The city might be small, but it certainly has a lot of places to get a slice. After trying out twelve different pizza restaurants in Kokomo, I’m excited to share my opinion on which ones are the very best.
Every pizza place had its own unique atmosphere and flavor, but only a few of them truly exceeded my expectations. My mission now is to guide you through all the pizza options in Kokomo, delivered with a humorous and lighthearted tone. So let’s dig into the deliciousness that awaits in this midwestern city!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Indiana
#1 Tank’s Pizza
- No delivery
I was skeptical when I first arrived, as the place looks like a tank… no pun intended. But once inside, I was hit with a wave of excitement that only comes from great pizza. The staff welcomed me warmly, and even though they don’t offer delivery, their restaurant is definitely worth the visit.
The walls were adorned with pictures of tanks and it really makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a unique and special experience. The atmosphere was one of family and community, which is part of what makes Tank’s Pizza so great.
As for the pizza itself, let me just say: wow! It’s truly some of the best pizza I have ever had. Each bite was full of flavor and could easily be shared between two people (so make sure to bring someone along with you!). They also offer an extensive topping selection, from classic favorites such as pepperoni and sausage to creative combinations like pesto and artichoke hearts.
No matter your tastes, Tank’s Pizza will satisfy them. Their pies are always cooked perfectly, with a crispy crust that holds up under whatever toppings you can dream up. I definitely recommend it if you’re in Kokomo looking for the best pizza around!
If you’re willing to go an extra 35 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Carmel!
#2 Stoney’s Sourdough Pizza Co.
- Has some vegetarian options
My first impression of the restaurant was that it was small and unassuming, with the pizza parlor surprisingly located in an old abandoned farmhouse. I quickly realized that Stoney’s not only had a great atmosphere but also amazing pizzas!
The menu at Stoney’s is full of great options for both meat-lovers and vegetarians alike. I decided to try their signature Sourdough Supreme, which included pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, onions, mushrooms and olives all on top of a thick crust. The combination of flavors was truly heavenly – the crunchy sourdough crust paired well with the zesty tomato sauce and gooey cheese.
I’m happy to report that my experience at Stoney’s Sourdough Pizza Co. exceeded expectations. Not only did they offer delicious pizza but they also had friendly staff who were more than willing to answer any questions I had about the ingredients and preparation process.
If you’re ever in Kokomo looking for great pizza, be sure to check out this hidden gem – you won’t regret it! Without a doubt, Stoney’s serves up some of the best pizza in town!
#3 PizzaCo
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere at PizzaCo was great. From the moment I walked in, I felt like I was home. The staff were friendly and very helpful. They took their time to explain all the different toppings and specials they had available.
The pizzas were cooked to perfection, with a nice thin crust that was crispy around the edges and fluffy in the middle. And it wasn’t just me who thought so – everyone around me remarked on how good it looked!
As for the toppings, they had some really interesting options that you don’t see elsewhere. Their signature “Kokomo Supreme” has pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, onions and garlic that all came together perfectly to create a delicious combination of flavors. Plus, you can get any topping your heart desires with their make-your-own-pizza option!
I would definitely recommend PizzaCo if you’re looking for the best pizza in Kokomo. It’s worth every penny!
#4 Glover’s Pizza and Ice Cream
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- No delivery
The crust is perfectly crunchy and the sauce is flavorful, with just the right amount of tang. The toppings are so fresh and delicious that it’s almost like eating a slice from Italy!
What really sets Glover’s apart from other pizzerias in Kokomo, however, is its insanely good dessert options. From ice cream sundaes to their homemade cannoli, there’s something to make everyone happy. It definitely makes for a great tourist spot!
On the downside, unfortunately, Glover’s Pizza and Ice Cream doesn’t offer delivery at this time. This means you’ll have to either pick up your order in-person or get creative with transportation options if you’re not in the area!
Overall, I think Glover’s Pizza and Ice Cream is one of the best pizza places in Kokomo – it’s definitely worth trying out!
#5 Oscar’s Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- No delivery
I had the pleasure of sampling the popular ‘Gorilla Cheese’ pizza, which was cooked to perfection. The crust was golden, the cheese melted in my mouth, and it totally hit the spot.
If like me you’re looking for a little slice of alcohol with your meal, then you’ll be happy to hear that Oscar’s Pizza serves up a great selection of drinks. From beer to wine and everything in between, there’s something for everyone here. And vegetarians will be glad to know that there are some options available – though the menu could do with a few more veggie-friendly dishes!
It’s also worth mentioning that desserts are available, making this an ideal spot for tourists looking for an evening out.
The only downside I can think of is that they don’t offer delivery – however if you’re nearby it’s definitely worth visiting to savour some of their fine fare! All in all Oscar’s Pizza is a great pizza joint and deserves its status as one of the best in Kokomo!
#6 Gabe’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
My first impression of Gabe’s Pizza was great. The restaurant has a cozy, inviting atmosphere that makes it a pleasant place to dine. The staff is friendly and helpful, and they were more than happy to answer my questions about their menu.
I decided to try their signature pie: the Chicken Alfredo Pizza. I have to admit – it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tried! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, and the tangy alfredo sauce added the perfect amount of flavor. The chicken on top was cooked perfectly, and there were plenty of fresh veggies for some crunchy texture.
Overall, Gabe’s Pizza exceeded my expectations in every way. From the cozy atmosphere to the delicious pizza, there’s nothing but good things to say about this place. I highly recommend trying it out if you’re in Kokomo – it might be your new favorite spot!
#7 Pizza King Dine In
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
The atmosphere was inviting, with a plethora of classic Italian décor. The staff was friendly and accommodating and the service was fast and efficient.
The pizza selection is vast; I tried the pepperoni, mushroom, and spinach combination and it blew my mind. Crust so thin it melts in your mouth, perfectly cooked toppings that tantalize your taste buds – this is what I’d call an example of true culinary mastery.
I also indulged in their signature garlic breadsticks which were well-seasoned and oh-so-buttery! The accompanying marinara dip was spot-on and complimented the breadsticks beautifully.
All in all, I would recommend Pizza King Dine In to anyone looking for the best pizza in Kokomo. Go there now and indulge yourself – you won’t regret it!
#8 Bruno’s Pizza Kokomo
- Has some vegetarian options
The moment I stepped inside the restaurant, I felt like I had been transported to a delightful little Italian pizzeria. The freshly-baked aroma of their gourmet pizza was enough to make my mouth water!
The service was outstanding. All of the staff were warm and friendly, and they went out of their way to make sure I had the best experience possible. They even offered me suggestions on what to order so that I would get the most out of my visit!
When it came time for me to order, I couldn’t decide between their delicious specialty pies or their classic hand tossed variety. In the end, I decided to go with the latter, and let me tell you it did not disappoint! The crust was crispy yet light and fluffy, and it was topped with generous amounts of fresh cheese, pepperoni, onions, peppers and more. The flavors were perfectly balanced with just enough spice to give you a kick!
I can honestly say that Bruno’s Pizza Kokomo is one of the best pizza places in town – hands down! Next time you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than this hidden gem in Kokomo. You won’t regret it!
If you’re willing to go an extra 37 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Noblesville!
#9 Martino’s Italian Villa
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has a kid’s menu
- No delivery
I have never had anything less than a fantastic experience here, and the hard liquor they serve is an added bonus to the already delicious pizza. Plus, they have a kid’s menu, so parents don’t have to worry about picky eaters. Vegetarians don’t miss out either – there are vegetarian options available so everyone can enjoy the glorious pizza.
But if you’re looking for delivery service, this place isn’t for you. Martino’s Italian Villa doesn’t offer delivery services unfortunately but they make up for it with their insanely good desserts. The tiramisu was especially noteworthy!
So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Kokomo, look no further than Martino’s Italian Villa. Not only do they serve great food and drinks, but it also makes for a nice tourist spot too!
#10 Harvey Hinklemeyers
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The dough is made fresh daily, hand-stretched and cooked to a perfect crisp. The sauce is out of this world! It tastes like it was made from a secret blend of Italian tomatoes, herbs, and spices that go together perfectly.
Toppings are also exquisite! Each one is carefully prepared and placed on the pizza just right. From classic pepperoni and sausage to unique combinations like grilled chicken and pineapple, there’s something delicious for everyone.
Service at Harvey Hinklemeyers is top notch too. They have an incredibly friendly staff that always greets you with a smile, no matter what time you come in. Plus, the prices are very reasonable given the quality of the ingredients used in their pizzas.
Overall I highly recommend Harvey Hinklemeyers if you’re looking for the best pizza in Kokomo!
#11 Gabe’s Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Serves alcohol
I recently visited Gabe’s and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The atmosphere was inviting and cozy, the staff were friendly and knowledgeable, and the pizza was delicious. From what I could see on their menu, they had a variety of toppings to choose from – everything from classic pepperoni to more exotic combinations like pineapple and jalapenos!
The pizza itself was cooked to perfection – the crust was cooked through just enough to give it some crunch without being too hard. The toppings were generous, flavorful, and fresh. It truly is some of the best pizza I have had in a long time!
If you’re looking for a great pizza experience in Kokomo, then look no further than Gabe’s Pizza. With its inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious pizza, it’s sure to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters. So next time you’re craving some comfort food in Kokomo, give Gabe’s Pizza a try – you won’t regret it!
#12 Noble Romans Craft Pizza & Pub
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has a kid’s menu
Their pizza is incredibly delicious – the crust is perfectly crispy and the ingredients they use are top-notch. Plus, their flavor combinations are creative and unique. I had a special called the ‘Kokomo Special’ which was topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, beef, peppers, and onion – it tasted incredible!
In addition to their great pizza, they also have some amazing sides. Their garlic breadsticks are especially delicious – they’re freshly made and covered in just the right amount of garlic butter. I could easily eat an entire plate of them on my own!
Noble Romans Craft Pizza & Pub is definitely worth visiting if you’re looking for the best pizza in Kokomo. The atmosphere here is also great – it’s a nice combination between a sports pub and a restaurant. So make sure to check it out when you’re in town!
