Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Milwaukee WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Wisconsin

Best Pizza in Milwaukee WI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

142 Views

My taste buds have taken me all around the world, trying the best pizza places on every continent. So it’s with confidence I can say Milwaukee has some great options worth checking out.

I recently took a tour of twelve pizza spots in this city to find out which one would be crowned the Best Pizza in Milwaukee WI. Follow my journey to discover which place came out on top and why!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Wisconsin

#1 Brute Sourdough Pizza

I was blown away by both the taste and texture of the pizza. The sourdough crust was extremely flavorful and had just the right amount of crunch. The sauce was tangy but not overpowering and the quality of ingredients used for topping the pizza was simply delicious. The pepperoni in particular was incredibly flavorful – talk about a flavor explosion!

The atmosphere at Brute Sourdough Pizza is also something to write home about. It’s a cozy, casual spot that puts you immediately at ease when you walk through the door; plus, they’re playing some really great music!

If you’re ever in Milwaukee WI and looking for an exceptional pizza experience, look no further than Brute Sourdough Pizza. Trust me – it’ll be the best decision you make all year!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Wauwatosa!

#2 San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

The first thing that struck me is the atmosphere – they’ve got some great décor that makes you feel like you’re in a real Italian pizzeria. The staff were all friendly and helpful, ready to answer any questions I had.

Now onto the pizza: it’s simply divine! They have an amazing selection of specialty pizzas, and if you have any dietary restrictions, there are some vegetarian options too. Of course, no meal is complete without a good drink – and this place doesn’t disappoint! Not only do they serve beer and wine, but they’ve even got hard liquor available so you can go wild!

For dessert, San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana has some insanely good options. From tiramisu to cannoli to cheesecake – each one was better than the last. It’s definitely worth saving room for dessert after your meal!

The only downside I could find with this place was that there’s no delivery option. But if you’re nearby or just passing through Milwaukee WI, it’s well worth taking the time to visit San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana for the best pizza around – plus it’s a nice tourist spot too!

#3 Fixture Pizza Pub

The first thing I noticed at Fixture Pizza Pub was the amazing decor. They have created this cozy, rustic atmosphere with wooden furniture and soft lighting that just made me feel right at home.

Next up is the food, which is really why I’m here. The pizza dough is made from scratch daily and topped with a variety of fresh and delicious toppings. My absolute favorite was the Lahey’s Spinach & Ricotta pizza – it was out of this world!

But what really sets Fixture Pizza Pub apart from other pizza places is their variety of specialty pizzas. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like Margherita, or something more adventurous like the Sausage & Pickled Jalapenos slice, they’ve got you covered!

The staff at Fixture Pizza Pub were all very friendly and knowledgeable about their menu, which was an added bonus when trying to decide what to order. To top it off, they also had great beer and wine selection to choose from if you’re looking for a complete experience.

All in all, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Milwaukee WI then look no further than Fixture Pizza Pub!

#4 Wy’east Pizza

The selection is really diverse, and they have plenty of vegetarian options that are just as good as the meat-heavy ones. Plus, they offer a great selection of desserts, which always pairs well with a good slice of pizza.

Of course, the best part has to be the alcohol. A cold beer or a glass of wine with your pizza is always delightful and Wy’east Pizza does not disappoint. Plus, you can skip the delivery fee because you can just show up in person!

All in all, I found my experience at Wy’east Pizza to be one of Milwaukee’s best pizzas. If you’re looking for delicious food and drinks with friends or family, then this is definitely the place for you.

#5 Vinchi’s Pizza

I was especially impressed with the array of hard liquor they were serving. Not only did they have all the classics like vodka and whisky, but also craft cocktails like Moscow Mules and Margaritas. I had a great time trying out different drinks and pairings with my pizza slices.

The pizza itself was top-notch too! The crust had that perfect crunchiness, and their sauce and cheese combination truly satisfied my taste buds. They definitely know how to make a delicious slice of pizza here!

My only complaint about Vinchi’s Pizza is that they don’t provide delivery services. So if you don’t live nearby, you’ll have to make the trip—but trust me, it’s worth it!

In conclusion, Vinchi’s Pizza is one of the best pizzerias I’ve ever visited in Milwaukee Wi thanks to their exemplary alcohol selection along with their delicious pizzas. Highly recommend Vinchi’s Pizza for any pizza craving you may have!

#6 Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant

I was pleasantly surprised that they not only offer delicious food, but they also serve adult beverages. From wine to beer and hard liquor, I’d say Tenuta’s is the most well-stocked pizza joint in the area!

The pizza itself is remarkable. Their classic hand-tossed pies have a thin and flavorful crust, combined with savory homemade sauces and quality ingredients. Even vegetarians won’t be left wanting at Tenuta’s – they offer plenty of meatless options as well.

And after pigging out on all that delicious pizza, you can top your night off with their amazing desserts. They’ve got gelato for the Italian purists, plus cakes and cookies for those with a sweet tooth.

My one complaint about Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant? They don’t deliver! You’ll have to come in and enjoy their top-notch food in person. But trust me – it’s worth it!

#7 Flourchild Pizza

As soon as I stepped through the doors, I could already tell that this place was special. The aroma of freshly baked dough and savory spices filled the air…I knew I was in for a treat!

Their menu featured many specialty pizzas created with the most unique flavor combinations. After much deliberation, I decided to try their signature creation – the Flourchild Pizza. It did not disappoint! They had managed to perfectly balance sweet and savory flavors, giving me an unforgettable experience. The crust was light and crispy on the outside while staying soft and chewy on the inside – definitely one of the best pies I’ve ever had!

The toppings were also top-notch, ranging from fresh veggies to pureed sauces. Each bite provided a distinct taste that kept me coming back for more (and more!).

To make matters even better, the staff at Flourchild Pizza was incredibly friendly and accommodating throughout my entire visit. They were quick to answer any questions I had about their offerings and made sure that I enjoyed every part of my dining experience.

In conclusion, it’s clear why Flourchild Pizza is known as having some of the best pizza in Milwaukee WI! If you’re ever in town, be sure to make a stop here – you won’t regret it!

#8 Transfer Pizzeria Café

The atmosphere alone is enough to make you want to stay for hours. It has a cozy, rustic feel with exposed brick walls and old-fashioned décor. The staff are friendly, attentive and knowledgeable about the menu.

When it comes to their pizza, Transfer Pizzeria Café really shines. They offer an impressive array of fresh ingredients and toppings, homemade dough and sauces made from scratch daily. My personal favorite was the Margherita Pizza with its deliciously light crust and herby-fresh tomato sauce topped with creamy mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes and fresh basil leaves – simply divine! All paired perfectly with a crisp glass of white wine – what more could a pizza lover ask for?

In conclusion, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Milwaukee WI then Transfer Pizzeria Café is a must try. I guarantee that you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in West Allis!

#9 Classic Slice

The first thing that struck me about this place was the atmosphere. It had a classic, old-school Italian feel to it. There were red-checkered tablecloths, vintage magazines on the walls, and even an old Philips CD player with 80s music playing in the background. It felt like I had stepped back in time!

The pizza itself was out of this world. The crust was thin and crispy and just crunchy enough. The sauce was flavorful without being too acidic or sweet. And oh my goodness, the cheese! It was gooey, smoky and delicious – truly some of the best cheese I’ve ever tasted on a pizza!

I tried both the classic pepperoni and one of their specialties – a ham & pineapple pizza. Both were equally amazing!

Of course, you can’t go wrong with their wide variety of appetizers and salads either.

To top off my experience at Classic Slice, their staff were incredibly friendly and helpful throughout the entire meal. They made sure everything went smoothly so I could enjoy my dinner to the fullest.

If you’re looking for some seriously good pizza in Milwaukee WI then look no further than Classic Slice!

#10 Tony’s Pizzeria, LLC

As soon as I walked in, I knew I was in for something special. The warm and inviting atmosphere immediately grabbed my attention. And the fresh aromas of tomato, oregano, and garlic filled the air. When Tony greeted me with a big smile, I knew this place wasn’t your typical pizzeria.

No corner was cut when it comes to quality – Tony’s Pizzeria uses only the freshest ingredients and toppings available. The dough is homemade daily, while their signature sauces are perfectly balanced between sweet and savory.

When I took my first bite of their pizza, it literally transported me to another world! Every flavor was distinct and each bite stayed with me long after it had been consumed. The texture of the crust was perfect – nice and crunchy on the outside but soft on the inside.

To top it all off, Tony adds his own special touch to each slice with a sprinkle of Italian herbs which adds an extra element of flavor. With every single bite its like tasting pizza from a different region from around the globe – Sicily, New York style or Chicago deep-dish? Every slice is unique!

After eating at Tony’s Pizzeria LLC I can confidently say that there really isn’t anywhere else in Milwaukee WI that serves such delicious pizza!

#11 Zaffiro’s Pizza & Bar

The bar has an extensive selection of beer and wine, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a slice (or two) of pizza. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting, with brick walls and cozy booths – it’s really quite charming!

When it comes to the food, Zaffiro’s delivers! Their pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, leading to a full-flavored experience that is sure to satisfy all pizza fans. They have several signature pies available; my favorite is their classic margarita pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. It satisfies all my taste buds in one bite!

Overall, I highly recommend dining at Zaffrio’s Pizza & Bar for some of the best pizza in Milwaukee WI. The friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere and delicious food are definitely worth the trek!

#12 Lisa’s Pizzeria

I’ve had the pleasure of tasting several different pizzas at Lisa’s and each one was amazing. From the classic cheese pizza to the unique Hawaiian topped with fresh pineapple, every slice was utterly delicious. The crust is always flavorful and slightly crunchy – just how I like it!

It’s clear that Lisa puts a lot of effort into preparing her pizzas, using only the freshest ingredients and taking the time to cook them to perfection. Every detail is taken into account – from presentation to flavor – making sure you get a great experience.

The atmosphere inside Lisa’s Pizzeria is warm and inviting too. All of the staff members are friendly and accommodating, willing to answer any questions or offer suggestions for your meal. Plus, they serve some really good beer!

I highly recommend Lisa’s Pizzeria if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Milwaukee WI – it’s definitely worth checking out!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Fixture Pizza Pub

Upon walking into Fixture Pizza Pub, the aroma of bubbling cheese and fresh sauce immediately hit my nostrils, making my stomach rumble in anticipation. The decor, with its rustic charm and quirky pizza-themed artwork, immediately put a smile on my face. I knew this was going to be a great pizza adventure.

As I sat down, a friendly server greeted me with a warm smile and a menu that was practically screaming, Eat me! I couldn’t resist. I ordered their signature deep dish pizza, appropriately named The Fixer-Upper. And let me tell you, this pizza was a masterpiece.

When it arrived at my table, I gasped. This deep dish wonder was covered in a blanket of gooey cheese, loaded with fresh toppings, and had a crust that was both crispy and airy. The first bite took me straight to pizza heaven. The flavors danced on my taste buds like a well-rehearsed ballet troupe, and I found myself doing a little happy pizza dance in my seat.

What sets Fixture Pizza Pub apart from the rest is their commitment to quality ingredients. The sauce was made from fresh tomatoes, the cheese was perfectly melted, and the toppings were generous and flavorful. Each bite was a reminder that I was experiencing something truly extraordinary.

So, if you find yourself in Milwaukee and crave a deep dish pizza that will make your taste buds do a happy dance, look no further than Fixture Pizza Pub. You won’t regret it!

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Zaffiro’s Pizza The Original

From the moment I stepped into Zaffiro’s, I felt like I was transported to the heart of Italy – if Italy had a cheesy sense of humor. The staff greeted me with big smiles and a laugh that could rival the volume of their pizza ovens. They clearly love what they do, and it shows in the deliciousness of their pizzas.

Let’s talk about the crust, shall we? Who needs a heavy, doughy crust when you can have a thin, crispy disc of heaven? Zaffiro’s knows how to get that perfect balance between crispy and chewy. It’s like biting into a cloud that has been lightly toasted and seasoned with pizza love. Seriously, it’s that good.

And the toppings! Zaffiro’s offers a plethora of options, from classic pepperoni to more adventurous combinations like spinach and goat cheese. I can’t resist their garlic and sausage combo – it’s so flavorful, it’s like a party in my mouth and everyone’s invited!

Oh, and did I mention the cheese? Melted and gooey, it stretches like a yoga master’s hamstring. It’s the kind of cheese that makes you want to rub it all over your face and declare your undying love for dairy.

In conclusion, if you’re in the mood for the best thin crust pizza in Milwaukee, Zaffiro’s is the place to go. Just make sure you bring an empty stomach and a sense of humor – because the only thing funnier than their jokes are the faces you’ll make when you take your first bite. Bon appétit!