Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lake Geneva (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Lake Geneva (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

158 Views

I’ve been lucky enough to try pizzas all over the world – from Italy to Michigan – and have tasted some pretty amazing pies. Now I’m bringing my pizza palette to Lake Geneva, where I’ll be reviewing twelve of the best pizza places in town.

Be sure to join me on this mouthwatering tour! With a humorous and lighthearted attitude, you won’t want to miss out on discovering who will come out on top as the best pizza in Lake Geneva.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 Next Door Pub & Pizzeria

I’ve tried pizza from the streets of New York and Rome, but none compare to the deliciousness of Next Door’s pies. They have a great selection of unique specialty pizzas, including their famous “Mac & Cheese Pizza” (voted by locals as the best pizza in Lake Genea), and I’m still dreams about it!

The atmosphere at Next Door Pub & Pizzeria is really something special too. The rustic decor gives it a cozy feeling that you won’t find in other pizza joints. And speaking of cozy feels, their freshly made dough wraps around your taste buds like a warm hug!

If you’re looking for a place to get the best pizza in Lake Geneva, you’ll want to make sure to check out Next Door Pub & Pizzeria!

If you’re willing to go an extra 22 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Lake Bluff!

#2 Upper Crust Pizzeria

No matter what kind of pizza you’re craving, Upper Crust has it all. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni pie or their specialty veggie pizza, they’ve got something to satisfy every taste bud. The crust and sauce are just the right amount of delicious. Each bite is better than the last and leaves me wanting more!

And let’s not forget about the toppings! Upper Crust takes their topping game seriously, from fresh veggies to gourmet meats and cheeses, you won’t be disappointed in their selection. Their pies are always cooked to perfection – you won’t find soggy crust here!

The atmosphere at Upper Crust is inviting and relaxed; it’s always great for a casual dinner with family or friends. Their prices are reasonable too, so you don’t have to break the bank to get a great tasting pizza. I highly recommend Upper Crust Pizzeria if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lake Geneva!

#3 MOD Pizza

I had the chance to try their pepperoni pizza, and it was out of this world! The crust was perfectly cooked so that it was both crunchy and soft. The cheese was melted to perfection and all of the different flavors blended together harmoniously. The pepperoni was especially delicious.

When I walked into MOD Pizza, I knew right away that this place is one of a kind. The atmosphere is inviting and comfortable making it a great spot for a casual dinner with friends or family. Plus, their customer service was top-notch – they made me feel right at home!

At MOD Pizza, you get to pick your own toppings, which makes creating your own unique pizza combination easy. After trying my own custom concoction, I can easily say that MOD Pizza has the best pizza in Lake Geneva!

#4 Oakfire

It’s not just the pizza that makes it one of the best spots in town. Oakfire has some great benefits to offer, too. They serve beer and hard liquor, which is always a plus. The kid’s menu is great for families. They also have some vegetarian options, so no one gets left out. And their dessert! Insanely good!

Oakfire isn’t just great for locals, it’s also a nice tourist spot with plenty of activities happening throughout the year. It’s also an awesome spot to watch all your favourite sports games – nothing beats cheering on your team at Oakfire!

Unfortunately, there is no delivery service at this restaurant, but I’d say walking over to pick up some of their gourmet pizza (and maybe a beer or two) is well worth the effort. All in all, Oakfire truly deserves its reputation as having the best pizza in Lake Geneva – it absolutely lives up to the hype!

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Waukesha!

#5 Clock Tower Pizza

I was pleasantly surprised as soon as I walked in the door. The atmosphere was friendly, and the staff was really helpful in guiding me through their vast selection of pies. As a true pizza connoisseur, I couldn’t help but drool at their delicious-looking selections.

The pizza itself is truly mouth-watering! Even before I took a bite, it smelled heavenly with its combination of warm dough, melted cheese and flavorful sauce. It didn’t take long for me to find my favorite topping: pepperoni! The peppers offering a slightly spicy and chewy texture that complemented the smooth sauce.

To top it all off, Clock Tower Pizza offers some pretty amazing prices. For what I get here compared to other places in town, this place is an absolute bargain – not to mention the fact that they offer daily specials so even those on a tight budget can enjoy some of the best pizza in Lake Geneva!

I highly recommend Clock Tower Pizza for anyone looking for an indulgent slice of pizza heaven – you won’t find a better spot in Lake Geneva!

#6 Crafted Italia

The atmosphere is great for tourists and sports fans. There’s an extensive drinks menu, so you can enjoy your favorite craft beer or a hard liquor of choice to accompany your pizza. Plus, the kid’s menu ensures that everyone has something to snack on!

Even vegetarians have options here – Crafted Italia really goes out of their way to make sure that everyone who visits can find something they love. And once you’ve finished up your meal, treat yourself with one of their insanely delicious desserts!

It would be nice if they offered delivery so I could enjoy this delectable pizza in the comfort of my own home, but who am I kidding? With the atmosphere and the excitement of watching a live game while chowing down on perfect cheesy slices, it’s well worth the visit.

I’m confident in declaring that Crafted Italia serves up some of the best pizza in Lake Geneva – so don’t miss out!

#7 Domino’s Pizza

I had the opportunity to visit the local Domino’s Pizza location and was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was surprisingly inviting and warm; they even had a friendly staff member ready to greet me at the door.

The pizza? It was simply divine! To be honest, I think it might have been one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted. It was perfectly cooked with a crispy, flavorful crust and delicious toppings that complemented each other perfectly. Not to mention, the fresh ingredients added an extra layer of flavor.

In addition to the great food, I found myself also impressed by their prices. For all the quality of their pizza, they are incredibly affordable compared to other restaurants in town.

All in all, Domino’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out if you’re in Lake Geneva! Their wonderful food, inviting atmosphere and budget-friendly prices make this restaurant an easy choice for anyone looking for some of the best pizza around.

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Kenosha!

#8 Mama Cimino’s Pizza

I must admit, I was a bit skeptical before walking through the door – but the aroma of fresh pizza dough drew me in. Once inside, there was plenty of seating and the staff were extremely friendly and welcoming.

The menu had a great selection of pizzas to choose from, including classic pies like the cheese and pepperoni, and unique options like the giardiniera veggie pizza. I decided to order their special – which was three different types of pizza: sausage, mushroom and spinach.

I’m not exaggerating when I say that this was probably the best pizza I’ve ever had! Everything about it was perfect: the crust was thin and crispy, yet richly flavored; the sauce had just enough tomatoey tang; and all of the ingredients blended together harmoniously.

If you’re searching for amazing pizza in Lake Geneva, Mama Cimino’s Pizza is hands down your best bet! Even as a food critic who’s been all over tasting pizza, I give this place two enthusiastic thumbs up.

#9 Gino’s East

From the moment I stepped in this cozy little corner pizzeria, I could tell that Gino’s East had something special. The bubbly staff welcomed me gratefully and the mouthwatering aroma of pizza was palpable in the air.

The pizzas here are simply superb. I ordered a classic pepperoni and mushroom pie, but was introduced to some of their more exotic creations like the Thai Chicken Pizza. No matter what you order, you’ll be sure to enjoy it; their dough is light yet chewy and their ingredients are always fresh and flavorful. Plus, they offer an amazing array of locally-brewed beers to pair your meal with!

The true highlight of my visit to Gino’s East however was the ambiance. With live jazz music spilling out onto the streets and laughter ringing off of every wall, it truly is a joyful place to dine. Plus through their open kitchen concept you can watch as each pizza is carefully crafted by the pizzaiolo himself!

Gino’s East certainly lives up to its reputation for being the best pizza in Lake Geneva – if you’re ever in town this is one spot you don’t want to miss out on!

#10 Rosati’s Pizza

My experience at Rosati’s started with the traditional Italian atmosphere, complete with red and white checkered table cloths and friendly staff. I was lucky enough to get a seat in the corner, perfect for observing the other customers enjoying their meals.

The menu had a great selection of pizza choices – from classic pepperoni to unique Chicago-style deep dish pies. I opted for a classic cheese pizza, but added some extras like mushrooms and black olives – which turned out to be the perfect combination! The crust was cooked just right and the cheese melted perfectly. It was definitely one of the best slices of pizza that I’ve ever eaten!

The service at Rosati’s was also excellent. My waitress was patient and accommodating throughout my meal, even though I took a while to decide on what toppings to put on my pizza. She also made sure that I had everything I needed throughout my stay there.

If you find yourself craving true Italian-style pizza in Lake Geneva, then Rosati’s is your best bet! They offer delicious hand-crafted pizzas at affordable prices with top notch service to match. You won’t be disappointed; Rosati’s truly is home to some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 29 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Huntley!

#11 Pizza Hut

The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is inviting. The menu has something for everyone – from classic pepperoni to more exotic options like Italian sausage and green olives. Even if you’re not a pizza-lover, they’ve got other delicious items on the menu.

What really sets Pizza Hut apart, though, is their dough. It’s light and fluffy yet packed with flavor – it almost melts in your mouth! Toppings are generous and everything is cooked to perfection. The crust is crispy and chewy enough to satisfy any pizza-lover!

I can honestly say that this is the best pizza I’ve ever had in Lake Geneva. If you’re looking for an unforgettable experience in pizza, make sure you check out Pizza Hut!

#12 Pizza Hut Express

I visited Pizza Hut Express to sample their pizza, and was pleasantly surprised. Not only did they have some delicious pizzas, but they also had a great selection of desserts! It was a nice tourist spot with friendly staff and good vibes.

The only downside I could find was the fact that it doesn’t offer delivery. But even that couldn’t take away from the delicious pizza! All I can say is that if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lake Geneva, then Pizza Hut Express is definitely worth checking out!