Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Lima OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Lima OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

508 Views

I’ll be brutally honest – some of the places were terrible. But, after scouring the city and trying a dozen places, I’m confident that I’ve pinpointed the very best pizza in Lima OH.

My review will encompass all types of pizza – from wood-fired ovens to deep dish and everything in between.

This won’t be your average food review as I put a humorous spin on my findings. After all, what’s life without a bit of humor? So grab a slice (or twelve) and join me as I explore the best pizza in Lima OH!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 TJ’S Pizza

I mean, it’s a no-brainer when you walk in the door and see their mouth-watering toppings bar. From classic pepperoni to veggie supreme, TJ’S Pizza has anything your heart (and bellies) could desire!

The crust is perfection – golden brown and with just the right amount of crunch. And each bite practically melts in your mouth. As for the sauce? It’s tangy, rich and so flavorful.

Their staff is also incredibly friendly and attentive. Not to mention that the pizzas are cooked faster than I have ever seen anywhere else! Before I knew it, my fresh-from-the-oven pizza was in front of me!

Overall, TJ’S Pizza is a great spot for delicious pizza at an unbeatable price. If you’re ever in Lima OH, be sure to stop by this gem – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 33 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Findlay!

#2 Rapid Fired Pizza

I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the pizza here. The crust was cooked to perfection, giving just the right amount of crunch when bitten into. The toppings and cheese were freshly made, giving that great blend of flavor that only a true pizza connoisseur can appreciate.

The special touch at Rapid Fired Pizza is the speed in which they prepare the pizzas; they have it ready and out in no time! I’ve honestly never seen such an efficient team before.

The customer service here is outstanding, too. They make sure to greet you with a smile as soon as you walk in and make sure your every need is taken care of quickly.

Honestly, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Lima OH, look no further than Rapid Fired Pizza! It’s definitely worth a visit!

#3 Fat Jack’s Pizza

I recently visited Fat Jack’s and had an amazing experience. The atmosphere was really nice and cozy, perfect for a family dinner or a night out with friends. It even has beer and hard liquor, so there is something for everyone!

The pizza itself was also top-notch! I had the pepperoni and mushroom combo, which was incredibly flavorful. And for those of you with kids, Fat Jack’s also has a great kid’s menu. They can pick their favorite toppings and have some fun making the perfect slice of pizza!

Besides excellent pizza, Fat Jack’s also serves up desserts like tiramisu and cannolis that are both delicious and great values. And if you’re looking to have some fun while you eat dinner, they have TVs around the restaurant so you can watch sports while you dine. It really adds to the atmosphere.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery services; however, given how good the pizza is, it’s well worth going in person to get it! Overall, I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great pizza in Lima OH; it truly is the best in town.

#4 Donatos Pizza

On my first visit, I immediately noticed how fresh their ingredients were. The crust was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. They also had an impressive selection of toppings to choose from. And when it came time to decide which topping combination I wanted, the friendly staff gave me excellent advice.

In terms of taste, Donatos Pizza blew me away! Every bite loaded with flavor, yet no single topping overpowered another. Plus, they offer gluten-free options for those who need it.

Finally, if you are anything like me and appreciate great service with your pizza meal, then Donatos should be at the top of your list! The staff was incredibly helpful and friendly throughout my entire visit.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Lima OH, then look no further than Donatos Pizza!

#5 Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

When I walked in, it was like stepping into a classic Italian pizza joint. The smell of melting cheese and baking dough filled the air and I knew immediately that I’d found something special.

The menu features all kinds of pizza classics, from pepperoni to vegan-friendly creations. Plus, there are over 20 different topping combinations to choose from. I decided to stick with the classics and ordered a large pepperoni pizza.

To my delight, the pizza had an incredibly thin yet chewy crust with just the right amount of charring around the edges. The balance between tangy tomato sauce and savory cheese had me wanting more! Add in generous portions of spicy pepperoni throughout and you’ve got yourself one delicious slice after another.

However, what sets Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill apart is not only its delectable pies but also its cozy atmosphere— perfect for gathering with friends or enjoying a quiet dinner for two. With its rustic decor and mellow music playing in the background, this restaurant has become a regular spot for me when visiting Lima OH!

If you’re looking for some serious comfort food at great prices, then look no further than Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill. For me, it easily wins the title of best pizza in Lima OH!

#6 Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill

I’ve never tasted anything like it before – the crust was light and crispy on the outside, with a fluffy and sweet center. The toppings were generous and varied, from savory to spicy, and all so fresh that I’m sure they must do a daily delivery for their ingredients!

I can highly recommend the Greek pizza – it packs a lot of flavor with plenty of feta cheese and black olives to give each bite some extra richness. Plus, the signature beer barrel sauce added just enough kick to make my taste buds dance.

The atmosphere at Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill is also amazing! With checkered table cloths, bright lighting, cozy booths, and amazing artwork adorning the walls, I felt like I had stepped into an Italian tavern in Naples! And the staff could not have been more attentive or friendly – they made sure my experience was top-notch.

All in all, Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill has earned my stamp of approval as having some of the best pizza in Lima OH. If you haven’t been yet, do yourself a favor and go try it for yourself! You won’t be disappointed.

#7 Fat Jack’s Pizza Spencerville Rd

When I arrived at Fat Jack’s, I immediately felt welcomed. The ambiance was perfect for a night out with friends or family. The restaurant has plenty of seating, TVs to watch the big game, and they even serve alcohol and hard liquor—what more could you want?

The food at Fat Jack’s is simply outstanding. The pizza was delicious, with the perfect combination of sweet and savory flavors. They also had a great selection of sides such as garlic knots and wings. And since they have a kid’s menu, your little ones won’t be left out of the fun!

My experience at Fat Jack’s wouldn’t have been complete without dessert. Not only did they have some tasty desserts to choose from, but they also had milkshakes in flavors like vanilla and chocolate-chip cookie dough!

One downside I found was that Fat Jack’s doesn’t offer delivery. But if you don’t mind making the trip across town for some delicious pizza, it is definitely worth it!

All in all, I would highly recommend visiting Fat Jack’s Pizza Spencerville Rd for what can only be described as the best pizza in Lima OH!

If you’re willing to go an extra 50 miles, you can get to 13 more pizza places in Bowling Green!

#8 Westgate Entertainment Center

I’m not sure what their secret is, but the flavor and texture of the pizza here is unlike any other I’ve encountered. The crust has the perfect crunch, while still being light and fluffy. The sauce had a great tang, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

My favorite thing about Westgate Entertainment Center was how they make all of their pizzas to order, so you can really customize it according to your tastes. And they always use quality ingredients, so you know you’re getting something that’s truly delicious.

Plus, the atmosphere was great! It was lively without being too noisy, and the decor was just right—not too modern or hipster-y but still stylish enough for a night out with friends.

Overall, I’d highly recommend Westgate Entertainment Center for a great pizza experience in Lima OH. It’s definitely one of the best I’ve tasted!

#9 Rigali’s Pizza Village

From the moment I stepped in, I was impressed by the inviting atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious smell of baking pies. The menu is full of options that are sure to please everyone. Whether you’re a fan of the classic Margherita Pizza or something more adventurous like their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, you’ll be sure to find something that hits the spot!

The pizza itself is nothing short of amazing. The crust is perfectly crispy and just thick enough to hold up all the toppings inside. You can tell they use only fresh ingredients as everything from the sauce to the cheese has an incredible flavor. And don’t even get me started on their speciality pizzas! That Rainbow Pie made my taste buds explode with joy!

If you’re ever in Lima OH, Rigali’s Pizza Village should definitely be at the top of your list for great pizza. The food is top-notch, the atmosphere inviting and it’s not too hard on the wallet either – what more could you ask for?

#10 Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders

To start, the atmosphere was inviting and comfortable. The staff was super friendly and happy to answer any questions I had about their pizzas.

The menu at Bellacino’s is extensive, featuring all sorts of classic pizzas like pepperoni, Hawaiian, and veggie as well as creative specialty pizzas. But what really stood out to me weren’t the usual suspects—it were the grinders! I tried one of the classic Italian grinders and it was to die for! It was so flavorful with the perfect balance of seasonings that I couldn’t resist getting a second one right away.

The pizza itself was delicious too. The crust was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crunch, and the toppings tasted incredibly fresh. The cheese had a great flavor that made each bite so enjoyable. Overall, I have no complaints about my time at Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders—the food was outstanding!

I’d highly recommend Bellacino’s Pizza & Grinders if you’re looking for some truly exceptional pizza in Lima OH—it definitely won’t disappoint!

#11 Godfather’s Pizza

I arrived at the restaurant expecting great things from their pizza, and I was not disappointed. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew something special was in the air—the sights and smells were unlike anything I had ever experienced before. The restaurant itself is cozy and inviting, and the staff were friendly and attentive.

When my pizza arrived, it was absolute perfection. It was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crustiness on the outside, making it perfect for folding over in that classic Italian way. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful—I could taste every bit of tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni and sausage (my favorite!) on each delicious bite.

In short, Godfather’s Pizza is hands-down my pick for having some of the best pizza in Lima OH! I would definitely recommend this spot when friends ask me where they should go for a great pizza meal.

#12 Fat Jack’s Pizza Findlay Rd

The first thing I noticed when I visited the joint was the rustic brick oven. Now, I’m no engineer, but it looked like a quality piece of equipment and I knew something delicious was coming my way!

After ordering my meal, I eagerly watched as they laid down the various ingredients on my pizza and then popped it in that glorious oven! As the tantalizing smell filled the room, my taste buds were going wild.

When they finally pulled out my fresh-baked pizza, the flavors of every ingredient exploded on my tongue. The crust was crispy and fluffy, and the sauce had just the right amount of kick. But what really stole the show were those bright green basil leaves scattered across the top – truly something special!

This appetizing pizza was one for the books. Not only did Fat Jack’s Pizza Findlay Rd serve up some of the best pizza in Lima OH, but their hospitality made me feel right at home. If you’re ever looking for a slice (or two), don’t hesitate to check this place out. Bon appetit!