Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Miami Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Florida

Best Pizza in Miami Beach (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

71 Views

I bring with me a wealth of pizza-tasting experience from my travels around the world, and I’m excited to share what I’ve found on this corner of South Beach. After some sampling, I have a list of the 12 best pizzas that Miami Beach has to offer.

So buckle up your taste buds and join me on an epic pizza adventure as we discover the creamiest cheese, most aromatic herbs, and tastiest toppings around! Which places are worth your dough? Let’s find out together.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Florida

#1 Pummarola Miami Beach “Pizza Napoletana”

On my visit to Pummarola, I was welcomed by a friendly staff and a bright, inviting atmosphere. The pizza was freshly made in the wood-fired oven, giving it that perfect smoky flavor. Each bite was perfectly tender with a chewy crust, thanks to the use of traditional Italian recipes.

The menu has something for everyone; some of the favorites on my list were the classic Margherita and the creative Quattro Formaggi. The Quattro Formaggi contains four different types of cheese with a hint of truffle oil – heavenly!

I also had their signature Pummarola salad which was light and zingy. It featured fresh greens, tomatoes, roasted peppers and olives served with an olive oil dressing – delicious!

To top off my meal, I had their homemade Tiramisu which was creamy and delightful. I couldn’t have asked for better service from start to finish!

Overall, Pummarolos’ authentic Napoletana pizza is simply the best in Miami Beach. If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience or just want to treat yourself to some amazing Italian food then this is definitely worth checking out!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Miami!

#2 Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza

The moment I stepped in the door, I knew I was in for something special. The atmosphere was cozy but modern and the restaurant staff were friendly and welcoming. But it was the pizza that stole my heart.

The crust is a perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, the toppings are fresh and flavorful, and the sauce is an absolute delight! Whether you get your pie with everything or just a few toppings, it’s sure to be one of the best pizzas you’ve ever tasted.

I can honestly say Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza produces some of the best pizza in Miami Beach. If you’re looking for delicious pies, this place should definitely be at the top of your list!

#3 Editor Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant was just perfect. The walls were decorated with giant pictures of the city, giving it a fun and upbeat vibe. The servers were courteous, friendly and informative – they definitely made me feel right at home!

The menu offered plenty of choices for both vegans and carnivores alike, so there really was something for everyone. I opted for the ‘Editor’s Choice’ pizza, which boasted a delicious combination of ricotta cheese, artichoke hearts, olives and zesty spices. It was truly divine!

But the main attraction at Editor Pizza is hands-down their signature thin-crust pizzas. They use fresh ingredients from local suppliers to craft some of the tastiest pizza pies in all of Miami Beach! The delicate yet crunchy crust provides an excellent texture contrast to their flavorful tomato sauce and cheesy topping. They also offer gluten free options for those with dietary restrictions.

All in all, Editor Pizza is simply one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever experienced! Whether you’re looking for a quick slice or planning a family gathering, this is definitely the place to go for amazing pizza in Miami Beach!

#4 Blozzom Pizza Moderna Romana

From the moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was in awe. Every aspect of Blozzom Pizza was crafted with care—from its modern yet rustic decor to its warm and inviting atmosphere.

The menu had a wide variety of pizza options, so it took me a while to decide which one I wanted. Ultimately, I decided to try their signature dish: The Blozzom Moderna Romana. It did not disappoint! The thin crust was cooked perfectly and tasted like a delectable mix of herbs, spices, and cheese. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, adding the perfect texture and taste to make this pizza an incredible culinary experience.

The pizza wasn’t the only thing that made this experience amazing; the service was top-notch! All of the employees were friendly and helpful, willing to answer any questions we had about ingredients or other menu items.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Miami Beach (or anywhere for that matter), look no further than Blozzom Pizza Moderna Romana!

#5 Evio’s Pizza & Grill South Beach

The first stop on my pizza pilgrimage was Evio’s, and boy am I glad that it was! The atmosphere at this restaurant is like none other. The walls are covered with pictures of famous Italian movies and the staff is so friendly and welcoming. Plus, they even have a stage where they showcase live music every night – what more could you ask for?

As for the pizza itself, I have to say that it was spectacular. From their signature ‘Deliziosa’ pizza to the ‘Mangia Mangia’, I have never tasted such deliciousness before! Even their classic cheese pizzas are as authentic as can be. Each one has perfectly melted cheese and perfectly crisp crust that just makes me want to keep eating.

Overall, Evio’s Pizza & Grill South Beach really stands out from the rest when it comes to pizza in Miami Beach. From its inviting atmosphere to its mouthwatering pizzas, this restaurant should definitely be added to your list of places to try out when visiting Miami Beach!

#6 Blocks Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is comfortable yet fun. I can see why it has become so popular. The staff was friendly and helpful throughout my visit.

Their pizza selection is excellent, but their signature “Miami Beach” pie was unbelievable! It had a thin, buttery crust with fresh mozzarella and roasted tomatoes on top — simply delicious! They have other unique pizzas, like the “Garden Pizza” with zucchini ribbons and pesto sauce, that were incredibly flavorful as well.

I also tried some of their classic sides like garlic breadsticks and spinach artichoke dip — both were rich in flavor and really melted in your mouth. And for dessert, I went for the Nutella calzone — oh my goodness! The warm gooey Nutella filling was heavenly- I couldn’t get enough.

Overall, Blocks Pizza serves up some of the best pizza in Miami Beach. They have something to satisfy everyone’s tastes — from classic pies to specialty creations — all made with the freshest ingredients around. So if you’re ever looking for an amazing pizza experience, then head over to Blocks Pizza!

#7 Harry’s Pizzeria Miami Beach

On my recent trip there, I was blown away. The atmosphere was lively and the pizza makers behind the counter were like a well oiled machine. From the scorching heat of their ovens to the fresh ingredients they were using, it was clear this place takes their pizza seriously.

My first impression of the food was phenomenal! The crust had a perfect crunch to it while still being light and fluffy at the same time. The sauce had a wonderful depth of flavor with hints of garlic and herbs that really made it pop. As for the cheese, you could definitely taste its quality-rich, creamy and delicious!

The toppings were also excellent- sparse enough to not overpower the flavor of the other components but generous enough so that you could actually taste each one. All in all, I have no doubt in my mind Harry’s Pizzeria Miami Beach deserves its mantle as some of the best pizza in Miami Beach!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Miami!

#8 Pizzette Miami

The restaurant is small and unassuming, but the pizza is anything but. The crust has just the right amount of crunch and chewiness, and the combination of sauces and toppings are truly unique. I tried the OG Margherita Pie first – it was amazing! The cheese was wonderfully melty, the sauce tangy, and the toppings were perfectly balanced.

I also tried their Signature Pizza that had bacon, feta cheese, truffle oil and arugula. It was delectable! The combination of ingredients worked together to create a truly unique flavor experience that I won’t soon forget.

The staff at Pizzette Miami are friendly and attentive as well. They definitely know their stuff when it comes to pizza-making! They’ll even let you in on a few secrets if you ask nicely.

Overall, Pizzette Miami is a great spot for not only some of the best pizza in Miami Beach, but for a great overall dining experience as well. I highly recommend this place if you’re visiting Miami Beach or just looking for a delicious slice of pizza!

#9 Piola

I was delighted to find a wide selection of pizza to choose from. From their Napoli styles to the Fiorentina, they had something for everyone. I chose the Pizza Veronese with tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and ham. The pizza was cooked perfectly with a slightly crispy crust, the right amount of cheese and an abundance of flavorful toppings.

The atmosphere at Piola is great too! It has a relaxed vibe with colorful decorations and candles that made me feel like I was dining in Italy. The staff were friendly and helpful as well.

I’m also happy to report that the prices are very affordable. You get great food at a fair price here which is always appreciated!

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Miami Beach, I highly recommend trying Piola!

#10 Pizza Rustica South Beach

The crust was the perfect combination of crispy and chewy. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the cheese was wonderfully melty. All in all, it was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had.

The toppings were also amazing! From roasted bell peppers to artichokes, they had a great selection that suited every pizza lover’s needs.

I’m not much of a wine drinker, but I tried their house red and it paired perfectly with my pizza. It wasn’t overwhelming or too sweet – just perfect!

Lastly, the staff were friendly and helpful – just like any good pizza joint should be. They even went so far as to recommend another flavor for me to try next time I visit!

All in all, Pizza Rustica South Beach is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for the best pizza in Miami Beach.

#11 Fratelli La Bufala – Miami Beach

On my first visit to this restaurant, I was immediately blown away by the decor. It almost made me feel like I was in Italy! The service was great too, as they were incredibly friendly and welcoming.

The pizza was a revelation. It had the perfect crust – neither too thick nor too thin. Topped with a plentiful selection of fresh and flavorful toppings, it’s no surprise that Fratelli La Bufala has gained such a loyal following of pizza-lovers in Miami Beach.

At Fratelli La Bufala – Miami Beach, you can really tell that their passion for serving up great pizza is surpassed only by their attention to detail in delivering an unbelievable dining experience! From the quaint atmosphere to the outstanding food, every aspect of this outstanding restaurant is top-notch. Without a doubt, Fratelli La Bufala – Miami Beach serves some of the best pizza in Miami Beach!

#12 Spris Artisan Pizza

The moment you step into the restaurant you can immediately tell that it’s a special place. The decor is modern and inviting, with a strong focus on showcasing their delicious pizzas. The staff was friendly and welcoming, which I felt added to the whole experience.

When it came time to order my food, I couldn’t make up my mind! Everything sounded amazing, so I had to go with one of the specials they recommended – the Prosciutto di Parma. Wow! Was it incredible! Fresh mozzarella cheese, prosciutto di Parma, roasted Roma tomatoes and a drizzle of truffle oil were perfectly combined on a crispy thin crust that simply melted in my mouth.

The true test for any pizzeria is the quality of their crust and Spris Artisan Pizza passes with flying colors. Plus, every pizza is made with only fresh ingredients that are sourced from local farmers markets. Needless to say, this helps bring out the best flavors in all their dishes.

If you’re ever in Miami Beach looking for some great-tasting pizza then look no further than Spris Artisan Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Pizza Rustica South Beach

Now, let’s talk about the benefits. Firstly, the fact that Pizza Rustica serves alcohol deserves a round of applause. Who doesn’t love an ice-cold beer with their cheesy pizza goodness? Plus, they offer some vegetarian options, so you can bring your herbivore buddies along without any worries. And did I mention they have dessert? Because nothing brings me more joy than ending a pizza feast with a sweet treat.

Speaking of joy, Pizza Rustica South Beach is also a nice tourist spot. You can people-watch and pretend you’re in an Italian piazza while chomping down on your heavenly thin crust creation. It truly adds a touch of class to your pizza-eating experience. You might even catch me there, penning my next food critique!

Now, let’s address the downside – they don’t accept reservations. So, if you’re a control freak like me who loves to plan every second of their life, leave your spreadsheet at home. Just take the leap of faith and trust that you’ll find a table. It might be a little chaotic, but hey, sometimes the best things in life are unexpected, just like stumbling upon the best thin crust pizza in South Beach!

In conclusion, Pizza Rustica South Beach is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Their thin crust will make your taste buds do a happy dance while the lively atmosphere and adult beverages will make your night unforgettable. So, grab your friends, keep your cool, and let the cheesy adventure begin!