Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Montgomery AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Alabama

Best Pizza in Montgomery AL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

160 Views

I’ve traveled the world tasting pizza, and even though you won’t find any Italian nonnas cooking up pizza al metro in Montgomery, there are some delicious pies worth exploring.

To help make your search easier, I’ve rounded up my top 12 picks for the best pizza in Montgomery AL – from experimental creations to classic takes on traditional recipes. With a combination of humor and helpful advice, I’m sure you’ll find something that’s right up your alley.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Alabama

#1 Extreme Pizza

The first thing that struck me was the smell of this place as soon as I stepped in. It was heavenly! From the freshly-baked crust to the array of toppings, their flavors were out of this world. The crust was thin and crispy on the outside but pillowy soft on the inside. And the toppings? Oh wow! They had a great selection from classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to some more exotic options like mango barbecue chicken and roasted yams.

The service at Extreme Pizza was excellent too. I can’t forget how welcoming everyone was and how quickly my pizza came out of the oven after ordering. And of course, let’s not forget about the drinks! They had a great selection to choose from and even had speciality alcoholic beverages for those looking for something stronger.

So if you’re looking for an amazing pizza in Montgomery AL, look no further than Extreme Pizza! It’s definitely worth checking out – I know I’ll be back soon!

If you’re willing to go an extra 48 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Auburn!

#2 Can a brotha get a slice

The pizza here is addictively delicious. The crust is light and perfectly baked, the cheese just enough to be gooey and flavorfully irresistible. Then there’s the toppings – oh boy! You can choose from an array of options that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

But it doesn’t stop there. The atmosphere at Can a brotha get a slice is one-of-a-kind: cozy and inviting with a hint of urban funkiness. And the staff are friendly and helpful, always ready to answer any questions you may have or assist in any way they can.

There’s not much more I can say – if you want some of the best pizza around, Can a brotha get a slice should be your go-to spot!

#3 Midtown Pizza Kitchen

The restaurant has a great atmosphere. It has lively, colorful decor, and people are always bustling about, eager to get their hands on a delicious slice. The wait staff is very friendly and helpful, which adds to the pizzeria’s inviting charm.

I was thoroughly impressed by the pizza I tasted. The thin crust was crispy and delicious, with just the right amount of charring on the edges. The cheese was flavorful and abundant, melting perfectly around all of the toppings. And speaking of toppings, these pies had creative combinations including botanicals like arugula, artichoke hearts and mushrooms that made for a truly exquisite flavor profile!

Overall, Midtown Pizza Kitchen offers some of the best pizza in Montgomery AL. If you’re looking for an amazing pie packed with flavor, this is definitely the place to be!

#4 The Pizza Place

The ambience is comfortable and inviting, with a modern touch. As soon as I walked through the door, the smell of freshly baked pizza wafted around me. I knew immediately that this was going to be an unforgettable experience.

The menu options are almost endless. You can choose from classic favorites like Pepperoni, Margherita, and Cheese Pizza; deliciously inventive creations such as BBQ Chicken and Hawaiian Pizza; or even design your own masterpiece! If you’re feeling adventurous, they have specials like the “Giuliana’s Special” which contains four different types of cheeses – it was made just for me!

I got the chance to try all these varieties of deliciousness and they were truly divine! The crust was light and fluffy with a perfect balance of crunchy edges and chewy middles. Each bite sent my taste buds into overdrive with its amazing flavor combinations that ranged from sweet to savory to spicy. Yum!

But what really impressed me about The Pizza Place was their commitment to quality ingredients. You can tell that each ingredient is fresh and carefully chosen for optimum flavor. And let’s not forget about the customer service – everyone here works hard to make sure you get exactly what you want in a timely manner.

Let’s be honest here – if you’re looking for the best pizza in Montgomery AL, then look no further than The Pizza Place! They have all the elements needed for a casual yet memorable dining experience: great food, friendly staff, reasonable prices, and an atmosphere that will make you feel right at home. Trust me when I say that you won’t regret making this your first stop on your pizza tour around town!

#5 Pies & Pints – Montgomery, AL

From the moment I walked in, I knew this was a top-notch pizza joint. The pleasant yet no-nonsense atmosphere was inviting and cozy – perfect for the evening.

As for the pizzas themselves, my goodness! They had a wide variety of options: classic margherita, delicious pepperoni, burgers, potatoes – simply put, you name it! The crusts were crispy yet tender and packed with flavor. In addition to tasting delicious, the ingredients all seemed to be of high quality and tasted fresh.

The service was great as well; everyone from the host to the server was warm and friendly, which is always important in creating a good dining experience.

In short, Pies & Pints – Montgomery AL brings it home when it comes to great pizza! Those looking for the best pizza in Montgomery should make sure they add this spot to their list of go-to places.

#6 Pieology Pizzeria, Montgomery / Chase Corner

When I first stepped in, I was impressed by the modern and inviting atmosphere that Pieology Pizzeria had to offer. The restaurant had a great selection of toppings and crusts from which to choose when creating my own personalized pizza pie.

To make my pizza even better, I opted to add some of their signature gourmet ingredients like artichoke hearts, salami, and roasted garlic. The final product turned out amazing! It had the perfect combination of crunchiness and chewiness that made it unforgettable.

Speaking of unforgettable, the team at Pieology Pizzeria was very friendly and professional throughout my visit; they made sure all my needs were catered to with attention to detail. And let’s not forget the value – each pizza is made-to-order at a reasonable price point.

If you’re ever in Montgomery AL looking for some quality pizza, Pieology Pizzeria should be your go-to spot! This restaurant serves up some of the best pizza in town and will leave you feeling satisfied every time.

#7 Tomatinos Pizza and Bake Shop

When I visited their shop, I was immediately taken by how open and inviting the space was. The restaurant had a warm and inviting atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The pizza ovens were blazing and smelled delicious as soon as I walked in.

The menu had several different types of pizza, from traditional Italian pizzas to more unique options like white pizzas topped with anything from artichoke hearts to shiitake mushrooms. I tried a traditional pepperoni pizza and the flavor was out of this world! The crust was thin but chewy and the sauce was tangy and flavorful. The combination of flavors created an amazing experience that left me wanting more.

What really set Tomatinos Pizza apart from other restaurants I’ve visited is their baking selection. They offer fresh-baked garlic knots, calzones, and strombolis that are second to none. Not only were these items delicious, but many of them contained unexpected ingredients like olives or onions which made for a truly unique experience.

Overall, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Montgomery AL then look no further than Tomatinos Pizza and Bake Shop – you won’t be disappointed!

#8 Marco’s Pizza

The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a hint of Italy around every corner. The staff was friendly, but professional. Plus, the extensive menu offerings meant that I didn’t have to choose between pepperoni and sausage – I could have both!

I ordered the deluxe pizza with extra mozzarella cheese, and it absolutely did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly crisp, the tomatoes were juicy and sweet, and the cheese was deliciously melted – all at the same time! It tasted like it had come right out of an Italian pizzeria.

Overall, Marco’s Pizza is hands-down the best pizza in Montgomery AL. From the welcoming atmosphere to mouthwatering flavors in every bite of their pizza, they really know how to hit all the right spots. This pizza is definitely worth a visit if you’re ever in town!

If you’re willing to go an extra 75 miles, you can get to 26 more pizza places in Columbus!

#9 Bibb Street Pizza Company

The moment I stepped through the door of Bibb Street Pizza Company, I knew my taste-buds were in for a treat. The smell of freshly baked pizza crust and melted cheese was tantalizing, and immediately made me hungry!

I decided to test out their specialty – the “Bibb St. Original”. It sure didn’t disappoint! They hit all the marks – doughy yet crunchy at the same time; it was a perfect balance between freshness and flavor. The cheese and toppings were top notch: the bell peppers added sweetness and crunch, and the pepperoni was just spicy enough for me.

To top it all off, the staff here is friendly and helpful. Asking them which toppings would work best with my style of pizza, they got it right every time. In addition, they also had some great deals on combination meals that saved me a lot of money.

All in all, I’d definitely recommend Bibb Street Pizza Company to anyone looking for great pizza in Montgomery AL – this is definitely one of the best places around when it comes to pizza!

#10 Pizza Perfect

The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, a perfect setting for a night out with friends. Then there’s the pizza itself – wow, it was amazing! The crust was just the right thickness and had a great flavor, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

But that’s not all! Pizza Perfect also has some of the most creative toppings I’ve ever seen. From their mac ‘n cheese pizza to their pepperoni cheeseburger pizza, you really can’t go wrong. They even have dessert pizzas like Nutella, strawberry & banana – yum!

I would highly recommend Pizza Perfect to anyone looking for a delicious slice of pizza and a good time. It may just be the best pizza in Montgomery AL!

#11 Marco’s Pizza

The atmosphere is great – it’s casual, but with a touch of class. The staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating. And the pizza? Let me tell you, it was amazing!

The crust is perfectly cooked with just the right amount of chewiness. The flavors are robust and the toppings are fresh and generous. The margherita was a real winner, with its creamy mozzarella and acidic tomatoes that balanced each other out perfectly.

But then there’s the speciality pizzas – like ‘The Beast’ packed with pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, onions, bell peppers, sausage and extra cheese – truly an incredible experience.

I’m fairly sure Marco’s Pizza has the best pizza in Montgomery AL. If you haven’t been there yet, you need to get yourself down there ASAP!

#12 SaZa Serious Italian Food

The first thing that stuck out to me when I walked in was how they had a kid’s menu – so this is definitely a great place for families with young kids. They also have vegetarian options, so not everyone has to eat the same thing. But the most impressive part was their array of alcohol! From draft beer to hard liquor, it’s all here and ready for you, no matter what your preference!

Now on to the main event: the pizza itself! The crust was light but still surprisingly crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Toppings were fresh and flavorful, with just enough cheese. All in all, it didn’t disappoint! And if you’re looking for something sweet after dinner, they offer some insanely good desserts that will make you keep coming back again and again.

The only downside is that they don’t deliver – which is a shame – but rest assured, it’s worth driving over there for a pizza night with friends or family. SaZa Serious Italian Food can certainly hold its own against all the other contenders of best pizza in Montgomery AL!