Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Marco Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Marco Island (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

244 Views

Throughout my travels, I’ve sampled pizza from just about every corner of the globe. From Chicago deep dish to Neapolitan, I’m always on the lookout for new and interesting pizzas!

So recently, I took a trip to Marco Island with one mission in mind—to find the best pizza they have to offer. I tasted 12 different kinds of pizza from restaurants all over the island and now I’m ready to reveal which one is the very best.

I can guarantee this is going to be an entertaining and lighthearted journey as we search for the best pizza in Marco Island!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Davide Italian Cafe

The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place to grab some pizza with friends. But let’s get right to the food. The pizzas were cooked to perfection, with a nice crisp on the outside and a fluffy interior. The sauce was amazing; rich and flavorful yet not overpowering. To top it off, the toppings were fresh and delicious!

What really blew me away about Davide Italian Cafe was the variety of pizzas available. From classic Margherita to creative specialty pies like their wood-fired Gorgonzola and pear pizza, you can find something to satisfy everyone’s cravings here. And don’t even get me started on their Italian-style thin-crust pizzas — out of this world!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Marco Island, Davide Italian Cafe is your place! I highly recommend giving them a try!

If you’re willing to go an extra 20 miles, you can get to 53 more pizza places in Naples!

#2 STONEWALLS

I’ve sampled pizza in some of the best restaurants across the globe, but STONEWALLS has made a huge impression on me. From their delicious thin-crust pizzas to their massive selection of toppings, this place really knows how to make a great pizza!

The atmosphere at STONEWALLS is also amazing. The restaurant itself is quite cozy, and they’ve done an excellent job of creating a space that feels both inviting and comfortable. And the staff are friendly and attentive, which just adds to the experience.

Another thing I love about STONEWALLS is that their prices are incredibly reasonable considering the quality of the food. Whether you’re looking for an affordable quick slice or an entire pie for dinner, you can’t go wrong here.

In conclusion, if you’re ever in Marco Island and craving some really good pizza, be sure to check out STONEWALLS! With its delicious food, great atmosphere and reasonable prices, it’s no wonder why this place has become one of my favorite spots in town!

#3 Sami’s

If you’re looking for a delicious pizza experience, then Sami’s is the place to go. The staff were friendly and accommodating, and I was served my piping hot meal in no time.

The crust was perfectly crunchy and not too thick, giving way to a generous helping of their signature tomato sauce. The cheese was soft and melted just the right amount, not to mention the toppings that gave the pie an incredible flavor! From pepperoni to mushroom and olives, this pizza had something for everyone’s palette.

The restaurant itself has a comfortable atmosphere, perfect for kicking back and enjoying a slice. Even the price point was affordable. All in all, it’s easy to see why Sami’s pizza is considered some of the best in Marco Island!

#4 Italian Deli and Market

My experience here wasn’t anything like I’d expected. The pizza was cooked to perfection, with an amazing crunchy crust and the perfect balance of sauces and toppings. It was so good that I ordered a second one!

The atmosphere at Italian Deli and Market is fantastic. The staff were very friendly and helpful, and they even recommended some of their best pizzas for me to try. The interior decor was tasteful and inviting, creating an overall pleasing dining experience.

I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for an unforgettable pizza experience in Marco Island. For my money, it’s the best pizza you’ll find in town!

#5 Sand Bar 🏖

The atmosphere here is great. It’s a nice tourist spot and it even serves your favorite hard liquors! Plus, they have lots of big screens so you can catch any sporting event that’s on.

But don’t plan on getting a delivery from Sand Bar 🏖 — they don’t offer that service. You’ll have to make the short trip to the restaurant if you’re looking for pizza perfection!

That said, making the trip is still definitely worth it. The pizza at this place is amazing and you won’t be disappointed with the wide selection. And if it gets a little too loud — or you want to get away from all the sports fans — take advantage of their outdoor seating as well!

I’m declaring Sand Bar 🏖 as my favorite pizza joint in Marco Island for sure! Give ’em a try and see why I’ve given them such high praise.

If you’re willing to go an extra 28 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Bonita Springs!

#6 Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House

As soon as I walked in, the mouth-watering aroma of freshly made pizza was overwhelming! The decorations were also quaint and inviting, with a nice atmosphere that felt like home.

The menu is extensive and offers a variety of different topping styles to choose from, including your usual classics like pepperoni and mushrooms. However, if you’re feeling adventurous there are more unique options like pineapple and kale. No matter what kind of toppings you prefer, Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House has something for everyone!

The taste was incredible! The thin crust was crispy but not too crunchy, and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. The cheese was perfectly melted and the toppings were cooked to perfection. In my opinion, Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House makes some of the best pizzas on Marco Island without a doubt!

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience with high quality ingredients at a reasonable price – look no further than Joey’s Pizza & Pasta House! It’s definitely one of my favorite places in Marco Island for sure!

#7 Pizza Cucina

Sure, they don’t offer delivery — but that just means you have to get up and go there yourself. The ambiance of the restaurant is great for tourists too; you won’t regret making the trip.

The pizza itself is top notch. Every bite has amazing flavor that can’t be replicated anywhere else. I’ve tried pizzas from all around the globe, and theirs are among my favorites. Plus, after you’re done with your meal, they even offer dessert! Can’t get much better than that.

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Marco Island, Pizza Cucina is definitely worth a try — it’s an experience like no other!

#8 Joey D’s Marco Island

I was immediately impressed by the variety of pizza options available on the menu. From classic pizzas to vegan and gluten free options, there’s something here for everyone. As a food critic, I appreciated the attention to detail that went into each pizza – from freshly made dough to unique toppings.

When it came to the quality of the pizza, I was blown away! Every bite was a burst of flavor and the crust had an amazing crunch. I especially enjoyed my favorite pizza – a classic pepperoni with extra cheese. The balance between all of the flavors was perfect!

The atmosphere at Joey D’s is inviting, which made it easy to enjoy my meal. It wasn’t too loud or crowded and they even have outdoor seating if you want to get some fresh air. The service was top-notch as well – attentive without being overbearing.

Overall, Joey D’s Marco Island is one of the best places for pizza in Marco Island! All aspects of their food and service make this place worthy of high praise!

#9 Tony’s N.Y. Pizza

The atmosphere at Tony’s is classic Italian, complete with red and white checkered tablecloths and Italian music playing in the background. It made me feel like I was sitting in a pizza joint in Southern Italy!

As for the pizza itself, it really is the best I’ve had in Marco Island. The crust is golden, flaky and crunchy, while the top is loaded with mozzarella cheese that oozes out when you take a bite. The tomato sauce has just the right amount of tangy flavor that pairs perfectly with its toppings.

I tried their “special” pizza – pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms – which was even better than I’d expected. The flavorful yet light toppings complemented the tasty crust extremely well.

Another highlight would have to be their speedy service – my pizza was ready in no time so I didn’t have to wait long before chowing down on this delicious treat!

All in all, if you’re craving some good ol’ N.Y.-style pizza then you should definitely pay Tony’s N.Y Pizza a visit – you won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 39 miles, you can get to 19 more pizza places in Fort Myers Beach!

#10 Little Caesars Pizza

I recently visited the restaurant and was delighted by the amazing ambiance. The colorful décor and bright atmosphere put me in the perfect mood for some delicious pizza! The staff were super friendly, which made the experience even better.

When it came to the pizzas themselves, I was blown away. First of all, they’re huge! I swear they take up half your plate! And every bite was heavenly – full of flavour and perfectly cooked. It wasn’t too greasy or oily either; they really nailed it with this one.

To top it off, their prices are incredibly affordable, so you can get a lot of food without breaking your bank account. All in all, Little Caesars Pizza is definitely a top contender when it comes to finding the best pizza in Marco Island!

#11 Marco Island Brewery

The environment is great for tourists or locals, and the beer selection is sure to please everyone. You can even get hard liquor if you want to kick things up a notch. Plus, I understand it’s a popular spot to watch sports!

On top of that, their pizza is phenomenal. The crust is thin and crispy, but with just enough substance; the cheese is perfectly melted and flavorful; and the toppings are fresh and unique without being too over-the-top. It’s honestly some of the best pizza I’ve had since my travels around the world!

The only downside I’ve found here is that they don’t offer delivery options. But let’s be honest – do you really want your awesome Marco Island Brewery pizza to sit in a box while it’s being driven across town? Nope, me neither!

If you’re in Marco Island and looking for some delicious pizza with a good atmosphere (plus some great drinks!), then look no further than Marco Island Brewery. In my opinion, their pizza deserves top honors among all the best pizzas in Marco Island!

#12 Zaza Mexican Restaurant

The atmosphere is great – with wicker furniture, music playing from the kitchen and lots of bright colors, it’s a fun place to be. The service is top-notch and the staff are friendly and helpful. I especially liked how the waiters kept checking in to make sure everything was satisfactory.

But onto the main event – the pizza. It was delicious! The crust was thin, yet crispy and just right for holding all the yummy toppings. The sauce was tasty with just the right blend of spices. Plus they have an impressive array of toppings to choose from; I went with jalapeños, cilantro, pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms.

I can say without hesitation that Zaza Mexican Restaurant has some of the best pizza in Marco Island! If you’re ever in town I highly recommend stopping by for a slice or two – you won’t regret it!