Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mt Pleasant MI (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Michigan

Best Pizza in Mt Pleasant MI (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

79 Views

I’ve sampled pizza all over the world but I rarely find the perfect slice. Fortunately, after visiting 12 different pizza places in Mt Pleasant MI, I found a few spots that can hold their own against the best of them!

This article will share my experiences and opinions on the best pizza places in this charming Michigan town. Expect some lighthearted humor as I walk you through each one, providing my honest take on what to expect from each unique pizzeria.

Let’s start our adventure and get ready to find out who serves up the best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Michigan

#1 Vin Trofeo’s Pizzeria & Pub

I stumbled in one random evening to find a warm, inviting atmosphere that immediately made me feel at home. The staff were unbelievably friendly and efficient and the place was spotless! As soon as I stepped in, I knew I had made the right choice.

The pizza was out of this world! Vin Trofeo’s offers fresh dough made daily, unique recipes and delicious toppings that feature some of the best flavor combinations you’ll ever find in a pizza. From their traditional pepperoni with extra cheese to their creative creations like vegetable supreme and BBQ chicken – there’s something for everyone here. My personal favorite is their delicious white pie with garlic-infused ricotta cheese and grilled zucchini slices – it was absolutely heavenly.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI, look no further than Vin Trofeo’s Pizzeria & Pub. From the delightful atmosphere to the mouthwatering pizzas – everything is simply perfect!

If you’re willing to go an extra 41 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Saginaw!

#2 Pisanello’s Pizza

On the outside, Pisanello’s looks like any other pizza restaurant. Inside, however, there is something special in the air. The delicious smells of just-baked pizza pies fill the room, and every inch is lit up with a bright, cheery atmosphere.

The menu offers a wide selection of both classic and unique pizzas. Whether you’re looking for a traditional pepperoni or something more daring like their Chicken Tikka Masala pie, they have it all!

The crust was the star of the show for me – it was perfectly thin and crispy with delightful bits of char that added flavorful complexity. The presentation was also spot-on – each slice had perfect ratios of toppings to cheese and sauce so that each bite was full of flavor.

What really sets Pisanello’s apart from others is their friendly staff. Our server was insanely helpful and patient as we asked her questions about the different pies. She went above and beyond to make sure we had a great experience!

In my opinion, Pisanello’s Pizza has earned its place as one of the best pizza restaurants in Mt Pleasant MI. If you haven’t tried it yet, I highly recommend you do so soon!

#3 Green Spot Pub

I recently had the pleasure of enjoying a meal at this well-known pizza restaurant and let me tell you that Green Spot Pub really is something special.

To begin with, the atmosphere inside was great; it was nice to be able to enjoy our delicious pizza while being able to watch some exciting sports on the multiple TVs around the restaurant. And, of course, being able to enjoy an ice cold beer (or hard liquor) while we ate was just an extra bonus! Not only that but it’s a great spot for tourists looking to get out of the house and explore Mt Pleasant.

However, there is one downside: Green Spot Pub does not offer delivery service which can be inconvenient for those who can’t make it out to the restaurant itself.

But overall, I’d have to say that Green Spot Pub definitely has some of the best pizza in Mt Pleasant – I highly recommend it for anyone looking for a unique dining experience!

#4 Mountain Town Station Restaurant & Brew Pub

I was struck by the pleasant atmosphere when I arrived at the restaurant. It’s a great place for tourists to visit with outdoor seating and views of town, plus it serves up both beer and liquor, so parents can relax while their kids enjoy a kid-friendly meal. And speaking of kids’ meals, they have an excellent selection – my daughter definitely enjoyed her pepperoni pizza!

But that’s not all; in addition to great pizza, they also have some insanely good desserts. I wasn’t expecting much after eating pizza, but I came away with a huge smile on my face after trying one of the delicious slices of New York-style cheesecake. Yum!

The only thing missing is delivery – something that would really be appreciated in Mt Pleasant MI. But if you’re looking for some tasty food and a great atmosphere, this is definitely the place to go. Whether you want to catch a sports game or just grab some lunch with friends and family, Mountain Town Station Restaurant & Brew Pub has you covered!

#5 Hunter’s Ale House

The atmosphere was great – it’s got that classic “pub” feel without being too dive-y, and they even have a kids’ menu which was a nice surprise. But here’s the real kicker – they serve alcohol! And not just beer or wine – but hard liquor too. I’m talking whiskey, vodka, you name it. It’s like going to a restaurant and being able to order shots along with your pizza – how cool is that!?

I sampled some of their pizza, and although I’ve had better in other cities around the world, this pizza definitely makes the list of Mt Pleasant MI’s best. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, and the crust was cooked just right – crisp on the outside and soft on the inside.

Unfortunately, Hunter’s Ale House doesn’t offer delivery so you’ll have to go there in person if you want to try their pizza (but trust me – it’s worth it!). They do however have delicious dessert options which make for a perfect finish to an evening out with family or friends.

All in all, Hunter’s Ale House is one of my top picks for best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI!

If you’re willing to go an extra 55 miles, you can get to 9 more pizza places in Frankenmuth!

#6 Pixie Restaurant

First of all, the restaurant itself has an inviting atmosphere; the walls are painted with cheerful images of pixies and the staff is friendly. Plus, the music playing in the background was quite pleasant.

Second, their menu had a great selection of pizzas from classic Italian-style to BBQ chicken pizza. Each one was unique and delicious! We tried everything from the traditional cheese to their own specialty pies. Every slice we ate was perfectly cooked and stayed warm throughout our meal. The flavors were incredible too – I even sampled some creative toppings like sausage and mushrooms that made my mouth water!

Finally, I must mention their amazing Detroit-style deep dish pizza. It was thick, gooey and just as good as its Chicago counterpart. The buttery crust was soft on the inside but nicely crisp on the outside; while still managing to stay together when picked up by hand. All in all, this pizza was definitely worth writing home about!

In conclusion, Pixie Restaurant serves up some of the best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI – quality food at an affordable price. If you’re ever in town be sure to give them a try; you won’t regret it!

#7 The Cabin

After trying the pies at The Cabin, I can honestly say that my expectations were exceeded. From the moment I stepped in, I felt like I was transported to a quaint pizzeria in Italy! The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff was incredibly friendly.

The pizza itself was outstanding – the crust was thin and crispy just how I like it, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the sauce was spot on. Even after having eaten enough pizza to fill a small swimming pool (it’s a tough job but somebody has to do it!), I still enjoyed every bite of The Cabin’s delicious pies.

If you’re ever in Mt Pleasant MI looking for great pizza, look no further. The Cabin has some of the best pies you could hope for!

#8 Blaze Pizza

I was really impressed when I first stepped into this place. They have a great atmosphere with modern decor and the staff are super friendly. Plus the pizza oven is right in front of you so you can watch them make your pizza – pretty cool!

As far as the pizza goes, it’s absolutely delicious. The crust has a nice crispiness to it and the toppings are all fresh and flavorful. My favorite pizza is their signature Blaze Pizza topped with pepperoni, black olives, mushrooms, and banana peppers. Their normal pizzas come in two sizes (6-inch or 8-inch) but they also offer personal-sized pizzas if you’re feeling extra hungry.

Overall, Blaze Pizza offers some of the best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI. The food quality is top notch and I definitely recommend this place to everyone!

#9 Pizza King

I never thought I’d find such an incredible pizza place in this small town. From the moment I walked in and caught a whiff of the fresh dough being made, I knew I was in for something special.

The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming towards me, even though they have no idea who I am or what my purpose is here. They showed me around their restaurant, speaking passionately about their different pizzas and telling me stories of where the ingredients are sourced from.

When it came time to try their food, I was amazed. Everything was so fresh and flavorful! The crust had this unique crunch to it that made every slice irresistible. And the sauces? Ah! Divine! There is nothing quite like the taste of Pizza King’s marinara sauce – truly out of this world!

To sum up – if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around, look no further than Pizza King in Mt Pleasant MI. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 62 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Grand Rapids!

#10 Jet’s Pizza

I’ve never seen anything like it–the toppings were fresh and flavorful, the crust was perfectly crispy yet soft, and the cheese was surprisingly high quality. The atmosphere was cheery too; the staff were friendly and always willing to make recommendations.

But what really set Jet’s Pizza apart for me was their attention to detail. From the selection of local craft beers on tap to the variety of traditional and specialty pies, they had thought of everything. Their secret sauce is particularly memorable–it’s got a kick that lingers in just the right way.

All in all, I would highly recommend Jet’s Pizza if you’re ever visiting Mt Pleasant MI–it’ll be worth your while! The best pizza in town can be found here!

#11 Hungry Howie’s Pizza

Not only was the crust impeccably thin and crispy, but the combination of flavors in their specialty pies was simply divine. The ‘Mile High Club’, with its generous layers of cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and olives more than made up for its lofty name. I also found their ‘Buffalo Chicken’ pizza to be quite a tasty surprise.

The restaurant itself was welcoming and inviting with a bright atmosphere that added to my experience. The staff were friendly and attentive to boot, giving me the sense that they truly cared about serving up quality pizza experiences to every customer who passes through their doors.

In conclusion, I highly recommend Hungry Howie’s Pizza if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Mt Pleasant MI! Go ahead and give them a try – you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Domino’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed was the amazing variety of crusts they have, ranging from Classic Hand-Tossed to Extra-Thin and Brooklyn Style. I tried them all and can honestly say that each one was better than the last.

The sauce is also really unique. It’s got a lot of flavor without being too overpowering. The cheese is great too—it’s got this nice smoky flavor, which really brings out the flavor of the other toppings.

Toppings wise, they’ve got it all, from pepperoni and sausage to veggies like mushrooms, spinach, and olives. Plus they’ve got some delicious gourmet options if you’re feeling adventurous.

All in all, Domino’s Pizza offers some of the best pizza around Mt Pleasant MI. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pizza or something more adventurous, there’s definitely something here for everyone!