Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lahaina (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Hawaii

Best Pizza in Lahaina (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

53 Views

After tasting over a dozen different pizza places, I’m proud to present my top pick for the absolute best pizza in Lahaina.

My taste buds have been around the world, and you can trust me that here are some worthwhile pies. With a lighthearted and humorous take on pizza reviews, I’ve found several amazing restaurants that offer delicious slices of goodness.

I’m excited to introduce you to my favorite place for the best pizza in Lahaina. Follow me on this mouth-watering journey as I explore 12 different restaurants in search of the ultimate pie!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Hawaii

#1 Sale Pepe

On my first visit, I was immediately impressed with the friendly staff and cozy atmosphere. The pizza was cooked to perfection with a slight crunch of crust, a light yet flavorful sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. I opted for the Hawaiian Pie – two words: divine! The combination of fruity pineapple with salty ham and crispy bacon made my taste buds go wild!

What makes Sale Pepe stand out from other pizza places is their quality ingredients. They only use fresh produce and flavorful herbs that truly make the meal special. You can taste their attention to detail in every bite.

In addition to great pizzas, Sale Pepe also offers an extensive selection of appetizers and sides, like garlic knots and prosciutto-wrapped asparagus spears. Plus you can wash it all down with one of their craft beers on tap or a unique Italian soda.

I’ve been all over the world tasting pizza but nothing compares to the pies I had at Sale Pepe. It’s definitely the best pizza in Lahaina!

If you’re willing to go an extra 12 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Kihei!

#2 Kamala’s Kitchen

The restaurant is conveniently located in a tourist spot, so it’s easy to find and grab some grub. While they don’t offer delivery, their takeout options are always piping hot and delicious.

Their specialty, the Kamala Special (olives, peppers, onions and sausage) is a must-try on your visit. The sauce they use is what makes this pizza unique. It’s savory and smoky with just the right amount of sweetness. The crust is crispy yet chewy with the perfect amount of char.

The restaurant itself has a cozy atmosphere with friendly staff that make you feel at home. Whether you’re looking for classic New York-style slices or something more adventurous, Kamala’s Kitchen has all the bases covered. In fact, I’d go as far as saying it has some of the best pizza in Lahaina!

#3 Lahaina Pizza Company

I’m not easily impressed, so I was pleasantly surprised when I tasted their delicious New York-style pizza. Here’s the best part — they even serve alcohol (and hard liquor!) so you can enjoy a nice cold one with your meal.

Speaking of drinks, the atmosphere here is great. It’s the perfect spot for tourists to hang out, and they’ve got plenty of kid-friendly options on the menu. Plus, when you’ve finished your meal there’s always dessert to look forward to.

The only downside I can think of is that they don’t do deliveries — but if you’re in Lahaina, this place should definitely be at the top of your list!

#4 Prison Street Pizza

The first thing that I noticed when walking in was how incredibly friendly the staff was. They were so welcoming and gave me a big smile, which made me feel right at home.

Next, the decor of this place is top-notch. It’s like you’re inside an actual prison cell, complete with prison bars and every detail down to the stone floors and brick walls. The atmosphere is definitely unique.

Now for the pizza – it’s absolutely amazing! The crust is crispy and has just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings are all fresh and flavorful, from the chunky tomatoes to the sweet, creamy cheese. And last but not least, there’s a great selection of sauces available ranging from mild to hot.

Overall, Prison Street Pizza is one of my current favorites for good pizza in Lahaina! Highly recommend it if you’re looking for a delicious meal.

If you’re willing to go an extra 17 miles, you can get to 10 more pizza places in Wailea!

#5 Round Table Pizza

It’s hard not to be impressed by the wide selection of toppings and custom combinations on offer at Round Table Pizza. Every time I’ve visited, I’m presented with a mouthwatering array of options that have delighted my taste buds!

The pizza dough is always thin and crispy, making for a perfect crust every time. Toppings are flavorful and generous – I actually leave feeling full and satisfied, not regretful from skimping on the ingredients.

To top it all off, the staff at Round Table Pizza are great. Everyone I’ve encountered has been friendly, helpful, and quick to give me my order. They make sure to check in during the meal to ensure everything is up to par – no stone left unturned here!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Lahaina, look no further than Round Table Pizza – they won’t disappoint!

#6 Pizza Paradiso Mediterranean Grill

The atmosphere was so inviting and warm, I felt right at home. The staff couldn’t be more helpful either – they all had great suggestions for what kind of pizza to try.

My favorite pizza ended up being the Mediterranean-style, with artichoke hearts, Kalamata olives, sundried tomatoes and feta cheese – it was heavenly! It had all the perfect flavors of the Mediterranean combined with a thin, crispy crust.

I also tried the BBQ Chicken Pizza which was a delicious combination of smoky BBQ sauce and tender chicken pieces. To top it all off, it came with some crunchy fried onions that gave it an extra kick of flavor.

I would highly recommend Pizza Paradiso Mediterranean Grill if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lahaina. Their selection is varied and their pizzas are cooked to perfection!

#7 Dollie’s Pub & Café

My journey began when I heard about Dollie’s from a good friend who told me that their pizza was the best in town. So, naturally, I decided to give it a try. And boy am I glad I did!

Their pizzas are made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. The crust is crisp and flavorful, while the toppings are plentiful and delicious. Plus, they offer a wide variety of combinations so there’s something for everyone.

The atmosphere at Dollie’s is warm and inviting. It’s the perfect spot for friends or family to gather and enjoy some great pizza. They also have great drinks, salads, and desserts to complement your meal.

Overall, I would absolutely recommend Dollie’s Pub & Café if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lahaina!

If you’re willing to go an extra 23 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Kihei!

#8 Nikki’s Pizza

I recently visited Nikki’s and I was amazed at the quality of both their service and, more importantly, the pizza. The staff were friendly and welcoming – it definitely felt like a tourist spot. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, making it a great place to bring friends or family for a casual evening out.

The selection at Nikki’s is really quite impressive too. You’ll find everything from classic Italian pizzas with delicious homemade sauces, to creative flavor combinations like banana calzone with crème fraîche. Whatever your taste buds crave, there’s something here that you’ll love!

But what really sets Nikki’s apart is the quality of the food. The crusts are always light and airy, never soggy or greasy; while the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Overall, my experience at this particular pizza spot has shown me that they’re not only committed to serving up some of the best pizza in Lahaina but also dedicated to providing excellent customer service.

My only complaint about Nikki’s Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery; otherwise I would be ordering from them all the time! If you find yourself in Lahaina though, I highly recommend checking out this hidden gem for some world-class pizza!

#9 Beachwalk Market & Pantry

I was so excited to finally make my way to this restaurant. The atmosphere was great and very touristy, which I loved. The staff were all friendly and helpful, especially when it came to advising me on what kind of pizza I should get – always a plus!

The food itself definitely did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crispy, yet still soft in certain places. And the toppings, wow! There were so many flavors going on that every bite was an adventure. Some of the standout pizzas were the classic Margherita and the Maui Sunrise – both of which hit the spot!

One special feature that Beachwalk Market & Pantry offers is their kid’s menu, which features several slices of cheese or pepperoni pizza. This makes it such a great choice for families looking for a fun lunch or dinner outing! And if you’ve got room afterwards, they also have delicious desserts too – who could say no?

Although one downside is that they don’t offer delivery service, I think it’s well worth it to go into the restaurant and enjoy all that they have to offer. All in all, I’d definitely recommend Beachwalk Market & Pantry to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Lahaina!

#10 Pizza Hut

I have to give my highest praises for their classic cheese pizza. The cheese was perfectly melted and the crust had just the right amount of crunch. It’s like they’ve perfected the art of pizza making!

I also tried their pepperoni and it was delicious. They don’t go overboard with the pepperoni, which is something I appreciate. My taste buds were in heaven as I chewed through each bite!

The staff at Pizza Hut was incredibly friendly, making sure I had everything I needed and that my order was cooked correctly. Plus, they weren’t stingy with the toppings – a definite plus!

Overall, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Lahaina, Pizza Hut is your place to go. Trust me – it will be worth every penny!

If you’re willing to go an extra 80 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Honolulu!

#11 The Pizza Connection

I recently visited this charming tourist spot and was immediately drawn in by its homey atmosphere. I could tell right away that the pizza would be delicious, and boy was I right! The Pizza Connection consistently delivers some of the most flavorful and unique pizzas I’ve ever tasted.

The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always willing to answer questions about their offerings. They even let me try a few samples before ordering! That’s the kind of excellent customer service that you don’t find everywhere these days.

My only complaint about The Pizza Connection is that they don’t offer delivery services, so if you want to try their amazing pies you have to do it on site. But trust me when I say it’s worth the trip. This pizzeria has become one of my favorite spots in Lahaina for good reason – they make some of the best pizza around!

#12 Brick oven Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is incredibly inviting. From the lively music to the friendly waitstaff, it’s obvious why so many people come here. Plus, it’s tough to ignore the delicious aromas of freshly cooked pizza that fill the air!

The pizza itself is remarkable. The crust – superbly thin and crispy – is freshly made every day and topped with an array of fresh vegetables, Italian cheeses and salamis. Every slice was cooked to perfection – not too soft or too hard – and it was loaded with flavor.

I’d highly recommend Brick oven Pizza if you’re in Lahaina and craving a great pizza experience. It definitely lives up to its title as the ‘best pizza in Lahaina!’

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizza Paradiso

Walking into this charming little restaurant, I was immediately hit with the aroma of freshly baked dough and melting cheese. The ambience was cozy and inviting, with a rustic decor that made me feel like I had stepped into an Italian grandmother’s kitchen.

Now, let’s talk about their pizza. Oh mama mia, it was a thing of beauty! The thin crust was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the cheese was gooey and heavenly. Every bite was a delight, and I found myself devouring slice after slice with reckless abandon.

But wait, there’s more! Pizza Paradiso also serves alcohol, and not just your run-of-the-mill beer and wine. They have a wide selection of hard liquor, which made this food critic very happy indeed. And for my vegetarian friends, fear not! They have some great meatless options that are just as delicious.

To top it all off, Pizza Paradiso offers a mouthwatering dessert menu. Their cannoli is to die for, and the tiramisu is simply divine. Trust me, you won’t want to skip dessert when you dine here.

Now, let’s address the downsides. Unfortunately, Pizza Paradiso does not offer delivery, which means you’ll have to pry yourself away from your cozy hotel room to go there. Additionally, they don’t accept reservations, so plan accordingly if you’re visiting during peak hours.

But hey, who needs delivery or reservations when you have the best thin crust pizza in maui waiting for you at Pizza Paradiso? Trust me, it’s worth every effort to experience this slice of pizza heaven.