I’m no stranger to pizza, having scoured the world for delicious pies that satisfy my palate. From the frozen pizzas of Italy to the Greek-style creations in Athens, I’ve tasted it all in my search for greatness.
So it only made sense that I’d eventually come to Madison NJ, equipped with a plan to find out which local pizza joint is the undisputed champion of cheesy goodness. After tasting twelve different places, I’m here to report back with my findings and share my top pick for the best pizza in Madison NJ!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Rose City Madison Pizza
- No delivery
On my visit to this unique pizzeria, I was immediately struck by the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza coming from the kitchen. The folks at Rose City Madison Pizza take great pride in their craft and it shows in their mouth-watering pies.
The toppings on the pizza were super fresh and cooked to perfection, while the dough and sauce were cooked to a golden brown that created a perfect crunchy crust on the bottom. It was simply delightful.
In addition to the excellent pizza, they also offer a variety of salads and savory sides that were just as good. I tried the garlic knots which had just enough bite and flavor that enhanced each bite of pizza.
The only downside to this restaurant is there’s no delivery option – so you’ll have to physically go there for your order. But trust me, it’s worth it!
All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Madison NJ, look no further than Rose City Madison Pizza!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Morristown!
#2 Sal’s
The flavor is consistently top-notch. The dough and sauce are flavorful, and their toppings are generous and delicious.
They also make a mean calzone. My favorite is the Meat Lover’s Calzone with extra pepperoni and sausage – mmmmmm!
But that’s not all they offer! Sal’s has a great selection of subs, salads, wings, and even some unique dishes. From the Baked Ziti Supreme to Chicken Parmigiana, they have something for everyone.
The atmosphere is casual but clean and inviting. The staff is friendly, courteous, and always up for a laugh or two.
But at the end of the day it comes down to the pizza – Sal’s does it right! I’d highly recommend this restaurant as a destination for great pizza in Madison NJ.
#3 Madison Market
The aroma of the ingredients hits you as soon as you walk in the door. The interior is cozy and inviting with wooden tables and chairs surrounding a brick oven in the corner. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, offering suggestions on toppings that would enhance my experience even more.
I decided to go with a classic margherita pizza topped with fresh basil and freshly-grated mozzarella cheese. With my first bite, I knew I had made the right decision. The crust was light, crispy and cooked to perfection; the sauce had a great balance of sweetness and acidity; and the toppings were so fresh they tasted like they had just been picked out of someone’s garden!
Overall, Madison Market truly delivers an amazing pizza experience that will keep me coming back for more. If you haven’t enjoyed their best pizza yet, why not head over there now? Best pizza in Madison NJ is just around the corner!
#4 Rocco’s Pizzeria~Trattoria
- Offers dessert
I visited this delightful spot on a sunny day, and the smell of freshly made pizza was in the air. As I walked in, I was greeted by friendly staff who made me feel right at home. The interior is cozy—it feels more like a trattoria than a pizzeria, with warm colors and rustic decor.
The menu features all the classic Italian favorites, including delicious thin-crust Roman-style pizzas, calzones, paninis and delectable appetizers like focaccia bread with fresh ricotta cheese. I decided to try their signature dish—the Rocco’s Pizzeria~Trattoria Specialty Pizza. It had tomato sauce with flavorful chunks of mozzarella cheese and savory pepperoni slices topping it off; this pizza was truly something special!
The crust was perfectly crunchy on the outside, yet fluffy inside; it melted in my mouth! The flavor combination was balanced between savory and sweet and hit every note that goes into making an amazing pizza.
All in all, Rocco’s Pizzeria~Trattoria is definitely the place to go for some of the best pizza around, and I can’t wait to come back for more!
#5 Arminio’s Italian Corner
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The first time I visited this restaurant, I was amazed by how authentic the pizzas were. Everything from the dough to the ingredients were so fresh it felt like I had taken a trip to Italy!
The pizza flavors are out of this world too – with classic Italian favorites like pepperoni and Italian sausage as well as some unique combinations like pulled pork, pineapple and jalapeno, and even an olive-artichoke-feta combination that is so good it should be illegal!
The toppings are plentiful and tasty, while the crust is perfectly thin and crispy. There’s also a great selection of salads, appetizers and desserts that make it easy to round out your meal.
Finally, Arminio’s Italian Corner has a great atmosphere. The décor is traditional Italian – with murals on the walls depicting scenes from the old country, the music playing in the background creating a cozy atmosphere. Plus, their friendly staff always makes sure you feel welcome and appreciated.
Overall I’m convinced that Arminio’s Italian Corner is THE place for amazing pizza in Madison NJ! Whether you’re just stopping by for a slice or planning a special evening out with family or friends, you won’t be disappointed. Highly recommended!
#6 Puleo’s Brick Oven
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has insanely good dessert
My first experience at Puleo’s was nothing short of amazing. From the moment we walked in, I could tell that the atmosphere was different than any other pizza place I’ve been too. The bright colors and cheery staff immediately put me in a great mood!
The pizza itself was delicious. The thin, crunchy crust paired perfectly with the melty cheese and flavorful toppings. It was definitely among some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten!
But what really sets Puleo’s apart from the competition is their unique selection of gourmet pizzas. Not only do they have classic pizzas such as pepperoni and supreme, but they also offer interesting combinations like Funghi and Prosciutto or even Olive Delight. It’s obvious that they take pride in their craftsmanship, which makes eating there an absolute pleasure.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Madison NJ, look no further than Puleo’s Brick Oven!
If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Elizabeth!
#7 Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co.
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
From the moment I stepped through the door at Tino’s, I knew this pizza joint was different. From the rustic interior and framed photos of Italian scenes to the wrought-iron chandeliers, it had a classic Italian charm. The wait staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, making it easy for me to quickly order my favorite pies.
After biting into my first slice of Margherita pizza, I knew why Tino’s is renowned as having some of the best pizza in Madison NJ. The sauce was perfectly seasoned and the dough was light yet with a chewy texture that made each bite deliciously satisfying. The bubbly mozzarella cheese gave every bite an extra cheesy kick and all of it came together in a harmony of distinct flavors.
If you’re ever looking for some delicious and freshly made artisan pizzas, then head on over to Tino’s Artisan Pizza Co! I guarantee you won’t be disappointed by their downright scrumptious pizzas.
#8 Italian Village Pizza
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I recently stopped in for a slice of their flagship Margherita Pie and it was spectacular. The crust was light and airy, with a delicate yet satisfying crunch that made every bite enjoyable. The sauce was flavorful and perfectly balanced with just the right amount of acidity, while the fresh mozzarella cheese added a great textural component to the pizza.
The experience was made even better when I tried one of their unique pies like the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza or their Spinach Artichoke Pie. I highly recommend these unorthodox but delicious pizzas from Italian Village Pizza!
When it comes to this type of food, nothing can beat Italian Village Pizza. There’s no doubt that this is the best pizza in Madison NJ. If you’re ever looking for delicious pie, this is definitely the place to be!
#9 Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
When I first entered the restaurant, I felt like I had been transported from modern day New Jersey to a traditional Italian pizzeria. From the music playing in the background to the smell of homemade sauce, it was a great atmosphere.
The menu featured an array of specialty pizzas that were sure to please any pizza connoisseur. The selection of toppings was also impressive – you could customize your pizza with some interesting combinations.
I decided on the Firehouse Special – a combination of roasted garlic, pepperoni and red onion with an amazing crust that was cooked to perfection. It was hands-down the best pizza I’ve ever had! The flavors just melted in my mouth and I couldn’t help but savor every bite.
The service was also outstanding – the staff was friendly, attentive and made me feel welcome from start to finish.
Overall, Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is definitely one of the most memorable places for great pizza in Madison NJ!
#10 Zio Gino Pizza & Grill
- Offers dessert
The restaurant has a welcoming, authentic Italian atmosphere and the staff are incredibly warm and friendly, so even if you’re not in the mood for pizza you’ll still have a great time.
The pizza itself is definitely worth writing home about! The crust is light and crispy, the sauce is flavorful and not too sweet, and the cheese melts perfectly into every bite. Their selection of toppings also makes this place stand out – you can get traditional toppings like pepperoni or sausage, but you can also try other more creative topping combinations. I’m a fan of their Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza, which features fresh arugula leaves on top of the melted cheese and salty prosciutto.
The bottom-line: Zio Gino’s Pizza & Grill is hands down the best pizza in Madison NJ! Whether you choose a classic combination or something unexpected, you’re sure to be satisfied with your meal.
#11 Florham Park Pizza
- Offers dessert
The crust was cooked to perfection, with a golden brown top and a slightly crunchy bottom. The toppings were plentiful and flavorful, not overwhelming the natural taste of the pizza. I also enjoyed the subtle hint of herbs in the sauce that added a unique flavor to this classic favorite dish.
The service at Florham Park Pizza was friendly and helpful, which is always an added bonus when it comes to getting quality food. The prices were very reasonable for the quality of food, making it an ideal spot for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends.
If you’re looking for good pizza in Madison NJ, look no further than Florham Park Pizza – hands down one of the best pizzas around!
If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Elizabeth!
#12 Nonna’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Has a kid’s menu
- Offers dessert
The menu is full of delicious options, including my favorite: the ‘Nonna Special’. It’s a one-of-a-kind combination of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers. Not only was it full of flavor but the crust was perfect – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside.
And if that wasn’t enough to get me hooked, they have an amazing selection of traditional Italian dishes as well! From lasagna to eggplant parmesan, each dish has its own unique flavor and texture that make them stand out from the rest.
The atmosphere at Nonna’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is warm and inviting. It’s like being transported back to Italy without having to leave your home. And since there are TVs throughout the restaurant, you can watch sports while enjoying a great meal.
Overall, I highly recommend Nonna’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant as the best pizza in Madison NJ. The food is authentic and delicious and the atmosphere is unbeatable.
