I’ve tried pizzas all over the world, from New York City to Naples, Italy. When I heard about Middleton WI’s fantastic pizza scene, I had to check it out for myself. After crisscrossing the town and trying 12 different pizza places, I can confidently say that Middleton is a great place for a pizza-loving foodie like me!
With tongue firmly in cheek (and stomachs full of cheesy deliciousness) my team and I set out to find the best pizza in Middleton WI. Keep reading to find out who we thought was the top dog when it came to Pizza in this charming little city!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin
#1 Novanta
- Has insanely good dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
The staff at Novanta are incredibly friendly and welcoming, and their enthusiasm for creating great-tasting pizza is contagious. It’s nice to see people take such pride in what they do. The atmosphere at Novanta is laid back and relaxed; it’s the perfect spot to hang out with friends or family.
The menu at Novanta is the perfect mix of classic and creative. They offer a plethora of traditional pizzas, as well as some creative takes on classic recipes. I was particularly impressed with their “Reindeer Pie”, which features reindeer sausage and red onions – definitely something I haven’t seen before! Every single pizza I’ve tried has been cooked perfectly – crispy on the outside, and doughy on the inside – just how pizza should be.
I highly recommend Novanta if you’re looking for the best pizza in Middleton WI! It’s an experience you won’t forget.
If you’re willing to go an extra 38 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Janesville!
#2 Villa Dolce
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol (and hard liquor!)
- Has insanely good dessert
- Nice tourist spot
The first time I stepped foot inside the restaurant, I was almost overwhelmed by the aromas of freshly cooked pizza. It was like a mouth-watering dream come true. The place had a great atmosphere and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable.
I decided to order their signature pizza, the Villa Dolce Special – a delicious combination of sautéed onions, bell peppers, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. The flavors melded together perfectly and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted! Even better than some of them I’ve tried around the world!
But what really sealed the deal for me was that Villa Dolce also offers unique gourmet pizzas with toppings like artichoke hearts, olives, goat cheese and more. As someone who loves to try new foods and experiment with different flavors, this restaurant is definitely a treat for my taste buds!
Whether you’re looking for authentic New York-style slices or gourmet pies, Villa Dolce is sure to please your tummy and make you smile! In my book it’s definitely one of the best pizza places in Middleton WI!
#3 Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘N’ Bake Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
First of all, I was impressed with their selection. There are so many toppings to choose from! Whether you’re a meat-lover or a vegetarian, there’s something for everyone at Papa Murphy’s.
The crust was perfectly crispy and the dough was light and fluffy–basically the ideal texture and flavor. And the toppings were so fresh and flavorful that they complemented each other perfectly!
I have to admit, though, I had my doubts about their ‘take ‘n’ bake’ concept. But after popping one in my oven and tasting the final product all my doubts vanished. The pizza comes out hot, delicious and ready-to-eat in no time.
The customer service here is top-notch as well. The staff is friendly and always willing to help out with any questions you may have. Plus, they provide speedy delivery if you don’t want to wait around for your pizza to bake!
Overall, I can confidently say that Papa Murphy’s knows how to make some of the best pizza in Middleton WI. If you’re ever in the area, don’t miss out on an opportunity to try it out for yourself!
#4 Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Madison West
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The pizza here is truly a work of art. They take the time to make sure each slice comes out perfect. The dough is hand-tossed for that homemade touch and the toppings are always fresh.
The staff at Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Madison West really knows their stuff when it comes to pizza! They have an eye for detail and make sure they get every aspect of their product right. From the perfectly cooked crust to the generous amounts of cheese, it’s obvious they care about their craft.
The atmosphere is inviting and the décor bright, making it a great place to grab a bite with friends or co-workers. There’s also lots of seating, so you can enjoy your meal without feeling cramped.
It’s no wonder Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Madison West is one of the best pizza restaurants in Middleton WI! Deliciously creative toppings, perfect ingredients, and masterful construction make this joint stand out from the rest! If you find yourself in Middleton WI, be sure to check it out—you won’t regret it!
#5 Jet’s Pizza
When I arrived, I was taken aback by the sheer size of the pizza joint. It was large and inviting, full of energy and bustling with customers.
The first thing that caught my eye when I walked in was the topping bar. They had an amazing selection of ingredients to choose from, ensuring you could build your own custom slice. From mushrooms to jalapenos and beyond, no matter what your taste buds crave – Jet’s Pizza has got you covered!
I decided to go for one of their signature pies: The Big Baby. This monster slice packed a punch with four types of cheese, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onions and green peppers all atop a thick crust. The Big Baby conquered my hunger in just one bite!
But it wasn’t only the food that made this visit so enjoyable – it was also the service. The staff at Jet’s Pizza were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout my dinner experience, making sure I had everything I needed right away. A special shout-out goes out to my server Ramon who suggested pairing my meal with their garlic butter sauce – perfection!
Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Middleton WI – look no further than Jet’s Pizza! From their vast topping selection to their attentive service staff – they’ve got everything you need to make sure your dinner experience is top-notch!
If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 12 more pizza places in Wisconsin Dells!
#6 The Roman Candle Middleton
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Serves alcohol
I was so impressed with the quality of their pizzas. The pizzas were cooked to perfection: a crispy crust filled with a variety of delicious toppings and enhanced by the perfect balance of flavor. What really stood out to me was their unique topping combinations; they offer something special that I hadn’t had before in my travels – like their pineapple-jalapeno pizza or white garlic sauce pizza – which made for an incredibly delightful experience!
The atmosphere was just as impressive as the food. Roman Candle Middleton has a laidback vibe that makes you feel right at home. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and eager to help guide you through the wide array of delicious offerings.
Overall, I would recommend Roman Candle Middleton to anyone who enjoys great tasting pizza and wants to get away from everyday life for a while. It’s simply the best pizza in Middleton WI and an unforgettable experience!
#7 MOD Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
I must say, the pizza here blew me away. The dough was light and crispy, with a great flavor that was both savory and sweet. The crust had wonderful char to it, yet remained soft and chewy in the middle.
The cheese was gooey and delicious, evenly distributed throughout the pizza. The vegetables were fresh and flavorful, adding an extra layer of deliciousness to each bite. The sauce was also spot on – tangy, salty, and maybe a hint of sweetness that brought out the flavors of all the toppings perfectly.
The variety of choices also impressed me – they offer personalized pizzas as well as pre-built favorites (including ‘The Classic’ which I highly recommend!). I’ve never seen an option like this before – you can truly have whatever type of pizza your heart desires!
Overall, MOD Pizza provided a great experience that I won’t soon forget. Not only did the food taste amazing – it was also reasonably priced for how generous their portions were. If you’re ever in Middleton WI looking for some excellent pizza, be sure to check out MOD Pizza!
#8 Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza
- Has a kid’s menu
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Serves alcohol
- Nice tourist spot
From the moment I stepped foot in this place, I was impressed with their friendly service and cleanliness. They clearly take pride in their restaurant.
I was greeted warmly by a employee that quickly ran through the menu of specialty pizzas, sandwiches and salads they had to offer. Not only were they well-priced but they also provided generous portions!
The pizza was cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese and toppings. Every one of my bites was bursting with flavor – unlike anything else I’ve tasted before!
Overall, Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza is definitely worth the money and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for an incredibly delicious pizza experience. It’s without a doubt the best pizza in Middleton WI!
#9 Hot Stuff Pizza
I’m talking top-notch quality here. From their fresh ingredients to their delicious, original recipes, they make some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. The crust is golden brown and crispy and the toppings are always cooked to perfection.
I’ve tried a few different combinations of toppings over my visits and they have all been tasty and full of flavor. The Sicilian is my favorite style of pizza at Hot Stuff Pizza; it has a great combination of flavors that just make my mouth water every time I take a bite. And not to mention the cheesy pull!
The customer service at Hot Stuff Pizza is second to none as well. They always greet me with a smile and are willing to answer any questions I have about their menu items. They’re friendly, efficient, and consistently provide great service each time I visit which is why I keep coming back for more!
Overall, Hot Stuff Pizza is definitely the best pizzeria in Middleton WI in my opinion and if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience then you must give them a try.
If you’re willing to go an extra 40 miles, you can get to 11 more pizza places in Wisconsin Dells!
#10 Rosati’s Pizza
- Serves alcohol
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I’m not exaggerating here – the flavor of their thin crust and the perfect balance of cheese and sauce is truly out of this world. Plus, you can customize your pizza with tons of toppings to make it exactly how you like it.
It’s hard to find a place that offers so much variety when it comes to pizzas, but Rosati’s has something for everyone and they really know what they’re doing. I even heard they import some ingredients from Italy just to enhance the flavor!
The atmosphere at Rosati’s is great too – warm lighting, cozy booths and friendly smiles from staff members. They even have live music performances on certain days which made my experience truly unforgettable.
All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Middleton WI, then look no further than Rosati’s Pizza! Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!
#11 Pizza Hut
I’m not sure what their secret is, but the pizza here is unquestionably delicious. The crust is light and crispy, lightly seasoned with herbs and spices. The sauce is bold, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. Their toppings are always fresh and cooked to perfection – cooked just enough to bring out all the flavors of the ingredients without burning them.
But when it comes to taste, you can’t forget about their signature cheese blend. It’s a little different from anywhere else I’ve tried and truly makes this pizza stand out from the rest. It’s creamy and rich with just a hint of sweetness that really brings the entire dish together.
The environment at Pizza Hut is also great – it feels like an old-school pizzeria with lots of character. There’s something for everyone here; whether you want to grab a quick slice or sit down for dinner, they have plenty of options. Plus, they make sure to keep things nice and clean so your dining experience is always enjoyable!
Overall, I would highly recommend Pizza Hut as one of the best places to get pizza in Middleton WI – especially if you’re looking for something truly unique!
#12 Pizza Hut
As soon as I entered the bright, inviting lobby, I knew I was in for something special. The cheesy aroma of freshly baked pizzas wafted through the air and immediately hit me – it was a smell that could only come from Pizza Hut!
The friendly staff was warm and welcoming, which only added to the delightful atmosphere. We quickly placed our order and waited for the perfect pizza to arrive.
The wait was worth it – when my plate arrived at my table, it looked like a work of art! From the golden brown crust to perfectly melted cheese, it was absolutely mouth-watering. And that’s not even mentioning the toppings! Pepperoni, mushrooms, olives – they all blended together perfectly into an amazing tasting pizza.
I’ve been lucky enough to try many different kinds of pizzas throughout my travels, but none quite compare to the pizza from Pizza Hut in Middleton WI. It really is some of the best pizza around!
