After tasting around 12 different pizzas, I can confidently say that the best pizza in town is definitely up for debate. Some places pride themselves on their thin crust pies, and others like to stuff their creations with fillings.
Everyone has different tastes when it comes to pizza, and my job is to find which restaurants are worth your time and money. So grab a slice and let’s see if my taste buds are on point!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Little Pizza Heaven
As soon as I stepped in the door, I was overwhelmed by the smells emanating from their ovens. The pizzas coming out of the oven were huge, and the crust had a perfect crunch. Every bite was packed with flavour that kept me wanting more.
The staff at Little Pizza Heaven were incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the ingredients they use, taking time to answer any questions I had before they served my slices.
I ordered their cheese pizza and it truly tasted like heaven. The toppings were spread evenly throughout, not settling just on top of one side. The sauce was zesty and tangy, making it hard to resist going for another slice!
The atmosphere of Little Pizza Heaven is also worth mentioning – the walls are painted a cheery yellow that makes you feel warm and welcome. Even though I was only there for lunch, I could see how busy this place gets during dinner hours – a testament to how great their food is.
Overall, Little Pizza Heaven has earned my highest recommendations for anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Montclair NJ! Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or dinner, you won’t be disappointed by their delicious pies and friendly service.
If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Nutley!
#2 Lyons Pizza Fried Chicken
This restaurant serves up delicious pies made with quality ingredients. The crust is always perfectly golden and crisp, while the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. Whether you prefer traditional topping combos like pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions, or something more creative like bacon, pineapple, and arugula, Lyons Pizza Fried Chicken can satisfy every pizza craving.
The atmosphere is also top notch. From the warm welcome of the friendly staff to the upbeat music playing throughout the restaurant, I felt right at home as soon as I stepped inside. Plus, it’s a great place for families to enjoy time together – there’s plenty of seating options so everyone can spread out and relax.
But what really sets this place apart from other pizza joints in town is their signature fried chicken! This juicy dish pairs perfectly with the pizza or can be enjoyed on its own. It’s definitely worth ordering an extra side of their special sweet and spicy sauce to dunk your chicken in!
At Lyons Pizza Fried Chicken you get the best of both worlds – great pizza and great fried chicken – in a vibrant atmosphere that will make you want to keep coming back for more. I’m convinced it offers Montclair NJ some of the best pizza around!
#3 Teglia Pizza Bar
- Offers dessert
From the moment I stepped into their restaurant, I knew something special was happening. The aroma of freshly-baked pizza filled the air, and it quickly put me in a great mood.
The staff at Teglia were incredibly friendly and helpful and gave me lots of information about their carefully crafted menu. As for the food itself, I’m telling you – it was out of this world! Every slice was cooked to absolute perfection with ingredients that sang in my mouth. The flavor combinations were truly unique and delicious and left my taste buds wanting more!
If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Montclair NJ, look no further than Teglia Pizza Bar. You won’t find better tasting pizza anywhere else!
#4 Belgiovine Delicatessen
The toppings are perfectly balanced and the crust is thin and crispy. Every bite was loaded with flavor, so much that I finished off my entire slice before I knew it!
The atmosphere was great too – there’s a chill vibe and some upbeat music playing in the background. Everyone always seems to be smiling and talking about their favorite slice of pizza.
Service-wise, Belgiovine Delicatessen does not disappoint. The staff is friendly, efficient, and knows how to make everyone feel welcome. They even have gluten-free options for those who need them!
If you’re looking for a good laugh (as well as some delicious pizza) I recommend visiting Belgiovine Delicatessen. It’s definitely worth the trip!
#5 Sofia’s Pizzeria
From the minute I walked into Sofia’s Pizzeria, I could immediately tell that this was a special place. The delightful aroma of freshly made dough and bubbling cheese wafted through the air. Their menu has an array of delicious toppings to choose from, so no matter what kind of pizza you’re in the mood for, they have something for everyone.
The pizzas here are cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust and just the right amount of cheese – so much that it’s almost sinful! Each bite melts in your mouth and leaves you wanting more.
The service is also top notch. Friendly employees greeted me with smiles and helped me pick out exactly what I wanted. It’s obvious they take great pride in their product and want to make sure every customer is satisfied.
If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Montclair NJ, then look no further than Sofia’s Pizzeria! I highly recommend it to anyone who is craving a delicious slice of pie – you won’t be disappointed!
#6 Brick + Dough
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The atmosphere at Brick + Dough is unique, with an old-school Italian feel. The interior is made of bricks and wood with a classic style, and the staff is super friendly and welcoming.
The pizza menu offers an extensive selection of specialty pies. Every one I tried was outstanding. My favorite was the “Grandma Pie” – layers of mozzarella and Parmesan cheese, crushed San Marzano tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil – so good! The crust was perfectly chewy and crisp, cooked in their brick oven. Yum!
I also had the chance to sample the brick-oven calzones, which were filled with ricotta, mozzarella and Parmesan cheeses plus bits of pepperoni. They were delicious! I could have consumed an entire order by myself.
Overall, Brick + Dough serves up some of the best pizza in Montclair NJ without a doubt. You won’t be disappointed if you stop in for dinner or pickup!
#7 Enzo Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Offers dessert
There’s something special about the atmosphere here, it’s a place where you can really spend time with friends, family or just by yourself. The music and the decor have a nice laid back vibe, perfect for sitting back and enjoying a delicious pizza.
The pizzas at Enzo Pizzeria & Restaurant are truly something special. Every pizza is handcrafted with freshly sourced ingredients and made as if it were for their own table. I’ve tasted different pizzas from all over the world but none compare to the unique flavor combinations at Enzo’s. Whether it is cheese pizza, pepperoni, Hawaiian or veggie – they’ve got something for everyone!
My favorite part of going to Enzo Pizzeria & Restaurant is how friendly the staff is. It feels like you’re one of their own family members, they greet you warmly and create an awesome experience that makes me want to come back again and again!
Overall, I would highly recommend this pizzeria as one of the best in Montclair NJ! So next time you’re looking for great pizza in town, don’t forget to check out Enzo Pizzeria & Restaurant!
#8 Mr. Dino’s
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere was inviting and the staff were friendly, which really added to the experience. The decor was simple yet charming, and it’s clear that Mr. Dino’s takes pride in their restaurant.
Now let’s talk about the pizza itself; it was absolutely incredible. The crust was perfectly cooked and had a crunchy texture that melted in my mouth. The toppings were flavorful and balanced just right with the cheese, sauce, and crust. Every bite was a delight!
I would highly recommend Mr. Dino’s to anyone looking for some of the best pizza in Montclair NJ. Even if you’re not in the area, it’s worth the trip just for this pizza! I know I’ll be back next time I’m in town.
If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Clifton!
#9 Ah’ Pizz – Montclair
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
The atmosphere is cool and casual, with a hip vibe that makes it the perfect spot for a night out. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable, and they always make sure to provide great customer service.
The pizzas at Ah’ Pizz – Montclair are absolutely divine. From classic margherita to specialty deluxe pies, there’s something for everyone here. The hand-tossed dough is light and airy, with just the right amount of crunch. The savory sauce is made from freshly-sourced tomatoes and herbs, and it’s complemented perfectly by the gooey cheese and wide variety of toppings. Each pizza is cooked to perfection in their wood-fired oven.
I’m convinced that Ah’ Pizz – Montclair has some of the best pizza in Montclair NJ! Whether you’re looking for a classic slice or something more creative, you won’t be disappointed when you visit this awesome restaurant. Bon appetite!
#10 Fiammella Wood Fired Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
The atmosphere was inviting, the pizza was unique, and the staff was friendly. As soon as I walked in, the wood-fired ovens greeted me with the smell of deliciousness. The menu featured some truly unique flavor combinations that you don’t find everywhere else — from a classic Margherita to a more adventurous Gorgonzola & Pear option.
I had the pleasure of sampling several items on the menu and am happy to report that it all lived up to its hype! From light and airy crusts to fresh ingredients, Fiammella knows how to make a great slice of pizza. My favorite item of the night was their signature Fiammella pizza featuring an Italian sausage blend and broccoli rabe. It was truly a memorable experience.
But what made this visit even more special were all the little extras like the house-made focaccia bread served before dinner and live music playing during dinner hours — both just added to the magical experience at Fiammella Wood Fired Pizza & Italian Restaurant. For anyone looking for good pizza in Montclair NJ, this is definitely worth checking out!
#11 Belgiovine’s Montclair Pizza
The pizza crust was just thin enough without being too crispy, while the cheese was oozing with flavor. The sauce had a nice garlicky flavor that really brought out all the other ingredients. Even better, their toppings were fresh and flavorful – from the pepperoni to the mushrooms.
The atmosphere was inviting as well – cozy booths and upbeat music resulted in a great experience from start to finish. And even though I ate way more than I should have, the service was impeccable and my waitress made sure to check in on me throughout my meal!
I can confidently say that if you’re looking for the best pizza in Montclair, NJ then Belgiovine’s Montclair Pizza is the place to be!
#12 Ruthie’s Bar-B-Q & Pizza – BBQ Barbecue And Thin Crust
The barbeque pizza is absolutely delicious. The combination of sweet and savory flavors creates a unique experience that you can only get at Ruthie’s. Not to mention, the thin crust is perfectly cooked – not too crunchy and not too soft.
The atmosphere at Ruthie’s is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends. The staff are friendly and accommodating, always making sure your order is correct before leaving the counter.
Perhaps my favorite thing about this place was the price – extremely reasonable for such amazing pizza! And if you’re looking for some extra flavor, they have an extensive selection of toppings to choose from and even some unique add-ons like jalapenos or olives.
Overall, I highly recommend Ruthie’s Bar-B-Q & Pizza – BBQ Barbecue And Thin Crust as the best pizza in Montclair NJ. Next time I’m in town, you can bet I’ll be stopping by for a slice (or two).
