Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Monterey CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in California

Best Pizza in Monterey CA (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

85 Views

Having sampled pizza all over the world, I’m ready to give an honest assessment of the best pizza in Monterey CA. In this review, I will cover 12 different places and compare their offerings for your convenience. As a serious food critic, I take my job very seriously – but in this article, I promise to keep it lighthearted and humorous as well!

So buckle up and get ready: it’s time to find out which joint serves up the best pizza in Monterey CA!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of California

#1 Pizza Hut Express

I stumbled across this place while meandering my way around the city and was pleasantly surprised to find the most delicious pizza around. The crust was light and crispy, the sauce was flavorful and well-balanced, and the cheese was melted to perfection.

The service at Pizza Hut Express is also top-notch; they were friendly, accommodating, and quick to ensure my order was just right. I didn’t feel rushed or like I couldn’t ask questions; they made sure that every customer felt like a VIP.

Unfortunately, one downside of Pizza Hut Express is that it doesn’t deliver — but for me that wasn’t an issue because I wanted to enjoy my evening out by savoring their delicious pizza in person. If you’re looking for a great pizza slice without having to wait long delivery times, this is the place for you!

Bottom line? Pizza Hut Express has some of the best pizza in Monterey CA – so if you’re in town, don’t forget to check out this amazing establishment!

If you’re willing to go an extra 3 miles, you can get to 17 more pizza places in Carmel-By-The-Sea!

#2 Heirloom Pizza Co.

When I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff was friendly and helpful in helping me decide what kind of pizza to get. And they didn’t disappoint!

The variety of pizzas was incredible! From classic Italian-style pies to speciality vegan options, there’s something for everyone here. I eventually settled on the White Truffle pizza. It’s made with fresh mozzarella, truffle oil, and garlic—and oh my goodness did it taste amazing! The crust had just the right amount of crunch and the flavors were simply incredible.

I also got a sample of their house-made gelato—decadent and delicious!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Monterey CA then Heirloom Pizza Co. is where it’s at. With great food and a relaxed atmosphere, it’s an experience you won’t soon forget.

#3 The Oven Pizzeria

The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with a rustic Italian vibe. The staff are incredibly friendly, making sure I always felt welcomed.

Most importantly, the pizza. The Oven Pizzeria serves up some of the most delicious pies I’ve ever had! From classic pepperoni to Mexican-style al pastor, they have something for everyone. Not only that, but their pizzas also feature some truly unique ingredients like roasted garlic, chipotle barbecue sauce, and chili flakes.

Their signature pizza has become my favorite – it’s an ultra-thin crust topped with creamy ricotta cheese and spinach. Yum!

If you’re in Monterey CA and looking for the best pizza around, look no further than The Oven Pizzeria! You won’t be disappointed!

#4 Tricycle Pizza | Order Online + In Person + By Phone

I couldn’t believe my eyes when I stepped into the restaurant. The pizza oven was gigantic and the cozy atmosphere of the place made me feel right at home.

The crust was thin and crispy, just how I like it. But what really blew me away were the unique toppings they had to offer! From their classic pepperoni and mushrooms to their unconventional orange chicken toppings, they had something for everyone.

The service at Tricycle Pizza was also top-notch. All of my questions were answered quickly by the friendly staff and they were more than happy to help with any special requests I had.

Overall, Tricycle Pizza is a great spot for pizza-lovers of all kinds. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite during lunch or a romantic dinner date, Tricycle Pizza has something for you. Trust me – if you’re in Monterey CA, make sure to stop by Tricycle Pizza – it’s simply the best!

#5 Pizza My Heart

From the moment I stepped foot into Pizza My Heart, I knew this was going to be a great experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, making sure that my visit was enjoyable from start to finish.

As for the food, it’s hard to find anything better than Pizza My Heart’s delicious pies. Each one is made with fresh ingredients and an expert hand. There’s something for everyone here – from classic combos like pepperoni and mushroom to more adventurous pies like buffalo chicken mac ‘n’ cheese. No matter what you get, you just can’t go wrong!

To top it all off, the atmosphere at Pizza My Heart is perfect for gathering with friends or family. The restaurant has a relaxed vibe and never feels too crowded or stuffy. Plus, they often have live music on the weekends, providing a great backdrop for your pizza-eating experience!

In conclusion, there’s no doubt in my mind that Pizza My Heart boasts some of the best pizza in Monterey CA. If you’re ever looking for a great place to grab a slice (or two!) head on over – you won’t be disappointed!

#6 Pelican Pizza

The restaurant has a great atmosphere, complete with all types of sea life decorating the walls. When I walked in I was immediately made to feel welcome and comfortable, which is an important factor in a good restaurant experience.

The servers were extremely friendly and helpful. I asked questions about the pizzas they served and they answered them all confidently and accurately.

As far as the pizza itself goes, it’s simply incredible! The crust has just the right amount of crunch, while the toppings are always cooked to perfection. The flavors are bold, yet balanced – not too much or too little of any one ingredient. And although other restaurants may have more toppings to choose from, I find Pelican Pizza does each topping justice on every pie.

I think what sets Pelican Pizza apart from other pizza places is that they put time into making sure their pizzas are truly special. Their commitment to quality shines through from start to finish – from the ingredients chosen for each pie to the time taken when cooking it – and speaks volumes about how much care is taken for every single customer’s experience at this restaurant.

Overall, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Monterey CA look no further than Pelican Pizza! It’ll definitely leave you satisfied!

#7 Pizza My Way

This restaurant is truly a special place when it comes to pizza. Upon arriving, I saw that they had fresh dough and hand-tossed crusts. Needless to say, my expectations were high.

However, what really made this the best pizza in Monterey CA was the toppings. They had all of my favorites – pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms and so much more – plus some really creative options like pineapple and walnuts. The combination was perfect!

The sauce was top-notch as well; it was spicy but not overwhelming and had just the right amount of zing to it. Even the cheese was amazing; it melted perfectly on all of the toppings and added a great flavor that complemented everything else nicely.

Overall, I can honestly say that this is one of the best pizzas around! If you’re ever in Monterey, do yourself a favor go check out Pizza My Way – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Gusto Handcrafted Pasta & Pizza

From the moment I walked in the door, I was greeted with a warm welcome and treated to an unforgettable experience. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, perfect for eating delicious pizza.

The menu offered a variety of options, from thin-crust pizzas to deep dish varieties and handmade pastas. After trying several different items, I can confidently say that Gusto knows how to make a great pie! The crust had just the right amount of crunch and lightness, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful. My favorite was their signature Margherita Pizza, made with the perfect combination of tomatoes, basil, garlic, mozzarella cheese, and olive oil.

Overall my experience at Gusto Handcrafted Pasta & Pizza was nothing short of wonderful! Not only did they serve up some of the best pizza in Monterey CA that I’ve ever had, but their friendly service made me feel like part of their family. It’s definitely one place you don’t want to miss out on when you’re visiting Monterey!

If you’re willing to go an extra 16 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Salinas!

#9 Gianni’s Pizza

I have to say, I was thoroughly impressed with their wood-fired oven as it produced some truly masterful pies. The crusts were light and fluffy with a perfect texture that made my taste buds swoon. Plus, they definitely didn’t skimp on the toppings – each piece of pizza was loaded with just the right amount of deliciousness!

Of course, one of the best parts about Gianni’s Pizza is that you get to choose all your own ingredients. You can really create something special when you pick out only the freshest, flavorful ingredients. And don’t even get me started on their sauces! I sampled their marinara and it was simply delicious – perfectly balanced between sweetness and acidity.

All in all, this restaurant offers some seriously amazing pizza – perhaps some of the best I’ve ever had! So if you’re ever looking for great pizza in Monterey CA….look no further than Gianni’s Pizza!

#10 Melville Tavern

It was a warm summer night and I decided to give Melville Tavern a try. From the outside, it looks like your typical tavern – nothing too extraordinary. But once you step in, you know that it’s special. The atmosphere was alive with people enjoying a good meal and conversation.

The menu had a wide variety of pizzas, some classic and some unique. I decided to start with their signature pizza: The Monterey Margherita Pizza. It was made with scratch-made dough and topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted cherry tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic oil and Parmesan cheese.

It looked delicious! The pizza was cooked to perfection; the crust was light and airy while the toppings were flavorful and abundant. The cheese melted perfectly and the sauce had just the right amount of sweetness. This is easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever tasted!

The service at Melville Tavern is also top notch; our server was friendly and accommodating. Every dish came out hot and timely, which made our evening even better!

Overall, Melville Tavern is definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some great pizza in Monterey CA. Their delicious pies are sure to leave you coming back again and again! Trust me, it’s worth a visit!

#11 Lalla Grill Del Monte

The restaurant itself is quite charming and I found myself drawn in by the cozy atmosphere. As for the pies themselves, they hit the spot! The crust was light and perfectly cooked and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. They offer an impressive selection of pizzas with things like spicy pepperoni, meat lovers, veggie supremes and more.

And let’s talk about their signature ‘Mountain Pie’ – it was a work of art! It had plenty of cheese on top, along with a generous array of grilled vegetables like peppers, eggplant, mushrooms and onions – all served over a tangy tomato sauce. Delicious!

I highly recommend Lalla Grill Del Monte if you’re looking for the best pizza in Monterey CA – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Mountain Mike’s Pizza

I entered the restaurant with high expectations and was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere: a cozy, inviting space with greenery surrounding it. The warm colors and inviting staff made my experience even more enjoyable.

The quality of the pizza is unparalleled. They use only fresh ingredients and their unique dough recipe makes for a delightful flavor. All of their pizzas are cooked in brick ovens that give them an incredibly crispy texture – perfect for those who like thin crusts!

Their menu is varied and extensive, with plenty of options for vegetarians, meat-lovers, and those who want something different. I was impressed with how accommodating they were when it came to customizing orders – something that isn’t always available elsewhere!

Overall, Mountain Mike’s Pizza definitely lives up to its reputation as one of the best places to get pizza in Monterey CA! Its unique atmosphere, delicious menu items, and friendly service make it a top choice for anyone looking for an amazing meal.