Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Naperville IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Illinois

Best Pizza in Naperville IL (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

359 Views

I’ve been lucky enough to try pizza from all over the world, so I thought I’d bring my experience here and check out some of Naperville’s offerings. After a rigorous tasting process of 12 different places, I’m happy to share my findings and declare the best pizza in Naperville IL.

I won’t take you through every single place on the list – who has that kind of time? – but I will give you my honest opinions, with some humor along the way. So grab a slice (or two!) of your favorite pizza and get ready to learn who takes home the crown.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Illinois

#1 Pizza Twist

I was blown away by the quality of their pizza. It was perfectly cooked, with a perfect crust and just enough sauce and cheese to bring out all the flavors without overpowering anything. The toppings were flavorful and fresh, as if they were made right in front of me.

The atmosphere at Pizza Twist is great. It’s warm and inviting – all the staff seem friendly and hospitable, making it a great place to hang out with friends or family.

Most importantly for me, the pies are incredibly reasonably priced, so I can have my fill of delicious slices without breaking the bank. Now that’s a nice twist!

In conclusion, Pizza Twist is an excellent choice for anyone looking for the best pizza in Naperville IL. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch break between errands or an evening out with friends, this is definitely the spot to go!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Aurora!

#2 Calogero’s

I was stunned when I first stepped through the restaurant’s door. The smell of fresh pizza and garlic wafting through the air, combined with the cheerful Italian tunes playing in the background, made me feel really welcome and excited to be there.

The menu was loaded with delicious options, including traditional Italian pies, gourmet creations, and even a gluten-free selection. To get a true sense of Calogero’s offerings, I ordered one of each – no easy feat! The margherita pizza was especially flavorful, with just the right amount of cheese and light tomato sauce. The meat lovers’ pizza offered that classic cheesy taste but with an extra kick thanks to the pepperoni and sausage toppings. Meanwhile, the gluten-free pizza managed to be just as tasty as its traditional counterparts – quite impressive!

But what really impressed me was their dessert selection. Calogero’s serves up some of best cannolis I’ve ever tasted! Rich, creamy filling wrapped in crunchy pastry shells – simply divine!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Naperville IL, look no further than Calogero’s. You won’t be disappointed by their delicious pies or divine desserts.

#3 Louie’s Pizza : Pizza, Gyros, Crepes

I stopped by Louie’s on a recent trip to the area, and what I found was nothing short of amazing. The pizzas were cooked to perfection, with the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. The crust was light and fluffy, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful.

I also tried their gyros, which were equally delicious. The marinated lamb was tender and juicy, served up with tangy tzatziki and topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and feta cheese.

Finally, I had one of their crepes for dessert. It was delicate yet flavorful — filled with Nutella and bananas — just enough sweetness without being cloying.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in the area (or some great gyros or crepes), head on over to Louie’s Pizza : Pizza, Gyros, Crepes! You won’t regret it!

#4 Little Pops NY Pizzeria

I was immediately impressed with the atmosphere of this place. The interior was cozy and comfortable, with just the right amount of pizzeria charm. I felt like I had stepped through a time machine and gone back to the 1950s!

The menu offered a wide variety of classic New York-style pizzas, as well as some exciting specialty pies. After much deliberation, I settled on the White Pizza – it didn’t disappoint! The crust was perfectly thin and crisp, and the combination of cheeses was a flavor sensation.

The amazing thing about Little Pops is that they don’t sacrifice quality for speed; each pizza is made to order with care and attention. My pizza arrived quickly and steaming hot. And did I mention how humongous the individual slices were? They could easily have fed two people!

If you’re looking for delicious New York-style pizza in Naperville IL, look no further than Little Pops NY Pizzeria. Whether you’re grabbing a single slice or ordering an entire pie, you’re guaranteed to be satisfied!

#5 MOD Pizza

The first thing I noticed when I walked in was the hustle and bustle of their amazing staff. Every employee was friendly, helpful and always had a smile on their face. It was refreshing to see so much positivity in the air!

Then I tried the food, and oh boy, what an experience that was! The crust was light and fluffy yet still had enough char for flavor. The sauce was full-bodied and bursting with flavor, while the cheese melted beautifully into every bite. It’s no wonder MOD Pizza has been voted best pizza in Naperville IL year after year!

In addition to the great food, MOD Pizza also has a great selection of toppings to choose from. From veggies to meats to cheeses, they literally have it all! Plus, you can go crazy with as many toppings as you want – all for one flat price. That is truly a deal that can’t be beat!

All in all, MOD Pizza is my new go-to spot for delicious pizza here in Naperville IL. If you’re looking for the best pizza around town – this is definitely it!

#6 Little Italian Pizza West

I’ve been to Italy, and this place brings me right back. There’s a warmth in the atmosphere that you won’t find anywhere else. From the smell of freshly baked dough to the friendly staff that greet you as if you’re family – it’s an experience unlike any other.

The pizza itself is outstanding. The ingredients are all fresh, and they have some unique combinations that will tantalize your taste buds. The crust is perfect – crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. And, the cheese melts perfectly!

I always make sure I leave enough room for dessert, and Little Italian Pizza West definitely didn’t disappoint. They have a great selection of cakes to choose from, including a mouthwatering ricotta cheesecake that is to die for.

If you’re looking for an authentic Italian experience with some of the best pizza in Naperville IL, look no further than Little Italian Pizza West!

#7 Intero Forno

My first visit to Intero Forno was nothing short of amazing. From their wide selection of appetizers to their mouth-watering pizza, it quickly became one of my favorite pizza spots in the area.

The atmosphere at Intero is unique, with a casual and relaxed vibe that makes you feel right at home no matter who you’re dining with. The staff are friendly and welcoming, always ready to answer any questions about the menu.

When it comes to the food, words can’t describe how delicious every dish I’ve tried here has been. The pizzas are cooked to perfection, the cheeses all melted to perfection and the toppings always just right. Their crusts are light and fluffy, like a pillow for your taste buds!

I especially love the calzones here – it’s like having all your favorite pizzas rolled up into one handy little package! I highly recommend trying them if you haven’t already.

Overall, Intero Forno is hands down one of the best pizza places in Naperville IL – so make sure you stop by soon before they run out!

#8 Naperville – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria

The interior has a rustic, old-world pizzeria ambiance that is perfect for dining in or taking out. The staff was friendly and attentive, and I felt welcomed from the moment I stepped through the door.

Now onto the main event: their pizza! Lou Malnati’s signature Chicago-style deep dish is an absolute must-try – to start with a solid crust, generously topped with buttery layers of cheese and tomato sauce, topped off with herbs and spices. When it came to ordering I had trouble deciding between the classic pepperoni and bacon varieties – they sounded equally delicious! In the end I opted for a half-and-half pizza – so now I don’t have to choose!

I quickly realized why Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria has been named one of the best pizza places in Naperville IL – their pizza is absolutely magnificent! From the thick chewy crust down to its simple yet flavorful toppings, everything was perfectly balanced. The flavors blended wonderfully together, creating a complex flavor that could only be compared with traditional Italian style cooking.

This experience will definitely be at the top of my list when it comes to finding great pizza in Naperville IL – Lou Malnati’s Pizzeria is without a doubt some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 9 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Downers Grove!

#9 Little Italian Pizza

Right away, I could tell this place was special. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting and the staff were friendly and knowledgeable about their pizzas.

The star of the show is definitely their pizzas. They have a wide variety of options from classic Neapolitan to modern-style pies with tons of toppings. Plus, they offer gluten-free options for those who need it! Every slice I tried was perfectly balanced in flavor and texture, right down to the crust which had a great chewiness without being too doughy or burnt.

But Little Italian Pizza isn’t just about the pizza – they also have an extensive menu of great sides such as garlic knots, chicken wings, and calzones that give you plenty of ways to round out your meal. And if you want something more unique they even offer salads and desserts (though the pizza really is enough by itself).

At the end of my visit I felt completely satisfied with Little Italian Pizza’s offerings and would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for some truly great pizza in Naperville IL!

#10 Adamo’s Pizza & Catering

I’m a bit of a pizza aficionado and I was thrilled when I heard about Adamo’s. From the moment I walked in, the inviting atmosphere made me feel right at home.

The staff were friendly and welcoming, and they even guided me through my order – telling me what their most popular dishes are so that I didn’t have to guess!

Once my order was taken, it was only a few minutes before it arrived to my table. The presentation alone was enough to make me salivate – it looked delicious!

But the true test is whether or not it tasted good, and let me tell you – that pizza is some of the best I’ve ever had! It had the perfect balance between cheese and sauce, with just enough toppings so as not to overwhelm the flavor.

I’m sure all their other food is equally as fantastic but this time I’ll stick with what I can vouch for: Adamo’s has some of the best pizza in Naperville IL! Highly recommended for anyone looking for great pizza.

#11 Old Town Pizza Of Naperville

From the first bite, I was amazed by the great taste and texture of the crust. It was crispy and chewy in all the right ways, and it had just the right amount of charring on the edges.

The tomato sauce was also spot-on with a robust flavor that complemented the cheese perfectly. It wasn’t overly sweet or salty, so it provided a nice balance to the overall experience.

I’ve had some great pizza in my travels, but Old Town Pizza Of Naperville really blew me away with its creative topping combinations. From traditional pepperoni to exotic varieties like eggplant parmesan and arugula with prosciutto, there’s something for everyone to enjoy here. Plus, they have a variety of vegetarian options too!

To top it off (no pun intended), the service at Old Town Pizza Of Naperville is top notch. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable; she answered all our questions about their menu and even offered up some great suggestions based on our tastes.

If you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience, look no further than Old Town Pizza Of Naperville! I can confidently say that it’s the best pizza in Naperville IL that I’ve ever had.

#12 Traverso’s

This family-run pizzeria has been around since the late ’80s, and it has definitely stood the test of time. The crust is thin, crispy, and perfectly cooked every time. And what’s even more impressive is the variety of toppings you can choose from. From classic Italian favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more eclectic choices like roasted garlic and anchovies, there’s something for everyone at Traverso’s.

The service here is really friendly too. The staff always makes sure to ask how many slices I want – trust me when I say they do not skimp on the cheese or toppings! My favorite menu items are the garlic knots and a slice of white pizza with spinach and ricotta – so delicious!

Overall, if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Naperville IL, head straight to Traverso’s! It’s worth every penny!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – Giordano’s

Now, let me start by saying that this place is a real gem. I mean, they serve alcohol, and not just your basic beer and wine. They’ve got hard liquor! So, if you’re like me and need something stronger than a glass of Merlot to handle the stress of choosing toppings, this place has got you covered.

Now, I know some of you crazy vegetarians out there might be thinking, What about us? Fear not, my leaf-loving friends! Giordano’s has some vegetarian options that will make you forget about your carnivorous desires. Their veggie pizza is loaded with fresh veggies and ooey-gooey cheese that will make you question why you ever needed meat in the first place.

But wait, there’s more! Giordano’s also offers dessert. Yep, you heard me right. Pizza AND dessert. It’s like a match made in cheesy heaven. And let me tell you, their chocolate chip cookie skillet is a game-changer. It’s warm, gooey, and guaranteed to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Now, I do have one gripe with this place. They don’t accept reservations. I mean, come on. Do they not know who I am? Edward, the world-renowned food critic, needs to be able to secure a table! But hey, I guess I’ll just have to wait like all the other peasants.

Overall, Giordano’s is not only a great place to grab some delicious deep dish pizza, but it’s also a nice spot for tourists to check out. So, if you’re looking for the best deep dish pizza in Naperville and maybe even a shot or two of tequila, give Giordano’s a try. You won’t be disappointed.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Aurelio’s Pizza Naperville

From the moment I stepped into Aurelio’s, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baking pizza permeated the air, making my stomach growl in anticipation. As I perused the menu, I couldn’t help but giggle at the clever pizza names. Who could resist ordering the Meat Me at the Corner or the Veggielicious?

When my pizza arrived at the table, I marveled at the perfectly crisp and golden thin crust. It was so thin, I could practically see through it! The toppings were abundant and of the highest quality. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, with the tangy tomato sauce dancing with the gooey cheese and the perfectly seasoned meats and veggies.

But it wasn’t just the pizza that made my experience at Aurelio’s memorable. The staff was delightfully quirky and attentive. They seemed genuinely excited to serve me their culinary creations. I couldn’t help but laugh as they sauntered across the restaurant, spinning the pizza dough in their hands like circus performers.

While I’ve had my fair share of pizza around the world, Aurelio’s Pizza Naperville stands out as a delicious, quirky, and downright fun pizza joint. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and stop by for a slice (or five) of their amazing thin crust pizza. Trust me, you won’t regret it!