Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lexington KY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Kentucky

Best Pizza in Lexington KY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

169 Views

I’m thrilled to put together this comprehensive review of twelve pizza places in the area. During my travels, I’ve tasted some of the most delicious pies around the world – so I’m confident I can help you decide where to get the best slice (or two) in Lexington.

With a humorous and lighthearted tone, I’ll give you an honest assessment of each establishment and weigh up the different factors that make for a great pizza experience. So, ready your taste buds and let’s explore which place will top the list for the best pizza in Lexington KY!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Kentucky

#1 PieTana

I’m not exaggerating when I say that PieTana serves up some of the most delicious pizza I’ve ever tried. The crust is perfectly crisp, the sauce has just the right amount of tang, and all their toppings are fresh and flavorful.

But what really sets PieTana apart from everyone else is their creative topping combination options. Whether you like traditional pepperoni or something more daring like pineapple-jalapeno-bacon (which happens to be my personal favorite), there’s something here for everyone.

The atmosphere is comfortable, too. You can come in for a casual dinner with your family or have an intimate date night away from the hustle and bustle of life.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Lexington KY, look no further than PieTana. With their top quality ingredients and amazing pizzas, it’s sure to hit the spot!

If you’re willing to go an extra 60 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Louisville!

#2 Blaze Pizza

I remember my first visit to Blaze Pizza. I walked in and was immediately enveloped by the smell of their freshly-baked pizzas. As I looked at the menu, I could tell that they had thoughtfully created an array of signature pizzas, each with its own unique flavor profile.

I decided to try their signature Blaze Pizza and let me just say, it was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy, topped with a perfect combination of tomatoes, cheese, and fresh herbs. The flavor literally exploded in my mouth with every bite!

The service at Blaze Pizza is top notch as well. Everyone is friendly and helpful which really adds to the overall dining experience. The ordering process is also smooth; they offer a variety of payment options that make paying for your pizza quick and easy.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lexington KY, then look no further than Blaze Pizza! Their amazing selection of pies plus their friendly service makes them a winner in my book!

#3 Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria by Fayette Mall

The moment I stepped inside, I knew this was the spot. The atmosphere was lively and welcoming, with delicious aromas coming from the kitchen. The staff were friendly and attentive, adding to the fantastic experience.

I started off with a classic Margherita pizza – sauce made from imported Italian tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, basil and olive oil. My first bite was heavenly – just the right amount of saltiness and crunch. My taste buds were delighted!

Next up, I sampled their Gorgonzola pizza with roasted sweet peppers and olives. This combination of salty flavors paired with sweet peppers is truly something special! It’s no wonder why this is one of Smashing Tomato’s signature pizzas.

Finally, I tried a wild concoction – a BBQ Chicken Pizza. Although unorthodox for an Italian joint, it worked surprisingly well! The smoky flavors complemented the savory chicken perfectly, making this pizza definitely worth a try for any adventurous foodie looking for something different in Lexington KY!

Overall, I highly recommend dining at Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria by Fayette Mall if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Lexington KY. From classic Margheritas to innovative creations like BBQ chicken pizzas – they’ve got your cravings covered!

#4 Pearl’s Pizza

I stopped in for dinner the other night, and I wasn’t sure what to expect. Little did I know that it would be such an incredible experience!

The atmosphere was energetic and vibrant, with a warm, inviting vibe. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which definitely added to the overall ambiance of the place.

The menu was extensive; there was something for everyone! They had all of your classic favorites like pepperoni and veggie pizzas as well as gourmet specialties such as Prosciutto & Arugula. You could even create your own masterpiece pie by choosing each ingredient that went into it – talk about delicious freedom!

When my pizza arrived at the table, I knew that I was in for a real treat. From the golden-brown crust to the perfectly melted cheese, everything was cooked to perfection. You could really taste the freshness of each ingredient, making this one of the most flavorful pizzas I’ve ever experienced!

If you’re ever in Lexington KY and looking for some truly amazing pizza, then Pearl’s Pizza is definitely worth a visit. Trust me: once you take that first bite, you’ll never go anywhere else for pizza again!

#5 Pie Five Pizza

At first glance, the atmosphere is cozy and inviting- it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a pizza and relax. The staff was friendly and took the time to answer all my questions.

The pizza itself was delicious! I got a classic cheese pie with fresh tomatoes, onions, peppers and olives. The crust was light and fluffy, with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was flavorful without being too overbearing, while the toppings were plentiful and flavorful.

I also tried their famous ‘pie-rito’ which comes in two varieties: chicken or steak. It’s basically a wrap made with their pizza dough (which is amazing), filled with your choice of topping plus lettuce, tomato and cheese. My piece of advice? Go for the chicken! It has so much flavor that you won’t even miss the steak!

Overall, Pie Five Pizza is an excellent bakery concept offering some of the best pizza in Lexington KY! The atmosphere is pleasant, staff are friendly and knowledgeable, food is freshly made and packed full of flavor. Give it a try next time you’re in town – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Smashing Tomato Pizzeria at Hamburg

From the moment I walked in, I was amazed. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, with rustic Italian decor and a warm fireplace. And the smell of fresh-baked pizza wafting through the air!

The menu items are unique and creative, like their Sweet Onion and Garlic Pie. The crust is thin but chewy, just how I like it. Their Savory Salami Pie is packed with flavor from the sweet tomatoes to the spicy salami. And you can’t go wrong with a classic Pepperoni Pie either.

Their salads are amazing too – fresh greens with herbs from their garden out back. And don’t forget dessert – homemade cannolis that are so decadent you won’t be able to stop at one!

I’ll definitely be back to try more of what Smashing Tomato Pizzeria has to offer! It’s without a doubt some of the best pizza in Lexington KY!

#7 MOD Pizza

The atmosphere at MOD Pizza was so inviting that I decided to stay from the time I walked in until the time I left. The staff was so friendly and helpful, they made me feel like part of the family.

Their menu is fantastic – it’s like a pizza paradise! They have all the classic pizzas, plus a bunch of unique options that you won’t find anywhere else. I tried the ‘GarlicPicante’, which was filled with delicious ingredients like garlic, red pepper flakes and mozzarella cheese – absolutely phenomenal!

They also have a variety of salads and sides, so if you’re not feeling a pizza you can still fill up on some good grub.

Overall, MOD Pizza has to be one of the best pizza places in Lexington KY. The prices were fair and their food was flavorful – what more could you want? Give it a try, you won’t regret it!

#8 Pies & Pints – Lexington, KY

The restaurant itself has a very casual atmosphere, with a relaxed and inviting setting. The pizza selection is great, ranging from traditional favorites like cheese and pepperoni to more creative and gourmet options. The dough is light, fluffy, and cooked to perfection each and every time.

One of the things I love most about Pies & Pints is their unique topping combinations that really bring out the flavor of the meal. The Butternut Squash Brie wild mushroom pizza was absolutely delicious – the combination of flavors was extraordinary!

Their pizzas also come in an array of sizes, making them perfect for sharing with family or friends. And if you’re looking to switch things up a bit, they offer some great salads too!

In my opinion, Pies & Pints offers the best pizza in Lexington KY – hands down! It’s definitely worth a visit when you’re in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 68 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Florence!

#9 Joe Bologna’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

When I walked into the restaurant, I was immediately hit with a pleasant aroma of delicious handcrafted pizza. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, perfect for a family outing or casual dinner with friends.

The menu had so many choices that it took me several minutes to decide what to get. In the end, I opted for one of their renowned specialty pies – the Grandma Bologna – which came topped with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, spinach, and garlic olive oil. It was nothing short of spectacular! Every bite burst with flavor and left me wanting more.

I’ve had pizza in New York City’s Little Italy and Naples’ finest trattorias, but none of them quite compared to Joe Bologna’s. This place is truly one in a million and I can confidently say that they make the best pizza in Lexington KY!

#10 MOD Pizza

I’m no stranger to pizza, and I can tell you that MOD Pizza is on the top of my list when it comes to delicious pies. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char. They have a variety of amazing toppings, all of which were fresh and flavorful. The combination of flavors was outstanding!

Moreover, the atmosphere at MOD Pizza was so inviting. My server was friendly and knowledgeable, providing helpful suggestions for creating the perfect pizza.

To top it all off, the price was very reasonable experience worth every penny. If you’re ever in town for some great pizza, don’t miss out on MOD Pizza. It may just be the best pizza in Lexington KY!

#11 Puccini’s Pizza Pasta-Chevy Chase Place

The crust is thin and perfectly cooked, never too greasy or burnt. The sauce has a complex flavor with a balance of sweet and savory notes. The toppings are fresh, flavorful and artfully crafted.

I love the variety of options this restaurant offers, from classic pepperoni to gourmet creations like the Sicilian-style pizza with fennel sausage, caramelized onions and goat cheese.

The ambiance at Puccini’s Pizza Pasta-Chevy Chase Place is cozy and inviting, perfect for a night out with friends or family. The staff is friendly and attentive, always eager to make sure everything is just right. They also have an excellent selection of Italian wines to pair with your meal.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Lexington KY, look no further than Puccini’s Pizza Pasta-Chevy Chase Place!

#12 Rise Up Pizza

The atmosphere is what really sets this place apart from the rest. As soon as you walk in, you’re greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that will have you wanting to stay for hours. The décor is modern and casual, so it’s perfect for any type of gathering.

Then there’s the pizza – oh the glorious pizza! The dough is made fresh each day and it comes out perfectly crispy yet still soft enough to give it a great flavor. Toppings are top notch – your classic pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms, etc., but also some more unique options like artichokes and sun-dried tomatoes. Everything comes together beautifully – they truly know how to make an amazing pizza!

To top things off (literally!), they offer a huge selection of craft beers to pair with your meal. From IPAs to stouts there is something for everyone’s taste buds!

So if you ever find yourself craving pizza in Lexington KY look no further than Rise Up Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Jet’s Pizza

Walking into Jet’s, I was immediately hit with a wave of cheesy goodness that made my taste buds have a party. And boy, did they know how to throw a party! The deep dish pizza at Jet’s is so thick, you could use it as a flotation device in case of a pizza-related emergency. Trust me, I’ve tried it. Floating in a sea of marinara sauce has never been so delicious.

Now, let’s talk about the toppings. At Jet’s, they pile them on like it’s Black Friday and they’re giving away free iPads. I’m not kidding, there were so many toppings on my pizza that I had to use a GPS to find the cheese. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers – you name it, they’ve got it. I even saw a slice with pineapple on it. Now, I know that’s controversial, but hey, to each their own.

The crust is like a beautiful work of art. It’s so flaky and buttery that it practically melts in your mouth. I could tell that they put a lot of love and carbs into making it. It’s like they took a regular pizza crust, injected it with steroids, and it became a pizza bodybuilder. I half expected it to flex its cheesy muscles.

So, if you’re in Lexington ky and you’re in the mood for some serious pizza pleasure, head on over to Jet’s. They’ve got the best deep dish pizza in town, and your taste buds will thank you. Trust me, I’m a professional pizza taster – and my palate doesn’t lie.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

From the moment I walked through the door, the intoxicating smell of freshly baked dough hit me like a cheesy locomotive. As a connoisseur of pizza, I knew this was going to be an experience to remember.

As I sat at my table, I couldn’t help but admire the hustle and bustle of the open kitchen. The chefs were tossing dough in the air like pizza gods, their hands a blur of flour and artistry. I was mesmerized, like a moth to a flame, or a college student to a 2 am slice.

The menu was a symphony of pizza perfection. I ordered a classic Margherita, because let’s be honest, it’s like the little black dress of pizza. When the pie arrived at my table, I was struck by its simplicity. The thin, crispy crust bubbled and browned to perfection, the tomato sauce delicately applied with the precision of a painter, and the mozzarella cheese draped over the top like a gooey, melty duvet.

As I took my first bite, I was immediately transported to pizza nirvana. The flavors danced across my taste buds like a lively Italian tango. The crust was so thin and crispy, it could have been mistaken for a potato chip. The sauce was tangy and robust, and the cheese…oh, the cheese! It was like a happy little pill of dairy delight.

In conclusion, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is a must-visit if you find yourself in Lexington, KY. Their thin crust pizza is a work of edible art that will have you singing praise like a pizza-loving choir. Trust me, I’ve been around the world and back, but this is definitely the best thin crust pizza in Lexington!