the traditionalist, a spicy pepperoni for the daring and a vegetable supreme for those looking for something more adventurous. Every single one was cooked to perfection and packed with flavour.

Manoli’s Pizza Company also offers up some interesting flavours; they have a unique selection of cured meats, smoked cheeses and even vegan/vegetarian options – which shows they truly care about providing variety in their menu.

To top off my experience, service at Manoli’s Pizza Company was exceptional – friendly and attentive staff made sure I was satisfied throughout my meal.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian-style pizza experience, look no further than Manoli’s Pizza Company! From its delicious ingredients to its excellent service, I can honestly say that this is some of the best pizza in Kihei – enjoy!

#10 Pizza Hut

As soon as you walk in, you can smell the delicious aroma of pizza wafting through the air. The presentation was great, with a wide selection of pizzas to choose from. Whether it’s the classic cheese or pepperoni, or something more exotic like BBQ chicken or shrimp Alfredo, there is a pizza for everyone!

The crust is light and fluffy, with just enough crunchiness to make it memorable. Each slice has just the right amount of sauce – not too much and not too little – making it perfect for any palate. And don’t forget about the cheese! It melts perfectly between each layer and creates an overall outstanding experience.

The customer service is nothing short of amazing – they are friendly and attentive, always willing to offer suggestions or answer any questions that you may have. And the prices can’t be beat! You really get your money’s worth here at Pizza Hut!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Kihei then look no further than Pizza Hut! I highly recommend paying them a visit – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Kihei!

#11 Fabiani’s Bakery and Pizzeria

I arrived at the restaurant to find a cozy atmosphere and a warm welcome from the friendly staff. With a tantalizing array of pizzas to choose from, I was overwhelmed with possibilities. After much deliberation, I decided to try the Fabiani’s special—a blend of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions and green peppers.

The pizza itself was out of this world! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy; the cheese was melted perfectly throughout the toppings; and the sauce had just enough flavor without being overpowering. It was truly the best pizza I have had in a long time.

In addition to great food, Fabiani’s also offers generous portions with excellent value for money. Whether you’re looking to dine in or take out your meal, you’re sure to be pleased with their selection.

As a traveling food critic who takes great pride in seeking out hidden gems around the globe, I can honestly say that Fabiani’s Bakery and Pizzeria is one of the best that Kihei has to offer! It definitely lives up to its reputation as having some of the best pizza around.

#12 Ferraro’s Bar e Ristorante

The ambience of the restaurant is great. You can tell they take pride in their establishment and it looks like a nice tourist spot. The service was polite and friendly too.

The pizza was delicious. Thin, crispy crust, with generous topping amounts for every slice! I would expect no less from such a high-quality restaurant. To top it off, they have vegetarian options so everyone at the table can enjoy their meal. As an added bonus, there’s even a kids’ menu if you’re bringing along the little ones.

Another great thing about Ferraro’s Bar e Ristorante is that they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!) to those who want it. And if you’re saving room for dessert, you’ll be glad to know that they offer some of the best desserts I’ve tasted in all my travels.

My only gripe about this place is that there’s no delivery option available. But apart from that, I’d definitely recommend this place as one of the best places to get pizza in Kihei!