Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Monmouth County (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New Jersey

Best Pizza in Monmouth County (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

956 Views

It’s been a long journey – I’ve sampled over a dozen pizza places from around the world and still feel there is no better place to get a slice than Monmouth County! After much tasting, testing, and evaluating, it’s time I reveal who makes the best pizza in this area.

But before we get to the results, let me warn you: this review isn’t for the faint of heart – it will be humorous and lighthearted – but also full of delicious details about the pizzas I’ve sampled. So sit back, relax, and enjoy reading my take on the best pizza in Monmouth County!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey

#1 Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza

I was amazed by the quality of the ingredients they use, like the fresh mozzarella and hand-made dough. The wood-fired oven gave my pizza a unique flavor and texture that you can only get with coal-fired cooking.

The staff were all very friendly and helpful – they even had some great recommendations for beer pairings!

What sets Del Ponte’s apart is their commitment to making a delicious pizza every time. They take pride in their craft and it shows. Each pizza is made to order, so the flavors are always on point. And if you’re looking for something unique, they offer signature pies like the ‘Hot Mess’ or ‘Deluxe’.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Monmouth County, look no further than Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 20 more pizza places in Belmar!

#2 Lino’s Pizzeria

The restaurant itself is less than luxurious. Let’s just say it has a certain charm about it (albeit a dusty, outdated one). But you don’t go to Lino’s for ambiance; you go there for the pizza. And let me tell you, what they make is nothing short of excellence.

The crust is always perfectly cooked — every time. Not too thin, not too thick — but that perfect balance that all great pizzas have. The toppings are also something to talk about; they use only the freshest ingredients and the flavor combinations are truly incredible!

I’m telling you, this place has found the secret ingredient of making amazing pizza: old-fashioned Italian pride and dedication! If you’re ever in Monmouth County and looking for a slice (or two!), this is definitely your place to be!

#3 Aiello’s of Brooklyn

I’m all about the classic New York-style pizza, and Aiello’s has it down to a science. From their traditional Sicilian slices to their more creative concoctions like the Cauliflower Parmigiana slice, there’s something for everyone here.

The crust is always perfectly thin and crunchy, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese that melts in your mouth. The toppings are always fresh and flavorful too. My personal favorite is the Eggplant Rollatini – its combination of eggplant and ricotta cheese is truly heavenly.

The service at Aiello’s is top-notch too; despite the crowds the staff never seems rushed or flustered. They always get our orders right, even when we make crazy requests! And they’re so friendly and welcoming; it feels like a family dinner every time I visit.

In my years of eating pizza around the world, I’ve tasted some amazing slices but none compare to Aiello’s – they have some of the best pizza in Monmouth County. If you want an amazing slice of pizza with fantastic service and a welcoming atmosphere, Aiello’s is where it’s at!

#4 Zoni’s Brooklyn Brick Coal Oven Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped in, I was immediately welcomed by the inviting smell of delicious pizza cooking in their ovens. The employees were friendly and helpful and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting.

I ordered a classic Margherita slice and it didn’t disappoint! The pizza was cooked perfectly, with a crispy crust along the edges, and a soft center that held all the toppings – tomatoes, mozzarella and basil – together perfectly. The flavor was remarkably balanced, with just enough tang from the tomatoes to give it that extra kick!

I wasn’t done yet though! After my slice, I decided to order a whole pie for takeaway. I opted for the Pepperoni Pizza with extra garlic sauce and let me tell you – it was amazing! Every single bite had bursts of flavor that left me wanting more. On top of all this, they also offer vegan options if that’s what you’re into!

Zoni’s Brooklyn Brick Coal Oven Pizzeria is truly one of the best pizzerias in Monmouth County. Whether you’re looking for dine-in or take away pizza, they have something to please everyone’s taste buds. So go ahead and check them out – you won’t regret it!

#5 Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant

I was floored by their selection of toppings, the quality of their crusts, and most importantly, their fresh ingredients. Every pizza I tried was a flavor explosion – from succulent pepperoni to fragrant basil and everything in between. The dough is always cooked to perfection and the cheese melts so beautifully!

But what really makes this place stand out is the atmosphere. The restaurant oozes sophistication with its cozy interior, dim lighting, and live jazz music playing in the background. Every time I come here, I feel like I’m entering another world full of deliciousness!

The staff is personable and attentive; they greet you with a warm welcome no matter how busy they get. Plus, the prices are great – it’s well worth your hard-earned money. All in all, Federico’s Pizza & Restaurant is my go-to spot for some of the best pizza in Monmouth County. Bon appetit!

#6 Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria

I recently stopped by this joint in search of some delicious pizza, and was not disappointed. The setup is inviting, with a vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff. Now onto the pizza!

I sampled their pepperoni pizza and it blew my mind! The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, while the sauce was tangy and flavorful. They piled on quality toppings that really made the flavor pop. I could tell right away that these folks know their way around an oven!

The service was friendly, efficient, and more than happy to chat about their food selections. All in all Pete & Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria is a great spot for anyone looking to sink their teeth into some of the best pizza in Monmouth County!

#7 Vic’s Italian Restaurant

As soon as you walk in, you’re greeted with a warm welcome and the heavenly smells of homemade pizza. I love their large variety of options on the menu. From classic pepperoni to their more inventive combinations like their Spinach & Feta Pizza, there’s something for everyone here.

I had the pleasure of trying all 3 of the pizzas they offered while I was there and can say definitively that they make some of the best pizza around! The dough was just thick enough, holding up under the weight of all the ingredients without being too soft. The sauce was flavorful and not overwhelming, making each bite taste fresh and delicious.

The atmosphere at Vic’s is great and really brings a smile to your face when you’re looking for a good time. There are tables available both indoors and outdoors, adding to the fun atmosphere outside in the summertime. Plus, there’s usually live music playing which makes it even better!

All in all, I highly recommend Vic’s Italian Restaurant for anyone looking for fantastic pizza in Monmouth County. It’s definitely one of my favorite pizza places that I’ve tried over my travels!

#8 Federici’s Family Restaurant

When I stepped inside Federici’s, I was immediately taken with the classic Italian atmosphere. The decor puts you right in the heart of Italy, so it’s not hard to imagine that whatever you’re about to eat is going to be amazing.

The menu offers a range of options from classic cheese pizza with tomato sauce to specialties like margherita and quattro formaggi. I went for the latter, and let me tell you – it was insanely delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked and the cheese taste divine.

Besides their excellent pizza offerings, Federici’s also has plenty of other treats like calzones and strombolis. They even have a kid’s menu and some vegetarian options, making this restaurant great for everyone! Oh, and did I mention they serve alcohol? Yes! As if that wasn’t enough of an incentive to come here, Federici’s also has some of the best desserts around – tiramisu, panna cotta…you name it.

I must say that this restaurant is definitely worth a visit. The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery service; nevertheless, it’s worth taking a trip to Monmouth County just to try their incredible pizza! Whether you’re looking for an enjoyable meal or just want to take a touristy break during your vacation, Federici’s Family Restaurant is sure to satisfy all your needs.

If you’re willing to go an extra 2 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Asbury Park!

#9 Pasquale’s Pizzeria

The atmosphere at this little pizzeria was excellent – the friendly staff, warm and inviting decor, not to mention the smell of delicious pizza wafting through the air.

Once I had a slice of their classic Margherita Pizza, I knew I’d struck pizza gold! The crust was light and fluffy while the sauce was tangy and flavorful. To top it off, they used top-quality mozzarella cheese that melted in my mouth.

The other pizzas were equally as tasty. Whether you go for the Prosciutto or Spicy Italian Sausage, you’re sure to be satisfied with your choice.

I left Pasquale’s Pizzeria feeling full and happy that I could finally say I’ve had some of the best pizza in Monmouth County!

#10 Federico’s Pizza On Main Oceanport

The restaurant has the perfect, cozy atmosphere to enjoy a slice of deliciousness. Plus, they serve beer and wine so you can really turn up the fun.

When it comes to the pizza itself, Federico’s is out of this world! The crust is just right – not too thin and not too thick. Toppinugs are fresh and flavorful, with meats that taste like they’ve been cooked by a 5-star chef. The cheese melts in your mouth like a cloud of savory goodness!

I must admit I was skeptical at first because of the location but that quickly disappeared after enjoying my first bite. Would I come back? Absolutely! In fact, I plan on dropping by again next time I’m in town. Federico’s Pizza is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Monmouth County looking for the best pizza around!

#11 Nunzio’s Pizzeria

I arrived at the restaurant and was immediately impressed by the warm atmosphere. I felt like I had been transported to Italy with the ancient-looking stone oven in the center of the pizzeria. As I approached the counter, eager to try a slice, Nunzio himself greeted me with a huge smile on his face.

Nunzio and his team recommended their signature Grandma Pie — a stuffed Sicilian square pizza with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese, italian sausage, and roasted bell peppers. All I can say is wow! The crust was cooked perfectly; it was thick and chewy yet crunchy around the edges. The toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful. Every bite was an absolute explosion of flavor!

But what really made this one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted was Nunzio’s exceptional service and hospitality. He even took me into the back prep area, where he explained how they make their signature wafer-thin crusts that are practically paper thin but still crunchy and chewy at the same time! It’s something you have to experience for yourself to truly understand its deliciousness.

Overall, I would highly recommend Nunzio’s Pizzeria if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Monmouth County. From their unique venue to their top-notch ingredients, you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Ippolito’s Cucina Italiana and Pizzeria

I recently stopped in to give it a try and boy am I glad I did. From the moment I stepped foot in the door, I knew this place was going to be good. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it a great spot for date night or dinner with friends.

But enough about the ambiance; let’s talk about the pizza! It’s truly amazing. The crust is thin yet hearty, creating a perfect balance of crunchy and chewy. The sauce is fresh and vibrant, adding just the right amount of flavor to each bite. And of course you can’t forget about their signature toppings – they bring out all the savory components in ways that make each slice memorable.

To sum it up: Ippolito’s Cucina Italiana and Pizzeria serves up some of the best pizza in Monmouth County and if you haven’t tried it yet, then you’re missing out!