Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Kingston NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Kingston NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

191 Views

I’ve sampled twelve different pizza places in the region, and I’m ready to share my opinion on which one makes the best ‘za!

My experience with pizza around the world has given me a good foundation for comparison. So whether you’re looking for a classic NY style slice or something with unique toppings and flavors, I’ve used my tastebuds to find you the most delicious options.

So let’s get ready to power up our ovens, because I’m about to tell you where you can find the Best Pizza in Kingston NY!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

The atmosphere here is amazing – the minute I stepped inside, the smell of freshly cooked pizza and the sound of Italian music filled the air! The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming – they really made me feel at home.

The pizza here is outstanding! The crust is crispy, the sauce is flavorful and there is just the right amount of cheese. They offer a wide variety of toppings from pepperoni to pineapple, and all taste delicious!

I was also impressed with their unique take on pizza – for example, their ‘chicken parmesan pizza’ which has a creamy white sauce base, topped with mozzarella cheese and succulent chicken parmesan pieces. It was heavenly!

Overall, my experience eating at Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante was excellent! The food, atmosphere and service were all top-notch – definitely worth 5 stars! If you’re ever in Kingston NY looking for great pizza, this should be your first stop!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 37 more pizza places in Hudson!

#2 Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza

My first visit to Enzo’s will stay in my memory for years: the atmosphere was inviting; the staff were friendly and helpful; and the pizzas were just breathtaking. The crust was deliciously golden brown, the toppings fresh and flavorful, and the sauce sublimely homemade.

I’ve had many different styles of pizza while traveling, but no other has ever quite compared to the pies at Enzo’s. Whether it was their fiery pepperoni pizza or their classic Margherita that I guzzled down in record time, they always seem to make sure every bite is perfection.

Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Kingston NY. Their fresh ingredients, generous servings, and excellent sense of hospitality have made this one of my favorite Italian restaurants around. So next time you’re thinking about where to get some of the best pizza in Kingston NY—look no further than Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza!

#3 Di Bella’s

It all starts with the delicious hand-tossed crust. It has just the right amount of crispness, not too thick and not too thin. Plus, they have a wide selection of toppings that have been meticulously sourced from the best suppliers. The cheese and sauce are incredible, and they’re generous with them too!

The atmosphere is great too; it’s a small, family oriented restaurant that makes you feel right at home. The service is top notch, so if you’re looking for a great place to have pizza with your family or friends then Di Bella’s should be at the top of your list.

My only complaint? I wish they offered delivery so I could get their delicious pizza right to my front door! All in all though Di Bella’s is an excellent choice for anyone looking for the best pizza in Kingston NY.

#4 King’s

As soon as I stepped into King’s, I knew I had come to the right place. The restaurant was cozy but inviting, with an old-school pizza joint vibe.

The menu featured all sorts of variations of delicious pizzas – something for everyone. My personal favorite was the garlic and herb white pizza with grilled chicken and ricotta – it was a flavor bomb!

Once my pizza arrived, my taste buds were in heaven! The crust was perfectly crispy yet maintained its chewiness at the same time. The sauce was full of rich tomato flavor that gave way to cheese and other toppings that simply melted in my mouth. It truly tasted like home, even though King’s is thousands of miles away from where I live.

Overall, my experience at King’s exceeded expectations – best pizza in Kingston NY hands down!

#5 A Slice of Italy

I have to say, the atmosphere here is second-to-none. With its traditional Italian décor and checkered tablecloths, you’ll feel like you’re in Italy!

The pizza itself is truly something special. The crust is thin, but not too thin that it falls apart once you take your first bite. The sauce is flavorful and the cheese melts perfectly. It’s hard to find a balance between these two components and A Slice of Italy has mastered it! Add some pepperoni and you’ve got perfection!

It’s impossible to talk about A Slice of Italy without mentioning the staff. They are so friendly and welcoming – they genuinely make you feel at home, which is exactly what I need when I’m reviewing great food!

All in all, I would highly recommend A Slice of Italy for anyone looking for the best pizza in Kingston NY. I absolutely love this place, and if I’m ever back in town, it will definitely be my go-to spot for pizza!

#6 Picnic Pizza

I recently stopped by this local pizza joint to give their pies a try, and they did not disappoint. The atmosphere was rustic yet inviting, with the brick oven gracing the back wall of the dining area.

The pizzas were cooked in this very same brick oven, and it produced some truly delicious results. The crust was crispy on the outside while still being slightly chewy on the inside – just how I like it! Toppings were generous and well-seasoned, making every bite a pleasure.

Overall, Picnic Pizza is an excellent spot for a casual meal or as part of an evening out. The restaurant has earned its title as one of the best pizza joints in Kingston NY!

If you’re willing to go an extra 13 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in New Paltz!

#7 440 Pizzeria

I arrived at 440 Pizzeria and was instantly charmed by the inviting atmosphere. The interior had a rustic Italian charm that immediately made me feel as though I was in Italy.

The pizza was cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven, creating that familiar smoky flavor. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and seemed to have been carefully selected to deliver the best taste possible.

My favorite dish of the evening was definitely the ‘specialty’ pizza which featured mushrooms, peppers and olives – delicious! The waitstaff was also very friendly and attentive, ensuring that I got my pizza exactly how I wanted it.

Overall, I can say without hesitation that 440 Pizzeria is one of the best places for pizza in Kingston NY. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than 440 Pizzeria. In my opinion, they serve up some of the best pizza around!

#8 Mario’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I entered the restaurant was the warm, friendly atmosphere. The staff were quick to greet me and the decor was cozy and inviting.

The pizza itself? Well, let’s just say that it stands up to—and in some cases surpasses—the pizza I’ve had all over Europe and the US. The crust was crisp and light, yet still had enough substance to hold up all of the delicious toppings. The sauce was flavorful and zesty, but not overpowering. And the cheese… well, let’s just say that my taste buds were doing a dance of joy after just one bite!

Overall, Mario’s Pizza is by far one of the best pizzerias around. If you’re ever in Kingston NY, don’t forget to stop by and enjoy their incredible pies!

#9 La Roma

From the moment I stepped through the door, I could tell that La Roma is serious about pizza. The aroma of freshly-made dough and bubbling cheese filled the air, instantly making my mouth water. As I perused the menu, I knew I was in for a treat – with so many delicious variations to choose from, it took me awhile to decide!

In the end, I went with one of their specialties – a classic margherita. It was hands down one of the best pizza’s I’ve tasted lately; every bite was an explosion of flavor. The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy while still retaining a nice chewiness on the inside. The sauce had the perfect balance of sweet and tart, and melted together nicely with mozzarella cheese that was just gooey enough.

Aside from great pizza, La Roma has excellent service as well; all staff were friendly and helpful. Plus, they offer a selection of beers and wines to perfectly complement your meal. All in all, La Roma serves up some of the best pizza in Kingston NY – definitely worth checking out if you’re in town!

#10 LOLA Pizza

As soon as I stepped foot in LOLA Pizza, I could feel the authenticity of the place. The decor had a rustic Italian charm that was inviting and comforting.

When it came to the food, I was not disappointed! Just one bite and I could tell that they know what they are doing at LOLA Pizza. The dough was perfectly crisp, the sauce flavorful and balanced, and the topping juicy and full of flavor. Not surprisingly considering how good their pizza is, their other dishes were also delicious.

I would not hesitate to recommend LOLA Pizza to anyone looking for great pizza. They really bring out the best in every slice – you can’t go wrong with this place!

#11 Matteo’s Pizza

I’m talking the real deal here. The crust was so fresh and fluffy… it tasted like it was made mere minutes before I took that first bite. Topping wise, they use only the finest ingredients and get creative with their combinations – I had their Pesto Alfredo pizza with tomatoes and feta and let me tell you, the flavor explosion was out of this world!

The atmosphere in the restaurant is also great. The decor is warm and rustic, giving a cozy feeling to the place where you can really relax and enjoy your meal. Plus, the staff are friendly and attentive – they really look after you to make sure your experience is top notch.

So if you’re ever in Kingston NY looking for a delicious pizza experience, definitely hit up Matteo’s Pizza – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Poughkeepsie!

#12 Steve’s Pizza & Deli

I must admit, I was skeptical at first. After all, a deli and a pizza place combined? But after trying it for myself, I quickly changed my mind. The pizza here was fantastic!

The dough was freshly made to perfection, the toppings were generous and flavorful, and the cheese had just the right amount of gooey goodness. It was obvious that Steve’s Pizza & Deli takes pride in their work – you can taste it in every single bite.

The atmosphere is also great – there’s plenty of seating for bigger groups and the service is friendly and fast. Plus, if you’re looking for something a little different than pizza (although why would you want that?), they also offer subs and salads that are quite tasty.

All in all, I’d highly recommend Steve’s Pizza & Deli if you’re looking for the best pizza in Kingston NY. I know I’ll be back soon to enjoy more of their delicious creations!