Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Macon GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Georgia

Best Pizza in Macon GA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

125 Views

Having experienced pizza around the world, I thought it would be a fun challenge to explore the pizza places in Macon. After eating twelve different pizzas, I found myself laughing out loud at some of the experiences while others were surprisingly delicious. But one place stood out as the very best for pizza in Macon GA. Join me on this journey of taste and discovery – you won’t regret it!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Georgia

#1 Hunt Brothers Pizza

Walking in I was immediately struck by the warm, inviting atmosphere. The staff are all so friendly and welcoming. They really make you feel at home!

I got the classic pepperoni and cheese pizza and it was truly amazing. The crust was cooked to perfection with a crispy yet fluffy texture. And the sauce! Oh my goodness, it had the perfect balance of spicy and sweet flavors while still being incredibly savory. The cheese was melty, gooey, and downright delicious. Not to mention all those glorious pepperonis scattered throughout adding a nice zestiness to every bite!

To top it off, I tried their new garlic parmesan wings which brought things to a whole new level of deliciousness! These wings were definitely some of the best I’ve ever tasted – juicy yet still nice and crunchy on the outside; full of flavor; and so satisfyingly garlicky! Yummmmmmm…

All-in-all, Hunt Brothers Pizza is one of my favorite pizza places that I’ve been lucky enough to come across during my travels. If you’re ever in Macon GA looking for some awesome pizza, look no further than Hunt Brothers – it’s truly an unmatched experience!

If you’re willing to go an extra 79 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Decatur!

#2 Ingleside Village Pizza

The pizza at Ingleside Village Pizza is made from fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. The crust is golden brown, the sauce is tangy, and the cheese is just the right amount of gooey. Plus, they have a wide variety of toppings so that you can create your own delicious masterpiece.

But what really sets Ingleside Village Pizza apart from other pizzerias in Macon GA is their customer service. Every time I’ve visited this restaurant, the staff has been exceptionally helpful and friendly. Whether I’m ordering in person or online, they always make sure I get exactly what I want.

I highly recommend Ingleside Village Pizza to anyone looking for delicious pizza in Macon GA – it truly is the best around!

#3 Your Pie Pizza

The atmosphere was relaxing and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a quick lunch. The ordering process was incredibly fast and efficient – no waiting in long lines here!

As for the pizza itself, it has the perfect balance of cheese, crust, and topping. The crust was chewy but not overly doughy, and it wasn’t too greasy or salty either. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the combination of flavors really came together to create something special.

I’m definitely making a point of coming back here when I’m passing through Macon again! This place truly has some of the best pizza around – if you’re ever in town make sure you check them out!

#4 Pig on a Pie

I was truly wowed by the quality of the pies here. The crust is to die for – it’s perfectly crispy and fluffy, without being too crunchy or chewy. Plus, the choice of toppings they offer is absolutely delicious. I opted for the “Garden Special,” which had a variety of fresh veggies on top and was out of this world!

The pizza at Pig on a Pie has such an incredible flavor. It’s definitely got a unique spin on traditional pizzas that I’ve tried before in other places. The sauce is a nice light tomato-based blend that pairs nicely with all the ingredients. And, their cheese mix is one of the best around – it adds an extra layer of flavor that really accents each bite you take.

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Macon GA, then Pig on a Pie should be your go-to spot! It’s got something to satisfy everyone’s taste buds while putting a smile on their face with every bite they take.

#5 Macon Pizza Company

When I arrived at Macon Pizza Company, I was impressed with their selection–everything from traditional classics like Cheese or Pepperoni to creative options like Pesto and Prosciutto. It’s clear that the team here knows how to make a great pizza. And when my order of Margherita with extra garlic arrived at the table, I was not disappointed!

The crust had the perfect crispiness and the combination of flavors in my toppings were amazing. The sauce was hearty, yet still light and flavorful. Plus, the extra garlic made me feel like I was eating a real Italian pizza–it saved me a flight to Italy during these uncertain times!

Overall, I can confidently say Macon Pizza Company has some of the best pizza in Macon GA. If you’re looking for an amazing slice that will take your taste buds on a trip around the world – this is definitely the place to go!

#6 Your Pie Pizza

When I walked in the door, I was immediately impressed by the atmosphere. The staff was super friendly, and the restaurant itself felt cozy and inviting.

The best part of all was the pizza! The dough was fluffy and light, with a perfect crunch on the outside. The toppings were fresh and flavorful – there’s no supermarket pepperoni here! Even better, I could customize my pizza exactly how I wanted it. They had sauces ranging from their signature red sauce to olive oil and garlic – plus lots of other great toppings!

My favorite thing about Your Pie Pizza is that they use an ancient brick oven for baking, which adds an incredible smoky flavor that can’t be found anywhere else. Plus, they offer beer and wine pairings with each pie – what more could you ask for?

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Macon GA (or anywhere else!), then look no further than Your Pie Pizza. Trust me: this place absolutely lives up to its reputation as one of the best pizzerias around!

#7 JAG’s Pizzeria and Pub

When I entered, I was welcomed by a friendly host and the warm aroma of pizza. The atmosphere was fun and inviting; there were a few TVs playing sports games and an arcade for kids.

The menu had plenty of options for everyone, from classic pizzas to gourmet creations. I decided to try their signature House Specialty – a delicious combination of all my favorite toppings – and it did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char! The cheese, veggies, meats, and sauce were all cooked to perfection.

And then there are the sides! JAG’s has some of the most creative side dishes I’ve ever encountered, like an Italian sausage calzone or an arugula pesto focaccia sandwich. Every item on the menu is bursting with flavor and worth trying at least once!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Macon GA , then look no further than JAG’s Pizzeria and Pub! With good food, great service, and a cozy atmosphere, this place will make your dining experience truly special.

#8 Fatty’s Pizza (Downtown)

What sets Fatty’s Pizza apart from the other pizza restaurants in Macon is their fresh ingredients. Every time I’ve been, they only serve the most delicious toppings and crusts. The smell of their ovens baking those heavenly pies just fills the room with anticipation!

Another thing that makes Fatty’s Pizza stand out is the atmosphere. The restaurant itself looks like a little oasis in the middle of downtown Macon with plenty of seating for all your friends and family. Plus, their friendly staff make you feel right at home as soon as you walk in – always eager to help you find whatever kind of pizza your heart desires.

Last but certainly not least, Fatty’s Pizza boasts some really amazing flavors! Whether it’s traditional pizzas like pepperoni or margherita, or something more special like a spinach artichoke pie or even an Italian sausage calzone – this place has something for everyone! The owners take great pride in their recipes – created by generations past – and it really shows with every slice.

Overall, I would highly recommend Fatty’s Pizza as one of the best places to find pizza in Macon GA! With its tasty ingredients, cozy atmosphere, and unique flavor combinations – this place has something special that you won’t want to miss out on!

If you’re willing to go an extra 80 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Lawrenceville!

#9 The Brick

When I arrived at the restaurant, I was greeted warmly and welcomed with open arms. My first impression was that this place is truly a one of a kind – the atmosphere is sophisticated yet relaxed, reminding me of some of my favorite pizza places in Rome.

I decided to indulge in one of their signature pizzas – the Big Brick Pizza. It certainly did not disappoint! The crust had a crunchy outer layer but was still light and airy inside. The cheese was made from only the freshest ingredients and melted perfectly in my mouth. But what really put it over the top for me were the tantalizing toppings – pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers and olives; each had just enough flavor to enhance the overall taste experience without overpowering each other or becoming lost in the mix.

In conclusion, The Brick serves up some of the best pizza in Macon GA – hands down! If you’re ever in town, don’t miss out on this incredible place!

#10 Romo’s Pizza

I’m never one to mince words, so I’ll be direct – the pizza at Romo’s is incredible! The crust is thin and flavorful, the cheese is perfectly melted, and the toppings are always fresh. It’s worth every penny spent.

The service here is also top-notch – friendly staff that really care about your experience. And did I mention the portions? They really go above and beyond to make sure you get enough pizza for your money.

Be warned, however – this place is popular and can get crowded on the weekends. But trust me; it’s worth waiting in line for a few minutes to have some of Romo’s fantastic pizza!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Macon GA, look no further than Romo’s Pizza – they know how to make an amazing pie!

#11 Johnny’s New York Style Pizza

The experience at Johnny’s felt like taking a bite out of the big apple and brought me right back to my childhood. The thin and crispy crust was flavorful and full of garlic, resulting in a delectable combination that could only be described as pure heaven.

My favorite part about this restaurant is the customer service. Everyone was so friendly and hospitable – they even remembered my name after I left (don’t worry, I used an alias). They made sure to fill up my glass of coke every time it got low, so I never had to ask for another one!

The selection at Johnny’s is unbeatable. They’ve got just about every kind of pizza imaginable, from spicy Italian sausage to four cheese. No matter what your craving is, you’ll find something delicious at Johnny’s.

I highly recommend Johnny’s New York Style Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Macon GA!

#12 Fatty’s Pizza (Tom Hill)

I’ve tasted a lot of pizza in my travels, and trust me when I say that the pies at Fatty’s are something special. From the perfectly cooked crust to the mouthwatering toppings, this restaurant knows how to deliver a great pizza experience.

The atmosphere of Fatty’s is also top-notch. The staff takes great care in making sure their customers have a pleasant dining experience, and they always serve their delicious food with a smile on their face. Plus, there’s always an interesting mix of people here – you never know what kind of conversation you might overhear!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Macon GA, look no further than Fatty’s Pizza (Tom Hill). For a truly exceptional pie that never fails to impress, this is definitely the place for you.