I like to consider myself a pizza connoisseur having sampled some of the most amazing pies around the world. But I was determined to find out more about the local pizza places in New Brunswick NJ, so I tasted 12 of them!
What followed was an adventure full of insight and laughs – and a few stomach aches too! But I was up for the challenge, and now I’m here to let you know which are the best pizza places in town. Buckle up and let’s get ready for a cheesy ride!
If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New Jersey
#1 Pappagallos Pizzeria Restaurant
I had heard some great things about this place and, boy, were they right! The atmosphere of the dining room was inviting, warm and friendly. The waitstaff was prompt and attentive to our needs.
When it came time to order the pizza, wow! It did not disappoint. The fresh ingredients, delicious crust, and perfect ratio of sauces to cheese made for a pizza experience like no other. Every slice I took was full of flavor – with just enough kick from the pepperoni.
The bottom line? Pappagallos Pizzeria Restaurant is definitely the best pizza in New Brunswick NJ – hands down! If you’re ever in town and craving pizza, don’t hesitate to swing by here for the best slice around!
If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 25 more pizza places in Somerset!
#2 Giddy’s Pizzeria
- Has a kid’s menu
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
My first impression of the pizzeria was its lively atmosphere – the walls are painted bright colors, and there’s always great music playing. Sure enough, the pizza lived up to my expectations!
The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of garlic. It’s clearly made with fresh ingredients that give it a flavorful taste. The cheese was melted to perfection and just oozed off each slice. And the toppings! Oh, I could go on and on about them because they were so delicious. We tried everything from peppers to mushrooms to anchovies – each topping had something unique and special about it.
To finish off our meal, we had dessert pizza for a special treat! I must admit I’m not usually a fan of sweets mixed with savory flavors but this one was surprisingly good – sweet dough topped with creamy Nutella and crunchy hazelnuts.
All in all, Giddy’s Pizzeria is a great place for anyone who loves pizza (and who doesn’t love pizza?). Whether you’re looking for a delicious dinner or an after-work snack, you won’t be disappointed here!
#3 Daniel’s Pizzeria
- Has some vegetarian options
The place itself is quite quaint, with a homey and inviting atmosphere. The staff was very friendly and eager to make sure my experience at the restaurant was top-notch.
I got the chance to try several of their specialty pies, each one more unique and delicious than the last. Their famous Meat Lover’s Pizza had just the right amount of spice and flavor that left me wanting more!
Their dessert pizzas were out of this world too – it’s hard to pick a favorite from the many options. I will definitely be coming back here for dinner some day soon!
Overall, Daniel’s Pizzeria has earned its title as the best pizza in New Brunswick NJ. I give them 5 stars for their amazing food, attentive service, and generous portions!
#4 P J’s Grill & Pizza – Food delivery in the New Brunswick area. Call or order online.
- Nice tourist spot
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The first thing that strikes you when you walk in is the mouth-watering smell of hand-tossed dough being stretched, smothered in fresh tomatoes, and baked to perfection. The staff are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable – they take the time to explain all their options and ensure your order is exactly how you want it.
The pizzas here are truly special – they’re loaded with generous portions of high-quality cheeses, meats, vegetables and seasonings! What really makes them stand out is the homemade crust – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. It’s truly a taste sensation like no other!
It’s no wonder P J’s Grill & Pizza has become a favorite for locals and visitors alike. With delicious food and unbeatable service, I can honestly say that it’s one of the best pizza places I’ve ever been to!
#5 Cristo’s Pizza and Grill
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
I was so excited to finally make it to Cristo’s! As soon as I walked in, I could smell the tantalizing aroma of freshly made pizza wafting through the air.
The staff at Cristo’s are incredibly friendly and welcoming, which only added to the experience. They’re always more than willing to answer questions and help out with whatever you need.
As for their food, they impressed me every step of the way! Their dough is soft and chewy, with just enough crunchiness on the edges. They have a wide selection of toppings too – from classic pepperoni and mushrooms to unique combinations like banana & bacon.
And their sauce…oh man! It’s like eating a sweet-tangy tomato explosion in your mouth! Plus, their cheese really ties everything together into one delicious bite after another. Yum!
Overall, I can confidently say that Cristo’s Pizza and Grill has some of the best pizza in New Brunswick NJ. If you want some great pizza without sacrificing quality or flavor, then this is definitely the place to go!
#6 U.S Chicken Pizza and Spanish Food
- Offers dessert
The restaurant is unassuming, and you’d never guess it offers such amazing gourmet pies. We opted for the ‘Ultimate Combo’ which comes with pepperoni, roasted chicken, hot honey BBQ sauce and bacon. The taste was quite unique – not too sweet or salty – it was a great balance of flavors, and the crust was fluffy yet crisp.
But that wasn’t all! To complement our meal we opted for an ‘exotic’ slice – one of their specialty pizzas that includes salami and banana peppers (yes, you read right). It was surprisingly delicious! The combination of savory ingredients mixed with sweet fruit really added something unexpected to the dish.
Overall, I highly recommend U.S Chicken Pizza and Spanish Food if you’re in New Brunswick NJ looking for a great pizza experience. Whether you prefer traditional styles or something more exotic, this place can accommodate your cravings. They’ve got some of the best pizza in town!
#7 King’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
- Offers dessert
- Has a kid’s menu
I arrived at King’s and was immediately taken in by the inviting atmosphere. From the warm colors on the walls to the cozy booths, I felt right at home. I wasted no time ordering their signature pizza: a cheese and pepperoni pie baked with love in their brick oven.
When it arrived at my table, I could smell the deliciousness before even tasting it. The cheese was perfectly melted, there was just enough pepperoni, and the crust had a nice crispness to it. With each bite, I could tell that this pizza had been prepared with exceptional care and skill – truly some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!
The staff were friendly, attentive, and eager to make sure that my experience was positive. In addition to their delicious pizzas, they also offer an array of other Italian specialties like pasta dishes, sandwiches and even desserts!
At King’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant, they have succeeded in creating not only fantastic food but also a wonderful ambiance for everyone to enjoy. If you’re looking for great food in New Brunswick NJ then this is definitely your spot for the best pizza around!
If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Middlesex!
#8 Douglas Pizza & Grill
- Offers dessert
- Nice tourist spot
- Has some vegetarian options
When I first arrived, I was immediately greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The staff members were super friendly and attentive, making sure my experience was top-notch. What really impressed me was the pizza – it was cooked to perfection. The crust was light and airy, the sauce flavorful and not overly sweet, and the toppings were fresh and plentiful.
And let me tell you – this is some delicious pizza! From the classic cheese and pepperoni pies to their unique specialty pizzas, like the “Doug’s Neapolitan” (a classic Italian combination of roasted garlic, red onions, spicy salami, pitted olives & two cheeses). Every slice I took was bursting with flavor!
Overall, Douglas Pizza & Grill is an excellent choice for some of the best pizza in New Brunswick NJ. If you’re looking for an incredible dinner out or just want a great takeaway dinner for home, there’s no better option than Douglas Pizza & Grill!
#9 R.U. Grill & Pizza
- Has some vegetarian options
- Offers dessert
This place does it all. The options are endless, and the quality is top-notch. Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese pizza, one loaded with toppings, or something unique like Greek pizza, they have it all.
The flavors here are simply divine. The BBQ pork pizza has a hint of sweetness that pairs perfectly with the smoky flavor of the BBQ sauce. Their signature pepperoni is packed with incredible zesty flavor. Even their veggie pizza packs an unforgettable punch of savory goodness.
But it’s not just their pies that keep me coming back; they also do wings and stromboli like no one else in town! The wings have a crispy exterior and juicy center that will make your taste buds sing with joy. And the stromboli? Oh boy! I’m telling you folks, it’s filled with so much deliciousness your mouth will be watering before you even take a bite!
Overall, R.U. Grill & Pizza has something for everyone and if you’re ever in New Brunswick NJ looking for some of the best pizza around – look no further than this amazing spot!
#10 Pizza City Easton Ave
- Offers dessert
- Has some vegetarian options
The first thing that caught my attention was the unique atmosphere. It’s unlike any other pizza restaurant I’ve been to. It has a modern, contemporary vibe with vibrant colors and a relaxed, inviting atmosphere.
I found the selection of pizzas to be quite impressive. They had traditional favorites such as the classic cheese and pepperoni combo as well as more unique options like buffalo chicken, pesto white clam and taco pizza (complete with beef, tomatoes, and lettuce). The flavors were bold and authentic – definitely some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted!
The friendly staff at Pizza City Easton Ave also deserves a special mention – they went out of their way to accommodate my dietary needs and make sure I enjoyed my experience.
All in all, Pizza City Easton Ave is hands down one of the best pizza spots in New Brunswick NJ. Not only are their pizzas delicious, but the atmosphere and customer service are top-notch as well! If you’re ever in the area, make sure to pay them a visit for an unbeatable pizza experience!
#11 Jimmy’s Grill
First, the atmosphere at Jimmy’s Grill is amazing. It looks like it was transported right out of Italy! They have a brick oven in the back and decor that makes you feel like you’re in Rome.
But more importantly, their pizza is out-of-this-world delicious. They use only the freshest ingredients, including flavorful meats and cheeses, and their unique sauces are truly one of a kind. The crust has just enough crunch to satisfy your cravings but not too much that it overpowers the toppings.
I also have to mention their unique selection of sides (all vegetarian!) which are perfect for those looking for something a little different than traditional pizza flavors.
Overall, I’d give Jimmy’s Grill five stars for bringing some of Italy to New Brunswick NJ! If you’re ever in town, make sure to check out this place – you won’t be disappointed!
#12 Gomez Pizza & Restaurant
I’ve had my fair share of pizza from multiple countries, neighborhoods, and cities, but Gomez Pizza definitely takes the cake. When I arrived at this local pizzeria, I immediately knew I was in for a treat.
The aroma of freshly made dough and the sight of a wood fire oven only increased my anticipation. The servers were friendly and helpful with their suggestions.
As for the food? Delicious! They have an extensive menu ranging from classic pepperoni styles to inventive combos like BBQ chicken or eggplant parmesan pizzas. They also have specialty pies like the Cali-style with jalapeños, peppers, and pineapple. It was amazing! Every bite was truly flavorful and cooked to perfection.
I will definitely be coming back soon to try their calzones, garlic knots, and grinders too. Gomez Pizza has made it into my list of the best pizza places in New Brunswick NJ and beyond!
