Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Monroeville (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Pennsylvania

Best Pizza in Monroeville (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

122 Views

In my latest mission to find the best pizza possible, I have made it my personal goal to sample a dozen pizzas from some of the most popular places in Monroeville. While the work of tasting twelve different types of pizza may sound daunting, I’m up for the challenge!

As an experienced food critic that has been all over the world sampling pizza, I’ve come to develop a sharpened taste for great pies. That being said, will Monroeville offer something worth writing home about? You’ll just have to read on and find out! So sit back with your favorite beverage and enjoy my humorous and lighthearted review of the twelve best pizzas in Monroeville.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Pennsylvania

#1 Mary Jo’s Pizzeria

When I first stepped into the cozy little restaurant, I was immediately greeted by the warm and welcoming staff. They made sure to let me know that their pizza is made with only the freshest ingredients, and it showed in the quality of the pie.

As soon as I took my first bite, I knew why Mary Jo’s Pizzeria was rated so highly. The dough was perfectly cooked and delicious – not too thick, not too thin. The tomato sauce had just the right amount of zing and flavor, and there were plenty of toppings to choose from. My favorite was their specialty topping: sautéed garlic! It gave each slice a burst of flavor that really set them apart from any other pizzeria.

The best part about Mary Jo’s Pizzeria? They have some of the best prices around town! You can’t beat their value for a tasty meal like this one.

If you’re ever in Monroeville looking for a great pizza spot with friendly service and amazing pies, then look no further than Mary Jo’s Pizzeria – they’ve got some of the best pizza in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#2 Cosmo’s Pizza

The atmosphere at Cosmo’s is fantastic. The walls are adorned with pictures of classic Italian scenes and rustic artifacts. And the smells emanating from the kitchen make it clear that they take their pizza very seriously!

The menu has a great selection. From traditional Italian fare to more creative options, like their meat lover’s pizza, there is something for every taste. Plus, for those feeling a bit more adventurous, they offer unique topping combinations like grilled chicken and artichoke hearts.

The pizza itself is simply divine! Even a crust purist would be satisfied as their crust is both crispy and chewy in all the right places. Toppings are generous and fresh; never canned or frozen. Plus, you can have your pizza cut however you like: thin slices or giant triangles – whatever you desire!

The only downside to Cosmo’s Pizza is that they don’t offer delivery service. You’ll have to come pick up your order in-person if you want to enjoy their delicious pie at your home or office.

All-in-all, I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Cosmo’s Pizza and highly recommend them for anyone looking to enjoy some of the best pizza in Monroeville!

#3 Caputo’s Friendly Inn

The atmosphere was great and the service was friendly. Plus, they serve alcohol which always adds to the overall experience.

I decided to try the Supreme pizza – it didn’t disappoint! The crust had a perfect crispness and the toppings were cooked just right. It was clearly made with love and expertise, just like all of their other pies.

Unfortunately, this spot doesn’t offer delivery so you’ll need to take a break from your day and come in for some good ol’ fashioned relaxation time. But trust me, it will be worth it!

If you’ve been searching for the best pizza around Monroeville, put Caputo’s Friendly Inn at the top of your list – you won’t regret it!

#4 Blaze Pizza

When I stepped into the restaurant, I was frankly astonished. The atmosphere was so inviting and the decor was modern and stylish. I could tell right away that this place takes pizza seriously.

The menu boasted all sorts of delicious options, from classic combos like pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous topping combinations like spicy chicken and pineapple. I opted for the Supreme Pizza with added banana peppers, one of the signature menu items.

The pizza arrived quickly, and it looked as good as it sounded! Every bite contained a delicious combination of flavors – spices, cheese, vegetables, and herbs all working together in harmony. It was cooked to perfection – crispy on the outside but still fluffy on the inside. Absolutely scrumptious!

I can confidently say that Blaze Pizza has some of the best pizza in Monroeville! The atmosphere, service, ingredients – everything is top-notch here! Highly recommend if you’re ever in town looking for great pizza.

#5 Meglio’s Pizza & Sandwiches

The pies at Meglio’s are unique and delicious. I had the pleasure of trying the signature pepperoni pizza, and it was pure heaven! The crust of the slice was perfectly thin and crispy, with just enough crunch to satisfy my carb craving. The sauce was nicely spiced with accents of garlic that created a flavorful harmony when paired with the cheese and pepperoni. Plus, it was cooked to perfection – not too much, not too little.

In addition to fantastic pizza, Meglio’s has an impressive selection of sandwiches which made my mouth water just looking at them! Obviously these aren’t your average “gourmet” subs – no sir! These babies are loaded up with tasty ingredients like fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, olive oil, cured meats and more.

I left Meglio’s Pizza & Sandwiches feeling fully satisfied but longing for more! I highly recommend a visit to this Monroeville treasure if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around. You won’t be disappointed!

#6 Dom’s Pizzeria

From the moment I stepped foot in the restaurant, I could tell that Dom’s Pizzeria was serious about making great pizza. The inside décor is tasteful and modern, with big-screen TVs to watch sports games and a relaxed atmosphere.

The menu at Dom’s Pizzeria is also top-notch. They offer a variety of pizzas including classic Italian, Caribbean-style, vegetarian, and even gourmet pizzas. For my money though, you can’t beat their classic pepperoni pizza which has just the right combination of sauce and cheese.

As for service, Dom’s Pizzeria staff are friendly and attentive. My waiter was helpful in explaining each pizza option and gave me some great recommendations based on my preferences. Plus they even threw in some extra garlic knots – definitely appreciated!

Overall I’d highly recommend visiting Dom’s Pizzeria if you’re looking for the best pizza in Monroeville. And if you happen to find yourself in Monroeville craving some delicious pizza – make sure to stop by Dom’s Pizzeria!

#7 Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

I don’t know what their secret ingredient is, but whatever it is, I want more of it! The crust was thick, fluffy, and just the right amount of crunchy. Plus, the pizza toppings were piled high with fresh ingredients that were cooked to perfectly.

The wings also deserve special mention – they were juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection! The traditional buffalo sauce was a great twist on an old classic.

My favorite part of this restaurant was the atmosphere – who knew coal fire ovens could be so cozy? The restaurant has a great vibe that is both inviting yet relaxed at the same time.

Overall, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is one of Monroeville’s best pizzerias and definitely worthy of a visit if you’re looking for quality Italian fare in town.

If you’re willing to go an extra 8 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Pittsburgh!

#8 James Street Tavern

The decor is quite unique – it feels like a tavern, complete with the giant flat-screen TVs for watching sports. It’s really a great place to catch a game and sip on some craft beer!

But what about the pizza? Well, I was definitely not disappointed. The traditional toppings like pepperoni and sausage were delicious, but they also had more interesting options like goat cheese and roasted red peppers. It was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of crunch.

The only downside is that James Street Tavern doesn’t offer delivery. But honestly, this isn’t much of an issue since the food is so good – it’s worth a trip out there to pick up your pie!

All in all, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Monroeville, make sure you check out James Street Tavern – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Papa Rocks Pizza Pub

The first thing I noticed when I stepped inside was the atmosphere. Whether you want to relax with friends, or get your pizza to go, Papa Rocks Pizza Pub is always a great choice! The staff was also friendly and welcoming.

I ordered a classic cheese pizza with some red pepper flakes on top and I could immediately tell this place got its reputation for a good reason! The crust was perfectly cooked and the cheese melted in my mouth. When it came to the toppings, nothing was lacking. Each ingredient was fresh and flavorful.

And if that wasn’t enough, they even had an innovative selection of specialty pizzas like cheesesteak pizzas, BBQ pizzas and more!

Overall, Papa Rocks Pizza Pub offers a winning combination of quality ingredients, great atmosphere, friendly service and delicious pizzas that make it the best pizza joint in Monroeville.

#10 DeNunzio’s Italian Trattoria

Let me tell you why – the dough is oh-so-fresh, crafted with a light and airy texture that makes it practically melt in your mouth. The toppings are generous and varied; from pepperoni to olives to artichoke hearts, you can have pretty much anything your palate desires.

And of course, the sauce. Ah, the sauce – spicy yet subtle, full of flavor that will have you licking your fingers in delight. Plus, their slices are huge so even if you’re feeling a bit peckish, one slice should do the trick!

But what really sets DeNunzio’s apart from every other pizza joint out there is their friendly service and cozy atmosphere. From the moment I walked in, I felt like family. There’s a warmth and openness that’s hard to find elsewhere, making it an ideal spot for a night out with friends or even an intimate dinner for two!

To sum it up: DeNunzio’s Italian Trattoria serves some of the best pizza in Monroeville (and perhaps in all of Pennsylvania!), so if you’re ever in town be sure to check it out! You won’t regret it – promise!

#11 Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Monroeville

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, which I think contributes to the excellent pizza. When I arrived I was warmly greeted by the staff, who were eager to answer my questions about the menu.

I decided on the pepperoni and mushroom pizza, which was quite delicious. The crust was nice and crisp, with a flavorful flavor. The pepperoni was cooked perfectly – not too greasy – and added an intense level of flavor to the dish. The mushrooms were cooked nicely as well, providing a wonderful contrast to the spicy pepperoni.

I also ordered some French fries and coleslaw as side dishes. Both were cooked really well – crispy on the outside and soft in the middle – and complimented my meal perfectly! All in all, Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Monroeville has truly earned its reputation for serving some of the best pizza in Monroeville!

#12 Napoli Pizza

The atmosphere was inviting and the staff is friendly. The attention to detail was surprisingly impressive, especially with the house-made dough that’s used for their pizzas. On top of that, they only use the freshest ingredients which is integral to great pizza.

I ordered a simple Margherita Pizza and it blew me away! The sauce was flavorful and the cheese was perfectly melted. Plus, I liked how thin the crust was cooked – not too crispy but just enough crunch.

Overall, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in Monroeville then Napoli Pizza should be your only choice. This place has definitely earned my seal of approval!